Aplicação Informática para Concursos de Arquitectura: oportunidade para a promoção da Participação Pública na Sociedade da Informação

November 22, 2017 | Autor: Bruno Moreira | Categoria: Information Technology, Architecture, Computer-Mediated Communication
Share Embed


Descrição do Produto

AI CA Apl i c aç ãoI nf or mát i c apar aConc ur s osdeAr qui t ec t ur a

opor t uni dadepar aapr omoç ãodaPar t i c i paç ãoPúbl i c anaSoc i edadedaI nf or maç ão

Di s s er t aç ãodeMes t r ado F AUP2009/2010

Br unoMi g ue l daS i l v aCa r v a l hoMor e i r a

!"#$%&'()*+,-)./01$%&*"&.&*2),%3.4)4*56*!.73$16%13.&88 !"!#$%&'()(*+")#)+)+"#!,!-.!+()+/)#$'0'")-.!+/123'0)+&)+4!0'*()(*+()+5&6!#,)-.!777

!"#$%&&#"'#"(%)*+,#"-'."#$/'0#1*#"'.%,"#'2%3#'4+5#&'6%""%("+'7%*#

8+9)#')+:!.!

;+' %5' *#,+&' +&' ,([email protected](!=()+&' %'[email protected]*(?(,+,%&' &#@(+(&R' %@#)J5(@+&' %'!#=A*(@+&9'15+'&#@(%,+,%'#),%'#'@#5!1*+,#"' !%&&#+='&%'+&&15(1'@#5#' #BN%@*#',#' I1#*(,(+)#'!"+*(@+5%)*%'(),(&!%)&]?%=9'15+'&#@(%,+,%' #),%' #' ,%&%N#' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' :' %[email protected]+=+' D=#B+=' `' !#*%)@(+,#' !%=+' E)*%")%*! %' !%=+' &1+' @[email protected](,+,%',%'=(,+"'@#5'@#)*%^,#&'51=*(5`,(+'()*%"[email protected]*(?#&/ '

H&*%&' @#)*%^,#&R' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&' !"%&%)*%&' )+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,#' !"#N%@*#' ,%'

+"I1(*%@*1"+R' @#)*M5' %5' &('#' !#*%)@(+=' ,%'!%"5(*("'15' 5%=C#"' %)*%),(5%)*#' ,#&' !"#N%@*#&' !#"' !+"*%' ,%' 15' !^B=(@#' 5%)#&' @+!+K' )+' =%(*1"+' ,+&' *"+,(@(#)+(&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+'5+(&'+B&*"[email protected]*+&-'+'!=+)*+R'#'@#"*%R'#'+=>+,#/ '

8'8!=(@+>3#'E)$#"5]*(@+'!+"+'G#)@1"&#&',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'Y8EG8Z'&1"D%')%&*%'@#)*%L*#'

@#5#' 15+' +!=(@+>3#' ()*%"[email protected]*(?+' I1%' &%'*"+,1K')15+'!=+*+$#"5+'#)=()%'@+!+K',%' "%&!#),%"' +,%I1+,+5%)*%':&')%@%&&(,+,%&',%'@#51)(@+>3#',#&'?]"(#&'[email protected]*#"%&'%)?#=?(,#&')#'!"#@%&&#/ '

\'&%1',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#'&%"]'@#),1K(,#'!#"'15+'%I1(!+'51=*(,([email protected](!=()+"/'8'!"%&%)*%'

0(&&%"*+>3#' ,%' ;%&*"+,#' @#)&*(*1(b&%' @#5#' 15' !"(5%("#' 5#5%)*#' ,%' &A)*%&%' I1%' !"#@1"+' )3#' &J' ,%5#)&*"+"' %&&%' @#)*%L*#' ,%' #!#"*1)(,+,%R' 5+&' *+5B`5' +!#)*+"' @+5()C#&' !+"+' #' %$%@*(?#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'+!=(@+>3#/

.+=+?"[email protected]+?%-'+"I1(*%@*1"+R' '@#)@1"&#R' '!+"*(@(!+>3#R''@#51)(@+>3#R' 'OEGR' 'WER''@#5!1*+,#"R' "%,%/

;,5$%6 1. Introdução

9

1.1 contexto

11

1.2 objecto

13

1.3 objectivos

13

1.4 método

15

1.5 estrutura

19

2. Estado da Arte

21

2.1 Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

23

2.1.1 da cidade, da rede e do indivíduo da SI

23

2.1.2 do computador e da Internet

31

2.1.3 em síntese – ou oportunidade, 1

47

2.2 Concurso de arquitectura e participação pública

51

2.2.1 do processo de um concurso de arquitectura

51

2.2.2 da participação pública

57

2.2.3 em síntese – ou oportunidade, 2

75

2.3 Comunicação e representação de projecto

79

2.3.1 da representação como acto criativo

79

2.3.2 da representação como meio de comunicação eficaz

85

2.3.3 em síntese –!ou oportunidade, 3

99

3. AICA 3.1 Definição da matriz de análise

103 105

3.1.1 da caracterização dos temas

105

3.1.2 da framework analitica

107

3.2 Dez indicadores para a AICA

111

3.2.1. tema 1!– utilizadores

114

3.2.2. tema 2 – interface

136

3.2.3 tema 3 – estrutura

143

3.2.4 tema 4 – conteúdos

157

3.3 Sistematização de indicadores na matriz da AICA

169

4. Conclusão

173

5. Referências

183

5.1 Bibliografia

184

5.2 Índice de figuras

190

5.3 Abreviaturas

195

<

*%),1681) *)9=6%1) *)9=6%1$>)4 */?1)5) *641.313.&

BB

@A*+,1.)53'()88

@A*+,1.)53'()

@C

@@

[email protected]?+0!&$*7$!

'

8' &#@(%,+,%' @#)*%5!#"_)%+' `' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&' 15+' &#@(%,+,%' D=#B+=-' D"+>+&' :&'

()#?+>a%&')#&'*"+)&!#"*%&R'+#'+15%)*#',+'?%=#@(,+,%'%5'?(+D%5')#'*%""(*J"(#'%':'[email protected](=(,+,%'%' "+!(,%K',%'@#51)(@+>3#R'+&',(&*_)@(+&'!+&&+"+5'+'&%"'5%,(,+&')#'*%5!#'I1%'`'@+,+'?%K'5+(&' @1"*#9' +' )#>3#' ,%' $"#)*%("+! $+K' @+,+' ?%K' 5%)#&' &%)*(,#R' I1%"' )+' ,(?(&3#' !#=A*(@#b +,5()(&*"+*(?+' ,#&' !+A&%&R' @#5#' #' ,%5#)&*"+' +' c)(3#' H1"#!%(+R' I1%"' )+' @#51)(@+>3#' %' ()$#"5+>3#R'@#5#' #' ,%5#)&*"+'+'D%)%"+=(K+>3#',#'1&#' ,#&'*%=%5J?%(&'%',+'E)*%")%*R'I1%"')+' @"(+>3#' ,%'@#)C%@(5%)*#R'@#5#'#',%5#)&*"+'#'@"%[email protected]%)*%'()*%"%&&%'!#"']"%+&',%'()?%&*(D+>3#' 51=*(,([email protected](!=()+"/ '

8'@"%[email protected]%)*%'51=*(,([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%')3#'&(D)(V(@+'I1%'+&',([email protected](!=()+&',%?+5' #1'%&*%N+5'

+' !%",%"' +' &1+' +1*#)#5(+R' 5+&' +)*%&' +' D+)C+"' 15+' 5+(#"' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' ()*%"[email protected]>3#' !#*%)@(+,+' !#"' +?+)>#&' *%@)#=JD(@#&R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' )+' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,#' @#5!1*+,#"' %' ,#&' 5%(#&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#/' E)*%",([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%R' 51=*(,([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%'%'*"+)&,([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%d' &3#' @#)@%(*#&' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&' !"%&%)*%&' )+' &#@(%,+,%' %' `' :' &1+' =1K' I1%' %&*+' 0(&&%"*+>3#' &%' ,%&%)?#=?%R' !"%*%),%),#' ,+"' #' &%1' @#)*"(B1*#' !+"+' +' N]' ()%?(*]?%=' +!"#L(5+>3#' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+':&'O%@)#=#D(+&',+'E)$#"5+>3#'%'G#51)(@+>3#'YOEGZ'%R'@#)&%I1%)*%5%)*%R'+'15+' &#@(%,+,%'@+,+'?%K'5+(&' ()$#"5+*(K+,+/' 8!%&+"' ,+' (5!#"*_)@(+' ,+' "%?#=1>3#' *%@)#=JD(@+R' +' "%?#=1>3#')%@%&&]"(+'`R'&#B"%*1,#R'@1=*1"+=/ '

7%&*%' @#)*%L*#' ,%' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+&' OEGR' ,+' @#)&#=(,+>3#' ,#' 5#,%=#' ,+'

W#@(%,+,%',+'E)$#"5+>3#'YWEZR',+'()?%&*(D+>3#'()*%"R'51=*('%'*"+)&,([email protected](!=()+"R'%',+'"%,1>3#',+&' $"#)*%("+&' %' ,(&*_)@(+&R' &1"D%' +' #!#"*1)(,+,%' ,%' +"*(@1=+"' +' +"I1(*%@*1"+' Y%5' !+"*(@1=+"' #' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+Z' @#5' +&' OEGR' *%),#' @#5#' #BN%@*(?#' +' @"(+>3#' ,%' 15+' !=+*+$#"5+' ,(D(*+='@+!+K',%'+1L(=(+"'*#,#'!"#@%&&#'%R')3#'5%)#&'(5!#"*+)*%R'@+!+K'*+5B`5',%'!"#5#?%"' #',(]=#D#'%)*"%'#&',(?%"&#&'[email protected]*#"%&')#'!"#@%&&#'Y!"#5#*#"%&R'*`@)(@#&R'1*(=(K+,#"%&'%'!^B=(@#Z' "%=+)>+),#' #' ,%B+*%' %5' *#")#' ,+' (5!#"*_)@(+' ,+' !+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+' @#5#' 5%(#' !+"+' [email protected]+)>+"'15'5%=C#"'+5B(%)*%'@#)&*"1A,#/

d 'W%' ()*%"'%' 51=*(,([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%' &%' "%$%"%5':' @#=+B#"+>3#' ,%R' "%&!%@*(?+5%)*%R' ,1+&' #1'5+(&',([email protected](!=()+&' +1*J)#5+&'@#5' #' #BN%@*(?#' ,%' ,%&%)?#=?%"' 15+' ()?%&*(D+>3#' %5' @#515R' +' *"+)&,([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%R' +!%&+"' ,%' )3#' +)1=+"' !#"' @#5!=%*#' +&' $"#)*%("+&',([email protected](!=()+"%&R'(5!=(@+' 15+'!"%,(&!#&(>3#' ,%' *#,+&'+&' %I1(!+&'%5',%&%)?#=?%"' +'()?%&*(D+>3#' !+"+' +=`5',+' %&$%"+' ,+' &1+',([email protected](!=()+/

@D

'

.+"+'+=`5',%&*%'@#)*%L*#'D=#B+=R'#'@#)*%L*#' !%&&#+=',#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#'*+5B`5'

`' "%=%?+)*%' !+"+' +' @#5!"%%)&3#' ,#' *"+B+=C#' I1%' +!"%&%)*+5#&-' #' &%1' *"+B+=C#' [email protected]*1+=' %)I1+)*#'E)?%&*(D+,#"',#'."#N%@*#'084G'+*"+?`&',#'GG4H eR')+'[email protected]=,+,%',%'8"I1(*%@*1"+',+' c)(?%"&(,+,%',#'.#"*#R'+&&15(1b&%'@#5#'!#)*#',%'!+"*(,+'!+"+'+'!"%&%)*%'0(&&%"*+>3#/ '

\'084G' X' 0(D(*+='8"@C(*%@*1"%' 4%!"%&%)*+*(#)'+),' G#551)(@+*(#)' X' `'15' !"#N%@*#'

,%' E0FO' V()+)@(+,#' !%=#' f4H7' I1%' &%' %)@#)*"+' +' &%"' ,%&%)?#=?(,#' !#"' 15' @#)&J"@(#' 51=*(,([email protected](!=()+"' $#"5+,#' !#"' *"M&' %5!"%&+&' ,+&' ]"%+&' ,+' *%@)#=#D(+' ,(D(*+=' %' ,%' &(&*%5+&R' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %' ,%&(D)' D"]V(@#R' %' !#"' ,1+&' 1)(,+,%&' ,%' EF0-' +' 4%(*#"(+' ,+' c)(?%"&(,+,%' ,#' .#"*#' %' +' [email protected]=,+,%' ,%' 8"I1(*%@*1"+' ,+' c)(?%"&(,+,%' ,#' .#"*#/' \' #BN%@*(?#' `' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,%' +!=(@+>a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+&' %5' *"M&' ?%"*%)*%&' %&!%@AV(@+&-' 084G' G#=+B#"+*(?#gR'084G'G#)@1"&#&h'%'084G'H&!+>#&'G(,+,%bG1=*1"+i/ '

\' *"+B+=C#' I1%' #' +1*#"' &%' %)@#)*"+' +' ,%&%)?#=?%"' %)I1+,"+b&%' )+' ?%"*%)*%' 084G'

G#)@1"&#&' %' *%5' +&&15(,#' 15' @+"]@*%"' *"+)&,([email protected](!=()+"R' )+' 5%,(,+' %5' I1%' @"1K+' @#)C%@(5%)*#&',+']"%+',([email protected](!=()+"',+'+"I1(*%@*1"+'@#5' @#)C%@(5%)*#&',+']"%+',+'*%@)#=#D(+' ,(D(*+=' %' ,%' &(&*%5+&R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' )#' I1%' ,(K' "%&!%(*#' +#' *%&*%R' @#)V(D1"+>3#' %' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',%'!=+*+$#"5+&',%'@#51)(@+>3#'+&&%)*%&')+'E)*%")%*/ '

H&*+' 0(&&%"*+>3#' @#)&*(*1('15' 5#5%)*#' ,%'&A)*%&%' ,%&&+' ()?%&*(D+>3#R'!"#@1"+),#'

+!#)*+"',(?%"&+&' !#&&(B(=(,+,%&'%'@+5()C#&'I1%'!#,%"3#'&%"'&%D1(,#&')#'084G/'0%&*%'5#,#R' %&!%"+b&%' I1%'+' !"%&%)*%' 0(&&%"*+>3#' ,%' ;%&*"+,#' &%N+' 15' !#)*#' ,%' !+"*(,+' !+"+' )#?#Y&Z' *"+B+=C#Y&Z',%'()?%&*(D+>3#'%)I1+,"+,#&')+'5%&5+'*%5]*(@+'%'@#5'#BN%@*(?#&'@#51)&/

e ' G%)*"#' ,%' G#51)(@+>3#' %' 4%!"%&%)*+>3#' [email protected](+=' YGG4HZ-' T"1!#' ,%' E)?%&*(D+>3#' ()*%D"+,#' )#' EF0' ,+' [email protected]=,+,%' ,%' 8"I1(*%@*1"+',+'c)(?%"&(,+,%',#'.#"*#-'G%)*"#',%'H&*1,#&',%'8"I1(*%@*1"+'%'c"B+)(&5#'YGH8cZ/ g'O"+B+=C#'@#=+B#"+*(?#'%5'D+B()%*%&',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'1"B+)(&5#'%')#'%)&()#',%'+"*%&R'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'%)D%)C+"(+/ h'G#51)(@+>3#',%'@#)*%^,#&',%'@#)@1"&#&',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'1"B+)(&5#'%',+'*"+)&$#"5+>3#',#'+5B(%)*%'@#)&*"1A,#/ i'G#51)(@+>3#',%'@#)*%^,#&'"%[email protected](#)+,#&'@#5'*1"(&5#'@1=*1"+='%'!+*"(5J)(#'+"I1(*%@*J)(@#',+'@(,+,%/

@E

[email protected]+!2B*0$! '

\' #BN%@*#' ,%' %&*1,#' ,+' !"%&%)*%' 0(&&%"*+>3#' `' @#)&*(*1A,#' !%=#' 1)(?%"&#' ,+&'

+!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&' 1*(=(K+,+&')#'!"#@%&&#',#&'@#)@1"&#&'!^B=(@#&' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'%5' #1*"#&'!"#@%&&#&'"%=%?+)*%&/

[email protected]+!2B*0$'D!= '

O%),#' @#5#' B+&%' +' 8EG8R' !"%*%),%b&%' @#5' %&*%' *"+B+=C#' @#)&*"1("' 15' 5#,%=#' ,%'

5+*"(K' @+!+K' ,%' ,+"' #' &1!#"*%' )%@%&&]"(#' :' !#&*%"(#"' ()?%&*(D+>3#' %' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+' +!=(@+>3#/' H&&%' 5#,%=#' ,%?%"]' "%V=%@*("R' !#"' 15' =+,#R' 15+' "#$%&'(#)' ,%' +)]=(&%' @+!+K',%' +"*(@1=+"',(?%"&#&' @#)@%(*#&' "%[email protected](#)+,#&' @#5' +'()?%&*(D+>3#' %' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+' 8EG89' !#"' #1*"#R' ,%?%"]' $1)@(#)+"' @#5#' ()&*"15%)*#' ,%' "%D(&*#R' !%"5(*(),#' +$%"("' %' "%D(&*+"' C(!J*%&%&',%'()?%&*(D+>3#'%',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#'*%),#'!#"'B+&%'%&&%&'5%&5#&'@#)@%(*#&/ '

8' !"%&%)*%' 0(&&%"*+>3#' !"%*%),%' @#)&*(*1("b&%' @#5#' +' !"(5%("+' +!"#L(5+>3#'

%&*"1*1"+,+':'()?%&*(D+>3#'084G'G#)@1"&#&R'!%=#'I1%'!#&&1('@#5#'#BN%@*(?#&d/

0%V()(>3#R' :' =1K' ,#&' @#)@%(*#&' %)@#)*"+,#&' )#' ,%@1"&#' ,+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+R' ,%' 15+' $"+5%S#"Q!,%'"%D(&*#'%'+)]=(&%R' &#B' $#"5+',%'5+*"(KR'@+!+K',%'&%"?("' @#5#' ()&*"15%)*#' !+"+'%&*"1*1"+"'+'()$#"5+>3#'"%=+*(?+'+'!"()@A!(#&'!+"+'#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'8EG89

e/

4%D(&*#' %' %&*"1*1"+>3#' )%&&+' 5+*"(K' ,%' !"()@A!(#&' !+"+' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+' 8EG8R' "%@#""%),#' +' ,(?%"&#&' @+&#&' ,%' %&*1,#' Y*%L*#&' @"A*(@#&R' +!=(@+>a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+&' !+"+' @#)@1"&#&' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'%'#1*"+&' +!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&' "%[email protected](#)+,+&' @#5' D%&*3#',%' ()$#"5+>3#R'*"+B+=C#'@#=+B#"+*(?#R'%'51=*(5`,(+Z/

@F

d

a

b

e c

f

g 6(D/'jd-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#'W%)*%k/

6(D/' jg-' GJ,(D#' ()*"#,1K(,#' )#' %,(*#"' ,%' *%L*#' ! 6(D/'je-'0%V()(>3#',%'@"(*`"(#&'!+"+'V(=*"+D%5',()_5(@+',%'"%$%"M)@(+&/

+

"

+'

!"#@%&&+5%)*#' ,+' B(B=(#D"+V(+' ,%' [email protected]#",#' @#5' +' )

#

"

5

+'

B ( B = ( # D " ] V ( @ +' %&!%@(V(@+,+/

6(D/'jh-'GJ,(D#'()*"#,1K(,#')#'%,(*#"',%'*%L*#'!+"+'(,%)*(V(@+>3#',%'"%$%"M)@(+&'(),(?(,1+(&/

6(D/' ji-' \"D+)(K+>3#' ,#&' +)%L#&',(D(*+(&' ,%' [email protected]#",#' @#5'@"(*`"(#&' ,%V()(,#&' !%=#' 1*(=(K+,#"R' "%1*(=(K+),#' +' ()$#"5+>3#' ()*"#,1K(,+')#&'@+5!#&'B(B=(#D"]V(@#&/

@G

[email protected]+,F$!(! '

0%' $#"5+' +' +*()D("' #&' #BN%@*(?#&' %L!=(@(*+,#&' )#' !#)*#' +)*%"(#"R' $#(' )%@%&&]"(#'

%$%@*1+"' 15+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+' %5' *#")#' ,%' *%5]*(@+&' %&&%)@(+(&' @+!+K%&' ,%' $#")%@%"' 15+' B+&%' @#)@%!*1+=' !+"+' +' ,%V()(>3#' ,+' 5+*"(K' %' !#&*%"(#"' "%D(&*#' ,%' !"()@A!(#&' ,%' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#'!+"+'+'8EG8d/

4%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+' %5' *#")#' ,#' !#*%)@(+=' ,#' @#)*%L*#' ,+' W#@(%,+,%' ,+' E)$#"5+>3#R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' +' @#51)(@+>3#' %5' "%,%' %' +&' +=*%"+>a%&' :' 5%*#,#=#D(+' ,%' !"#N%@*#R' %)I1+)*#'#!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'8EG89

e/

4%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+' %5' *#")#' ,#' !#*%)@(+=' ,#' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %)I1+)*#' #!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+'!"#5#>3#',+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+R'%'(,%)*(V(@+>3#',%'[email protected]*#"%&'@+!+K%&' ,%'+'!"#5#?%"'#1'()(B("9

g/

4%?(&3#'=(*%"]"(+'%5' *#")#',+'*%5]*(@+',+'@#51)(@+>3#' %'"%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%'!"#N%@*#' %',#' 5%(#' @#)&*"1A,#R' !"#@1"+),#' (,%)*(V(@+"' I1+=(,+,%&' %' ,%V(@(M)@(+&' ,#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#',(&!#)A?%(&R'!+"+'15+'@#""%@*+'()*%D"+>3#')+'8EG8/

'

7#' ,%@1"&#' ,%&*+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+' $#"+5' 1*(=(K+,+&' ,(?%"&+&' $%""+5%)*+&' I1%'

!%"5(*("+5' )A?%(&' ,%' +B#",+D%5' ,($%"%)@(+,#&' %' @#5!=%5%)*+"%&/' 6#(' )#&&#' #BN%@*(?#' +' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,%' $%""+5%)*+&' *%@)#=JD(@+&' @+!+K%&' ,%' +1L(=(+"' #' "%D(&*#R' +' #"D+)(K+>3#' %' +"*(@1=+>3#',+'()$#"5+>3#R'%'@+!+K%&',%'&%'@#)&*(*1A"%5R'%=+&'5%&5+&R'@#5#'@+&#&',%'%&*1,#R' "+K3#' !%=+'I1+='@#)&(,%"]5#&' (5!#"*+)*%'+' &1+'"%$%"M)@(+/'8'"%=+>3#'@#5'+'8EG8'`'%?(,%)*%' !#(&'%=+'&%"]R'*+5B`5R'15+'!=+*+$#"5+',%'D%&*3#',%'()$#"5+>3#/ '

8&&(5R'*%),#'%&*+'()?%&*(D+>3#'!#"'#BN%@*(?#'#'5#,%=#',%'5+*"(K'!+"+'15+'+!=(@+>3#'

()$#"5]*(@+R' "%?%=#1b&%' %&&%)@(+=' !#,%"' %&*1,+"' %' *%&*+"' $%""+5%)*+&' %' +!=(@+>a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+&' I1%' !%"5(*(&&%5' +D(=(K+"' #&' !"#@%&&#&' ,%' @"(+>3#R' #"D+)(K+>3#' %' !%&I1(&+' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#/'8&&(5R'%)*"%'+&'+!=(@+>a%&'1*(=(K+,+&R',%&*[email protected]+5#&'+&'&%D1()*%&d/

8!=(@+>3#' W%)*%k l-' +!=(@+>3#' !+"+'D%&*3#' ,%'"%$%"M)@(+&' B(B=(#D"]V(@+&9'+' &1+' 1*(=(K+>3#' !%"5(*(1'+$%"("'+&'&%D1()*%&'I1+=(,+,%&d/d/

c5+'?(&3#'1)(V(@+,+',+'()*%"[email protected]%'+"*(@1=+),#'Y+Z'=(&*+D%5',+&'"%$%"M)@(+&'@#5'YBZ' #&' @+5!#&' B(B=(#D"]V(@#&' +&&#@(+,#&R' [email protected]'+)%L#&' %5' $#"5+*#' ,(D(*+=' %'Y,Z' V(=*"#&' !+"+'!%&I1(&+',%'"%$%"M)@(+&9

l'''YOC(",'W*"%%*'W#*S+"%'E)@R')/,/Z/

@H

6(D/'jm-'W%@>3#',+'%&*"1*1"+',+'()?%&*(D+>3#/

6(D/'jn-'W%@>3#',+'"%?(&3#'B(B=(#D"]V(@+//

6(D/'jq-'.+"*(@1=+"(K+>3#',#'*J!(@#'+&&()+=+,#')+'6(D/'jn'!%"5(*(),#' *"+B+=C+"')#'!+"*(@1=+"'&%5'!%",%"'+')#>3#',#'*#,#/

6(D/'jl-'W%@>3#',+'%&*"1*1"+',+'()?%&*(D+>3#/ 6(D/'dj-'8&&#@(+>3#',%',(?%"&#&'@#)*%^,#&'+#&'*J!(@#&o&1B*J!(@#&/

6(D/'dd-'p(&1+=(K+>3#',#&'5%&5#&'@#)*%^,#&'%5',(?%"&#&'$#"5+*#&/

@I

d/e/

8'+*"(B1(>3#',%'V(=*"#&' %&*]*(@#&'X'I1(@Q*+D&'Y%Z'X'%'V(=*"#&' ,()_5(@#&'X'@#==%@*(#)&'' :&'"%$%"M)@(+&'@#5'B+&%'%5'@"(*`"(#&',%V()(,#&'!%=#'1*(=(K+,#"m9

d/g/

8' +"*(@1=+>3#' @#5' +'+!=(@+>3#' ,%' %,(>3#' ,%' *%L*#-'&%=%@@(#)+,+' +' "%$%"M)@(+' )+' ()*%"[email protected]%',#'W%)*%kR'B+&*+'15' !"#@%&&#',%'@#!(+"[email protected]#=+"'!+"+'&%"'()*"#,1K(,#' 15' @J,(D#' )#' *%L*#' I1%' &%"]' +1*#5+*(@+5%)*%' ,%[email protected]#,(V(@+,#' )+' B(B=(#D"+V(+' ,%' [email protected]#",#'@#5'+')#"5+'&%=%@@(#)+,+9

d/h/

8' +"*(@1=+>3#' @#5' #' &(&*%5+' ,%'V(@C%("#&' ,#' &(&*%5+' #!%"+*(?#' ,#' @#5!1*+,#"R' !%"5(*(),#' #' +"I1(?+5%)*#' %' #"D+)(K+>3#' ,#&' +)%L#&' ,(D(*+(&' %5' !+&*+&' %' V(@C%("#&' ,%' [email protected]#",#' @#5' @"(*`"(#&' !"%,%V()(,#&R' "%1*(=(K+),#' +' ()$#"5+>3#' ()*"#,1K(,+' )#&' @+5!#&' B(B=(#D"]V(@#&n9'#&' +)%L#&' V(@+5' +"I1(?+,#&' )#' V(@C%("#' ^)(@#',+'+!=(@+>3#'D+"+)*(),#'+&&(5'+'!#"*+B(=(,+,%',+&'"%$%"M)@(+&/

e/

8!=(@+>3#'r;(),k 9-'+!=(@+>3#'!+"+'@"(+>3#' ,%'5+!+&' 5%)*+(&9'+'&1+'1*(=(K+>3#' !%"5(*(1' +$%"("'+&'&%D1()*%&'I1+=(,+,%&e/d/

8,%I1+>3#'+'5^=*(!=#&'1&#&9')+'!"%&%)*%'0(&&%"*+>3#'#&'5+!+&'5%)*+(&'&%"?("+5' !+"+' %&*"1*1"+"' +' ()?%&*(D+>3#R' "%D(&*+"' &A)*%&%&' ,+&' "%?(&a%&' B(B=(#D"]V(@+&' %$%@*1+,+&R' %&*"1*1"+,+&' !#"' +1*#"o#B"[email protected]+!A*1=#R' %' !"#,1K("' 5+!+&' 5%)*+(&' !+"+'&%"?("%5'@#5#'&A)*%&%&'D"]V(@+&',%',%*%"5()+,#&'@#)*%^,#&9

e/e/

[email protected](=(,+,%' ,%' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,+' ()*%"[email protected]%R' )#5%+,+5%)*%' )#' I1%' ,(K' "%&!%(*#' :' @"(+>3#' ,%' *J!(@#&' %' &1B*J!(@#&' %' &1+' "%#"D+)(K+>3#' 5%,(+)*%' &(5!=%&' ,"+DF,"#!9' !#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%' *"+B+=C+"' &(51=*+)%+5%)*%' )#' *#,#' %' )+' !+"*%' 5%,(+)*%'+*"(B1(>3#',#'s$#@#t'+',%*%"5()+,#'*J!(@#'#1'&1B*J!(@#'9

e/g/

[email protected](,+,%',%' +&&#@(+"' %'"%[email protected](#)+"'@#)*%^,#&' ,%')+*1"%K+',(?%"&+'+#&' *J!(@#&o &1B*J!(@#&-' C(!%"=(D+>a%&' !+"+' !]D()+&' )+' E)*%")%*' %' =(D+>a%&' +' V(@C%("#&' =#@+(&' @#5#'(5+D%)&R'?A,%#&'%'&#)&R')#*+&R'!+=+?"[email protected]+?%'%'[email protected]#)%&9

e/h/

[email protected](,+,%' ,%' ?(&1+=(K+>3#' ,#&' @#)*%^,#&' %5' ,(?%"&#&' $#"5+*#&-'%5' $#"5+' ,%' *%L*#'#1'%5'$#"5+*#'D"]V(@#R',%'[email protected]#",#'@#5'?]"(#&'*(!#&',%'=+P#1*'!"`b,%V()(,#&/

m'7#' %L%5!=#'+#' =+,#' $#('&#=(@(*+,+' +'+!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%'"%$%"M)@(+&'I1%' !#&&1A&&%5'#' 5+"@+,#"'sG#)@/'8"I1(*%@*1"+t' %' @#5',+*+' ,%'!1B=(@+>3#'!#&*%"(#"'+#'+)#'ejjj/ n'7#' %L%5!=#' +#'=+,#' $#('&#=(@(*+,+'+' #"D+)(K+>3#' ,#&'+)%L#&' %5'!+&*+&',%'[email protected]#",#' @#5'#' )#5%' ,#' +1*#"'Y+!%=(,#R' du' )#5%Z' %'+' ,+*+',+'!1B=(@+>3#'Y+)#ZR'&%),#'#'V(@C%("#'"%)#5%+,#',%'[email protected]#",#'@#5'#'*A*1=#',+'!1B=(@+>3#/ q''Yr;(),'2*,R')/,/Z/

@<

'

H&*+&' ,1+&' $%""+5%)*+&'"%?%=+"+5b&%'%V(@+K%&')+'(,%)*(V(@+>3#' %'"%D(&*#' ,%'+1*#"%&' %'

#B"+&'5+(&'"%=%?+)*%&'!+"+'%&*+'()?%&*(D+>3#R'+1L(=(+),#')#'!"#@%&&#',%'"%@#=C+'B(B=(#D"]V(@+' &#B"%' #&' *%5+&' %)1)@(+,#&' )#&' #BN%@*(?#&' ,+' 0(&&%"*+>3#R' B%5' @#5#' )+' %&*"1*1"+>3#' ,+' !"J!"(+' 0(&&%"*+>3#' I1%R' !#"' )+*1"%K+R' &%' ?(1' #B"(D+,+' +' +,#!*+"' I1%"' 15' @+"]@*%"' 5+(&' D%)%"+=(&*+R'I1%"'15'@+"]@*%"'5+(&'%&!%@AV(@#/ '

\' %&*1,#' &%"]' ()(@(+,#' )#' !"JL(5#' @+!A*1=#' X' H&*+,#' ,+' 8"*%' X' ,%' #),%' ,%?%"3#'

&1"D("' #&' @#)@%(*#&' $1),+5%)*+(&' !+"+'+' !#&*%"(#"' %=+B#"+>3#' ,#' 5#,%=#' ,%'5+*"(K' !+"+' #' 084G'G#)@1"&#&/

@B

[email protected]+*=$#%$%#) '

8' 0(&&%"*+>3#' %)@#)*"+b&%' %&*"1*1"+,+' %5' ,1+&' !+"*%&' $1),+5%)*+(&R'

@#""%&!#),%)*%&'+#&' @+!A*1=#&' e'%'gR'"%&!%@*(?+5%)*%R' #'H&*+,#' ,+'8"*%'%' +' 8EG8/'8&' !+"*%&' )3#' !"#@1"+5' "%V=%@*("' 15+'#!#&(>3#'O%#"(+o."]*(@+R'!#&(>3#'I1%'&%"(+'&(5!=(&*+'%'+5BAD1+9' !#,%5#&R')#' %)*+)*#R'@#)&(,%"+"'#' H&*+,#',+'8"*%'15'@+!A*1=#'5+(&'D%)%"+=(&*+'%'+'8EG8'15' @+!A*1=#'5+(&'%&!%@AV(@#R',("%@@(#)+,#'+#'%$%@*(?#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'+!=(@+>3#/ '

7#' H&*+,#' ,+' 8"*%' &%"]' %$%@*1+,+' 15+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+' %5' *"M&' !#)*#&' &#B"%'

*%5]*(@+&'I1%'@#)&(,%"]5#&'%&&%)@(+(&'!+"+'#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',#'*"+B+=C#d/

W#@(%,+,%' ,+' E)$#"5+>3#' %' ,+' G#51)(@+>3#' X' I1%' !"#@1"+"]' %L!=(@(*+"' #' @#)*%L*#' @#)*%5!#"_)%#' #),%' +' @"(+>3#R' 5+)(!1=+>3#' %' @#51)(@+>3#' ,%' @#)*%^,#&' %5' "%,%' +&&15%'!+!%='!"(5#",(+=')+'*"+)&$#"5+>3#' ,+'@(,+,%'%',#'(),(?A,1#',+'WER'@#)*%L*#' %&&%' !+"+'#'I1+='@#)*"(B1A"+5'#&'&%I1%)@(+(&'+?+)>#&'*%@)#=JD(@#&')+'@#5!1*+>3#'%'E)*%")%*9

e/

G#)@1"&#' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+'X'I1%'!"#@1"+"]' (,%)*(V(@+"'#&' 5#*(?#&' I1%'+!%=+5' +#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+'8EG8R' ,%&(D)+,+5%)*%' +' )%@%&&(,+,%',%' "%&!#),%"' :&' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&' @#5!=%L+&' %L(DM)@(+&' ,#' !"#N%@*#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' %5' !+"*(@1=+"' ,+I1%=%'()&%"(,#')15'@#)@1"&#R'%':')%@%&&(,+,%',%'!"#5#?%"'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+9

g/

G#51)(@+>3#'%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#',%'!"#N%@*#' X'I1%'!"#@1"+"]'"%@#)C%@%"'+'@[email protected](,+,%'I1%' !#&&1A5#&' %5' @#51)(@+"' +*"+?`&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&R' B%5' @#5#' +' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' +&' +,+!*+"'+#&'#BN%@*(?#&'%'+#&',%&*()+*]"(#&',+'@#51)(@+>3#R'&+=(%)*+),#'+'(5!#"*_)@(+',#' &1!#"*%',(D(*+='%'()*%"[email protected]*(?#')+'!"#5#>3#',%'15+'@#51)(@+>3#'5+(&'%V(@+K/

'

\&' *"M&' !#)*#&R' +=`5' ,%' !"#@1"+"%5' ,%5#)&*"+"' #' @=(5+' ,%' #!#"*1)(,+,%' I1%'

@#)&(,%"+5#&' %L(&*("' !+"+'#' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+'8!=(@+>3#' E)$#"5]*(@+R' ("3#'$#")%@%"' +'B+&%' @#)@%!*1+=' I1%' &%"]' $1),+5%)*+=' !+"+' +' %=+B#"+>3#' ,+' &%D1),+' !+"*%',+'0(&&%"*+>3#R' I1%' &%"]'%&*"1*1"+,+'%5'*"M&'5#5%)*#&d/

0%V()(>3#' ,%'15+'5+*"(K',%' +)]=(&%' @#5' B+&%')+'"%?(&3#'=(*%"]"(+' %$%@*1+,+R')#&'I1+*"#' *%5+&' $1),+5%)*+(&' ,%*%"5()+,#&' Y1*(=(K+,#"R' ()*%"[email protected]%R' %&*"1*1"+' %' @#)*%^,#Z' %' )+' $"+5%S#"Q',%'+)]=(&%'@#)&*"1A,+'!+"+'=C%',+"'&1!#"*%9

e/

0%*%"5()+>3#' ,%' ,%K' (),(@+,#"%&' $1),+5%)*+(&' !+"+' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+' 8EG8R' &1!#"*+,+'!%=+',%[email protected]"(>3#',%',(?%"&+&'$#)*%&'%'+!=(@+>a%&'%L(&*%)*%&9

g/

W(&*%5+*(K+>3#',%&&%&'(),(@+,#"%&')+'5+*"(K',%'+)]=(&%/

DC

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

'

*J)%$65&56*5&*+,-)./&'()*6*5&*2)/3,$%&'()* *2),%3.4)*56*&.73$16%13.&*6*"&.1$%$"&'()*"K9#$%& *2)/3,$%&'()*6*.6".646,1&'()*56*".)=6%1)

ESTADO DA ARTE

[email protected]

DA*L41&5)*5&*!.1688

DA*L41&5)*5&*!.16

DD

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

6(D/'de-'7%1"#)'()'*C%'+5PD,+=+

ESTADO DA ARTE

[email protected]?+4!0'*()(*+()+5&6!#,)-.!+*+()+H!,%&'0)-.!+

!"#"#$%&$'(%&%)*$%&$+)%)$)$%,$(-%(./%0,$%&$12$ '

8'C(&*J"(+'%'+'5#"$#=#D(+',+&'@(,+,%&'`'(),(&&#@(]?%=',+&'"%=+>a%&'&#@(+(&'I1%')%=+&'&%'

%&*+B%=%@%5/'8' @(,+,%'`'15' @#5!=%L#' +"*%[email protected]*#' C15+)#'I1%'%L!"%&&+',%'$#"5+'@"(&*+=()+'+' *+5B`5' @#5!=%L+'+"*(@1=+>3#' ,+'&#@(%,+,%' I1%'#' @#)&*"J(/'8=`5' ,+',(5%)&3#' 5+*%"(+='I1%' =C%' `' ()%"%)*%R' +' @(,+,%' `' *+5B`5' @#)&*"1A,+' !%=+&' "%=+>a%&' &#@(+(&' %&*+B%=%@(,+&' !%=#&' @(,+,3#&' %)I1+)*#'(),(?A,1#&' %'%)I1+)*#'5%5B"#&',%'?]"(#&' D"1!#&'&#@(+(&R'@+,+'I1+='@#5' ,($%"%)*%&' D"+1&' ,%' "%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%'%' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' ()*%"?%)>3#' )+' @#)&*"1>3#' ,#' *%@(,#' 1"B+)#',+'@(,+,%/ '

8' ()$#"5+>3#' %'+' @#51)(@+>3#' ,%&%5!%)C+5' 15' !+!%=' (5!#"*+)*%')+'@#)&*"1>3#'

,+&' @(,+,%&/'G#)*1,#R'WE'`R'C#N%R'15' @#)@%(*#'=+"D+5%)*%'1*(=(K+,#'!+"+',%&(D)+"'+'&#@(%,+,%' @#)*%5!#"_)%+',+' %"+',(D(*+=R',#'@#5!1*+,#"' %',+'E)*%")%*' X' 15+'&#@(%,+,%'I1%'+!%&+"',%' )3#'*%"'()?%)*+,#'#'@#)@%(*#',%'"%,%'djR'&%5',^?(,+'#'+5!=(#1/ '

8' "%,%' `R' ,%' [email protected]*#R' 15' @#)@%(*#' $1),+5%)*+=' !#(&' @#)*`5' %5' &(' +&' )#>a%&' ,%'

+!"#L(5+>3#R',%'=(D+>3#R',%'+"*(@1=+>3#R',%'"%[email protected](#)+5%)*#'X'%R')+'WER'`'15'@#)@%(*#'@+,+'?%K' 5+(&' "%[email protected](#)+,#' @#5' +' %&*"1*1"+>3#R' +' 5+)(!1=+>3#' %' +' *"+)&5(&&3#' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#-' %&*"1*1"+"' +' ()$#"5+>3#' %5' "%,%' !#&&(B(=(*+b)#&' )#?+&' $#"5+&' ,%' "%[email protected](#)+"' %' [email protected]%,%"' :' ()$#"5+>3#R' 5+(&' !"JL(5+&' ,+' )%1"#V(&(#=#D(+' C15+)+' %' ,#' 5#,%=#' ,%' +!"%),(K+D%5' @#)%L(#)(&*+ddR'$#"5+&'%&&+&'I1%'N]'&%'%)@#)*"+5'+'&%"'1*(=(K+,+&' %5'+!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&' @#5#'#'5#*#"',%'!%&I1(&+'0%=(@(#1&de '#1'+';+D(@'vC%%=',+'T##D=%dg9'5+)(!1=+"'+'()$#"5+>3#' %5' "%,%'!%"5(*%b)#&' )#?+&' $#"5+&' ,%'*"+B+=C#' @#=+B#"+*(?#9' %' *"+)&5(*("' +' ()$#"5+>3#' %5' "%,%' !%"5(*%' 15+' 5+(#"' %V(@]@(+' )+' ,(&*"(B1(>3#' ,%&&+' ()$#"5+>3#R' [email protected]+)>+),#' 5+(#"' ?(&(B(=(,+,%/'

dj' 4%$%"(5#b)#&'I1%"'+' "%,%&'VA&(@+&'%' 5+*%"(+(&'X' @#5#' +&' %&*"+,+&R' #&'@+5()C#&b,%b$%""#' X' I1%"'+'"%,%&',(D(*+(&'X' +'E)*%")%*R' +&'"%,%&'*%=%$J)(@+&R'%*@/ dd'8'+"I1(*%@*1"+' @#)%L(#)(&*+' `'()*(5+5%)*%' ()&!("+,+')+'+"I1(*%@*1"+' ,#'@`"%B"#' C15+)#R'!"%$%"(),#' 1*(=(K+"'#&'@#)@%(*#&',%' )J' %' ,%' "%,%' %5'&1B&*(*1(>3#' +#&' @#)@%(*#&',%' )%1"J)(#' %' ,%' &()+!&%9' #&' )J&'&3#' ()*%"@#)%@*+,#&'%)*"%' &(R' !#,%),#' $#"5+"'%' $+K%"'!+"*%',%',(?%"&+&'"%,%&'#),%'`'+"5+K%)+,#'#'@#)C%@(5%)*#/''Y;%)%K%&R'ejdjZ de'8!=(@+>3#' I1%' %&*"1*1"+' +&'!]D()+&',+' E)*%")%*',%' [email protected]#",#' @#5'!+=+?"[email protected]+?%'X' +&'*+D&'X',%V()(,+&'!%=#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&R'&%),#' !#&&A?%=' )+?%D+"' !#"'*+D&' #1' @#)N1)*#&' ,%' *+D&' %R' +&&(5R' %)@#)*"+"' @#)*%^,#&' )+' E)*%")%*' ,%' 15+' $#"5+' 5+(&' &%5_)*(@+' %' 5%)#&'=(*%"+=/''Yw+C##xR'ejdjZ dg ' 8' ;+D(@' vC%%=' `' 15+' #!>3#' ,%' ?(&1+=(K+>3#' ,#&' "%&1=*+,#&',#' 5#*#"' ,%' !%&I1(&+' ,+' T##D=%R' #),%' %&*%&' &%' %)@#)*"+5' %&*"1*1"+,#&'%5'"%,%R'&%),#'!#&&A?%='+')+?%D+>3#',#'1*(=(K+,#"'!#"'%&&+'"%,%/

DE

DF

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

6(D/'dg-'\.OH'."#N%@*-'5+!+',+'E)*%")%*'%5'ejjg

6(D/'dh-'81*#%&*"+,+'%5'y+)DQ#QR'O+(=_),(+'

ESTADO DA ARTE

'

\' @#)@%(*#' N]' C+?(+' &(,#' %)1)@(+,#' !#"' p+))%?+"' y1&C' Yy1&CR' dqhiZR' I1%' &%'

!"#)1)@(#1' @#)*"+' +&' $#"5+&' %&*]*(@+&' ,%' #"D+)(K+>3#' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#' I1%' (5!%"+?+5' )+' @#51)(,+,%'@(%)*AV(@+/' 8&' !+=+?"+&' ,%'y1&C'&3#' *3#' @=+"+&' %'[email protected]*1+(&'I1+)*#' #=C+"' !+"+'15+' ]"?#"%',%'V(@C%("#&',#&'5+(&'"%@%)*%&'W(&*%5+&'\!%"+*(?#&dh / '

H5'+=*%")+*(?+'+'%&*%'5#,%=#'%&*]*(@#R'y1&C'!"#!a%'15'5#,%=#'#),%'#'I1%'()*%"%&&+'

)3#' `'#' =1D+"' #),%'#'@#)*%^,#' &%'%)@#)*"+'D1+",+,#R'5+&'+&'+&&#@(+>a%&'I1%')#&' !%"5(*%5' @C%D+"' +*`' %=%' %' +&' I1%R' +' !+"*("' ,%=%R' )#&' !%"5(*%5' @C%D+"' +' @#)*%^,#&' "%[email protected](#)+,#&/' 7+' @#)*%5!#"_)%+'v%B'e/jR'!#,%5#&'@=+&&(V(@+"'%&*+&'+&&#@(+>a%&'@#5#'*+D&*+,&!,-%$.! %/.0! 0(&1! .(2! '(#)! 2,$2! '$34! 52! (6&#$2&1! 73! 84449! 2,&! $11(:/$2/(.! ("!2,(-;,21!!8?-1,3#' ,%'

@#)*%^,#&' ,(D(*+(&' @#5#' (5+D%)&R' V(=5%&' %'&#)&/' 73#' !#,%5#&R'@#)*1,#R' %&I1%@%"' +&' "%,%&' +)+=JD(@+&' X' +&' "1+&R' +&' %&*"+,+&R' #&' @+5()C#&b,%b$%""#' X' !#"' #),%'@("@1=+5' +&' !%&&#+&R'#&' *"+)&!#"*%&' %' +&' 5%"@+,#"(+&9' ,%?%5#&R' )#' %)*+)*#R' "%@#)C%@%"' I1%' +&' "%,%&' ,(D(*+(&' &%' %)@#)*"+5' +'+,I1("("' @+,+' ?%K'5+(&' (5!#"*_)@(+' [email protected]%':&' +)+=JD(@+&' X' %'+*`'+&' ^=*(5+&' N]' &%' %)@#)*"+5' +' &%"' ?("*1+=(K+,+&' %5' 51),#&' +=*%")+*(?#&' ,(D(*+(&' @#5#' #' W%@#),'2($%di ' %' #' T##D=%'H+"*C dlR'+(),+'I1%'#'@#)@%(*#',%'51),#'?("*1+=')3#'&%N+')#?#'%'&%5!"%'*%)C+5#& D84449!&12$0(!0&!$=;-%$!"(#%$! &.E(=E/0(1!:(%!%-.0(1!E/#2-$/1!0&10&!(!$=E(#&:&#!0$!#&=/;/F(!84449! -%!D$G-/D!&!-%!%H12/:(!D$=/D4D!!8I6/==#',%&*+&'"%,%&'*%5'!"#5#?(,#R'+=`5',+&'%?(,%)*%&'+=*%"+>a%&'5#"$#=JD(@+&'

)+&' @(,+,%&R' +=*%"+>a%&')+'!%"@%!>3#' %'@#5!#"*+5%)*#&'I1%'#&' (),(?A,1#&' %'D"1!#&' &#@(+(&' 5+)($%&*+5' &#B"%' %=+&-' #' I1%' %"+' =#)DA)I1#' !+&&+' +' %&*+"' 5+(&' !%"*#R' %' #' I1%' %"+' ,%[email protected]#)C%@(,#'5+(&'[email protected](=5%)*%'&%'*#")+'[email protected]%&&A?%= dm/'8&'@"%[email protected]%)*%&'[email protected](=(,+,%&',%'@#51)(@+>3#' !#,%5R'@#)*1,#R' *#")+"b&%' )15+' !"(&3#' !+"+' #' (),(?A,1#' ,+'WER' ,%&*()+,#' +' %&*+"R' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&R'&%5!"%'#)=()%/ D84449!$-%&.2$#! $! 0/12#/7-/TF(! 0(! -1(! 0$1!2&:.(=(;/$1!0&! /."(#%$TF(! &! :(%-./:$TF(! 8+5U9!.(! %-.0(!V:/0&.2$=!W!:$6$Q!0&!;&#$#!%-0$.T$1!2#X;/:$1!.(1!&12/=(1!0&!E/0$3#' ,(D(*+=R'%'+'!"#,1K("'?+"(+,#&'*(!#&',%'()$#"5+>3#',%'15+'$#"5+'&(&*%5]*(@+/'G#)*1,#R'&%'!#"' 15' =+,#' %=%' &%' ,%&,#B"+' %5' 5^=*(!=+&' !%"&#)+=(,+,%&R' !#"' #1*"#' %=%' ,%&%N+' &%"' 15' &J' %' [email protected]%,%"':'&1+'()$#"5+>3#')15'&J'=1D+"/'H&&+'@#),(>3#' [email protected](=(*+')3#'&J'#'[email protected]%&&#',%&&%'(),(?A,1#' :'&1+'()$#"5+>3#R'%?(*+),#'+'&1+',(&!%"&3#'!%=#&'?]"(#&'%I1(!+5%)*#&' !#"'%=%'5+)1&%+,#&R' @#5#' *+5B`5' [email protected](=(*+' +' &1+' !+"*(=C+R' %?(*+),#' +' 51=*(!=(@+>3#' ,+' ()$#"5+>3#/' 6"1*#' ,+' I1+)*(,+,%' %L!#)%)@(+=' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#' ,($%"%)@(+,+' I1%' %&*%' (),(?A,1#' !"#,1KR' )3#' =C%' "%&*+"]R',%@%"*#R'+=*%")+*(?+'&%)3#'+'&1+'D%&*3#' @%)*"+=(K+,+/'7%&*%'@#)*%L*#R' @#)@%(*#&' @#5#' @=#1,'@#5!1*()D dn'%',+*+'&P)@C"#)(K+*(#)dq'+&&15%5'15+'(5!#"*_)@(+'@+,+'?%K'5+(#"')+'WE/ '

\'(),(?A,1#',+'WE'!"%@(&+'@#51)(@+"' ,(?%"&#&'*(!#&',%'()$#"5+>3#'X'*%L*#&R'(5+D%)&R'

?A,%#&R'%*@/'X'%'@#5',(?%"&#&'#BN%@*(?#&'X'!"#5#>3#'!%&&#+=R'*"+B+=C#'@#=+B#"+*(?#R'%*@//'%'!+"+' (&&#' "%@#""%' +' +!=(@+>a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+&R' I1%' =C%' !%"5(*%5' 5+)*%"' %&&+' @#51)(@+>3#' @#5' #1*"#&'(),(?A,1#&/'7#'!"#@%&&#R'%=%'[email protected]+B+'!#"'*%"'I1%'@#51)(@+"'@#5'%&&+&'+!=(@+>a%&R'I1%'&%' ,%&%N+5R'!#"'(&&#'5%&5#R'@+,+'?%K'5+(&'()*%"[email protected]*(?+&'%'$]@%(&',%'1*(=(K+"/ '

8'()$#"5+>3#'*+5B`5'&%',%&%N+R'@+,+'?%K'5+(&R'!#"*]*(=/

dm 'y+&*+b)#&'!%)&+"')#' T##D=%' H+"*C' 'YT##D=%R'ejdj+ZR' 15+'+!=(@+>3#' I1%' )#&'!%"5(*%' ?(&(*+"'?("*1+=5%)*%'I1+=I1%"' =1D+"',#' D=#B#'*%""%&*"%R'$#")%@%),#b)#&',+,#&'!"%@(&#&'&#B"%'%&&+&'=#@+=(K+>a%&/ dn's8' G=#1,'(&'+'*P!%' #$'!+"+==%=' +),',(&*"(B1*%,'&P&*%5'@#)&(&*()D'#$'+' @#==%@*(#)'#$'()*%"[email protected]#))%@*%,'+),'?("*1+=(K%,'@#5!1*%"&' *C+*' +"%' ,P)+5(@+==P' !"#?(&(#)%,' +),' !"%&%)*%,' +&' #)%' #"' 5#"%' 1)(V(%,' @#5!1*()D' "%"@%&' B+&%,' #)' &%"?(@%b=%?%=' +D"%%5%)*&'%&*+B=(&C%,'*C"#1DC')%D#*(+*(#)'B%*S%%)'*C%'&%"?(@%'!"#?(,%"'+),'@#)&15%"&/t''Yy1PP+R'w%#R'F'p%)1D#!+=R'ejjnZ/ dq ' s0+*+' &P)@C"#)(K+*(#)' *%@C)#=#D(%&' +"%' ,%&(D)%,' *#' &P)@C"#)(K%' +' &()D=%' &%*' #$' ,+*+' B%*S%%)' *S#' #"' 5#"%' ,%?(@%&R' +1*#5+*(@+==P' @#!P()D' @C+)D%&' [email protected]' +),' $#"*C' Y///Z' 0+*+' &P)@C"#)(K+*(#)' @+)' B%' =#@+=' &P)@C"#)(K+*(#)' SC%"%' *C%' ,%?(@%' +),' @#5!1*%"' +"%' &(,%bBPb&(,%' +),' ,+*+' (&' *"+)&$%""%,' #"' "%5#*%' &P)@C"#)(K+*(#)' SC%)' +' 1&%"' (&' 5#B(=%' +),' *C%' ,+*+' (&' &P)@C"#)(K%,'#?%"'+'5#B(=%')%*S#"Q/t''Yf1()W*"%%*'E)@/R'ejdjZ

ESTADO DA ARTE

D[(#2X2/=!1F(!(1!6#(O&:2(13#' [email protected]%&&A?%='%5' I1+=I1%"' =1D+"R'%5'

I1+=I1%"' C#"]"(#R' %' %5' I1+=I1%"' %I1(!+5%)*#' ,(D(*+=/' 8' E)*%")%*' +V("5+b&%' @#5#' +' !=+*+$#"5+' [email protected]%&&A?%=' !#"' )+*1"%K+R' %' +&' +!=(@+>a%&' S%BbB+&%, ej ' &3#' 15' !+&&#' =JD(@#' %' %?#=1*(?#',%'15'!"#@%&&#'I1%'@#5%>#1'!%=#&',+,#&'%'@#)*()1+'+D#"+'@#5'+&'+!=(@+>a%&R'I1%' *+5B`5' &%' ,%&%N+5' !#"*]*%(&/' 8=`5' ,(&&#R' +' [email protected]%&&(B(=(,+,%' :' E)*%")%*! N]' &%' %&*%),%1' !+"+' +=`5',#'@#5!1*+,#"'V(L#'!+"+'()@=1("',(&!#&(*(?#&'5J?%(&'@#5#'#'@#5!1*+,#"'!#"*]*(=R'#'!,+R' #'*%=%5J?%=R'%'=%(*#"',%'%B##Q&/ '

\' (),(?A,1#' ,+' WE' !%"*%)@%' +&&(5' +' 15' @"%[email protected]%)*%' )^5%"#' ,%' "%,%&' ,(D(*+(&' %'

+)+=JD(@+&R'%'+'@(,+,%'+!%"@%B%1b&%' I1%' %"+' )%@%&&]"(#' "%[email protected](#)+"' %&&+&' "%,%&'%)*"%'&(' !+"+' ,+"' "%&!#&*+':&' )%@%&&(,+,%&' ,%&&%'(),(?A,1#/'\'@#)@%(*#' )3#' `' 15+' ()?%)>3#' ,+'WE-' @#5#' +!#)*+'2(&B#+R'N]'G=+1,%'z%)"P',%'W+()*'W(5#)'C+?(+'@#)&*"1A,#R'%5'\&!=$!]&(#;$./Q$2/(.!0&! M$!I(:/&2W'YdndhZ'%'M&!^(-E&$-!U,#/12/$./1%&'YdneiZR'15'%)*%),(5%)*#',+'&#@(%,+,%'@#5#!D84449!(#;$./1%(!84449!"(#%$0(!6(#!-%!2&:/0(!0&!#&0&13#' X' B+&*+b)#&' !%)&+"' )+&' "%,%&' &%5' V(#&R')#&' *%=%5J?%(&R' )#' y=1%*##*CR')+' E)*%")%*9' +' !"%&%)>+' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(#"' ,%&*+&' "%,%&' !+"%@%' ,%?%"b&%R' !"%@(&+5%)*%R' :' &1+' +1&M)@(+'X'5+*%"(+='X'I1%'[email protected](=(*+'+'&1+'(5!=%5%)*+>3#-'&%'+'V(B"+'J!*(@+'%'+'+1*#b%&*"+,+'&3#' @#5!+"]?%(&'%5' *%"5#&' ,+'!"#5%&&+',%'?%=#@(,+,%'I1%'@#)*M5R'#'5%&5#')3#'&%'!#,%',(K%"' ,+'&1+'[email protected](=(,+,%',%'(5!=%5%)*+>3#')+'@(,+,%/ '

H&*%'!+"+,#L#'1=*"+!+&&+'+'"%,%'%'%&*%),%b&%'+#&' &%1&' %$%(*#&-'+'"%,%'I1%'+!"#L(5+R'

I1%'"%[email protected](#)+R'I1%'!"#5#?%'+'@#51)(@+>3#R' !#,%'B%5'!+1*+"b&%'!#"'!"()@A!(#&'@#)*"]"(#&'%' !"#5#?%"' +)*%&' +' 5+)(!1=+>3#' %' #' (&#=+5%)*#' X' @#)*"+,(>3#' ,%' 15+' &#@(%,+,%' @#)*%5!#"_)%+' #),%' #' $%)J5%)#' ,+' D=#B+=(K+>3#' !+"%@%' +!"#L(5+"b)#&' 5+(&' ,#&' I1%' )#&'

ej'8!=(@+>a%&'I1%')3#',%!%),%5',+' ()&*+=+>3#' ,%'&#$*S+"%'+,(@(#)+=')#' @#5!1*+,#"'!+"+' +=`5',#')+?%D+,#"',+'E)*%")%*'X'!#"' ,%$%(*#R'!"`b()&*+=+,#'%'!"#)*#'+'1*(=(K+"/

DI

D<

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

%&*3#'=#)D%',#'I1%',#&'I1%')#&'%&*3#'!%"*#/ '

\'(),(?A,1#' ,+' WE' !"#5#?%'#' &%1'(&#=+5%)*#' )+'!"#@1"+',+Y&Z' &1+Y&Z' (,%)*(,+,%Y&Z'

#)=()%-'%=%' 1*(=(K+' +'"%,%'!+"+' %L!"%&&+"' #' &%1' 51),#R'+' &1+' @#)[email protected](M)@(+R' #&' &%1&' C]B(*#&' %' ?+=#"%&9'+'[email protected](=(,+,%'%'+'?%=#@(,+,%'@#5'I1%'(&*#' !#,%' &%"' $%(*#'[email protected]*1+=5%)*%'X'!%)&%5#&')+' %L!=#&3#' ,+&'+!=(@+>a%&',%'"%,%&'&#@(+(&' )+'E)*%")%*' X'@#)&*(*1%5'15' %&*A51=#' %'!"#5#?%5' 15+' )%@%&&(,+,%' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(#"' %5' %&*+"' #)=()%R' !"#@%&&#' N]' ()(@(+,#' @#5' +' ()?%)>3#' ,#' *%=%5J?%=/ DZ! $:&=&#$TF(! 0$! E&=(:/0$0&! 0&! :/#:-=$TF(! 0$! /."(#%$TF(! :(##&16(.0&! $! -%$! 6#(:-#$! 0&! /.0/E/0-$=/0$0&+'(),(?(,1+=')+'E)*%")%*'*#")#1b&%'#B"(D+*J"(+'!+"+'#&'(),(?A,1#&'%'!+"+'+&'

%5!"%&+&R' I1%' !"#@1"+5' %L!"%&&+"' +' &1+' (),(?(,1+=(,+,%R' (,%)*(,+,%' %' 5+"@+"' +' &1+' !"%&%)>+'#)=()%R' )15' %&$#">#' I1%'!#,%'@#)*%"'%5' &('15',%&%N#' @#51)(@+*(?#'5+&R' *+5B`5R' 15' ,%&%N#' ()$#"5+*(?#9' #' @"%[email protected](5%)*#' %L!#)%)@(+=' ,#&' "%D(&*#&' ,%' ,#5A)(#' )+' 5.2&#.&2' %L!"%&&+'B%5'%&*+'!"#@1"+',#'%&!+>#'!%&&#+='#)=()% ed/' '

H&*%&'!"#B=%5+&')3#' &3#' %[email protected]=1&(?+5%)*%',(D(*+(&-'#&'!"#B=%5+&',+'WE'&3#'*+5B`5'#&'

!"#B=%5+&',+'!"J!"(+'@(,+,%DZ!:/0$0&!&`6#&11$!6#(7=&%X2/:$1!:$#$1!a!I5!84449!:(%(!:/0$0&!0/"-1$!84449!2#$%$!0&!#&0&1!0&!P=-`(1! 84449!Z1!#&0&1!0/;/2$/1!84449!6#(11&;-&%!(!0&1$P/(!0&!84449!6(11/7/=/2$#!(!"-.:/(.$%&.2(!0&!-%$!E/0$! -#7$.$!%$#:$0$!6&=(1!P=-`(1!PH1/:(1!&!/."(#%$2/E(14D!!8b-#2$0(+5' +'$+=*+"'#&' E.U&R' :&' @(,+,%&'$+=*+5' %&*"+,+&' !+"+'"%&!#),%"' :'

5+&&(V(@+>3#' ,#' 1&#' ,#' +1*#5J?%=-' )+' 5%&5+' J!*(@+' ,#' (&#=+5%)*#' ,(D(*+=R' #' (&#=+5%)*#' +)+=JD(@#' 5+)($%&*+,#' )+' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,#' +1*#5J?%=' !"(?+,#' [email protected]#5' *+L+&' ,%' #@1!+>3#' 51(*#' B+(L+&Z'`'*+5B`5'+'@+1&+',#&'!"()@(!+(&'!"#B=%5+&',%'@("@1=+>3#'"#,#?(]"(#&9'@#5#'&#=1>a%&' "+,(@+(&R' #1' +15%)*+5#&' +' "%,%R' #1' "%,1K(5#&' +' @("@1=+>3#9' +' &%5%=C+)>+' %)*"%' +' WE' %' +' @(,+,%'!+"%@%'*%"5()+"'+I1(-'&%'#'+15%)*#',+'"%,%'`'+(),+'15+'&#=1>3#'+,5(&&A?%='!+"+'+'WER' !+"+' +'@(,+,%'X'N]'"%!=%*+',%' +1*#b%&*"+,+&R'*^)%(&R'!#)*%&'%'?(+,1*#&' X'+'&#=1>3#' `'@+,+' ?%K' 5%)#&' ?(]?%=9'&#=1>a%&' ,%'@#5!"#5(&&#R'@#5#' +'z(DC'\@@1!+)@P'p%C(@=%'2+)%'%5' \)*+"(#ee'

ed ' 0%' [email protected]#",#' @#5' #' OC%' W1),+P' O(5%&' ' YOC%' W1),+P' O(5%&R' ejjnZR' @(*+),#' +' \G0HR' `' #' !"J!"(#' !"#*#@#=#' )15`"(@#' ,%' (,%)*(V(@+>3#' ,#&',(&!#&(*(?#&'*%@)#=JD(@#&'I1%' [email protected]%,%5':' "%,%'Y#' E.Z' I1%'%&*]' %5'@+1&+9' +'\G0H'@"M'I1%' &%'*#")+"]'#B&#=%*#' )#&' ()[email protected](#&' ,%' ejddR' *+=' +' !"#=($%"+>3#' ,#' )^5%"#' ,%' ,(&!#&(*(?#&' I1%' [email protected]%,%5' [email protected]*1+=5%)*%' :' E)*%")%*-' @#5!1*+,#"%&' V(L#&R' !#"*]*%(&R'&5+"*!C#)%&R'%*@9'+'[email protected]*1+=(K+>3#',#'!"#*#@#=#'`'1"D%)*%/ ee'8' z\p' %5'\)*+"(#' `'15+' $+(L+',%' @("@1=+>3#'%5'+1*#b%&*"+,+' "%&%"?+,+'!+"+'?%[email protected]=#&'@#5'5+(&',#' I1%' 15'#@1!+)*%-' sz(DC' #@@1!+)@P' ?%C(@=%' =+)%&' *C+*' +==#S' C(DCS+P&' *#' @+""P' 5#"%' !%#!=%' ()' $%S%"' ?%C(@=%&'B%@+1&%' *C%P' +"%' "%&%"?%,' $#"' ?%C(@=%&' @+""P()D'5#"%'*C+)'#)%'!%"&#)/t''Yf1%%){&'!"()*%"'$#"'\)*+"(#R'ejjqZ

ESTADO DA ARTE

*M5' ?(),#' +' &%"' *%&*+,+&R'&#=1>a%&' I1%' )3#' !"#@1"+5' )%5' +15%)*+"' +'"%,%')%5' "%,1K("' +' @("@1=+>3#R'+!#&*+),#'+)*%&')+'#!*(5(K+>3#',#'!"#@%&&#',%'@("@1=+>3#')+'"%,%/'\'0W2'#!%"#1' ,%'$#"5+'&%5%=C+)*%R'5+&')#'51),#',(D(*+=eg/ '

8=`5' ,%' !#,%"' !"#5#?%"' #' &%1' (&#=+5%)*#R' #' (),(?A,1#' ,+' WE' !#,%' &%"' ?A*(5+' ,%'

5+)(!1=+>3#-' #' !%"(D#' ,+' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,+&' OEG'@#5#' 5%(#' ,%' !%"&1+&3#R' @#),(@(#)+5%)*#' %' 5+)(!1=+>3#eh ' `' 15' !%"(D#' I1%' `' "%+=' %' I1%' ,%?%5#&' *%"' %5' @#)*+' ,1"+)*%' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'8EG8R'&#B' !%)+',#'!"#N%@*#'$"[email protected]+&&+"')15',#&'&%1&'!"#!J&(*#&'B+&(=+"%&-' #' ,%' !"#5#?%"' 15+' @#51)(@+>3#' %V(@+K' %' ()*%"[email protected]*(?+' %)*"%' #&' ?]"(#&' [email protected]*#"%&' )#' !"#@%&&#' +"I1(*%@*J)(@#ei ' @#5' #' #BN%@*(?#' ,%' !"#5#?%"' +' @#)@%!>3#' ,%' %,([email protected](#&' %' %&!+>#&' 5+(&' I1+=(V(@+,#&' %' I1%' !"#?(,%)@(%5' "%&!#&*+&' +,%I1+,+&' :&' )%@%&&(,+,%&' "%+(&' ,#&' @(,+,3#&/' G#5'%$%(*#R'#' @#)C%@(5%)*#' %'+'[email protected](=(,+,%',%'#!%"+"'+&'OEG'`R'@#5#'I1+=I1%"' @#)C%@(5%)*#R' 15+' $#)*%' ,%' !#,%"' I1%' !#,%"]' &%"' +!"#?%(*+,+' !+"+' V()&' ,($%"%)*%&' ,#' I1%' +I1%=%' I1%' !"%*%),%5#&'!"#!#"-'+'8EG8'("]'!"#@1"+"'+V("5+"b&%'@#5#'15+'$%""+5%)*+'@+!+K',%'"%&#=?%"' 15' !"#B=%5+' @#)@"%*#' X' +' !+"*(@(!+>3#' )15' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' X' !"#@1"+),#' !"#5#?%"'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+'+*"+?`&',%'15+'$%""+5%)*+'@+!+K',%'[email protected](=(*+"'+'@#51)(@+>3#' %)*"%'#&' ?]"(#&' [email protected]*#"%&' %)?#=?(,#&' %'+' @#5!"%%)&3#' ,%'@#)*%^,#&' %&!%@AV(@#&' !#"' !+"*%',%' 15'!^B=(@#'+=+"D+,#/ '

O%),#' *#,+&' %&*+&' !+=+?"+&' %5' @#)&(,%"+>3#R' @"%5#&' &%"' 1"D%)*%' +' +=*%"+>3#' ,#'

!+"+,(D5+' ,+' WE9'+' ()*%",([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%R' +' ()*%"[email protected]*(?(,+,%R' +' @%)*"+=(,+,%' ,+' ()$#"5+>3#' X' *#,#&' %&*%&'@#)@%(*#&'I1%'"%$%"(5#&'X'!+"%@%5' @#=#@+"b)#&')15+'#1*"+',(5%)&3#-'+',%'15+' W#@(%,+,%' ,+'E)$#"5+>3#' %',+' G#51)(@+>3#' YWEGZ'I1%',%?%"]'&%"' @+!+K',%' 1*(=(K+"'*#,#&'#&' "%@1"&#&'*%@)#=JD(@#&'I1%'!#&&1(')#'&%)*(,#',%'@##!%"+"')+'@#)&*"1>3#',+'&1+'@(,+,%/ '

G#5#'?%"%5#&'+,(+)*%R'[email protected]"%,(*+5#&'I1%'+'+!=(@+>3#',%&*%&'"%@1"&#&'*%@)#=JD(@#&'+#'

@#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' !#,%' @#)&*(*1("' 15+' $#"5+' ,%' +N1,+"' +'!"#5#?%"' +' !+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+'%R'@#)&%I1%)*%5%)*%R'+'@##!%"+>3#'!"%*%),(,+')+'@#)&*"1>3#',+'@(,+,%/

eg '\' 0W2' X' ,(D(*+=' [email protected]"(B%"'=()%'X' !%"5(*(1' +' *"+)&$%"M)@(+' ,%' ,+,#&',(D(*+(&'&#B"%' 15+'()$"+b%&*"1*1"+' N]'%L(&*%)*%' X'+' =()C+' *%=%$J)(@+'X' I1%' %&*+?+'&1Bb+!"#?%(*+,+')+' 5%,(,+'%5'I1%'%"+'+!%)+&'1*(=(K+,+' !+"+' +' *"+)&5(&&3#' ,%' ,+,#&'+)+=JD(@#&-' +' ?#K' C15+)+/ eh'|Y///Z'+'()$#"5]*(@+'?%(#'!"#@1"+"',#5()+"'+'5%)&+D%5'%'+'()$#"5+>3#|''Y61"*+,#R'ejjeBZ ei 'H)*%),(,#&' %5'&%)*(,#' =+*#R'%)D=#B+),#' I1%"'#&'"%&!#)&]?%(&'!%=+' %)@#5%),+R' @#)@%!>3#' %' 1&1$"1*#' ,+&' #B"+&'%' %&!+>#&' +"I1(*%@*J)(@#&/

DB

EC

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

6(D/'di-';]I1()+',%'O1"()D'&%D1),#'O#5'01))%'

6(D/'dl-'."#*J*(!#'@#)*%5!#"_)%#'',+';]I1()+',%'O1"()D

ESTADO DA ARTE

!"#"!$%,$',3405&%,+$)$%&$2-5)+-)5

'

\'@#)*%L*#'%5'*#")#' ,+'W#@(%,+,%',+'E)$#"5+>3#'%'G#51)(@+>3#' *%5' (5!1=&(#)+,#'

+=*%"+>a%&' &(D)(V(@+*(?+&' )#&' 5#,#&' ,%' ?(,+' %' !"#@%&&#&' !"#,1*(?#&R' %' #' 5%"@+,#' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+'%'@#)&*"1>3#')3#'`'%[email protected]%!>3#/ '

7#' %)*+)*#R',+,+' +'&1+' @#5!=%L(,+,%R' !%&#' %' (5!+@*#' )+' %@#)#5(+R' &3#' 5%"@+,#&'

#),%' ()*%"?%)>a%&' ,%' $1),#' &3#' 51(*#' ,([email protected]%(&' ,%' (5!=%5%)*+"/' 0%' [email protected]*#R' `' %?(,%)*%' I1%' *%5#&' *#,#' 15' &(&*%5+' !"#,1*(?#' 5#)*+,#' &#B"%' ()&*"15%)*#&' %' 5`*#,#&' ,%' *"+B+=C#' 1=*"+!+&&+,#&R'5+&'*+5B`5' `'@=+"#'I1%'+'()*%""1!>3#' ,%&&%'&(&*%5+'!+"+'(5!=%5%)*+>3#',%' )#?#&'5`*#,#&'%'$%""+5%)*+&' `'+=D#' I1%')3#'!#,%'&%"'%$%@*1+,#' ,%'$#"5+'+B"1!*+R'5+&'I1%' D"+,1+=5%)*%' %' )+*1"+=5%)*%' *%5' ?(),#' +' ,%@#""%"R' $"1*#' ,+' @[email protected](,+,%' ()*%")+' ,+' ,([email protected](!=()+el / '

c5+'&%I1M)@(+',%'[email protected]#)*%@(5%)*#&' *%5' ?(),#' +' +=*%"+"' +' $#"5+' @#5#' &%'@#)@%B%' %'

@#51)(@+'+"I1(*%@*1"+9'`R'!#"'(&&#R')%@%&&]"(#' @#5!"%%),%"5#&' #' !%"@1"&#' %'+'=JD(@+',%&*%&' [email protected]#)*%@(5%)*#&' !+"+' @#)&%D1("5#&' %)I1+,"+"' %' N1&*(V(@+"' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+' 8EG8' )3#' @#5#' 15+' $%""+5%)*+' %[email protected])*"(@+' %' %L*%5!#"_)%+R' 5+&' @#5#' 15+' $%""+5%)*+' )+*1"+=' +#' )A?%=',+&' %L(DM)@(+&' ,#' &%1'*%5!#-'"%$%"(5#b)#&' :'()?%)>3#' ,#' @#5!1*+,#"' %',#&' G80' %' :' ()?%)>3#',+'E)*%")%*em /

!"

#$"%&'(&)*+"#+",+-./0$#+1"("#+2"345

'

8' ()?%)>3#' ,#' @#5!1*+,#"' $#(',%*%"5()+)*%' )+'+=*%"+>3#' ,#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%'*"+B+=C#'

%5'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'!"#@%&&#'%5'&('=JD(@#' %'D"+,1+=-'8=+)'O1"()D'!"#!a%R'%5' dqgmR'15' 5#,%=#' *%J"(@#' ,%' 15+' 5]I1()+' ,%' !"#@%&&+5%)*#' X' +' ;]I1()+' ,%' O1"()D' X' I1%' @#)&(&*(+' %&&%)@(+=5%)*%')15+'V(*+' @#5!#&*+' !#"' ?]"(#&' B=#@#&R' @+,+' I1+='@#5' 15' &A5B#=#' D"+?+,#' YK%"#' #1' 15ZR' 15+' @+B%>+' @+!+K' ,%' &%' ,%&=#@+"' +#' =#)D#' ,%&&+' V(*+' Y!+"+' +' %&I1%",+' #1' ,("%(*+' +#' =#)D#' ,+' V(*+Z' %' 15+' *+B%=+' @#5' ()&*"1>a%&' !+"+'+' 5]I1()+' X')15+' +)+=#D(+' +#' !"#D"+5+'()$#"5]*(@#/

el'|.#,%5#&'@#)&*+*+"',%&,%'N]'I1%' +'+"I1(*%@*1"+')3#' %&*]'#!%"[email protected](#)+=(K+,+'!+"+'+'W/E/R'5+&'&%"(+' ()N1&*#' ,%(L+"',%' "%@#)C%@%"' +'&1+',(&!#)(B(=(,+,%'!+"+'+$"#)*+"'#')#?#'@#)*%L*#'@1=*1"+=R'+#')A?%=',+'@(,+,%R',+'@#)&*"1>3#'%',#'!"#N%@*#/|''Y61"*+,#R'ejje+Z em 'G#5#' ?%"%5#&R' %&*%&' ,#(&' [email protected]#)*%@(5%)*#&'"%?%=+"+5b&%' ,%*%"5()+)*%&'!+"+'+' +=*%"+>3#' ,+' 5%*#,#=#D(+' ,%' !"#N%@*#' +' *"M&' )A?%(&-'#',%&%)C#R'+'@#51)(@+>3#'%'#'*"+B+=C#'@#=+B#"+*(?#'%5'+"I1(*%@*1"+/

[email protected]

ED

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

6(D/'dm-'\'H0p8G'

ESTADO DA ARTE

'

8'[email protected]>3#' ,+'5]I1()+'%"+',%*%"5()+,+'!#"'*"M&'[email protected]*#"%&-'+'&1+'!#&(>3#R'#'&A5B#=#'=(,#'

)%&&+'!#&(>3#R'%'15+'*+B%=+'@#5'()&*"1>a%&en/ '

G+,+' *"+)&(>3#' !#,(+' &%"',%[email protected]"(*+'&#B' +' $#"5+' ,%'15+' ()&*"1>3#' Y&12$0(KR' IH%7(=(R'

&12$0(!"#$R' ' $:TF(ZR' +#' I1%' @#""%&!#),%"(+' 15+' [email protected]>3#' I1%'&%' !#,%"(+' ,%[email protected]"%?%"' @#5#' s&%' +' 5]I1()+'%&*(?%"')#'&12$0(K'%'#'&12$0(K'@#)*(?%"'IH%7(=(R'!+&&+"'+#'&12$0(!"#$'%'*#5+"'+'$:TF(' YI1%' !#,%"(+' &%"' +' ,%&=#@+>3#' ,+' 5]I1()+' !+"+' +' %&I1%",+o,("%(*+R' #1' +' ()[email protected]"(>3#' ,#&' &A5B#=#&'jodZt/''Yy+"Q%"b.=155%"R'ejjhZ '

H&*%' @#)N1)*#' ,%' ()&*"1>a%&' !%"5(*("(+' "%+=(K+"' @][email protected]=#&' @#5!=%L#&R' ,%V()(),#' #'

V(D1"+' ,#' $=;(#/2%(! @#5#' 15' @#)N1)*#' ,%' #!%"+>a%&' )%@%&&]"(+&' :' "%&#=1>3#' ,%' 15' !"#B=%5+DI-:,! $! ;&.&#$=/Q&0!/.12#-:2/(.!1&2! /1!).('.!$1!$.!$=;(#/2,%!c!$!6#(:&0-#&!"(#!1(=E/.;!$!;/E&.! 6#(7=&%4D!!8d$=$33#R' %)I1+)*#'$%""+5%)*+'D%)`"(@+R',%?%"(+' &%"'+=+"D+,+'+')3#'%&!%@(+=(&*+&R',%?%"(+'&%"',(&!#)(B(=(K+,+'+'1*(=(K+,#"%&'@#51)&/|''Y2(&B#+R'dqqmZ'

EE

EF

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

6(D/'dn-'%&''(!)*+,!"*-!$"./(0"'X'0\W

6(D/'dq-'WQ%*@C!+,'

6(D/'ej-'123,0(45&*%16**7*18$&0()*9:;3#' ,%' D"]V(@#&' )#&' %@"3&' ,#&' @#5!1*+,#"%&R' +!"#L(5+),#' +(),+' 5+(&' #&' @#5!1*+,#"%&' ,#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' @#51)&R' %'+B"(),#' @+5()C#' +#' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,#&' TcEU&/' W%"(+' %&*+' *%@)#=#D(+' I1%' ("(+' !%"5(*("' #' +,?%)*#' ,#' ,%&%)C#' +&&(&*(,#'!#"'@#5!1*+,#"'X'G80/ '

\' @#)@%(*#' ,%' G80' %' +' !"(5%("+' +!=(@+>3#' !"]*(@+' &3#' +*"(B1A,#&' +#' WQ%*@C!+,! ,%'

W1*C%"=+),'' Y[+=+PR' ejjhZR' !+"*%' ,%'15' !"#N%@*#' ,%' ()?%&*(D+>3#' !+"+'#B*%)>3#',%'.C/0/' )#' ;EOR'%5'dqlgR'I1%'@#)&(&*(+')15+'+!=(@+>3#'()$#"5]*(@+'I1%'!%"5(*(+'#',%&%)C#'&#B"%'#'%@"3' ,%' 15' @#5!1*+,#"' @#5' "%@1"&#' +' 15' ,(&!#&(*(?#' +!#)*+,#"' &%5%=C+)*%' +' 15+' @+)%*+/' 8!%&+"',%&*%',(&!#&(*(?#'(),(@(+"'+'5+)1+=(,+,%R'+'+!=(@+>3#' N]'!#&&1A+'@+"[email protected]*%"A&*(@+&' I1%'#' ,%&%)C#' *"+,(@(#)+=' )3#' @#)*%5!=+?+R' @#5#' +' !#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+"' V(D1"+&' D%#5`*"(@+&'@#5#'=()C+&'"%@*+&'%'I1+,"+,#&'@#5'*#*+='!"%@(&3#/ !

c5'+)#'5+(&'*+",%'8=%L+),%"'!1B=(@+"(+'^(2&1!(.!2,&!I3.2,&1/1!("!b(#%h

!

*e&!$#&!1&$#:,/.;!"(#!1(%&!)/.0!("!,$#%(.3!7&2'&&.!2'(!/.2$.;/7=&1h!$!"(#%!',/:,!'&!

,$E&! .(2! 3&2! 0&1/;.&0! ! 8Z=&`$.0#' 1)(?%"&(*]"(+' Y[+=+PR' ejjhZ/' H&*+' !"(5%("+' D%"+>3#' ,%' +!=(@+>a%&' G803#'$#('=(5(*+,+/ '

8' &%D1),+' D%"+>3#' ,%' +!=(@+>a%&' G80R' !#*%)@(+,+' !#"' %&&%' @#5!1*+,#"' !%&&#+=' %'

!%=#' ,%&%N#' ,%' *#")+"' #' ,%&%)C#' +&&(&*(,#' !#"' @#5!1*+,#"' 5+(&' [email protected]%&&A?%=R' ("(+' @#)&%D1("' ,%5#@"+*(K+"'#'1&#',#'G80R'5+&'@#5'15'@1&*#'!+"+'+'+"I1(*%@*1"+/

EG

EH

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

6(D/'ed-'8!=(@+>3#'v#"=,?(%S'

6(D/'ee-'8!=(@+>3#'4%?(*'

ESTADO DA ARTE

*84449!',/=&!2,&!P/#12g;&.&#$2/(.!1312&%1!'&#&!/.2#(0-:&0!$1!*7-/=0/.;!0&1/;.!1312&%1>!2,&!1&:(.0g ;&.&#$2/(.! '&#&! ).('.! $1! 0#$"2/.;! $.0! %(0&=/.;! 1312&%1! 84449! ^(! =(.;&#! 0/0! 2,&! 1("2'$#&!! ,$.0=&!1-:,! 7-/=0/.;g16&:/P/:! (7O&:21!1-:,! $1! 0((#1!84449!]$2,&#! 84449! 0&$=2! '/2,! 6(=3;(.1!!8d$=$33#',%',"+$*()D',%&*+'&%D1),+'D%"+>3#',%'+!=(@+>a%&'UZ\/ '

G#)*1,#R' +&' @"%[email protected]%)*%&' %L(DM)@(+&' ,#' (),(?A,1#',+'WEa%&' ,%&*+' &%D1),+' D%"+>3#' ,%' +!=(@+>a%&R' I1+),#' +!=(@+,+&' +#' 5%"@+,#' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+-' +&' %)*(,+,%&' &3#' *"+*+,+&' ,#' !#)*#' ,%' ?(&*+' %&*"(*+5%)*%' D%#5`*"(@#R' %' +!%&+"' ,#' D"+),%' +?+)>#' &#B"%' #' ,%&%)C#' 5+)1+=' Y5%,(>a%&' "(D#"#&+&R' @][email protected]=#' ,%' ]"%+&R' ?#=15%&R' ,%&%)C#' @#5' +1LA=(#' ,%' @#),(@(#)+)*%&' D%#5`*"(@#&R' !#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' *"(,(5%)&(#)+(&R' #!%"+>a%&' B##=%+)+&R' %*@/Z' %=+&' )3#' !#&&1%5'+'()*%=(DM)@(+'!+"+'&+B%"%5'(!G-&!1F('#1':(%(!1&!0&E&%!:(%6(#2$#9'+=`5',(&&#R'%&*%' *(!#' ,%'+!=(@+>a%&' ()@(*+'+#' *"+B+=C#' &#B"%'+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#R' :'&%5%=C+)>+' ,#' I1%'[email protected]#)*%@%' @#5'#',%&%)C#'5+)1+=gjR'#'I1%'#"(D()+'$"%I1%)*%5%)*%'()@#)D"1M)@(+&'%)*"%'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%'15' 5%&5#'#BN%@*#'+"I1(*%@*J)(@#'X'15+'N+)%=+'I1%'$#('+=*%"+,+'%5'!=+)*+R'5+&'I1%')3#' #' $#(')#'+=>+,#/ '

8')%@%&&(,+,%',%'"%+N1&*+"'%&*+&'+!=(@+>a%&'+#'5%"@+,#' ,+'+"I1(*%@*1"+'*%"]',(*+,#'

15'"%D"%&&#'+#'%)*%),(5%)*#',#',%&%)C#' ,(D(*+='B+&%+,#'%5'#BN%@*#&'()*%=(D%)*%&'%')3#' %5' %)*(,+,%&' D%#5`*"(@+&/'H5' dqngR' &#B'#"(%)*+>3#' ,%'w%C1,+'[+=+PR'15' D"1!#',%'()?%&*(D+>3#' @"(+?+' #' v#"=,?(%SR' 15+' +!=(@+>3#' ,%' ,%&%)C#' +"I1(*%@*J)(@#' ()*%=(D%)*%R' I1%' "%@#)C%@(+' #BN%@*#&' @#5#' !#"*+&R'N+)%=+&R'!+"%,%&' %'#&' 5+)(!1=+?+',#' !#)*#' ,%'?(&*+'D%#5`*"(@#'%')3#b D%#5`*"(@#/' [email protected]*1+=5%)*%R' %&*%' *(!#' ,%' +!=(@+>a%&' *%5' ?(),#' +' +,I1("("' 15' )A?%=' ,%' &#V(&*(@+>3#' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&' %=%?+,#R' @#5#' #' ,%5#)&*"+5' +!=(@+>a%&' @#5#' #' 4%?(*' 8"@C(*%@*1"%''Y81*#,%&QR'E)@/R'ejdj+Z'#'8"@C(@+,'YT"+!C(&#$*R'ejdjZ'#1'#'y%)*=%P'8"@C(*%@*1"%'' Yy%)*=%P'WP&*%5&'E)@#"!#"+*%,R'ejdjZ4 '

8&'+!=(@+>a%&'G80',%&*+'*%"@%("+'D%"+>3#'?(%"+5'!%"5(*("'#!%"+"'&#B"%'15'5#,%=#R'+'

!+"*("' ,#' I1+=R' %' %5' I1+=I1%"' 5#5%)*#R' &%' !#,(+' "%*("+"' 15+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' X' !+"*(@1=+"(,+,%' I1%' #' ,%&%)C#' +"*%&+)+=' )3#' !%"5(*(+R' !#(&' (5!=(@+?+' +' #!%"+>3#' ,("%@*+' &#B"%'+'"%!"%&%)*+>3#/' 8&&(5R' +' @#)@%!>3#' +"I1(*%@*J)(@+'!"#@%&&+b&%'@#5' +' @#)&*"1>3#' ,#' 5#,%=#R' %' )3#' @#5' +' @#)&*"1>3#' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&9' %&*+&' &1"D%5' )+*1"+=5%)*%' I1+),#' &#=(@(*+,+&R''%''5%,(+)*%''#!%"+,#"%&''I1%''()*%"&%@*+5''%&&%''5#,%=#''%''V(=*"+5''+''()$#"5+>3#R' gj '7+*1"+=5%)*%R' @#5'51(*+&'?+)*+D%)&' &#B"%' #' ,%&%)C#' 5+)1+=' X' %&*+&' +!=(@+>a%&',%' ,"+$*()D' *"+B+=C+5' )+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#R' 5+&'!%"5(*%5'15+'@[email protected](,+,%',%'5+)(!1=+>3#'I1%')3#'%&*]'+#'[email protected]+)@%',#',%&%)C#'*"+,(@(#)+=/

EI

E<

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

ESTADO DA ARTE

"%?%=+),#' +!%)+&' +' ()$#"5+>3#' &#=(@(*+,+/' ' %=(5()+,+' +' ()@#)D"1M)@(+' %)*"%' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&R''')+'''5%,(,+''%5'I1%R''+#''@#)*"]"(#'',#''I1%''[email protected]#)*%@%''@#5''+&''+!=(@+>a%&'',%' ,"+$*()DR'%=+&'%&*3#'()*%"=(D+,+&/'8'@#)@%!>3#',#'5#,%=#',(D(*+='[email protected](=(*+R'()@=1&(?%R'+'@"(+>3#',%' 5+I1%*+&'VA&(@+&'+*"+?`&',%'!"#@%&&#&'5%@_)(@#&'X'#'G8;4! !

\'5`*#,#',%'!"#N%@*+"'&#$"%R'!#"'(&&#R'+=*%"+>a%&'&(D)(V(@+*(?+&-

D84449!.(E(1! /.12#-%&.2(1a%&'@#5#'G80'YG#5!1*%"b+(,%,'

,"+$*()DZ' 5+&' +)*%&' @#5#' G880' YG#5!1*%"b+(,%,' +"@C(*%@*1"+=' ,%&(D)ZR' +=*%"+>3#' I1%R' !#"' 15' =+,#R' "%@#)C%@%' #' %)$#I1%' ,%&*+&' +!=(@+>a%&' )#' 5%"@+,#' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %R' !#"' #1*"#R' "%@#)C%@%'+',($%"%)>+',%'$1),#'%)*"%'#',"+$*()D'%'#' ,%&(D)R' #' !"(5%("#' +&&#@(+,#'+#' "(D#"R':' @#)?%)>3#'%':'#BN%@*(?(,+,%R'%'#'&%D1),#':'!"#N%@>3#'%':'+)*%@(!+>3#''Y2(&B#+R'dqqmZ/ '

H&*%' *"+B+=C#' &#B"%' #' 5#,%=#' *%5' ?(),#' +' +D(=(K+"' #' !"#@%&&#' ,%' @"(+>3#' ,%'

"%!"%&%)*+>a%&' *"(,(5%)&(#)+(&' D%"+,+&' !#"' @#5!1*+,#"R' 15+' ?%K'I1%'#' 5#,%=#' )3#' `' 15' #BN%@*#' +,(@(#)+='I1%'&%' *%5' I1%' @#)&*"1("'+'!+"*("' ,%'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&' B(,(5%)&(#)+(&R'5+&' 15',+,#',#'!"#N%@*#9'%&*+&'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&R'B%5'@#5#'#1*"+&',%'@+"]@*%"'5+(&'+B&*"[email protected]*#R'&3#' 5+(&'[email protected](=5%)*%'@"(+,+&'@#5'+'1*(=(K+>3#',%&*+&'+!=(@+>a%&'G880/'G#5#'"%&1=*+,#R'*+='!#,%"]' !"#5#?%"' +' 5%=C#"' @#51)(@+>3#' ,#&' !"#N%@*#&' %R' @#)&%I1%)*%5%)*%R' 15+' 5%=C#"' !+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+/ '

' +(),+' ,%' "%+=>+"' I1%' %&*+&' +!=(@+>a%&' *M5' ?(),#' +' ()*%"%&&+"b&%R' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&R'

&#B"%'#'*"+B+=C#'@#=+B#"+*(?#'%5'"%,%R'&1!#"*+,#'!%=+'5.2&#.&2h *84449! $! U]! k:(=$7(#$TF(! #&%(2$l! $(! :(%7/.$#! (! -1(! 0&! %&/(1! :(%6-2$:/(.$/1! 0&! $6(/(! $(! 6#(O&:2(! $6#(`/%$! (1! 0/"&#&.2&1! &16&:/$=/12$1! &! /.2&;#$! $1! "$1&1! 0&! 6#(O&:2(! &! :(.12#-TF(!8m-$#&1%$3#'%)*"%'+&'%I1(!+&',%'!"#N%@*#'%'5()(5(K+"'#&' %""#&',%'!"#N%@*#R'()*%D"+),#b&%'@#5'+&'+!=(@+>a%&',%',%&%)C#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%L(&*%)*%&/ '

.%=+'&1+'"%=%?_)@(+R'+'()?%)>3#',+'E)*%")%*'&%"]'#'!"JL(5#'!#)*#'%5'+)]=(&%/

EB

FC

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

6(D/'eg-'G%)*"+=(K%,R'0%@%)*"+=(K%,'+),'0(&*"(B1*%,'7%*S#"Q&

6(D/'eh-'84.87HO'2#D(@+=';+!R'dqmm

ESTADO DA ARTE

!"

#$"%&'(&)*+"#$"6&0(1&(0

'

8' #1*"+' ()?%)>3#' ,%*%"5()+)*%R' @#5#' N]' "%$%"(5#&R' $#(' +' E)*%")%*/' O+=' @#5#' #'

@#5!1*+,#"R' +' ()?%)>3#' )3#' @#1B%' +' 15+' !%&&#+' %' $#(' #' "%&1=*+,#' ,%' 15+' &`"(%' ,%' [email protected]#)*%@(5%)*#&R'I1%'!+&&+5#&'+',%[email protected]"%?%"/ '

H5' dqldR' 2%#)+",' [=%()"#@Q' !"#!a%' 15' %&*1,#' !+"+' #B*%)>3#' ,%' .C/0/' )#' ;EO'

()*(*1=+,#' 5."(#%$2/(.! b=('! /.! M$#;&! U(%%-./:$2/(.! ^&21' Y[=%()"#@QR' dqldZ' I1%' ("(+' "%?#[email protected](#)+"'+'*"+)&5(&&3#',%',+,#&')+&'"%,%&',%'()$#"5+>3#/ '

8'*"+)&5(&&3#',%',+,#&'!#"'[email protected]#*%&R'@"(+,+'!#"'[=%()"#@QR'y+"+)'%'0+?(%&R'!%"5(*(+'+'

@("@1=+>3#' ,(&*"(B1A,+',#&' ,+,#&R'!%"5(*(),#' :' "%,%'+,+!*+"b&%' +#' 5+(#"'#1'5%)#"'V=1L#',%' ()$#"5+>3#R'!#(&' +'5%)&+D%5' )3#' )%@%&&(*+?+',%' &%"' *"+)&5(*(,+',%'$#"5+'@#)*A)1+' )+'&1+' *#*+=(,+,%/' [=%()"#@Q' !"#@1"+?+' +&&(5' 15' &#=1>3#' !+"+' #' @#)D%&*(#)+5%)*#' ,+&' @#51)(@+>a%&' *%=%D"]V(@+&' %' +&' =()C+&' *%=%$J)(@+&' #@1!+,+&R' !#"' %[email protected]%&&#' ,%' @+"D+R' 5+&' [email protected]+B+"(+' !#"' ?%"' +' *%@)#=#D(+' +!=(@+,+' :' +(),+' !#"' )[email protected]%"' E)*%")%*/' H&&+' *"+)&5(&&3#' ,%' ,+,#&' !#"' [email protected]#*%&' X' [email protected]%*' &S(*@C()DR' %5' +=*%")+*(?+' +#' G("@1(*' &S(*@C()D' X' !%"5(*(+' +' *"+)&5(&&3#' ,%' ,+,#&' %)*"%' !#)*#&' +"B(*"]"(#&' ,+' "%,%' &%5' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' 15+' =(D+>3#' ,("%@*+'%)*"%'%=%&'X'+'()$#"5+>3#'&%D1("(+',%'$#"5+'&%D5%)*+,+'!#"'?]"(#&'*"#>#&',+'"%,%'+*`' @C%D+"'+#'&%1',%&*()#/ !

W1"D%' +&&(5R' %5' dqlqR' 15+' "%,%' ,%' @#5!1*+,#"%&' ()*%"@#)%@*+,#&' ,%)#5()+,#'

84.87HO' I1%' =(D+"(+' +' c)(?%"&(,+,%' ,+' G+=($#")(+R' 2#&' 8)D%=%&' %' #' W*+)$#",' 4%&%+"@C' E)&*(*1*%R'+#&'I1+(&'&%'N1)*+"(+5R',#(&'5%&%&',%!#(&R'+'c)(?%"&(,+,%',%'c*+C'%'+'c)(?%"&(,+,%' ,%'G+=($#")(+R'W+)*+'y+"B+"+'YG#5!1*%"'z(&*#"P';1&%15R'ejjlZ/ '

8' "%,%' @#)*()1+"(+' +' @"%[email protected]%"' %' &1"D("(+5' #1*"+&' "%,%&' !+"+=%=+&/' \' @#)@%(*#' ,%'

5.2&#.&2' &1"D("(+' !%=+' !"(5%("+' ?%K' )+' %&!%@(V(@+>3#' ,#' !"#*#@#=#' I1%' !%"5(*(+' ()*%"=(D+"' %&&+&' "%,%&'%)*"%'&('X!I6&:/P/:$2/(.! ("!5.2&#.&2! +#$.1%/11/(.!U(.2#(=![#(;#$%'YOG.Z'%'&%"?("(+' !+"+' ,%&(D)+"' +'@"%[email protected]%)*%' "%,%',%'@#5!1*+,#"%&' ()*%"@#)%@*+,#&' YG%"$R' 0+=+=R' F' W1)&C()%R' dqmhZ/ '

G#5' #' ?#=15%' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#' %' ,%' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' )+' 5.2&#.&2! +' +15%)*+"'

%L!#)%)@(+=5%)*%' )+&',`@+,+&' ,%'dqnj'%' dqqjR' #' !"#B=%5+',%'@#5#'%)@#)*"+"'()$#"5+>3#' )+' 5.2&#.&2! @#5%>#1' +' D+)C+"' !%&#/' E)&!("+,#' !%=+' (,%(+&' ,%' p+))%?+"' y1&C' %' !%=#' &%1' !"#*J*(!#',%'dqhi',%'15+'5]I1()+'!+"+'+"5+K%)+5%)*#'%'!%&I1(&+'()*1(*(?+',%'()$#"5+>3#' X'#'5%5%L-'5%5#"P'%L*%)&(#)!'Yy1&CR'dqhiZ'I1%'?("(+'+'()&!("+"'+'*%@)#=#D(+',#'C(!%"*%L*#'X' O%,'7%=&#)'?("(+' +' ,%$%),%"' +' ,%5#@"+*(K+>3#' ,+' 5.2&#.&2! %' +' &1+'[email protected]%&&(B(=(,+,%' +'!%&&#+&' 5%)#&'%&!%@(+=(K+,+&/ '

W%"(+' O(5' y%")%"&b2%%' +' ()?%)*+"R' %5' dqnqR' +' (5!=%5%)*+>3#' ,#' @#)@%(*#' ,#'

[email protected]

FD

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

C(!%"*%L*#'B+&%+,#')+'5.2&#.&2R'@"(+),#'+&'"+AK%&',+'vvv4!8'!+"*("',%&*%'5#5%)*#'&1"D("+5' #&'7#('1R'+!=(@+>a%&',%')+?%D+>3#')+'vvvR'%'#&'5#*#"%&',%'!%&I1(&+')+'vvv784 !

[email protected]*1+=5%)*%' +&&(&*(5#&' +' 15+' +=*%"+>3#' ,%' !+"+,(D5+R' +#' !#)*#' ,%' &%' +!%=(,+"' #'

$%)J5%)#' ,%' v%B' e/j-' +' +B%"*1"+' ,+' vvv' :' @#51)(@+>3#' ()*%"[email protected]*(?+' %)*"%' #&' &%1&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' %' :' D%&*3#' ,%'@#)*%^,#&' ,()_5(@#&R' %5' #!#&(>3#' :' ?(&3#' &12X2/:$! ,+'vvv' ,%' 2%%/' H&*+' %?#=1>3#R' +!#(+,+' %5' *%@)#=#D(+&' %' =()D1+D%)&' ,%' !"#D"+5+>3#' 5+(&' "%@%)*%&R' @#5#'#'.z.R'!%"5(*%5' 15+'5+(#"'()*%"[email protected]>3#'%)*"%'#&'1*(=(K+,#"%&',+'vvv!+#'$#")%@%"%5b =C%&' #!%"+,#"%&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' ,($%"%)@(+,#&/' 8&&(&*(5#&' +&&(5' :' !"#=($%"+>3#' ,%' $J"1)&' #)=()%R' %&!+>#&' !+"+' @C+*' %' ?(,%#[email protected]#)$%"M)@(+/' W%' %&*+&' $%""+5%)*+&R' )15' !"(5%("#' )A?%=R' !#,%5'&%"'%)*%),(,+&'@#5#'$%""+5%)*+&',%'&#@(+=(K+>3#R'%=+&'!#&&1%5'%5'&('+'@[email protected](,+,%',%' &%"?("%5' #1*"#&' !"#!J&(*#&' @#5#' #' *"+B+=C#' @#=+B#"+*(?#' %5' "%,%R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' )#' ,#5A)(#',+'+"I1(*%@*1"+/ !

8' ()?%)>3#' ,+' E)*%")%*! !#*%)@(#1! +' @"(+>3#' ,%' +!=(@+>a%&' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&'

%&!%@(+=(K+,+&')#&',#5A)(#&',+'@#51)(@+>3#'%'@#=+B#"+>3#'%5',(?%"&+&']"%+&',([email protected](!=()+"%&'%' I1%R'!#"*+)*#R'*+5B`5'+*()D(1'+'+"I1(*%@*1"+/ !

0%'[email protected]*#R'+&'+=*%"+>a%&':'5%*#,#=#D(+',%'!"#N%@*#')3#'&%'%)@#)*"+5'+!%)+&'+'#@#""%"'

+#' )A?%=' ,#' ,%&%)C#' %' @#51)(@+>3#' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+9' %)@#)*"+5b&%' *+5B`5' )#&' !"J!"(#&' !"#@%&&#&' I1%' +' 5#?%5R' ,%&,%' +' ,%V()(>3#' ,+&' )%@%&&(,+,%&' !#"' !+"*%' ,#' @=(%)*%R' :' %=+B#"+>3#' ,#&' !"#N%@*#&' %' @##",%)+>3#' %)*"%' +&' %I1(!+&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' %)D%)C+"(+' %' %&!%@(+=(,+,%&R' +#' [email protected]#5!+)C+5%)*#' ,#' !"#@%&&#' @+5+"]"(#' %' :' @#)&*"1>3#' ,+' #B"+R' #B"(D+),#' +&&(5' +' 15' +=+"D+5%)*#' ,+&' @[email protected](,+,%&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' ,%' 15' @#)N1)*#' ,%' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(#"' %' 5+(&' ,(?%"&(V(@+,#' I1%R' +!%&+"' ,+&' &1+&' ,($%"%)>+&R' I1%"' &%"' @+!+K',%'@#)@"%*(K+"'15' #BN%@*(?#'@#515'X'+'@#)&*"1>3#' ,%'5%=C#"%&'%&!+>#&' %'%,([email protected](#&' %R' @#)&%I1%)*%5%)*%R'+'#B*%)>3#',%'15'5%=C#"'+5B(%)*%')+*1"+='%'@#)&*"1A,#/ '

H5' &A)*%&%R' !#,%5#&' +V("5+"' I1%' +&' +=*%"+>a%&' +#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' !"#N%@*#R'

!#*%)@(+,#&' !%=#' @#5!1*+,#"' %' !%=+'5.2&#.&2R' %&*3#' +'#@#""%"' +'*"M&' )A?%(&-')#' ,#' ,%&%)C#' +&&(&*(,#R')#',#'*"+B+=C#'@#=+B#"+*(?#'%5'"%,%'%')#',+'@#51)(@+>3#',%'!"#N%@*#!

*84449!2,&!:(%6-2&#!E/1-$=/Q$2/(.!%&0/-%+'%)*"%'#' @#)@%(*#' ,%'E)*%")%*' X' 15+'"%,%'()*%"@#)%@*+,+' ,%'@#5!1*+,#"%&'X'%'+' vvv' X' 15+',+&'&1+&' +!=(@+>a%&R' B+&%+,+' )#' =,2".$"#$&' %' )#' >[email protected]".:* 7#*%b&%' I1%'#1*"+&'+!=(@+>a%&R'@#5#' #' %5+(=R'$+K%5'!+"*%' ,+'-!$".!"$*5+&')3#' ,+'AAA:

ESTADO DA ARTE

'

8&' )#?+&' $%""+5%)*+&' ()$#"5]*(@+&' *M5' 5#*(?+,#' "%V=%La%&' @"A*(@+&' &#B"%' +&' &1+&'

!#*%)@(+=(,+,%&-'[+=+P''Y[+=+PR'ejjhZ'&()*%*(K+'%&*+&'?+)*+D%)&'%5'&%(&'!#)*#&'%&&%)@(+(&'ge '%' #' D"1!#' ,%'()?%&*(D+>3#' G8W8' X' cG2'G%)*"%'$#"' 8,?+)@%,'W!+*(+='8)+=P&(&' X!%5' @()@#R' @#5#' )#&'"%$%"%'y1=5%"''Yy1=5%"R'ejjdZgg/ '

W3#' +&' OEG' %' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,%' $%""+5%)*+&' ()$#"5]*(@+&' I1%' !#*%)@(+5' %&*+'

%?#=1>3#R' +=*%"+),#' +' $#"5+' @#5#' #' @=(%)*%' ()*%"+D%' @#5' #' +"I1(*%@*#R' @#5#' #' +"I1(*%@*#' ()*%"+D%' @#5' +&' %)*(,+,%&' =(@%)@(+,#"+&' %' #1*"+&' %I1(!+&' ,%' !"#N%@*#' X' %R' !%"D1)*+5#&R' !#"I1%')3#'+' $#"5+'@#5#' @=(%)*%R' +"I1(*%@*#' %'!^B=(@#R' %)*"%' #1*"#&R' ()*%"+D%5' %)*"%' &(')#' ,%@1"&#',%'15'@#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+Ä '

8'8EG8' )3#'!#,%"(+R'!#"*+)*#R',%(L+"' ,%'&%D1("' %&*%'@+5()C#' %'[email protected]*1+"')15' ,#5A)(#'

!"#@%&&1+=R'+!"#?%(*+),#' +(),+'#'[email protected]*#',+&' [email protected]*1+(&' $%""+5%)*+&' ,%'()$#"5+>3#',%'@#)*%^,#&' "%=+*(?#&'+#&' @#)@1"&#&' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'&%"%5R' )+'&1+'D`)%&%R'()&*"15%)*+(&gh/' ')%@%&&]"(#' I1%'%&*+&'$%""+5%)*+&'+B+),#)%5'#'5%"#'@+"]@*%"'()$#"5+*(?#b()&*"15%)*+=R',%(L+),#',%'&%' @#5!#"*+"%5' @#5#' 5%(#&' ,%'()$#"5+>3#' 1)(=+*%"+=R' !+"+'!#,%"%5' [email protected]+)>+"'15+',(5%)&3#' ,%'!=+*+$#"5+',%'@#51)(@+>3#' ()*%"[email protected]*(?+R' ()*1(*(?+'%'%V(@+KR'@+!+K',%' ()V=1%)@(+"'+' !"J!"(+' 5%*#,#=#D(+' [email protected]%)*%' :' !+"*(@(!+>3#' )15' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' ,%&,%' +' ()[email protected]"(>3#R' +' #B*%)>3#' %' @"(+>3#' ,+' ()$#"5+>3#' !"%=(5()+"R' #' %[email protected]=+"%@(5%)*#' ,%' ,^?(,+&R' +' &1B5(&&3#',%' !"#!#&*+&R'#'?(&(#)+5%)*#'%'@#5!+"+>3#',%'!"#!#&*+&'@#)@#""%)*%&R'+',([email protected]&&3#'!^B=(@+',+&' (,%(+&'X',%&%N+?%=5%)*%',1"+)*%'*#,+&'+&'$+&%&',%'!"#N%@*#/ '

z+?%"]' "%&(&*M)@(+' :' 51,+)>+R' )3#' &J' !%=+' N]'"%$%"(,+' ,(V(@1=,+,%' %5' #!%"+"' )15'

&(&*%5+'!"#,1*(?#' @#5!=%L#R'5+&' *+5B`5' !%=+&'(5!=(@+>a%&'!#=A*(@+&'I1%'(&&#'(5!=(@+'%'!#"' +=D15' !"%@#)@%(*#' )+' +,#!>3#' ,+&' )#?+&' *%@)#=#D(+&' )#&' 5%"@+,#&' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %' @#)&*"1>3#R'!+"*(@1=+"5%)*%')+'+,#!>3#',%')#?+&'5%*#,#=#D(+&',%'*"+B+=C#D84449!-%$!:-=2-#$! $#G-/2&:2N./:$!$/.0$!0(%/.$0$3#Z9' eZ' E)*%"=()Q()D' Y()*%"=(D+>3#' ,+&' ?]"(+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&Z9'gZ' E)$#"5+*(#)';+)+D%5%)*' [email protected]%&&#' +' "%@1"&#&',%' ()$#"5+>3#Z9' hZ'p(&1+=(K+*(#)'Y!"#,1>3#' ,%'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&' "%+=(&*+&' +' !+"*("' ,#&' 5#,%=#&Z9' iZ' E)*%==(D%)@%' Y,%V()(>3#' ,%' "%D"+&' )+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#Z9' %' lZ' G#))%@*(?(*P' Y*"+B+=C#' @#=+B#"+*(?#Z/ gg ' s4%!"%&%)*()D' *C%' D%#5%*"(@' +),' D%#D"+!C(@' $#"5' #$'*C%' &P&*%5' Y///Z' +*' ,($$%"%)*' D%#D"+!C(@bD%#5%*"(@' [email protected]+=%&R' +),' 1&()D' ,($$%"%)*' *P!%&' #$'5%,(+9' ;#,%=()D' 5#?%5%)*&'+),'"%=+*(#)&C(!&' B%*S%%)' *C%' ?+"(#1&' @#5!#)%)*&' #$' *C%' B1(=*' %)?("#)5%)*9' &Q%*@C',($$%"%)*'+=*%")+*(?%' ,%&(D)&'SC(@C'+,,"%&&'*C%'!"#B=%5' ()' I1%&*(#)9' p(&1+=(K()D' *C%' eb0' 5+!'D%#5%*"P'#"'D%#D"+!CP' ()' gb0' +*' ,($$%"%)*' [email protected]+=%&9' OP()D' *#D%*C%"' +==' *C(&' ?+"(#1&' &#$*S+"%' ()' +' )%*S#"Q%,'!+"*(@(!+*#"P' ,(D(*+=' %)?("#)5%)*/t' ' Yy1=5%"R' ejjdZ gh ' E&*#' `R' !"#!#"@(#)+5' ()$#"5+>3#' &#B"%' #&' @#)@1"&#&' 5+&' )3#' !#&&1%5' @#5#' #BN%@*(?#' !"()@(!+=' +' @"(+>3#' ,%' 15+' !=+*+$#"5+'@#51)(@+*(?+/

FE

FF

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

'

H&*+'()`"@(+'!#,%"]'%L!=(@+"'+'"+K3#'!%=+'I1+=-

DZ!%$/(#/$! 0(1!$#G-/2&:2(1! :(.2/.-$! $! &.:$#$#! (! :/7&#&16$T(! :(%(!1&.0(! &%$/=1!&!UZ\3#'%'G#51)(@+>3#' +N1,+5'+'%L!=(@+"'

%&*+'!#&*1"+R',+'5%&5+'$#"5+'I1%'C#N%'@#)&(,%"+5#&'s)#"5+=t'I1%'15'N#?%5'@#)&(D+'#!%"+"' [email protected](=5%)*%'15' @#5!1*+,#"' %' 15' +,1=*#' %)@#)*"%'5+(#"%&' ,(V(@1=,+,%&/'8' I1%&*3#')3#'%&*]R' @#)*1,#R'+!%)+&'"%[email protected](#)+,+'@#5' 15+'$+(L+'%*]"(+',+'!#!1=+>3#'X'+'$#"5+>3#'*+5B`5'`'15' !"#B=%5+D84449!&%!;&#$=3#'!+"*(@1=+"5%)*%'"%?%=+,#"%&',+'&(*1+>3#D[(#2-;$=!&.:(.2#$g1&!.-%!;#-6(!0&!6$H1&1!&-#(6&-1!$2#$1$0(!.(!G-&!#&16&/2$! a!/.2#(0-TF(!0(! %(0&=(!0$!DI5D!!8Z"(.1(!p!b-#2$0(3#' %' 15' +5BAD1#' @#)*"#=#' ,%' ?%"&a%&' %' !%"5(&&a%&' ,%' [email protected]%&&#/' 8' +!=(@+>3#' 1*(=(K+,+' X' #' @=(%)*%' ,%' %5+(='X' `' ()@+!+K',%'"%&!#),%"':'@#5!=%L(,+,%',%&&+&')%@%&&(,+,%&'!+"*(@1=+"%&/'G#)*1,#R'%',%'$#"5+' (),([email protected]*A?%=R'#'@#5!1*+,#"'$+K'C#N%'!+"*%',#'I1#*(,(+)#R'&#B"%*1,#' ,+&'D%"+>a%&'5+(&')#?+&/' H&*%' ,+,#R' N1)*+5%)*%' @#5' #' @+"]@*%"' N#?%5' ,#&' +"I1(*%@*#&' !#"*1D1%&%&gi ' @#)&*(*1(R' %5' )#&&#' %)*%),%"R' 15+' #!#"*1)(,+,%' !+"+' +' (5!=%5%)*+>3#' ,+' .=+*+$#"5+' 0(D(*+=' I1%' )#&' !"#!#5#&' ,%&%)?#=?%"/' .+"+'+&'D%"+>a%&' 5%)#&'N#?%)&R'5+&' 5+(&' $#"*%5%)*%' %)"+(K+,+&' )#' 5%"@+,#R'+'$+5(=(+"(,+,%'!#,%"]'&%"'D"+,1+=5%)*%'@#)I1(&*+,+-

gi ' W%D1),#' %&*1,#' ,%' ;+)1%=' p(==+?%",%' G+B"+=' seog' ,#&' +"I1(*%@*#&' !#"*1D1%&%&' *M5' 5%)#&' ,%' hj' +)#&' %' %)*"+"+5' )+' !"#V(&&3#' C]' ,`@+,+' %' 5%(+' )#' 5]L(5#tR' s\' "%N1?%)%[email protected](5%)*#' ,+' !"#V(&&3#' `' Y///Z' 15' $%)J5%)#' "%@%)*%' Y///Z' %' +B&#=1*+5%)*%' "+,(@+=/t''YG+B"+='F'y#"D%&R'ejjlZ

ESTADO DA ARTE

Dq.2#$%(1!.-%!G-$#2(!0&!,(2&=!8449!^F(!.(1!1&.2/%(1!&%!:$1$!0&.2#(!0&=&4!U(.2-0(+/' 8' *%),M)@(+' ,#' &%"' C15+)#' !+"+' +&&%)*+"' %' &%'

(,%)*(V(@+"' )15'=1D+"R' )15+'"%=(D(3#R' )15+'$+5A=(+'#1'D"1!#' `' ()I1%&*(#)]?%=R' )3#' #B&*+)*%' C+?%"%5' %[email protected]%!>a%&' :' "%D"+' X' %' ,(*#1' #' +B+),#)#' D"+,1+=' ,#' 5#,#' ,%' ?(,+' )J5+,+/' [email protected]*1+=5%)*%R' ,+,#' #' %=%?+,#' "(*5#' ,%' *"+)&$#"5+>3#' ,+' "%+=(,+,%R' `' )+*1"+=' I1%' %&&+' "%&(&*M)@(+' &%' $+>+' &%)*("' ,%' $#"5+' [email protected]%)*1+,+R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' )#' I1%' ,(K' "%&!%(*#' :' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,+&' OEG/' c5+' ,+&' +5%+>+&' +#' [email protected]%&&#' ,+' 8EG8' I1%' !"%*%),%5#&' ,%&%)?#=?%"' `' !"%@(&+5%)*%'%&&+' X' #'[email protected]*1+='%&*+,#' ,+'!"]*(@+',%'!"#N%@*#' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'#),%'+(),+' )#&' &%)*(5#&' %&*"+)C+5%)*%' @#)$#"*]?%(&' 0&1&.,$.0(! a! %F(! :(%! (! #&:-#1(! 0(! :(%6-2$0(#/' .+"%@%b)#&'+!%)+&'15+'I1%&*3#',%'*%5!#'+*`'I1%'%&*%'@#)$#"*#'&%'*#")%'%&*"+)C#R'*+='@#5#'#' I1+"*#',#'C#*%=',%'2%[email protected]'%'I1%'?#=*%5#&'+'!%)&+"'I1%'?+=%'+'!%)+'&%"')J5+,+'5+(&'15+'?%K/ '

8' 8EG8' !"%@(&+R' !#"' (&&#R' ,%' &%"' 15+' "%+=(,+,%' C#N%R' !+"+' !#,%"' +V("5+"b&%'

D"+,1+=5%)*%'@#5#'15'#BN%@*#'$+5(=(+"'[email protected]%&&A?%='+*"+?`&',+'/.2&#"$:&',%'15'@#5!1*+,#"/ '

8*"+?`&',#'*%5!#'%',+'1*(=(K+>3#R'#'#BN%@*#'%&*"+)C#' *#")+"b&%b]'$+5(=(+"/'8'5%*]$#"+'

,+'@"(+)>+R' ,%'7%(='2%[email protected]' %[email protected](,+'15' %$%(*#' ,%&%N]?%=' ,+'+!=(@+>3#-'+#' $#")%@%"' ,%'$#"5+' ()*1(*(?+'%'^*(='$%""+5%)*+&' %' @+)+(&' ,%'@#51)(@+>3#R' +' !=+*+$#"5+'!#,%' +!"#L(5+"',%'15+' $#"5+'()#?+,#"+' #&' [email protected]*#"%&' ,#' !"#@%&&#' ,#' @#)@1"&#' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+/' G#)&*+*+),#' +'5+(&b ?+=(+' ,%&*%'!"#@%&&#R' #&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' ,%&*+' !=+*+$#"5+'!#,%"3#' +!"%),%"R'@#5' #' "%@1"&#' ,+' *%@)#=#D(+R'15+')#?+'$#"5+',%'!%)&+"'#'!"#N%@*#R'+'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'#'@#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+R' ,%'*+='$#"5+'I1%'&%'!+&&+"3#'+'(,%)*(V(@+"'@#5'*#,#' #' !"#@%&&#/'715' $1*1"#'5+(&' #1'5%)#&' !"JL(5#R'+'(,%(+',%'()@#51)(@+>3#'%)*"%'%&*%&'+D%)*%&'&%"]'15+'(,%(+'%&*"+)C+/'7#'!"%&%)*%R DV!0&1$P/(!84449!.F(!W!-%!0&1$P/(!2&:.(=N;/:(3#' ,#' !#,%"' ,%' ,%@(&3#'%)*"%'*#,#&'#&'()*%"?%)(%)*%&')#'!"#@%&&#/

gl ' |Y///Z' #' %L%5!=#' ,+' @"(+)>+' +' |+,+!*+"b&%|' :' =()D1+D%5'Y///Z' (=1&*"+' #' $1)@(#)+5%)*#' ,+' 5(5%&%/' 8' @"(+)>+' |+B&#"?%|' 15+' =()D1+D%5'%L*%")+'+*"+?`&',%'15'!"#@%&&#',%'(5(*+>3#'%',%!#(&'1&+b+'@"(+*(?+5%)*%'!+"+'#&'&%1&'!"J!"(#&'V()&/|''Y2%[email protected]'ejjlZ

FG

FH

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

D84449!2,&! $/%! 1,(-=0! 7&!2(! ,$E&! $==! 2,&!$:2(#1! /.! 2,&! 6=$../.;! 6#(:&11!$0&G-$2&=3! #&6#&1&.2&0! $.0!2(! 6#(E/0&!2,&%!'/2,!2,&!$66#(6#/$2&!0&:/1/(.! %$)/.;!6('&#!'/2,/.! 2,&!1&E&#$=!12$;&1!("! 2,&!6=$../.;!$.0!0&1/;.!6#(:&114>!!8^&2(+"' +'&1+'(5!=%5%)*+>3#' )+'&#@(%,+,%9'@#5'#'+!"#?%(*+5%)*#' ,+'@[email protected](,+,%'()+*+',+'"%,%'%',+'5.2&#.&2' %5' *#")+"' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'@(,+,%' [email protected]%&&A?%(&' +'15' 5+(#"' )^5%"#',%'!%&&#+&R' @"%5#&' I1%'%&&+'(5!=%5%)*+>3#'("]'#@#""%"'D"+,1+='%')+*1"+=5%)*%/

gm '|Y///Z' +&' *`@)(@+&'"+"+5%)*%' %)*"+5' ,%'$#"5+' +B"1!*+' )15+' &#@(%,+,%R' %=+&'*M5'15+' C(&*J"(+/' W3#' #&'[email protected]*#"%&'&#@(+(&'I1%' +&' &%=%@@(#)+5R' I1%' %[email protected]#=C%5' +&' !"#!"(%,+,%&' I1%' =C%&' ()*%"%&&+5R' I1%' +&' !a%5' %5' $1)@(#)+5%)*#' %' I1%R' !+"+' %&&%' V(5R' 5#B(=(K+5' #&' &+B%"%&' #1' #&' @#)C%@(5%)*#&' @(%)*AV(@#&' %&!%@AV(@#&/' 8&' *`@)(@+&' &3#' &1!#"*%&' %' %L!"%&&a%&' ,%' %&*"+*`D(+&' &%=%@@(#)+,+&'%'1*(=(K+,+&'!#"'[email protected]*#"%&/|''[email protected]%"R'dqqlZ gn' sY///Z' SC(=%' (*' (&'?%"P' (5!#"*+)*' *#' B%'+S+"%'#$' ,($$%"%)*' *##=&'+),' *%@C)(I1%&' Y///Z' 5#&*'(5!#"*+)*' (&'+)'1),%"&*+),()D' #$' *C%' #?%"+=='#BN%@*(?%&'#$'!+"*(@(!+*(#)t''Y3#' ,#' *%@(,#' ,+' @(,+,%R' %L!"%&&+&' %5' !"#@%&&#&' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#' %' @#51)(@+>3#'!"#5#?(,#&'!%=#&'(),(?A,1#&',+'WE/ '

7%&&%' @#)*%L*#R' (,%)*(V(@]5#&' +' (5!#"*_)@(+',#' @#)@%(*#' ,%'#&0&R'"%[email protected](#)+,#' @#5''

%&&%&' !"#@%&&#&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' %' ,%' %&*"1*1"+>3#R' 5+)(!1=+>3#' %' *"+)&5(&&3#' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#',%'$#"5+',()_5(@+R'*+='@#5#'p+))%?+"'y1&C'N]'C+?(+'&1D%"(,#'%5'dqhi/ '

G#5' %&&%'@#)@%(*#' %5' 5%)*%R' (,%)*(V(@+5#&' ,#(&' *(!#&' $1),+5%)*+(&' ,%' "%,%' X' +&'

"%,%&' ,(D(*+(&' %' +&' "%,%&' +)+=JD(@+&' X' %' "%@#)C%@%5#&R' +!%&+"' ,+' @#5!=%5%)*+"(,+,%' %' (5!#"*_)@(+',%'+5B+&R'#'@"%[email protected]%)*%',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+&'!"(5%("+&'[email protected]%':&'^=*(5+&/ '

4%@#)C%@%5#&' I1%' %&*%' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#R' )3#' #B&*+)*%' @#)&*(*1("' 15+' 5+(&b?+=(+'

!+"+'#'(),(?A,1#',+'WER'"%,1K(),#'+&',(&*_)@(+&'%'+'$"#)*%("+',#',%[email protected]#)C%@(,#R'@#""%'#'"([email protected]#',%' &%'*#")+"')15+'&1+'!"(&3#R'%&*+),#'#'(),(?A,1#',+'WE',%&*()+,#'+'%&*+"'1&%6#&!#)=()%/ '

4%&#=?%5#&' %)*3#' $#@+"' #' (),(?A,1#' ,+' WE' %' +' &1+' @#5!=%L(,+,%R' +' &1+' 5^=*(!=+'

!%"&#)+=(,+,%R'%'+'&1+')%@%&&(,+,%',%'!"#,1K("'%'[email protected]%,%"':'&1+'()$#"5+>3#R'@#51)(@+),#R')#' !"#@%&&#R'@#5'15')^5%"#'@+,+'?%K'5+(#"',%'+!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&/ '

4%$%"(5#&' I1%' #' (),(?A,1#' ,+' WE' !%"*%)@%' +' 15' )^5%"#' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&' %=%?+,#' ,%'

"%,%&' ,(D(*+(&' %' +)+=JD(@+&R' [email protected]*#' I1%' *%"]' @#),1K(,#' +' 15+' 5+(#"' !"#@1"+' ,+' &1+' +"*(@1=+>3#'X'[email protected](=(*+),#'+&&(5'+'$#"5+'@#5'#'(),(?A,1#',+'WE'@("@1=+'!#"'%)*"%'+&'"%,%&/ '

6#@]5#&'%)*3#'+&'"%,%&',(D(*+(&'%'"%$%"(5#&',#(&'+!+"%)*%&'!+"+,#L#&-'!"(5%("#R'I1%'

+!%&+"' ,+&' "%,%&' ,(D(*+(&' %&*+"%5' @+,+' ?%K'5+(&' !"%&%)*%&' )#' )#&&#' 5%(#R' %&*3#' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&' +1&%)*%&' %5' *%"5#&' 5+*%"(+(&9' %' &%D1),#R' I1%' %&&+&' "%,%&' I1%' !"#5#?%5' +' @#51)(@+>3#'!#,%5R'&%'5+='1*(=(K+,+&R'!"#5#?%"'+'5+)(!1=+>3#'%'#'(&#=+5%)*#/ '

\'(&#=+5%)*#' "%V=%@*%' 15+'!"#@1"+' %[email protected]%&&(?+' ,%' +V("5+>3#' ,+' (,%)*(,+,%' #)=()%R' #'

I1%'&#B"%@+""%D+'+'"%,%',(D(*+=9'#'5%&5#' [email protected]#)*%@%'@#5'+'"%,%'+)+=JD(@+R'%?(,%)@(+),#' I1%' #&' !"#B=%5+&' ,+' WE' &3#R' *+5B`5R' #&' !"#B=%5+&' ,+' @(,+,%9' +' 5+)(!1=+>3#' =%?#1b)#&' +' "%@#)C%@%"'I1%'+'@[email protected](,+,%',%' #!%"+"' +&' OEG'"%!"%&%)*+'15' !#,%"' I1%' !#,%'&%"'1*(=(K+,#' !+"+'@#),(@(#)+"'+'[email protected]>3#'C15+)+/ '

G#5'*#,+'%&*+',()_5(@+'%5'5%)*%R'@#)&(,%"]5#&'1"D%)*%'+'+=*%"+>3#',#' !+"+,(D5+'

,+'W#@(%,+,%',+'E)$#"5+>3#' !+"+'15+'W#@(%,+,%',+'E)$#"5+>3#' %'G#51)(@+>3#R'I1%',%?%"]' +!"#?%(*+"' #&' "%@1"&#&' *%@)#=JD(@#&' +#' &%1' [email protected]+)@%' !+"+' %)@#)*"+"' 5%=C#"%&' $#"5+&' ,%' @##!%"+"' )+' @#)&*"1>3#' ,#' @#5!=%L#' +"*%[email protected]*#' C15+)#' I1%' @#5%>]5#&' !#"' "%$%"("' X' +' @(,+,%/

FI

F<

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

6(D/'ei-'0(+D"+5+b&A)*%&%-'s,+'@(,+,%R',+'"%,%R'%',#'(),(?A,1#',+'WEt

6(D/'el-'0(+D"+5+b&A)*%&%-'s0#'@#5!1*+,#"'%',+'E)*%")%*t

ESTADO DA ARTE

'

H5's0(!:(%6-2$0(#!&!0$! /.2&#.&2t'"%@#)C%@%5#&R' !#"'15'=+,#R' +',(&!#)(B(=(,+,%',#'

%L%"@[email protected](#',+'+"I1(*%@*1"+'&%'+,+!*+"'+#' @#)*%L*#',+'&#@(%,+,%'#),%'&%'()&%"%'5+&R'!#"'#1*"#R' +'!%&+,+'5]I1()+'!"#,1*(?+'&#B"%'+'I1+='&%'+!#(+'%'I1%'*#=%"+'+=*%"+>a%&'=%)*+&'%'D"+,1+(&/ '

G+"[email protected]*%"(K+5#&' *+5B`5' @#5#' =%)*#&' %' D"+,1+(&' #&' +?+)>#&' *%@)#=JD(@#&' I1%' *M5'

?(),#' +' !"#5#?%"' +' +=*%"+>3#' ,+&' $#"5+&' @#5#' &%' "%!"%&%)*+' %' @#51)(@+' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' ,%&(D)+,+5%)*%'+'()?%)>3#',#'@#5!1*+,#"!%'+'()?%)>3#',+'E)*%")%*/ '

W#B"%' +' !"(5%("+R' "%$%"(5#&' +' C%"+)>+' ,+' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' @][email protected]=#' +=D#"A*5(@#' ,#'

!"#*J*(!#' @#)@%!*1+=',+' ;]I1()+' ,%' O1"()D' %R' &#B"%*1,#R' ,+' ;]I1()+' c)(?%"&+=',%'O1"()DR' !+"+,(D5+' ,#' @#5!1*+,#"' 5#,%")#9' "%$%"(5#&' +' &1+' 5+*%"(+=(K+>3#' )#' H0p8GR' 5]I1()+' !%&+,+' %' @#5!=%L+' ,%' #!%"+"9' "%$%"(5#&' #&' %&$#">#&' )#' &%)*(,#' ,%' +!"#L(5+"' #&' @#5!1*+,#"%&' +#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&R' ,%&(D)+,+5%)*%' +*"+?`&' ,+' @"(+>3#' ,%' ()*%"[email protected]%&' ?(&1+(&' D"]V(@+&' X' #&' TcE' X' !"#!#&*#&' !#"' 3#' %)*"%' !#)*#&' +"B(*"]"(#&' ,+' "%,%' 5%,(+)*%' +'@("@1=+>3#' ,+'()$#"5+>3#' !#"' !#)*#&' ()*%"5`,(#&R' +*`' [email protected]+)>+"' #' ,%&*()#9' (,%)*(V(@+5#&' +' "%,%' ,%' @#5!1*+,#"%&' ()*%"@#)%@*+,#&' ,%&(D)+,+' !#"' 84.87HOR' @1N#' @"%[email protected](5%)*#' %' [email protected]%&&#' ("(+' 5#*(?+"' #' +!+"%@(5%)*#' ,%' "%,%&' !+"+=%=+&R' ,+),#' #"(D%5' +#' !"#B=%5+' ,+' &1+' +"*(@1=+>3#9' %&*%' ?("(+' +' &%"' "%&#=?(,#' @#5' +' I6&:/P/:$2/(.! ("! 5.2&#.&2! +#$.1%/11/(.! U(.2#(=R' 15' !"#*#@#=#',%'@#51)(@+>3#' )+' 5.2&#.&2' @+!+K',%' +"*(@1=+"' +&' "%,%&' %L(&*%)*%&R'%'I1%'?("(+'+'@#)&#=(,+"'+'1*(=(K+>3#',+'!+=+?"+'5.2&#.&2'!+"+',%&(D)+"'+'@"%[email protected]%)*%' "%,%' ,%'@#5!1*+,#"%&9')+',`@+,+',%'dqnj'%'dqqj'#' &%1'@"%[email protected](5%)*#'%'+15%)*#' ,%')^5%"#' ,%'1*(=(K+,#"%&' ?("(+'+'[email protected]&+"' 15' )#?#' !"#B=%5+' ,+' "%,%'X' +' D%&*3#' %V(@+K'%'+'!%&I1(&+',%' ()$#"5+>3#' )+' 5.2&#.&2! X' 5#*(?+),#' O%,' 7%=&#)' +' !"#!Å"' +' ,%5#@"+*(K+>3#' ,#' [email protected]%&&#' :' 5.2&#.&2!%'O(5'y%")%"&b2%%'+'()?%)*+"'#'I1%'&%"(+'+'vvv!c!15+'$#"5+'()*1(*(?+',%'[email protected]%,%"'+' @#)*%^,#&' ,+'5.2&#.&29'+'!+"*("' ,+I1('#' &1"D(5%)*#' ,%' 5#*#"%&' ,%'[email protected]+' %',+' v%B' e/j'*M5' *#")+,#'+'vvv!)15'"%@1"&#',()_5(@#' #),%'#&' @#)*%^,#&'&3#'@"(+,#&'@#)*()1+5%)*%'!%=#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&R'"%+=>+),#'+'!#&&(B(=(,+,%',#'*"+B+=C#'@#=+B#"+*(?#')+'"%,%/

FB

GC

Sociedade da Informação e da Comunicação

'

.#"' *1,#' (&*#R' @"%5#&' I1%' #' @#)*%L*#' [email protected]*1+=' ,+' W#@(%,+,%' ,+' E)$#"5+>3#' %'

G#51)(@+>3#' Y+' D%)%"+=(K+>3#' ,#' 1&#' ,#' @#5!1*+,#"' !%&&#+=' %' ,+' 5.2&#.&2R' +' &1+' !#"*+B(=(,+,%R'#' ()@"%5%)*#' ,+' &1+' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%'?(&1+=(K+>3#' %' *"+)&5(&&3#' ,%' @#)*%^,#&' 51=*(5`,(+R' +'@"%[email protected]%)*%' [email protected](=(,+,%'%5' !"#,1K("' %'!+"*(=C+"' ()$#"5+>3#' )+' "%,%' %' *"+B+=C+"' @#=+B#"+*(?+5%)*%Z' !"#!#"@(#)+' 15' @=(5+' !"#[email protected](#' +#' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,%' $%""+5%)*+&' *%@)#=JD(@+&' @+!+K%&' ,%' +1L(=(+"' #' (),(?A,1#' ,+' WE' )+' "%+=(K+>3#' ,#&' &%1&' #BN%@*(?#&' %' "%&#=1>3#',#&'&%1&'!"#B=%5+&/ '

\'@#)*%L*#' +&&15%b&%' +&&(5' @#5#' +' !+=+?"[email protected]+?%' ,%&*%' [email protected]+!A*1=#' %' +'!"(5%("+'

#!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+'#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'8EG84

ESTADO DA ARTE

[email protected]+H!&0%#=!+(*+)#I%'$*0$%#)+*+")#$'0'")-.!+"123'0)

!"!"#$%,$4+,')77,$%)$03$',-'0+7,$%)$&+80(5)'50+&$ '

G#5#' $#(' !#&&A?%='%)*%),%"' )#' !#)*#' +)*%"(#"R' +' &#@(%,+,%' @+5()C+' )#' &%)*(,#' ,%'

15+' @#5!=%L(,+,%' @+,+' ?%K'5+(#"' )#' I1%' ,(K'"%&!%(*#' :' @"(+>3#R' D%&*3#' %' *"+)&5(&&3#' ,+' ()$#"5+>3#R'#'I1%'=C%'D+"+)*(1'+',%&(D)+>3#',%'WE/ '

H&*+' @#5!=%L(,+,%' &J' `' !#&&A?%=' @#5' 15+' @+,+'?%K'5+(#"' "+!(,%K'%' I1+=(,+,%' ,%'

@#51)(@+>3#' %' ()$#"5+>3#9' %5' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' #&' !"#N%@*#&R'%&!+>#&' %' %,([email protected](#&' &3#' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&' @#5!=%L#&' $"1*#' )3#' &J' ,%' )%@%&&(,+,%&' [email protected]"%[email protected](,+&' ,%' @#)$#"*#' %' ,+' %?#=1>3#' ,+&' *`@)(@+&' %'5+*%"(+(&' ,%' @#)&*"1>3#R' 5+&' *+5B`5' ,%' )#"5+&' 5+(&' %L(D%)*%&' ,%' "%D1=+>3#' %' !=+)%+5%)*#' ,#' +5B(%)*%' @#)&*"1A,#/'8' #B"+',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+' `' @+,+'?%K'5%)#&' %)*%),(,+' @#5#' 15+' !%>+' (&#=+,+R' 5+&' +)*%&' ()*%D"+,+' )15' &(&*%5+' @#5!=%L#' ,%' "%=+>a%&' @1N#' %I1(=AB"(#',%!%),%R'@+,+'?%K'5+(&R',#&'?+=#"%&',+'@#=+B#"+>3#'%',#'@#5!"#5(&&#/ '

\'@#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'"%!"%&%)*+'15+'#!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+'@#=#@+"'%5',(]=#D#' +'

+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'#'D"+),%'!^B=(@#9'`R'(D1+=5%)*%R'15' !"#@%&&#' @#5!=%L#' I1%R' )+'&1+'%&&M)@(+R' !"#5#?%' +' +"*(@1=+>3#' ,%' ?]"(#&' [email protected]*#"%&gq ' )#' &%)*(,#' ,%' %)@#)*"+"' +' 5%=C#"' &#=1>3#' +"I1(*%@*J)(@+' !+"+' 15' ,%*%"5()+,#' %&!+>#' #1' %,([email protected](#/' 8' @#51)(@+>3#' %)*"%' #&' ?]"(#&' [email protected]*#"%&' %)?#=?(,#&' X' %I1(!+&' ,%' !"#N%@*#' %' @##",%)+>3#R' @=(%)*%R' $1*1"#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' %' #' D"+),%' !^B=(@#' X' !%"5(*%b=C%&R' *%),#' %5' @#)*+' #' #BN%@*(?#' @#515' +' I1%' &%' !"#!a%5R' @#5!=%*+"%5b&%'51*1+5%)*%R'5()(5(K+),#'+&&(5'+&'&1+&',(V(@1=,+,%&'!+"*(@1=+"%&/ '

E)*%"%&&+' %)*3#'@#5!"%%),%"' #' $1)@(#)+5%)*#',%' 15'@#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'%5'

!+"*(@1=+"' #' @#)@1"&#' !^B=(@#' X' #' I1%' (5!=(@+R' )%@%&&+"(+5%)*%R' #' &%1' %)I1+,"+5%)*#' )#' @#)*%L*#'=%D+='!#"*1D1M&hj / '

\'@#)@1"&#' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'`'15'!"#@%&&#'I1%'!%"5(*%R'!#"' 15'=+,#R'+!"%&%)*+"'+#'

@=(%)*%'15' )^5%"#' 5+(&'%=%?+,#' ,%'!"#!#&*+&' ,#' I1%'+I1%=%' I1%' &%"(+'+!"%&%)*+,#'@+&#' #' !"#N%@*#' $#&&%' +,N1,(@+,#' ,("%@*+5%)*%' +' 15+' %I1(!+' ,%' !"#N%@*#9' !#"' #1*"#R' !%"5(*%' I1%' 5+(&' %I1(!+&' ,%' !"#N%@*#' *%)C+5' +' !#&&(B(=(,+,%',%' %=+B#"+"' !"#!#&*+&' !+"+' %&&%' @=(%)*%R' gq'\' @#)@%(*#' ,%' [email protected]*#"'!+"%@%b)#&'+,%I1+,#' !+"+' ,%&(D)+"'#&'()*%"?%)(%)*%&')15'!"#@%&&#' ,%'!+"*(@(!+>3#' )+'5%,(,+' %5'I1%' )#&' "%5%*%' !+"+' #' ,%&%5!%)C#' ,%' 15' !+!%=' X' $1),+5%)*+=' )15' !"#@%&&#' ,%&*%' *(!#' `R' !"%@(&+5%)*%R' +' @=+"+' ,%V()(>3#' %' +"*(@1=+>3#' ,#&' ?]"(#&' !+!`(&' %' "%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%&' X' %' *+5B`5')#&' !#,%' "%5%*%"' !+"+' 15+' (,%(+' ,%' $+=&(,+,%R' ,%' &(51=+>3#R' (,%(+'I1%'!#,%'@#)&*(*1("'15'%)*"+?%':'!+"*(@(!+>3#/' hj'O+=' )3#' &(D)(V(@+'I1%' #&'#BN%@*(?#&',#' 084G'&%' "%V("+5'+!%)+&':'5#,+=(,+,%' ,#' @#)@1"&#' !^B=(@#' %'%[email protected]=1&(?+5%)*%'+#' )#&&#' !+A&/'G#)*1,#R',+,#&'#' 5+(#"'()*%"%&&%'!^B=(@#',%&*%' *(!#' ,%'@#)@1"&#' Y)#"5+=5%)*%' +&&#@(+,#' +'#B"+&'@#5'D"+),%' ([email protected]*#' )#' %&!+>#' ,+'@(,+,%Z' %' +' %&!%@(V(@(,+,%' ,%' @+,+' !+A&'"%=+*(?+5%)*%':&'@#5!=%L+&'5+*`"(+&',+' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %'!+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+R' %&*+'$#@+=(K+>3#'+!"%&%)*#1b&%'@#5#'#'!#)*#',%'!+"*(,+'5+(&'=JD(@#'!+"+'+'()?%&*(D+>3#/

[email protected]

GD

Concurso de arquitectura e participação pública

!#,%),#' !#"' (&&#' @#)&*(*1("' 15+' (5!#"*+)*%' #!#"*1)(,+,%' !"#V(&&(#)+=hd9' )3#' 5%)#&' (5!#"*+)*%'`'#'[email protected]*#',#')^5%"#',%'!"#!#&*+&'%)"(I1%@%"'+',([email protected]&&3#'%5'*#")#',#&'!"#N%@*#&R' !%"5(*(),#' %&*+B%=%@%"' !#)*#&' ,%' @#5!+"+>3#R' +!"#L(5+>a%&' %' ,(?%"DM)@(+&' %)*"%' +&' !"#!#&*+&'+!"%&%)*+,+&R'!"#@1"+),#'+&&(5'%)@#)*"+"'+'&#=1>3#'5+(&'+,%I1+,+'!+"+'#'%&!+>#' #1'%,([email protected](#/ '

8&&(5R' !+"+' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+' 8EG8R' `' ?(*+=' @#)C%@%"' #&' @J,(D#&R' @#)@%(*#&' %'

!"#@%,(5%)*#&' I1%' !#,%5' +$%@*+"' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,%' 15' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+/' 8' $#)*%'!"(5]"(+'!+"+'+B#",+"5#&'+'I1%&*3#' `'#'!#"*+='y8WH' X'@#)*"+*#&'!^B=(@#&'#)=()%' X'

I1%'&%'(,%)*(V(@+'@#5# *84449! -%! &16$T(! 0&!0/X=(;(! :(%! (1! /.2&#E&./&.2&1! .-%! :(.2#$2(! 6j7=/:(!!85^U53#'#)=()%'@%"*(V(@+,+&'!%=#'GHTH4/ '

4%V("+b&%R'@#5#' )#*+'(5!#"*+)*%R'I1%'I1%"' #'GG.R'I1%"' #'y8WHR'I1%"'+&'!=+*+$#"5+&'

,%'@#)*"+*+>3#' %L(&*%)*%&' &%'"%!#"*+5'+'15'5%"@+,#'+=+"D+,#' ,%'[email protected]*(?(,+,%&R'%')3#' +!%)+&' +#' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+' X' #' I1%R' &%'!#"' 15' =+,#' "%!"%&%)*+'15+' @#),(@(#)+)*%' +#' %&*1,#R' !%=+' $+=*+',%'5+(#"'%&!%@(V(@(,+,%R'!#"'#1*"#' "%!"%&%)*+'15+'!#*%)@(+=(,+,%'!+"+'+'8EG8-'#',%'%=+' &%' !#,%"' +V("5+"' !%=+' &1+' %&!%@(V(@(,+,%R' ,("%@@(#)+,+' !+"+' #' 5%"@+,#' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' $#")%@%),#' #&' #!%"+,#"%&' %&!%@AV(@#&' I1%' #1*"+&' !=+*+$#"5+&R' !#"' &%"%5' D%)`"(@+&R' )3#' !#&&1%5/' 8&&(5R' ,#(&' !#&&A?%(&' @+5()C#&' &%'+!#)*+5'!+"+'#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'8EG8-'15' )#'&%)*(,#',+'&1+'+V("5+>3#' @#5#' !=+*+$#"5+' ,%' @#)*"+*+>3#' (),%!%),%)*%'[email protected]!"(),#' +&' $1)>a%&' ,+&' !=+*+$#"5+&' [email protected]*1+(&' %' #$%"%@%),#' #!%"+,#"%&' +,(@(#)+(&' "%[email protected](#)+,#&' @#5' #&' @#)@1"&#&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+Z' %' #1*"#' )#' &%)*(,#' ,%' $1)@(#)+"' @#5#' 15+' %L*%)&3#' ,+&' !=+*+$#"5+&' %L(&*%)*%&R' #$%"%@%),#' #&' "%$%"(,#&' #!%"+,#"%&R' 5+&' ,%(L+),#' +' "%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%',+'@#)*"+*+>3#'!+"+'+&'^=*(5+&/ '

E),%!%),%)*%5%)*%' ,#' !%"@1"&#' +' +,#!*+"R' #' @#)C%@(5%)*#' ,#' !"#@%&&#' ,%' 15'

hd '8*%)*%b&%R' @#)*1,#R' I1%' +' !+"*(@(!+>3#' )15'@#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' [email protected]+""%*+' 15' ()?%&*(5%)*#' ,%' *%5!#' %' "%@1"&#&' &%5' D+"+)*(+' ,%' "%*#")#R' #' I1%' @#=#@+' &`"(#&' %)*"+?%&' :' !+"*(@(!+>3#R' &#B"%*1,#' !+"+' +&' !"]*(@+&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' 5%)#&' %&*+B%=%@(,+&')#'5%"@+,#/ he '\' y8WH' s+Z' @%)*"+=(K+' +' ()$#"5+>3#' 5+(&'(5!#"*+)*%' &#B"%' #&' @#)*"+*#&' !^B=(@#&' @%=%B"+,#&9' BZ' !1B=(@(*+R' %)*"%' #1*"#&R' #' =+)>+5%)*#' ,%' @#)@1"&#&' %' ,%' #1*"#&' !"#@%,(5%)*#&' ,%' @#)*"+*+>3#R' +' @%=%B"+>3#' ,%' @#)*"+*#' !#"' +N1&*%' ,("%@*#R' +&' &+)>a%&' +!=(@+,+&'!#"'()$"[email protected]>a%&'+#' GJ,(D#' ,#&'G#)*"+*#&'.^B=(@#&9' @Z',(?1=D+' @#)*%^,#&'*`@)(@#&'%' =%D(&=+>3#' "%=%?+)*%9' ,Z' +!"#L(5+'+&' ()&*(*1(>a%&' ,#' @(,+,3#R' )+' 5%,(,+' %5' I1%' %&*(51=+' +' #B&%"?+>3#' %' #' @#)C%@(5%)*#' ,+' ,%&!%&+' !^B=(@+' %$%@*1+,+/t' ' YE7GER' ejjn+Z

ESTADO DA ARTE

@#)@1"&#'`'$1),+5%)*+='!+"+'&+B%"'%5'I1%'@#),(>a%&' +'8EG8'!#,%"]'&%"')%=%'()*%D"+,+9'+I1(' &1"D%'+'!"(5%("+',(V(@1=,+,%R'!#(&')3#'%L(&*%'15'^)(@#'*(!#',%'G#)@1"&#-'+'D"+),%',($%"%)>+R' !#"?%)*1"+R' *%"]' +' ?%"' @#5' #' *(!#' ,%' @=(%)*%' ,#' G#)@1"&#R' I1%' !#,%"]' &%"' #1' 15' @=(%)*%' !"(?+,#' #1' 15' @=(%)*%' !^B=(@#/' \' ^=*(5#R' @"%5#&R' *%5' 15+' [email protected](=(,+,%' ,%' ()*%"?%)>3#' )+' "%+=(,+,%'@+!+K',%'!"#,1K("'D"+),%&'*"+)&$#"5+>a%&')#&'%&!+>#&',+'@(,+,%R'"+K3#'!%=+'I1+='#' @#)@1"&#' !^B=(@#' &%' +&&15%' @#5#' 15' #BN%@*#' ,%' %&*1,#' (5!#"*+)*%' !+"+' +' !"%&%)*%' 0(&&%"*+>3#'%R'@#)&%I1%)*%5%)*%R'!+"+'#'084G/ '

7#' %)*+)*#R' *+5B`5' #' @#)@1"&#' !^B=(@#' !#&&1(' ?+"(+)*%&R' #1' *(!#&9'+&&(5R' %' @#5#'

%L(&*%5'?]"(#&'*(!#&' ,%'@#)@1"&#'!^B=(@#R'@+,+'I1+='@#5'#&'!"#@%,(5%)*#&'!"J!"(#&hg R'C#1?%' +')%@%&&(,+,%',%'&%=%@@(#)+"'#&'*(!#&'5+(&'"%=%?+)*%&'!+"+'#' %&*1,#R'*%),#'&(,#'%=%(*#&' @#5#' 5+(&'%&*"+*`D(@#&'+I1%=%&'I1%'!"#5#?%5'15+'5+(#"'!+"*(@(!+>3#'%',([email protected]&&3#',+&'(,%(+&hh/ '

8&&(5R' ,%'%)*"%'#&' ?]"(#&'*(!#&' ,%' @#)@1"&#' !^B=(@#' %L(&*%)*%&R'&%=%@@(#)+5#&'#' ,%'

@#)@%!>3#' @#5#' #' !"#@%,(5%)*#',%'"%$%"M)@(+'+'%&*%'%&*1,#'X')3#'&J'!%=+'&1+'+,%I1+>3#' +#' @#)*%L*#' ,#' @#)@1"&#' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'5+&' *+5B`5' !%=#'&%1'!#&*%"(#"' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' %5' @#)@1"&#'!^B=(@#'#1'@#)@1"&#'=(5(*+,#'!#"'!"`?(+'I1+=(V(@+>3#'YI1%R'%5'+5B#&' #&'@+&#&R'*M5' !#"' #BN%@*(?#' +' !+"*(@(!+>3#' ,%' ?]"(+&' %)*(,+,%&' )+' %=+B#"+>3#' ,%' ?]"(+&' !"#!#&*+&' !+"+' "%&#=1>3#',%'15'!"#D"+5+Z/

hg ' G#)@1"&#' ,%' @#)@%!>3#R' @#)@1"&#' !^B=(@#R' @#)@1"&#' =(5(*+,#' !#"' !"`?(+' I1+=(V(@+>3#R' @#)@1"&#' !^B=(@#' %&!%@(+=R' +N1&*%' ,("%@*#R')%D#@(+>3#'%',(]=#D#'@#)@#""%)@(+=/ hh ' .#"' %L%5!=#R' %)*%),%5#&' &%"' 5+(&' "%=%?+)*%' !+"+' +' 8EG8' +' &1+' ()*%D"+>3#' )15' @#)@1"&#' ,%' @#)@%!>3#' YI1%' +!%=+' :' !+"*(@(!+>3#' ,%' ?]"(+&'%)*(,+,%&Z' ,#' I1%' )15'+N1&*%' ,("%@*#' YI1%' @#)*%5!=+' +' !+"*(@(!+>3#' ,%' +!%)+&'15+Z9' *+=' )3#' &(D)(V(@+' I1%' +' 8EG8' )3#' !#&&+' &%"' ,%&%)?#=?(,+' @#5'?(&*+' :' &1+' +!=(@+>3#' )15'+N1&*%' ,("%@*#R' 5+&' %&&+' )3#' ,%?%"]' &%"R' @"%5#&R' +' &1+' !"(#"(,+,%/

GE

GF

Concurso de arquitectura e participação pública

6(D/'em-'6=1L#D"+5+',#'@#)@1"&#',%'@#)@%!>3#

ESTADO DA ARTE

'

.#"',%V()(>3#R'#'@#)@1"&#',%'@#)@%!>3#'`-

*84449! -%! /.12#-%&.2(! 6#(:&0/%&.2$=! &16&:/$=!G-&!6&#%/2&!a! &.2/0$0&!$0O-0/:$.2&!1&=&::/(.$#! -%! (-!%$/1!2#$7$=,(1! 0&! :(.:&6TF(! ! 85^U53#' Y)#' I1+='+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'`'=(5(*+,+'%5' $1)>3#',+'@[email protected](,+,%'*`@)(@+',#&' @+),(,+*#&R'&1N%(*+'+' +?+=(+>3#' !#"' !+"*%' ,+' %)*(,+,%' +,N1,(@+)*%Z/' H5' +5B#&' #&' @+&#&' #&' @+),(,+*#&' *%"3#' I1%' [email protected]%,%"'+#&'*%"5#&',%'"%$%"M)@(+'X',#@15%)*+>3#'!"%=(5()+"'I1%'?(&+'()$#"5+"'#&'@+),(,+*#&' &#B"%'#&'#BN%@*(?#&'%'!"#@%,(5%)*#&' ,#'@#)@1"&#R'%'$#")%@%"b=C%&'+&'!%>+&',%&%)C+,+&'%o#1' %[email protected]"(*+&' )%@%&&]"(+&' :' "%+=(K+>3#' ,+&' !"#!#&*+&9' )%&*%' !+&&#' +' 8EG8' !#,%"]' #$%"%@%"' 15+' ()*%"[email protected]%' *%@)#=JD(@+' +N1&*+,+' :' %L(B(>3#' ,%&*%&' @#)*%^,#&R' @#5' !+"*(@1=+"' ()*%"%&&%' )+&' !%>+&' ,%&%)C+,+&R' (),#' +&&(5' !+"+' +=`5' ,#' 5%"#' ,%[email protected]+""%D+5%)*#' ,#&' V(@C%("#&' !+"+' #' @#5!1*+,#"/ '

7%&*+' $+&%' !#,%"3#' +(),+' &1"D("' ,^?(,+&' &#B"%' #&' *%"5#&' ,%' "%$%"M)@(+'

,(&!#)(B(=(K+,#&R' #&' I1+(&' ,%?%"3#' &%"' %[email protected]=+"%@(,+&' )+' !=+*+$#"5+' %=%@*"J)(@+' X' +' 8EG8R' @"%5#&R' !#,%"]' #$%"%@%"' 15' %&!+>#' !+"+' %[email protected]=+"%@(5%)*#' ,+&' ,^?(,+&' I1%' ?]' !+"+' +=`5' ,+' @#51)(@+>3#'!#"'@#""%(#'%=%@*"J)(@#/ '

8!J&' %&*%' !+&&#R' @+&#' +' %)*(,+,%' +,N1,(@+)*%' !"%*%),+' &%=%@@(#)+"' #&' @+),(,+*#&'

+,5(&&A?%(&' :' +!"%&%)*+>3#' ,+&' !"#!#&*+&R' %&*%&' *%"3#' I1%' +!"%&%)*+"' ,#@15%)*+>3#' !+"+' ,%5#)&*"+"'+'&1+'@[email protected](,+,%hi/ '

8!J&' %&*+' !"`bI1+=(V(@+>3#' YI1+),#' +!=(@]?%=Z' #' V=1L#D"+5+' ,#' @#)@1"&#' ,%'

@#)@%!>3#' +!#)*+'=#D#'!+"+'+'+!"%&%)*+>3#',+&' !"#!#&*+&'!#"'!+"*%',#&'@#)@#""%)*%&/'8I1(R' @"%5#&' I1%'%L(&*%' 15' C(+*#' I1%'+' 8EG8' !#,%"]' &1!"(5("R' %'I1%' ,(K'"%&!%(*#' :' #B*%)>3#' ,%' $%%,[email protected]',1"+)*%'+'$+&%',%'@#)@%!>3#' ,+&' !"#!#&*+&-'+'8EG8'!#,%"]'$#")%@%"'15+'()*%"[email protected]%' @#5!#&*+' !#"' ,(?%"&#&' #!%"+,#"%&' @+!+K%&' ,%' !"#5#?%"' #' ,(]=#D#' %)*"%' @#)@#""%)*%&R'

hi '7#"5+=5%)*%' %&*%&',#@15%)*#&' "%!#"*+5b&%' +' (),(@+,#"%&' %&*+*A&*(@#&' I1%' @#5!"#?%5'+' @[email protected](,+,%' ,#' @#)@#""%)*%' %5' @#)@"%*(K+"'+'#B"+R'@+&#'&%N+'?%)@%,#"+R'@#5#'+'&(*1+>3#'%@#)J5(@+',#'@#)@#""%)*%R'+'%L!%"(M)@(+'!"]*(@+R'%*@/

GG

GH

Concurso de arquitectura e participação pública

!"#5#*#"%&'%'!^B=(@#'%5'D%"+= hlR'%'@+!+K',%'()$#"5+"'#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+&'!"#!#&*+&/ '

\&'!+&&#&'&%D1()*%&'I1%'%)*%),%5#&',%&*[email protected]+"',(K%5'"%&!%(*#R'!"(5%("#R':'&1B5(&&3#'

,#&' *"+B+=C#&' ,%' @#)@%!>3#R' %' &%D1),#' :' +?+=(+>3#' ,%&&%&' *"+B+=C#&/' 8I1(' @"%5#&' I1%' #' &1!#"*%' ,(D(*+=' !"#!#"@(#)+,#' !%=+' 8EG8' !#,%"]' @#)&*(*1("' 15' 5%(#' !+"+' %&*"1*1"+"' +' &1B5(&&3#' ,#&' @#)*%^,#&' %' +' &1+' ?(&1+=(K+>3#' !+"+' %$%(*#&' ,%' +?+=(+>3#' ,#' N1"(' %o#1' @#)C%@(5%)*#' ,#' !^B=(@#R' $#")%@%),#' %&!+>#&' "%&%"?+,#&' !+"+' +'%)*"%D+',%',%*%"5()+,#&' %=%5%)*#&' X' @#5#' %&!+>#' !+"+' &1B5(&&3#' ,+' (5!=+)*+>3#R' %&!+>#' !+"+' &1B5(&&3#' ,#&' +=>+,#&R'%*@hm/'G"%5#&'I1%'%&*+'+?+=(+>3#',+&'!"#!#&*+&'*+5B`5'!#,%"(+'&%"'$%(*+'#)=()%'!%=#' D"+),%'!^B=(@#R'@#5'5+(#"'#1'5%)#"'!%&#')+',%@(&3#',#'N^"(/ '

G#5#' )#*+' ,%' @#)@=1&3#R' ,%?%5#&' "%$%"("' I1%' #' @#)@1"&#' !^B=(@#' ,%' @#)@%!>3#'

"%!"%&%)*+R'!#"?%)*1"+R'#' *(!#',%'@#)@1"&#'5+(&'@#5!=%L#'+'I1%'+'8EG8'!#,%"]',+"'"%&!#&*+R' &#B"%*1,#' !%=+' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' @15!"("' "%I1(&(*#&' *`@)(@#&' %L(DA?%(&' :&' !=+*+$#"5+&' %=%@*"J)(@+&' @%"*(V(@+,+&R' !%=+' D+"+)*(+',%'+)#)(5+*#' ,+&' !"#!#&*+&R' %'!#"' )%@%&&(,+,%&' ,%' &%D1"+)>+' %' (&%)>3#R' ,+,#' %&*+"%5' %5' N#D#' @#5' 5+(#"' ()*%)&(,+,%' ?+=#"%&' %' ,()C%("#&' !^B=(@#&/' 7#' %)*+)*#R' ,%?%5#&' *%"' %5' @#)*+' I1%' #&' @#)@1"&#&' !"#5#?(,#&' !#"' ()(@(+*(?+' !"(?+,+'!#,%"3#' &%"' *+5B`5' 15' (5!#"*+)*%' @+&#' ,%' %&*1,#' %' ,%' +!=(@+>3#' !+"+' +' 8EG8R' %' !#,%"3#' 5%&5#' @#)*%"' 5%)#&' =(5(*+>a%&' *`@)(@+&' %' =%D+(&R' [email protected](=(*+),#' +&&(5' #' !"#@%&&#' !+"*(@(!+*(?#/ '

H5' I1+=I1%"' ,+&' &(*1+>a%&R' @"%5#&R' #' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' &1"D%' @#5#' 15+'

#!#"*1)(,+,%' !+"+' +' !"#5#>3#' ,+' !+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+' )+' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' *%5]*(@+' I1%' )#&' ()*%"%&&+'+B#",+"'%5'&%D1(,+/

hl'73#'#B&*+)*%'&%N+'15+' $1)@(#)+=(,+,%'()*%"%&&+)*%R'C]'I1%' +?%"(D1+"'+' &1+'!#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%'()*%D"+>3#' )15'G#)@1"&#' ,%&*+' )+*1"%K+R')#5%+,+5%)*%' !#"'I1%&*a%&' ,%' +)#)(5+*#' ,+&'!"#!#&*+&/'G#)*1,#R'+' (5!=%5%)*+>3#R' @"%5#&R' &%"]' 5+(&'[email protected](@+' )#' @+&#',%'@#)@1"&#&'@#5'!"#5#*#"%&'!"(?+,#&/ hm '0%?%5#&'*%"R'@#)*1,#R' +*%)>3#' +' I1%'%&*%' !+"*(@(#)+5%)*#R' &%'%[email protected]%&&(?#R'!#,%"]' =(5(*+"'+'@"(+*(?(,+,%' ,#&'@#)@#""%)*%&')+' @#5!#&(>3#',#&'!+()`(&',%'%)*"%D+9'!#"'#1*"#'=+,#R'!#,%"]'[email protected](=(*+"'@#5!+"+>a%&'5+(&'#BN%@*(?+&',#&'*"+B+=C#&/

ESTADO DA ARTE

!"!"!$%&$4&+5('(4&9:,$4;3#',#'+5B(%)*%'@#)&*"1A,#R'&%),#'#' @#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'15+'#!#"*1)(,+,%' !+"+'*%&*+"'%&&%&'!"#@%&&#&',%'@#51)(@+>3#R'@+B%),#':&'+&&#@(+>a%&'%'!"]*(@+&'!"#V(&&(#)+(&' !+"*%' ,+' "%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%' )+' !"#5#>3#' ,#' !"#@%&&#hn /' H&*+' @"%[email protected]%)*%' @#)[email protected](%)@(+=(K+>3#' !#,%"]' &%"' "%&1=*+,#' *+5B`5' ,#' "%@#)C%@(5%)*#' ,#' ,`V(@(*' ,%5#@"]*(@#' )#&' !"#@%&&#&' ,%' !=+)%+5%)*#R',+,#'I1%'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+'`'%)*%),(,+'@#5#'15+'+5%+>+'+#&' ()*%"%&&%&' %@#)J5(@#&'%'!#=A*(@#&',%'+=D1)&*+,&!12(#3!("!6$#2/:/6$2/(.!#-.1!6$#$==&=!2(!2,$2!("!0&%(:#$:33#' !^B=(@+'"%!"%&%)*%'15+'+5%+>+'+#&'()*%"%&&%&',([email protected](!=()+"%&' ,#&' *`@)(@#&' "%&!#)&]?%(&' !%=+&' #B"+&' %'+#&' ()*%"%&&%&' %@#)J5(@#&' ,#&' &%1&' 5+(&' ,("%@*#&' !"#5#*#"%&9'!"%*%),%5#&R'%5'+=*%")+*(?+R'!"#!#"'15' %)*%),(5%)*#',+'!+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+' @#5#' 15' !"#@%&&#' ?+)*+N#&#' !+"+' *#,+&' +&' !+"*%&' X' ,%&,%' I1%' #' &%1' %)*%),(5%)*#R' +"*(@1=+>3#' %' ,(?(&3#' ,%' "%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%&' &%N+' B%5' @#)&%D1(,#/' WJ' +*"+?`&' ,#' "%@#)C%@(5%)*#'5^*1#' ,+&'&1+&'?+)*+D%)&'!#,%"]'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+'@#)&*(*1("b&%'@#5#' "%D"+' %' )3#' @#5#' %[email protected]%!>3#' +#' !"#@%&&#' +"I1(*%@*J)(@#' %R' %5' !+"*(@1=+"R' +#' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+/'8'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+',%?%'&%"'%)@+"+,+'@#5#'15'@#5!=%5%)*#'^*(='+'*#,#&'#&' !"#N%@*#&'%')3#'+!%)+&'+'+=D1)&/ '

8&&(5R'%'&%5'@#=#@+"'%5'@+1&+'#&'@#)C%@(5%)*#&'*`@)(@#&R'@(%)*AV(@#&'%o#1'+"*A&*(@#&'

,#' +"I1(*%@*#' %' #&' ()*%"%&&%&' %@#)J5(@#&' ,#' !"#5#*#"' %' @=(%)*%R' `' )%@%&&]"(#' #' "%@#)C%@(5%)*#' ,+'(5!#"*_)@(+',#' @#)*"(B1*#' X'@%"*+5%)*%'5+(&'(5%,(+*#'%'%5!A"(@#' X',#' @(,+,3#' I1%' ?(?%' %' @#)C%@%' #' =1D+"' ,+' ()*%"?%)>3#' &#B' #1*"#' !#)*#' ,%'?(&*+'X' #' ,#' &%)&#' @#515'%'#',+'%L!%"(M)@(+hq/' \'@#)C%@(5%)*#'@(%)*AV(@#' %' #' @#)C%@(5%)*#'%5!A"(@#'&3#R'!#"' (&&#R',1+&' #",%)&',%'@#)C%@(5%)*#' ,(&*()*+&'I1%',%?%5'$1)@(#)+"'%5'@#5!=%5%)*+"(,+,%'%'

hn ' sY///Z' !"#$%&&(#)+=' #"D+)(K+*(#)&' +),' !"[email protected]*(@%&' @+)' !=+P' +' Q%P' "#=%' ()' Y///Z' !"#5#*()D' S(,%"' &#@(+=' %)D+D%5%)*' *C"#1DCR' $#"' %L+5!=%R'@#5!%*(*(#)&/|''Y3#',#&' C]B(*#&',%'!+"*(@(!+>3#',+' &#@(%,+,%' !#"*1D1%&+R' *+)*#' 5+(&' I1%' %&*+' ?#)*+,%' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' (.=/.&' N]' %L(&*%-' )3#' !#,%5#&' &%"' (),($%"%)*%&' Y+(),+' I1%' +&' *%)C+5#&' I1%' #B&%"?+"' @#5' 15' #=C+"' @"A*(@#' %' +*%)*#Z' +#' [email protected]%&&#' ,+&' %5%"D%)*%&' !=+*+$#"5+&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' )+' 5.2&#.&2' I1%' &%' @#)&*(*1%5' @#5#' 15' +1*M)*(@#' $%)J5%)#' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' D=#B+=ijR' %' :' I1+=' +' &#@(%,+,%' !#"*1D1%&+' )3#' `' %[email protected]%!>3#/' ' )%@%&&]"(#' *"+)&!#"' %&*+' ?#)*+,%' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' !+"+' #&' 5%"@+,#&' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %' ,+'@#)&*"1>3#R' @#=#@+),#' #' @#)@1"&#' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+')#'@%)*"#' ,+&',([email protected]&&a%&/ '

.+"+' +=D1)&' +1*#"%&R' #' "%@%)*%' %' +(),+' [email protected]*1+=' $"[email protected]+&&#' ,+' %@#)#5(+' ()*%")[email protected](#)+=R'

@#5' %$%(*#&' )#*]?%(&' )#&' 5%"@+,#&' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %' @#)&*"1>3#' X' *+5B`5' ?A*(5+&' ,+' +!+"M)@(+R'(5+D%5'%'%&!%@1=+>3#'X'@#)&*(*1('15+'#!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+'"%!%)&+"'+'=(D+>3#'%)*"%' +'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'+'&#@(%,+,%D84449! 2,&! E! E$=-&1! (.! ',/:,! 2,$2! 2#$0&! '$1! "(-.0&0! $#&! 7&/.;! :$==&0! /.2(! G-&12/(.3#' @#5!=%*+' ,#' %)*%),(5%)*#' "%,[email protected](#)(&*+R' $1)@(#)+=(&*+R' @%)*"+=(K+,#' %' %&*]*(@#id ' ,#' 5#,%=#' ,%' .=+)%+5%)*#'+*`'%)*3#'%)*%),(,#'@#5#'%L%5!=+"R'C%",+,#',#';#?(5%)*#';#,%")#*Z2! 6#&1&.23#t9' @#)&1=*+' Y)A?%=' hR' ,%V()(,#' @#5#' s15' @#)?(*%' :' #!()(3#' ,#&' @(,+,3#&' Y///Z' 5+&' &%5' D+"+)*(+&' ,%' I1%' %&*+&' &%"3#' *#5+,+&' %5' @#)&(,%"+>3#t9' %' !+"@%"(+' Y)A?%=' lR' I1%' @#)&(,%"]5#&' &(5(=+"' :' Ç)%D#@(+>3#U' ,%' 3#' "%=+*(?+5%)*%'+#&' !"#B=%5+&',([email protected](!=()+"%&',+'+"I1(*%@*1"+-' D84449!.&'! 5+! 2((=1! $.0! 2&:,./G-&1! 6&#%/2! 0/""&#&.2! "(#%1! ("! /."(#%$2/(.! 0&=/E!#/ ii ' +'%)*"%' %&*+' @#)@%!>3#' (,%+=(&*+' %' +' %$%@*(?+'(5!=%5%)*+>3#' !"]*(@+R'5#*(?+,+'!#"'?]"(+&' "+Ka%&' I1%'!"#@1"+"%5#&R' %5' &%D1(,+R' %L!=(@(*+"/ '

\'!"(5%("#' %)*"+?%':'!+"*(@(!+>3#')#')#&&#'!+A&'&%"]R'!#"?%)*1"+R'+'+1&M)@(+',%'15+'

*"+,(>3#'!+"*(@(!+*(?+R'I1%'!#,%"]'&%"'%L!=(@+,#'!%=#' @+"]@*%"'"%=+*(?+5%)*%'N#?%5',+' )#&&+' ,%5#@"[email protected](+R' %' !%=#' @+"]@*%"' N#?%5' ,+' !"J!"(+' !"#V(&&3#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*#il -' %&*+R' *+=' @#5#' +' @#)@%B%5#&' C#N%R' `' 15' $%)J5%)#' "%@%)*%-' )+' H1"#!+' ,#' 7#"*%R' #' %&*+B%=%@(5%)*#' ,%' $"#)*%("+&'@#5' #1*"#&'!"#V(&&(#)+(&'"%[email protected](#)+,#&' @#5'+'@#)&*"1>3#' %'#'%L%"@[email protected](#',+'!"#V(&&3#' &1N%(*#' +'=(@%)>+'@#5%>#1'+',+"b&%'%)*%'+'!+"*("',#' W`@/'rEr' 'Y3#' ,#' !"#@%&&#-

il'\'!"#V(&&(#)+='I1%R'%5')#&&#'%)*%),%"R',%?%"]'+&&15("'15+'!#&*1"+'5+(&'[email protected]*(?+')+'!"#5#>3#',+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+/ im'8'\8'$#('@"(+,+'%5'dqqnR'+*"+?`&',#'0%@"%*#b2%(')udmloqnR',%'g',%'3#',+'()(@(+*(?+'=%D(&=+*(?+'!#!1=+"'X'sc5',("%(*#',#&'@(,+,3#&t/

ESTADO DA ARTE

!

D84449!.(1!$.(1!AK!(!]&/.(!f./0(!&E/0&.:/$E$!&`6&#/o.:/$1!0&![=$.&$%&.2(!U(=$7(#$2/E(!

G-&! 1&! :$#$:2&#/Q$E$%! 6(#! 1&#&%! :/#:-.12$.:/$/13#' %5'+&!%@*#&'=(5(*+,#&',#'!"#N%@*#'Y3#'!+"%@%'*%"'#"(D%5')+'!"J!"(+'$#"5+>3#'[email protected]+,`5(@+',#&'+"I1(*%@*#&R',%5+&(+,#' @%)*"+,+'%5'?+=#"%&'$#"5+(&'%'$1)@(#)+(&lj/ '

G#5#' +!#)*+'7%*#'Y7%*#R' ejjeZR'+'+1&M)@(+' ,%'15'@#)*%L*#'!#=A*(@#' %'()&*(*[email protected](#)+='

!"#[email protected](#' :'@#51)(@+>3#' %)*"%'#&'?]"(#&'[email protected]*#"%&'`'*+5B`5'15'[email protected]*#"' I1%',(V(@1=*+'#'!"#@%&&#' !+"*(@(!+*(?#-' +' I1%&*3#' %&&%)@(+=' "%!#"*+b&%' :' !+"*(=C+' ,%' !#,%"R' N]' I1%' !+"*(@(!+>3#' `' !#,%"ld ' !+"+' @#)*"#=+"' I1%"' #&' !"#@%&&#&R' I1%"' #' !"#,1*#' V()+=/' 8' I1%&*3#' ,#' @#)*%L*#' !#=A*(@#' Y%' %@#)J5(@#Z' `' *+5B`5' "%$%"(,+' !#"' 3#',%!%),(+'%5'=+"D+'%[email protected]+=+',+'@[email protected](,+,%',%'V()+)@(+5%)*#',#'D#?%")#'B"(*_)(@#/ lg'sY///Z' %)&1"()D' *C+*')%S' !"#@%&&%&'+"%' ()*%D"+*%,'()*#' %L(&*()D'D#?%")+)@%'&*"[email protected]*1"%&'&#' *C+*' ,%=(B%"+*(?%' +),'"%!"%&%)*+*(?%' $#"5&'#$'D#?%")+)@%'+"%')#*'()'@#)V=(@*/t''Y8=B%"*'F'.+&&5#"%R'ejjnZ

HE

HF

Concurso de arquitectura e participação pública

I1%'`',+,+':&'&1+&'#!()(a%&R'!#"'!+"*%',+&'()&*(*1(>a%&'%'!%&&#+&'"%&!#)&]?%(&'!%=+'!"#5#>3#' ,%',%B+*%&' !^B=(@#&R' [email protected]*#' I1%',%&5#*(?+' #' !^B=(@#' ()*%"%&&+,#' %5' !+"*(@(!+"lhR' &#B"%*1,#' I1+),#' %&*%'`'#B"(D+,#'+',%&=#@+"b&%'V(&(@+5%)*%'+#&'=1D+"%&' #),%'#'!"#@%&&#'!+"*(@(!+*(?#' ,%@#""%D+,&!6-7=/:! .&&01! 2(! 7&=/&E&! $.0! 2#-12! %(#&!12#(.;=3! /.! 2,&! /.12/2-2/(.1! $.0! 2,&!6&(6=&!'/2,! %(#&! #&16(.1/7/=/23!"(#! 2,&! 2#$.1"(#%$2/(.! ("! 2,&! :/234! I(%&2,/.;! 2,$2! '/==!.$2-#$==3! (::-#! /"! 2,&3!$#&!;/E&.!2,&!6(11/7/=/23!("!6=$3/.;!$!%(#&!$:2/E&!#(=&!/.!2,&!6#(:&11+' ,#'@(,+,3#' %5' "%=+>3#' +#&'D"+),%&' !"#N%@*#&',%' ()*%"%&&%'

!^B=(@#' `' *+5B`5' ,%@#""%)*%' ,%' 15+' @#)[email protected](M)@(+' D%)%"+=(K+,+' I1%' +,5(*%'+'%L(&*M)@(+',%' D"1!#&' ,%'()*%"%&&%'%',%'!"%&&3#' %@#)J5(@#&'%'!#=A*(@#&'@+!+K%&',%'()V=1%)@(+"R'()@=1&(?%R'#&' !+"%@%"%&' *`@)(@#&' "%=+*(?#&' +' %&&%&' !"#N%@*#&R' I1%'@+%5' +&&(5' %5' ,%[email protected]"`,(*#' %' 5#*(?+5' +' +D(*+>3#' !#!1=+"li/' [email protected]"%,(*+5#&' I1%' +' @#)V(+)>+' ,%?%' &%"' "%&*+B%=%@(,+R' 5+&' +#' 5%&5#' *%5!#' [email protected]"%,(*+5#&' )+' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' "%&!#)&+B(=(K+>3#' ,#&' [email protected]*#"%&' )#&' !"#@%&&#&' ,%' !+"*(@(!+>3#R'&#B'!%)+',%R' )+'+1&M)@(+' ,%&*+' "%&!#)&+B(=(K+>3#R'+&'#!()(a%&' !%",%"%5' ?+=#"/' .+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+'@#5'%$%@*(?#'!#,%"',%',%@(&3#'@+"%@%',#'&%)*(,#',%'"%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%',%' *#,#&'#&'I1%')%=+'!+"*(@(!+5R'()@=1&(?`',#'!^B=(@#*U(."-1/(.! $7(-2! ',&#&! 0&:/1/(.! %$)/.;! 6('&#! =/&1! :$.! 7&! "$2$=! 2(! 1-::&11"-=! 6$#2/:/6$2/(.4! V.:&!$;$/.3#' )3#'&J' ,%&&+'"%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%'@#5#'

*+5B`5' ,%' I1%5' +' ,%?%"]' +&&15("R' #1' &%N+R' I1+(&' #&' D"1!#&' ,%' #!()(3#' I1%' ,%?%5' &%"' @C+5+,#&':'!+"*(@(!+>3#'Y%'I1%5'#&',%?%'"%!"%&%)*+"Z'%'I1+(&'#&'@"(*`"(#&'+&&#@(+,#&'+'%&&+' &%=%@>3#ll /' c5+' ()@#""%@*+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' !#,%"]' @#),1K("R' !#&*%"(#"5%)*%R' +' I1%' #&' ()*%"%&&%&' ,%$%),(,#&' &%N+5' 5+(&' #&' ,#' "%!"%&%)*+)*%',#' I1%' #&' ,#&' "%!"%&%)*+,#&R'#' I1%'

lh'0+?(,&#)'+!#)*+'#' ,%[email protected]"`,(*#',+' #!()(3#' !#!1=+"'@#5#' 15+'"+K3#'!+"+'+'$+=*+',%'!+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+-'s8)#*C%"'?(%S'S#1=,' &1DD%&*' *C+*'*C%'!"#5#*(#)'#$' !1B=(@'!+"*(@(!+*(#)'(&'+' S+&*%' #$'"%"@%&'+&'*C%' "%&!#)&%'(&' +==' *#' #$*%)'+!+*C%*(@/t' 'Y0+?(,&#)R' dqqnZ' li ' sY///Z' @"%[email protected]%)*%' @#)[email protected](M)@(+' ,+' %L(&*M)@(+' ,%' D"1!#&' ,%' !"%&&3#' I1%' ()V=1%)@(+5' +&' +D%),+&' %' ,%@(&a%&' !^B=(@+&R' *M5' #"(D()+,#' 15'()@"%5%)*#',+' ,%[email protected]#)V(+)>+',+'!#!1=+>3#'[email protected]%':&',%@(&a%&'!^B=(@+&'I1%'&%'B+&%(+5'%[email protected]=1&(?+5%)*%' %5'!"()@A!(#&' *`@)(@#&'%'"[email protected](#)+(&/t''Y8=?%&R'ejjdZ ll ' y+&%+,#&' )15+' +)]=(&%' %&*+*A&*(@+' ,+' !#!1=+>3#' =#@+=Ä' y+&%+,#&' )+' !"#L(5(,+,%' %5' "%=+>3#' +#' =1D+"' ,%' ()*%"?%)>3#Ä' [email protected]=1("'#1'()*%D"+"'+&'5()#"(+&Ä

ESTADO DA ARTE

#"(D()+"]'!"#B=%5+&'$1*1"#&')+'(5!=%5%)*+>3#',+&'5%,(,+&'[email protected]#",+,+&/ '

\'[email protected]*#"'*%5!#"+='+!#)*+,#'!#"'+'

,#&' !"#5#*#"%&' %' !"#N%@*(&*+&' [email protected]%' :' 51*]?%=' #!()(3#' !#!1=+"lm ' +#' 5%&5#' *%5!#' I1%' +' ,%[email protected]"%)>+',+'!#!1=+>3#')#'!"#@%&&#'`'[email protected]%)*1+,+'!#"'15+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+'I1%'@#)&(&*%' 1)(@+5%)*%' )+' @+!*+>3#' ,%'#!()(a%&' ,%' @(,+,3#&R' [email protected](=5%)*%' 5+)(!1=]?%(&' D"+>+&' +#' !#,%"' ,+' (5+D%5' %' ,+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&ln R' "%=+*(?+&' +' !"#N%@*#&' !"+*(@+5%)*%' V()+=(K+,#&' %' +!"#?+,#&/' 8' Y()ZN1&*(V(@+>3#' ,%&*%' !"#@%&&#' !#,%' !"%),%"b&%R' @#5#' +!#)*+' 0+?(,&#)R' )+' @"%)>+'I1%'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+'@#),1K'+'+*"+&#&')#'&(&*%5+',%'!"#,1>3#'+"I1(*%@*J)(@+ lq/ '

8'%[email protected]%&&(?+'C(%"+"I1(K+>3#',+'@#51)(@+>3#'`R'*+5B`5R'15' !"#B=%5+R'I1%'&%'*"+,1K'

$#"5+=5%)*%' )+' @"(+>3#' ,%' 15+'%&*"1*1"+' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' ?%"*(@+=')+'I1+='+&' ()$#"5+>a%&' !"#?%)(%)*%&' ,+'B+&%'+!%)+&' @C%D+5' +#' *#!#' V(=*"+,+&' !#"' )15%"#&#&' ()*%"5%,(]"(#&R'%' +&' ()$#"5+>a%&',%'*#!#'@C%D+5':'B+&%'@#5'5+)($%&*+',(V(@1=,+,%/'7+*1"+=5%)*%R'%&*%'`'*+5B`5' #'"%&1=*+,#',+'(5!#&&(B(=(,+,%',%'#1?("'*#,#&'#&'@(,+,3#&R'#'I1%'=%?+)*+'#',([email protected](='!"#B=%5+',%' @#5#'&%=%@@(#)+"'#&'D"1!#&',%'()*%"%&&%'+'&%"%5'#1?(,#&R'%'I1%5'#&'"%!"%&%)*+*qE&.! ',&.! %$./6-=$2/(.! /1! .(2! /.2&.0&03#',%',%B+*%&' &#B"%'#&' 5%&5#&'+&&1)*#&'%'+'15+',%[email protected]"%,(B(=(K+>3#'D%"+=',#'!"#@%&&#/ ' ' '

lm 'sY///Z' !1B=(@'#!()(#)'Y///Z' @C+)D%&'#?%"'*(5%' X'+' @1""%)*=P' [email protected]=#?%,' B1(=,()D'5+P' C+?%'B%%)' ?%"P' @#)*"#?%"&(+=' ()'(*&'%+"=P' &*+D%&/t''Y3#')#'!"#@%&&#'`R'+=(]&R'"%&1=*+)*%',+')+*1"%K+',(?%"&+',#&'

?]"(#&' ()*%"?%)(%)*%&R' @+,+' I1+=' @#5' #' &%1' )A?%=' ,%' @#)C%@(5%)*#' %5!A"(@#R' @(%)*AV(@#' %' +"*A&*(@#R' #' I1%' &%'*"+,1K')#' ,($%"%)*%' %)*%),(5%)*#' ,#&'5%&5#&' @#)@%(*#&' %' ,+' "%+=(,+,%/' G#5#'+!#)*+'8=?%&R DI&!%&1%(!0&.2#(!0&!-%!j./:(!:$%6(!0/1:/6=/.$#!84449!,X!-%$!:(.1/0&=!$%7/;-/0$0&!.(!-1(! 0(1!:(.:&/2(1!84449!2$=!0/P/:-=0$0&!&12$#X!7$12$.2&!%-=2/6=/:$0$! &%!:(.2&`2(1!:(%-./:$2/E(1!G-&! &.E(=E$%!-%$!;#$.0&!0/E/0$0&!84449!0&!$;&.2&14>!!8Z=E&13#R' I1%' ,%?%' &%"' %)*%),(,+' @#5#' 15' ,+,#R' &%"]'

[email protected]%)*1,+,+' &%' #' "%&!#)&]?%=' !%=+' !"#5#>3#' ,%&&+' @#51)(@+>3#' )3#' %&*(?%"' ,%?(,+5%)*%' !"%!+"+,#' !+"+' =(,+"' @#5' +&' ,($%"%)>+&' %&*"1*1"+(&' ,#&' ?]"(#&' [email protected]*#"%&9' !#"' !"%!+"+>3#' %)*%),%5#&' )3#' &J' 15' $#"*%' @#)C%@(5%)*#' ,+' &1+' ]"%+' ,([email protected](!=()+"R' 5+&' *+5B`5' 15+' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' +"*(@1=+"' ,($%"%)*%&' !#&(>a%&R' 5#*(?+,+&' !#"' ()*%"%&&%&' !#=A*(@#&' %o#1' %@#)J5(@#&R'@+!+K%&'()@=1&(?%',%'+$%@*+"'#&'!"J!"(#&'?+=#"%&',#'@##",%)+,#"/ '

.#"'%&*%'5#*(?#R'@"%5#&'I1%'%&&%'@##",%)+,#"R'$1)>3#'I1%'!#,%"]'&%"'@15!"(,+'!%=#'

+"I1(*%@*#R',%?%"]'+,#!*+"'15+'!#&*1"+'[email protected]*(?+')+'!"#@1"+',+&'5%=C#"%&'&#=1>a%&/

ESTADO DA ARTE

!"

.$1$"/-$".1+-+)*+"#$".$10%,%.$)*+

'

."#5#?%"' +' !+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+' `' !"#5#?%"' +' ()*%",([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%-' #&' ?]"(#&'

[email protected]*#"%&' @C+5+,#&' :' "%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%' !#&&1%5' ,($%"%)*%&' [email protected]"#1),&' @1=*1"+(&' %' @(%)*AV(@#&R'#'I1%'=%?+'+'I1%'@+,+'15',%=%&'%)*%),+'#'!"#B=%5+'X'#'#BN%@*#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'X'%' #' !"#@%&&#' X'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+'X',%'15+' $#"5+'!"J!"(+R' #"+'?+=#"(K+),#' +&!%@*#&' 5+(&' $1)@(#)+(&R' %@#)J5(@#&R' $#"5+(&R' !#=A*(@#&' %' &#@(+(&/' H&*+' +B%"*1"+R' @"%5#&R' %5' )+,+' ,%&?+=#"(K+' #' !+!%=' ,#' +"I1(*%@*#R' +)*%&' !%=#' @#)*"]"(#-' `b=C%' %L(D(,#' 15' %&$#">#' +,(@(#)+=' !+"+'D+"+)*("' +'@##",%)+>3#' %)*"%' #&'?]"(#&'[email protected]*#"%&'%'+' @#5!+*(B(=(,+,%',+&'&1+&'(,%(+&mj/' 8' ,(V(@1=,+,%' ,#' !"#@%&&#' @#)&*(*1(' 15+' ,+&' "+Ka%&' !%=+&' I1+(&' #' 5#,%=#' ,%' %L%"@[email protected](#' !"#V(&&(#)+=',#' +"I1(*%@*#' `R' 51(*+&' ?%K%&R' @%)*"+,#' %[email protected]=1&(?+5%)*%')+'&1+'!"#V(&&3#' %' )#&' &%1&'?+=#"%&',([email protected](!=()+"%&R'+!%&+"',+'!"#V(&&3#'&%"R'@#5#'+!#)*+'3#' ,%' !%&&#+&R' !"#@%&&#&' ,%' ,%&%)C#' %' %,([email protected](#&' @#5' #' #BN%@*(?#',%' !"#,1K("' ()$#"5+>3#'@+!+K',%'()$#"5+"'#'!"#N%@*#' 'Ya%&' +'!+"*("' ,%' 5#,%=#&' %&*"(*+5%)*%',([email protected](!=()+"%&R' +B"(),#' +' +"I1(*%@*1"+'+' 15+'5+(#"' ()*%",([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%'X' &%5' !"%N1AK#' !+"+'+' +1*#)#5(+' %'+' "%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%',%' @##",%)+>3#' I1%R'@"%5#&R',%?%"]' @#)*()1+"'+'!%"*%)@%"':'+"I1(*%@*1"+/' G#5#'+!#)*+'8=?%&R' %&*+' +=*%"+>3#' 5%*#,#=JD(@+' N]' &%' %)@#)*"+' %5' !"#@%&&#' )#' ,#5A)(#' ,#' .=+)%+5%)*#' ,#' O%""(*J"(#R'$"1*#',%'15',%B+*%'@#5'15+'"(I1%K+',%'@#)*%^,#'+!%)+&'!#&&A?%='@#5#'"%&1=*+,#' ,#',(]=#D#'()*%",([email protected](!=()+"'%)*"%'+'%I1(!+'%'#&',(?%"&#&'%=%5%)*#&'%)?#=?(,#&')#'!"#@%&&#me / '

7%&*%' &%)*(,#R' 3#' ()*%",([email protected](!=()+"' `' 15+'

"%+=(,+,%' I1%'&%' %)@#)*"+' +' &%"' @#)&*"1A,+'!#"' ?]"(+&' %)*(,+,%&R'!#*%)@(+,+' !%=+' E)*%")%*R' 5+&R' +!%&+"' ,+' ,(&!#)(B(=(,+,%R' `' !+"+' 3#' (),("%@*+R' @+B%),#' +#' +"I1(*%@*#' #' !+!%=',%' ()*%D"+"'%'@##",%)+"'#'@#)C%@(5%)*#'!"#?%)(%)*%',+&'?]"(+&']"%+&',#'&+B%"/ '

7#' %)*+)*#R' )3#' &J' +#' +"I1(*%@*#' @+B%' +' !"#5#>3#' ,+' !+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+-' `' +#'

@=(%)*%' I1%' @+B%"]' D"+),%' %&$#">#' )+' !"#5#>3#' ,+' !+"*(@(!+>3#R' I1%' &%' *"+,1K("]' )15' ()?%&*(5%)*#' ,%'*%5!#'%',%'"%@1"&#&'V()+)@%("#&-'#'@=(%)*%')%@%&&(*+R'!#"' (&&#R',%'+!"%%),%"' +&'?+)*+D%)&',#'!"#@%&&#'!+"*(@(!+*(?#'!+"+'+'&1+'#B"+R'I1%"',1"+)*%'+'$+&%',%'!"#N%@*#R'I1%"' !+"+' #' !J&b#B"+R' !+"+' %&*+"' ,(&!#&*#' +' V()+)@(+"' #' !"#@%&&#R' @+&#' @#)*"]"(#' #' *%5!#' ,(&!%),(,#' !%=#&' +"I1(*%@*#&' &%"]' 5A)(5#mi9' +=`5' ,(&*#R' %)I1+)*#' !"#5#*#"' ,+' #B"+' %' ,#' @#)@1"&#R'#'@=(%)*%',%?%"]'%&*+"',(&!#)A?%='!+"+'#' ,(]=#D#' %R'5+(&'(5!#"*+)*%R'!+"+'[email protected]%(*+"'#&' ,+,#&' !"#?%)(%)*%&',#'!"#@%&&#'!+"*(@(!+*(?#R'&#B"%*1,#' &%'%&*%'&%'*"+*+"',%'15+'()&*(*1(>3#' &#@(+=D+,&!#(=&!$.0!$22/2-0&1!("!:=/&.21!2(!'/0&#!1(:/$=!6$#2/:/6$2/(.!$#&!("!;#&$2!/%6(#2$.:&3#' ,#'!^B=(@#',%'[email protected]#",#'@#5'#'*(!#' ,%'%,([email protected](#' #1'

%&!+>#' +'@#)@%B%"9'@#5#' "%$%"%'#&' I1%' &#=(@(*+5' 15+' 5+(#"' !+"*(@(!+>3#' !#!1=+"' +#' !+&&#' I1%' #1*"#&' )3#' !#&&1%5' %&&+' +*"[email protected]*(?(,+,%/' ."#5#?%"'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+'`R'*+5B`5R'&+B%"'%5'I1%'@("@1)&*_)@(+&'+'!"#5#?%"/ml '

\' !^B=(@#' *+5B`5' ,%&%5!%)C+' 15' !+!%=' $1),+5%)*+=' )#' !"#@%&&#' !+"*(@(!+*(?#R'

,%?%),#' &%"' !%)&+,+' 15+' %&*"+*`D(+' !+"+' #' *#")+"' 5+(&' @#)[email protected](%)*%' ,#&' !"#B=%5+&' ,+' mg 'sOC%' Ç!+"*(@(!+*#"P' +),'"%V=%@*(?%' ,%&(D)U' 5%*C#,#=#DP' Y///Z' ()?#=?%&'1&%"&U' !+"*(@(!+*(#)' +),' %?#=?()D' &*+D%&'#$'%?+=1+*(#)/' z%"%' ,($$%"%)*' *P!%&'#$' 1&%"&R' *C%' !"#N%@*' *%+5'+),'&!%@(+=(&*&' @#5%' *#D%*C%"' *#' %?+=1+*%' %[email protected]' )%S' &*+D%' #$',%?%=#!5%)*' Y///Z' 1)*(=' *C%' &#$*S+"%' (&'"%+,P' *#' 1&%/t' ' Ya%&' @#5#' OC%+' 4%),%"' ' YW#=(,' E"(&' O%@C)#=#D(%&R' ejdjZR' 15+' +!=(@+>3#' ,%' !"#,1>3#' ,%' (5+D%)&' @#5!1*+,#"(K+,+&'+' !+"*("',%'5#,%=#&',(D(*+(&' *"(,(5%)&(#)+(&R'!"#@%&&#' ,#' I1+=' #' +1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#' $+K' !+"*%',%&,%'3#'!+"*(@(!+,+',#'!"#D"+5+',%'15'@#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'X'!#"?%)*1"+'

#'!"(5%("#'5#5%)*#'#),%'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+'!#,%"]'&%"'*(,+'%5'@#)*+'X'`'"%$%"(,+'@#5#' 15+'5%,(,+' !#&(*(?+nd 'I1%'*+5B`5' N]' ,%5#)&*"#1'&%"' @+!+K' ,%'!"#,1K("' B#)&' "%&1=*+,#&R' @#5#' +' H(&C()' [email protected]##=' )#' 3#' [email protected]#5!+)C+,+&' ,%'"%&!#)&]?%(&' @+!+K%&',%' %[email protected]=+"%@%"' ,^?(,+&R' B%5' @#5#' +' !1B=(@(*+>3#' $"+)@+' ,#&' =#@+(&' #),%' &%' !"#@%&&+"3#' +&' mm'|W*(51=+*()D' ,%5+),'$#"'!+"*(@(!+*(#)'S(*C()'&#@(%*P'Y///Z')%%,&'*#' B%'B+&%,'#)'+'S(,%"'!1B=(@'1),%"&*+),()D'#$'+"@C(*%@*1"+=' ,%&(D)'(&&1%&R' +),'C%"%'D#?%")5%)*R'!#=(@Pb5+Q()D' B#,(%&'+),'*C%'!"#$%&&(#)+='#"D+)(&+*(#)&')%%,'*#' !=+P' Q%P'"#=%&/|''Y3#',#'%&!+>#'#1'%,([email protected](#R'+?+=(+),#'D"+1&',%'&+*(&$+>3#o()&+*(&$+>3#R'%*@/'!#,%),#'%&*%' 5#5%)*#' @#)&*(*1("R' :' &%5%=C+)>+' ,%'#1*"+&R' 15+'$+&%',%'!"#N%@*#' !=+)%+,+'%'%L%@1*+,+nh/' E5!#"*+)*%'`R'&%N+'I1+='$#"'+'$+&%',#'%)?#=?(5%)*#',#'!^B=(@#R'*#")+"'@=+"#'I1+(&'#&'#BN%@*(?#&' %'#&'"%&1=*+,#&'!"]*(@#&'%&!%"+,#&',#'!"#@%&&#R'&#B'!%)+',%'D%"+"')#'!^B=(@#'15'&%)*(5%)*#' ,%',%&(=1&3#'I1%'@#),1K("]':',%&5#*(?+>3#/ *V!\Vq!84449!:(.:=-/-!$!&12&!6#(6N1/2(!G-&!$!"$=2$!0&!0&P/./TF(!6#WE/$!0(!*1:(6&>!0(!6#(:&11(!0&! &.E(=E/%&.2(! ;&#$! "#&G-&.2&%&.2&! $(1! 6$#2/:/6$.2&1! 0&1/=-1F(! 0&E/0(! a1! "$=1$1! &`6&:2$2/E$1! :#/$0$14>!!8Z=E&1+' %)*"%' #' I1%' ;@0+,%' ,%V()(1' !#"' %&*"+*`D(+' *#!b,#S)' %'

%&*"+*`D(+'B#**#5b1!R' &%),#'+'^=*(5+'5+(&'!"JL(5+',#'%&!A"(*#' ,%'[email protected]#=+B#"+>3#'V=%LA?%=t'I1%' +5B(@(#)+5#&/

nh ' sOC%' !"#$%&&(#)' &C#1=,' @#)&(,%"' *C%' ?(+B(=(*P' #$' "%+&&%"*()D' *C%' !#&*[email protected]#5!=%*(#)' $%%,[email protected]' &*+D%' S(*C()' *C%' .=+)' #$' v#"Qt''Y3#R' +!"#L(5+),#' +&' ,(?%"&+&' ]"%+&' %' [email protected]*#"%&' ,%' 15' !"#@%&&#' @#5!=%L#' @#5#' #' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+/' 8&' OEG'&3#' 15' 5%(#' @+!+K',%' !"#5#?%"' %&*+'C#"(K#)*+=(,+,%')+' @#51)(@+>3#R' #$%"%@%),#b&%' @#5#' +=*%")+*(?+' +#' *"+,(@(#)+=' ()I1`"(*#R' @=+"+5%)*%' C(%"]"I1(@#ni / D+$%7W%! ,X! %-0$.T$1! 1/;./P/:$2/E$1! .$1! &12#-2-#$1! 0&! :(%-./:$TF(! G-&#',#&'()*%"?%)(%)*%&'%R' @#)&%I1%)*%5%)*%R':')3#[email protected]#51)(@+>3#/' G#)*1,#R'+'(5!#"*_)@(+',+'5.2&#[email protected]#5#'?%[email protected]=#',%' @#51)(@+>3#'%' !"#5#>3#' ,+' !+"*(@(!+>3#' *%5' &(,#' "%$%"(,#' !#"'?]"(#&' +1*#"%&R' *#")+),#' #' !"#@%&&#'5+(&'+*"[email protected]*(?#nlR' #$%"%@%),#')#?+&' $#"5+&' ,%'?%"' +'@(,+,%R' )#5%+,+5%)*%'+*"+?`&' ,%'5#,%=#&' ,(D(*+(&nm '+#&'I1+(&' !#,%'&%"' +&&#@(+,+'()$#"5+>3#'D%#D"]V(@+',(D(*+= nn'X'TEW'XR'%' @#5#'$#"5+',%'!"#5#?%"'15+'0%5#@"[email protected](+'0(D(*+= nqR'!"#@%&&#' I1%'!#,%"]'&%"?("',%'%&*A51=#' %'5#*(?+"'+'@=+&&%'!#=A*(@+'+'+!#(+"'#'!"#@%&&#/ '

H5' &A)*%&%R'!#,%5#&' +V("5+"' I1%' *#,#&' #&' @+5()C#&' +!#)*+,#&' *M5' %5' @#515' #'

[email protected]*#' ,%' "%I1%"%"%5' 15+' 5+(#"' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#' %' @#51)(@+>3#' %)*"%' *#,#&' #&' [email protected]*#"%&R' #' I1%' )#&' @#=#@+' !%"+)*%' #' !"#B=%5+' ,%' @#5#' D+"+)*("' %&&+' %L(DM)@(+9' `' !"%@(&+5%)*%' +' %&*%' )A?%=' I1%' %)I1+,"+5#&' +' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,+&' OEG' @#5#' $%""+5%)*+' (),(&!%)&]?%=':'%=%?+>3#',+&' @[email protected](,+,%&' @#51)(@+*(?+&' ,#&' *`@)(@#&R'@=(%)*%&' %'!^B=(@#R'%'+' ni ' |7#' [email protected]*1+=' @#)*%L*#' =%D(&=+*(?#R' +' ^)(@+' $#"5+' %L(&*%)*%' ,%' @+!*+"' +' #!()(3#' ,#' @(,+,3#' &#B"%' +=D15+' ()*%"?%)>3#' ,%' )+*1"%K+' 1"B+)+' `' #' ()I1`"(*#R'15'!"#@%&&#' 5#"#&#' %'!#[email protected]#'#BN%@*(?#/'H&*%'!"#@%&&#' !#,%"]' &%"'%)"(I1%@(,#' +*"+?`&',+&')#?+&' *%@)#=#D(+&' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#' ,%' $#"5+' +' *#")+"' #' !"#@%&&#' ,%' *"+)&$#"5+>3#' ,+' @(,+,%' 5+(&' ,(?1=D+,#' %' !+"*(@(!+,#/|''YG+""+!+*#&#R'ejjeZ nl ' sp("*1+=' 4%+=(*P' 5#,%=&' *C+*' @+)' B%' ()*%"[email protected]*(?%=P' %L!=#"%,' S(==' 1),#1B*%,=P' 5+Q%' *C%' ?(&1+=' !"%&%)*+*(#)' #$' (,%+&' +),' !"#!#&+=&'+*'!=+))()D'5%%*()D&'#"'#?%"'*C%'()*%")%*'$+"'5#"%'()*%"%&*()D'+),'1),%"&*+),+B=%'$#"'*C%'!1B=(@t''Yy1=5%"R'ejjdZ nm'sY///Z' 1"B+)'5#,%=&'+"%')#S' ,(&*"(B1*%,'#?%"'*C%' ()*%")%*'1&()D' p4;2' Y*C%'p("*1+=' 4%+=(*P';#,%==()D' 2+)D1+D%ZR' +'D%#5%*"(@' 5#,%==()D' =+)D1+D%' *C+*' +==#S&' 1&%"&' *#' ,%V()%' D%#5%*"(@' #BN%@*&' +&' S%==' +&' +==' &#"*&' #$' "%),%"()D' +),' +)(5+*(#)' %=%5%)*&/t''Yy1=5%"R'ejjdZ nn 'sY///Z' E)*%")%*' TEW' C+&',%?%=#!%,' "+!(,=P' Y///Z' "%&1=*()D'()' *C%' 5(D"+*(#)' #$'%' TEW' $1)@*(#)+=(*P' *#' *C%' vvv' Y///Z' OC(&' Y///Z' C+&' *+Q%)' %=%5%)*&' #$' TEW' *#' 5+&&' +1,(%)@%&/' Y///Z' OC%&%' +!!=(@+*(#)&' ()@#"!#"+*%' TEW' +&' #)b=()%' *##=&' *#' ,(&&%5()+*%' ()$#"5+*(#)' Y///Z' &C#S' C#S' &!+*(+=' ()$#"5+*(#)' @+)' B%' 1&%,' *#' ()$#"5' +' D(?%)' ()*%"%&*' D"#1!' #"' +1,(%)@%' *C"#1DC' E)*%")%*' TEW/t''Y0#P=%R'0#,D%R'F'W5(*CR'dqqnZ nq'sOC%' )#S' S(,%&!"%+,'1&%' #$'*C%'()*%")%*'C+&'&!+S)%,'+')%S'+"%+' #$'!=+))()DR'*C+*' #$',(D(*+=' ,%5#@"[email protected]/' Ç0(D(*+=' ,%5#@"[email protected]' C+&'B%@#5%' *C%' )%S'*%"5'@#()%,'*#' %L!=+()'*C%' 1&%' #$')%S' *%@C)#=#D(%&'[email protected]'+&'*C%'()*%")%*' ()'*C%' 5#,%")'!#=(*(@+=' &P&*%5'*#' &!+S)'+'S(,%"'"+)D%'#$'?#*%"&/t''Yy1=5%"R'ejjdZ

[email protected]

ID

Concurso de arquitectura e participação pública

8EG8'@#5#' 15+'+!=(@+>3#' !"]*(@+',%&&+&' *%@)#=#D(+&/'8'@"(+>3#' ,%'$%""+5%)*+&' ,%'&1!#"*%':' ,%@(&3#'!#*%)@(+'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#qj'&%),#'#'&1!#"*%',(D(*+='15+ D84449! 6=$2$"(#%$! &P/:/&.2&! 84449! 6$#$! -%$! :(%-./:$TF(! &.2#&! $! Z#G-/2&:2-#$! 84449! &! -%$! 6(6-=$TF(D!!8r/.(-=,/$:3#R'@#)*1,#R'%5'51*+>3#/'H&*%',%&AD)(#'@#51)(@+*(?#'N]' C+?(+'&(,#'+!#)*+,#'!#"'z%+=%P'%5'dqqeR'@#5#'(),(@+'8=?%&*t&$=&3!84449!6#(6Y&!$!:#/$TF(!0&!6=$2$"(#%$!(#;$./Q$:/(.$=!&!2W:./:$!7$1&$0$!.$!:(.12#-TF(!0&! #&0&1! 0&!:(%-./:$TF(!&!:((6&#$TF(!&.2#&!-%$! 6=-#$=/0$0&!0&!1&:2(#&1!0$! 1(:/&0$0&!86j7=/:(!!8Z=E&13#' !^B=(@+R' )+' 5%,(,+' %5' I1%' $#(' !#&&A?%=' @#)$%"("' +#&' @(,+,3#&' #' !#,%"' ,%' @#5!"%%),%"'5%=C#"'+&'!"#!#&*+&',%'!"#N%@*#De&!7&=/&E&!2,$2!2,&!6#&1&.2!0/;/2$=!6=$2"(#%!$.0!12$2&!("!2,&!$#2!:(%6-2&#!E/1-$=/Q$2/(.!$==('1! 2,&!6-7=/:!2(!6=$3!$!%(#&!/%6(#2$.2!#(=&!/.!2,&!0&:/1/(.!%$)/.;!6#(:&114>!!8^&2(3#R' +' *%5]*(@+' ,+'

@#51)(@+>3#'%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#',%'!"#N%@*#'@#5'"%@1"&#':&'OEGR'N1)*+5%)*%'@#5'+&'+=*%"+>a%&' :' 5%*#,#=#D(+' ,%' !"#N%@*#' I1%' *M5' ?(),#' +' &%"' (5!=%5%)*+,+&R' *%"]' #' !+!%=' @%)*"+=' ,#' *%"@%("#'%'^=*(5#'*%L*#'&#B"%'#'H&*+,#',+'8"*%R'I1%'+!"%&%)*+5#&'%5'&%D1(,+/

IE

IF

Concurso de arquitectura e participação pública

6(D/'gj-'0(+D"+5+b&A)*%&%-'s,#'!"#@%&&#',%'15'G#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+Et

6(D/'gd-'0(+D"+5+b&A)*%&%-'s,+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+t

ESTADO DA ARTE

!"!"6$)3$7/-5)7)$!"#$"#%#&'$()*+*,-"/

'

H5' s0(!6#(:&11(! 0&!-%! :(.:-#1(! 0&! $#G-/2&:2-#$>' "%[email protected](#)]5#&' +' @#5!=%L(,+,%' ,+'

&#@(%,+,%' @#)*%5!#"_)%+' @#5' +' @#5!=%L(,+,%' ,#&' !"#N%@*#&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' +5B+&' 5#*(?+,+&'!%=+&'5+(#"%&'%L(DM)@(+&',#&'1*(=(K+,#"%&R',#&'5+*%"(+(&'%'*`@)(@+&' @#)&*"1*(?+&R'%' ,#'I1+,"#')#"5+*(?#' +!=(@]?%=/'4%@#)C%@%5#&' I1%'+'#B"+',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'`'@+,+'?%K'5%)#&' 15+' !%>+' (&#=+,+R' &%),#' +)*%&' ()*%D"+,+' )15+' @#5!=%L+' "%,%' X' +' @(,+,%' X' @1N#' %I1(=AB"(#' ,%!%),%',+'@#=+B#"+>3#' ,#&' [email protected]*#"%&'%)?#=?(,#&')+'&1+'@#)&*"1>3#9'&1"D%'+&&(5' +' V(D1"+',#' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' @#5#' 5%(#' !+"+' !"#5#?%"' +' @#51)(@+>3#' %' [email protected]+)>+"' %&&%' %I1(=AB"(#/ '

E,%)*(V(@]5#&' +'?+)*+D%5' ,#' !"#@%&&#' X'!"#5#?%"' 15' 5+(#"' ,%B+*%'%5' *#")#' ,+&'

%?%)*1+(&' &#=1>a%&R' D"+>+&' +#' 5+(#"' )^5%"#' ,%'!"#!#&*+&' %' %I1(!+&' @#)@#""%)*%&' ' X' !+"+' "+!(,+5%)*%'@#)&*+*+"5#&' I1%'#'!"#@%&&#',#'@#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'`'5^=*(!=#' )+&' &1+&' %L!"%&&a%&R'&%),#'#'@+"]@*%"',#'!"#5#*#"'X'!^B=(@#'#1'!"(?+,#'X'15+',($%"%)>+'$1),+5%)*+=/ '

8&&15(5#&' #' @#)@1"&#' !^B=(@#' @#5#' *(!#' $1),+5%)*+=R' !%=+' &1+' 5+(#"' @[email protected](,+,%'

,%'()*%"?%)>3#')#'*%@(,#' 1"B+)#',+'@(,+,%R'%',%)*"#',%&*%'#'@#)@1"&#',%'@#)@%!>3#'!%=#'&%1' @+"]@*%"',%'+B%"*1"+':'*%5]*(@+',+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'%'+,%I1+>3#'+#'5%"@+,#',+'+"I1(*%@*1"+/ '

H5' s0$! 6$#2/:/6$TF(! 6j7=/:$t'"%$%"(5#&' +' @"%[email protected]%)*%' ?#)*+,%' %5' ()*%D"+"' #' !^B=(@#'

)+&' ,([email protected]&&a%&' &#B"%' #' +5B(%)*%' @#)&*"1A,#R' "%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%' I1%' ,%?%' &%"' +&&15(,+' *+5B`5' !%=+&' +&&#@(+>a%&' %' !"]*(@+&' !"#V(&&(#)+(&/' 4%$%"(5#&' +' (5!#"*_)@(+' ,%' %)*%),%"' +' !+"*(@(!+>3#'@#5#'15' !"#@%&&#' ?+)*+N#&#' !+"+'*#,+&' +&' !+"*%&' %')3#' @#5#' 15+'+5%+>+'+#&' ()*%"%&&%&',([email protected](!=()+"%&',#&'*`@)(@#&'%'+#&'()*%"%&&%&'%@#)J5(@#b!#=A*(@#&',#&'!"#5#*#"%&/ '

4%$%"(5#&' #'@"%[email protected]%)*%'()*%"%&&%'!%=+'1*(=(K+>3#',+&'!=+*+$#"5+&' ,%'@#51)(@+>3#' )+'

5.2&#.&2' %' +' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' ,%&=#@+"' #' ()*%"%&&%' ,#' !^B=(@#' !+"+' 1*(=(K+"' !=+*+$#"5+&' &%5%=C+)*%&' !+"+',([email protected]&&3#' ,#' +5B(%)*%' @#)&*"1A,#R' %' +(),+' #' [email protected]*1+=' @#)*%L*#' %@#)J5(@#' @#5#'#!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+'"%!%)&+"'+'=(D+>3#'%)*"%'+'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'+'&#@(%,+,%/ '

4%$%"(5#&' #' %)*%),(5%)*#' [email protected]*1+=' ,#' .=+)%+5%)*#' @#5#' !"#@%&&#' %' )3#' @#5#'

!"#,1*#' X'#'I1%')#&'@#),1K(1':')%@%&&(,+,%',%',%V()("' I1%5R'I1+),#'%'@#5#' !+"*(@(!+'X'%R' 5+(&' (5!#"*+)*%' +(),+R' #' !#"I1M' ,+' !+"*(@(!+>3#-' &#B"%' #' ^=*(5#' +B+),#)]5#&' #' $1),+5%)*+=(&5#',%'15+'N1&*(V(@+>3#'(,%#=JD(@+'!+"+'+V("5+"'+')#&&+'@"%)>+')+'!+"*(@(!+>3#' @#5#' 5%(#' ,%' %$%@*(?+5%)*%' #B*%"' 15' 5%=C#"' +5B(%)*%' @#)&*"1A,#' X' =#D#R' +V("5+),#' +' (5!#"*_)@(+'I1%"',#'!"#@%&&#R'I1%"',#'!"#,1*#/ '

4%@#)C%@%5#&' +' %L(&*M)@(+' ,%' %)*"+?%&' :' !+"*(@(!+>3#R' @#5%>+),#' !%=#' @+"]@*%"'

N#?%5''',+''',%5#@"[email protected](+''%'',+''!"#V(&&3#'',%''+"I1(*%@*#''%5'''.#"*1D+=R''5+&'''&%5'''=C%''+*"(B1("'

IG

IH

Concurso de arquitectura e participação pública

ESTADO DA ARTE

,("%@*+5%)*%'15+'"%=+>3#'@+1&+b%$%(*#9'"%$%"(5#&'#'@+"]@*%"'%=(*(&*+',+'!"#V(&&3#R'!#"?%)*1"+'' ()(@(+,#' )+'&1+'$#"5+>3#R'@#5#' [email protected]*#"' ,%' (&#=+5%)*#' !"#V(&&(#)+='[email protected]%'+'15+'5+(#"' "%=+>3#' @#5' #1*"+&' ]"%+&' !"#V(&&(#)+(&' %' @#5' #' !^B=(@#9'"%@#)C%@%5#&' +' +1&M)@(+' ,%' 15' @#)*%L*#' !#=A*(@#' %' ()&*(*[email protected](#)+='+,%I1+,#':'!"#5#>3#' ,+'!+"*(@(!+>3#R'5#*(?+,#' !%=+' ,(V(@1=,+,%',%' !+"*(=C+',#'!#,%"R'%'+'(5!#&&(B(=(,+,%',%'@#)@%B%"'#'!"#@%&&#'$#"+',%&&%'@#)*%L*#9'"%$%"(5#&' +'$+=*+',%'%L!%"(M)@(+',#'!^B=(@#'%5'5+*`"(+',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'+'&1+',%[email protected]"%)>+')+&'%&*"1*1"+&' "%&!#)&]?%(&' !%=+' !"#5#>3#' ,+' !+"*(@(!+>3#R' (),(@+),#' +' )%@%&&(,+,%',%'"%&*+B%=%@%"'%&*+' @#)V(+)>+' B+&%+,+' )+' "%&!#)&+B(=(K+>3#' ,%' *#,#&' #&' [email protected]*#"%&R' ()@=1&(?`' ,#' D"+),%' !^B=(@#9' "%$%"(5#&'#'"%@%(#',%'+*"+&#&')#'&(&*%5+'!"#,1*(?#'@#5#'5#*(?#'!+"+')3#'(5!=%5%)*+>3#',+' !+"*(@(!+>3#R'%'+')%@%&&(,+,%',%'%)*%),%"'%&&%'+*"+&#' @#5#' ()?%&*(5%)*#'$1*1"#9'!#"'^=*(5#R' "%@#)C%@%5#&' +' %[email protected]%&&(?+' C(%"+"I1(K+>3#' ,+' @#51)(@+>3#R' "%&1=*+)*%' %5' %&*"1*1"+&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#'?%"*(@+(&'#),%'+'()$#"5+>3#'+!"%&%)*+',(V(@1=,+,%&'%5'@("@1=+"/ '

G#5#' "%&!#&*+' +' %&*%&' !"#B=%5+&' (,%)*(V(@]5#&' +=D15+&' 5%,(,+&' @+!+K%&' ,%'

!"#5#?%"'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#-'+'!"#5#>3#' ,+'()*%",([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%'X')%@%&&]"(+',+,#'#',($%"%)*%' [email protected]"#1),',#&'[email protected]*#"%&'%)?#=?(,#&')#'!"#@%&&#'X'[email protected]*#'I1%')3#',(5()1('5+&'?+=#"(K+'#'!+!%=' ,#' +"I1(*%@*#' %)I1+)*#' @##",%)+,#"9' +' +,#!>3#' ,%' 15' 5#,%=#' ,%' %L%"@[email protected](#' !"#V(&&(#)+=' @%)*"+,#' )+' ()?%&*(D+>3#' ,%' ]"%+&' )3#b%[email protected]=1&(?+5%)*%',([email protected](!=()+"%&R' 5#,%=#' [email protected](=(*+,#' !%=+' %L(&*M)@(+'[email protected]*1+=',%'B+&%&',%',+,#&' #)=()%',%'$]@(='[email protected]%& '#' !+!%='(5!1=&(#)+,#"' ,#'@=(%)*%R' I1%' ,%?%"]'%)*%),%"' +'!+"*(@(!+>3#' @#5#' 15' ()?%&*(5%)*#' +' =#)D#' !"+K#' %' )3#' @#5#' 15' ,%&!%",[email protected](#' ,%' *%5!#' %' "%@1"&#&' V()+)@%("#&9' +' @#""%@*+' +,%I1+>3#' ,#&' !"#@%&&#&' ,%' !+"*(@(!+>3#'+#'*(!#',%'%,([email protected](#'#1'%&!+>#'+'@#)@%B%"'N]' I1%R'!#"'%L%5!=#R' 15'%I1(!+5%)*#' !^B=(@#' !#,%"]'&%"'5+(&'*#=%"+)*%':'!+"*(@(!+>3#',#'I1%'15+'C+B(*+>3#'!"(?+,+9'+'()*%D"+>3#' ,+'!+"*(@(!+>3#' ,#' !^B=(@#' %5'*#,+&' +&' $+&%&' ,%'!"#N%@*#R' ,%&,%'+'$+&%',%'@#)@%!>3#' ()(@(+=' +*`':'+?+=(+>3#',#',%&%5!%)C#',#' %,([email protected](#' #1'%&!+>#'@#)&*"1A,#9'%R'V()+=5%)*%R'+'+,#!>3#',%' 15+' %&*"+*`D(+' ,%' @#=+B#"+>3#' V=%LA?%=' %)*"%' !"#5#*#"%&' %' #' !^B=(@#R' *%),#' %&*%' &(,#' %[email protected]=+"%@(,#R' $! 6#/(#/R' &#B"%' #&' "%@1"&#&R' @#),(@(#)+)*%&' %' #BN%@*(?#&' ,#' !"#@%&&#' ,+' !+"*(@(!+>3#R'%&*"+*`D(+'%&&+'I1%',%?%"]'!"%?%"'%&*"1*1"+&',%'@#51)(@+>3#'5+(&'C#"(K#)*+(&/ '

.#"' ^=*(5#R' "%@#)C%@%5#&' I1%' #&' @+5()C#&' +!#)*+,#&' !+"+' +' !"#5#>3#' ,+'

!+"*(@(!+>3#' !#,%5' &%"' @#)@"%*(K+,#&' @#5' +' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,%' $%""+5%)*+&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' +&&%)*%&' )+&' OEGR' @+!+K%&' ,%' ()*%D"+"' )#?+&' 5%*#,#=#D(+&' ,%' !"#N%@*#' B%5' @#5#' )#?+&' $#"5+&',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'%'@#51)(@+>3#'I1%'*%5#&'+#',(&!Å"/ '

.#"'%&*+&'"+Ka%&R'#' @#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'"%?%=+b&%'@#5#'15+'#!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+'

!"#5#?%"'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'%'15'5#*(?#'!+"+'#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'8EG8R'!"%*%),%),#b&%'15+' !=+*+$#"5+'@+!+K',%'"%&#=?%"'#&'%)*"+?%&'%'!#*%)@(+"'+&'5%,(,+&'"%$%"(,+&/ '

\' 5#*(?#' +&&15%b&%' +&&(5' @#5#' +' !+=+?"[email protected]+?%' ,%&*%' [email protected]+!A*1=#' %' +' &%D1),+'

#!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+'#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'8EG84

II

I<

Comunicação e Representação de Projecto

6(D/'ge-'8!"#!"(+>3#',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#',+'"%+=(,+,%'X'#"*#$#*#/

6(D/'gg-'8!"#!"(+>3#',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#',+'"%+=(,+,%'X'5#,%=#'g,/

6(D/'gh-'8"*(@1=+>3#',+&',1+&'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&/

6(D/'gi-'4%!"%&%)*+>3#',%'!"#N%@*#'&#B"%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'@#5!=%L+',+'"%+=(,+,%/

ESTADO DA ARTE

[email protected]+H!,%&'0)-.!+*+#*"#*=*&$)-.!+(*+"#!B*0$!

!"6"#$%&$+)4+)7)-5&9:,$',3,$&'5,$'+(&5(., '

.%=+' &1+' )+*1"%K+' %' #BN%@*(?#&' %&!%@AV(@#&R' +' 8EG8' ,%?%"]' &%"' @+!+K' ,%' @#51)(@+"'

@#)*%^,#&' ,("%@*+5%)*%' "%[email protected](#)+,#&' @#5' +' [email protected]*(?(,+,%' ,%' !"#N%@*#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' @#)*%^,#&' %&&%&' I1%' )#&' ()*%"%&&+5' %[email protected]=+"%@%"/' H&*+' `' 15+' I1%&*3#' %&&%)@(+='%'I1%' )3#' &%' "%!#"*+' +!%)+&' +#' !"#B=%5+' *%@)#=JD(@#' ,%' %L(B("' @#)*%^,#&' )15' %@"39' `' %&&%)@(+=' &+B%"' I1+(&'#&'@#)*%^,#&'+'%L(B("'%'@#5'I1%'@+"[email protected]*%"A&*(@+&R',%'$#"5+'+'[email protected](=(*+"'+'&1+'@#5!"%%)&3#' !#"' !+"*%' ,%'*#,#&'#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' ,+'+!=(@+>3#' ()$#"5]*(@+' %R' @#)&%I1%)*%5%)*%R' &%"?("%5' @#5#'5+*%"(+='%V(@+K'!+"+'+'!"#5#>3#',#',(]=#D#'%',+',([email protected]&&3#',+&'(,%(+&/ '

8' 8EG8' !"%*%),%' @#51)(@+"' #' @#5!=%L#' +"*%[email protected]*#' C15+)#' I1%' `' +' @(,+,%R' 5+&'

*+5B`5'+&'!"#!#&*+&',%'()*%"?%)>3#'I1%'#'?(&+5'*"+)&$#"5+"9'%5'&A)*%&%R'+'8EG8',%?%"]'&%"' @+!+K' ,%' ()*%D"+"' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,+' "%+=(,+,%' %L(&*%)*%R' 5+&' *+5B`5' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%' !"#N%@*#&',%'*"+)&$#"5+>3#',%&&+'"%+=(,+,%/ '

H)@#)*"+5#&'+&&(5'I1%&*a%&',%'$1),#'%'I1%',(K%5'"%&!%(*#':'$"#)*%("+'%)*"%'+&',1+&'

"%+=(,+,%&-'+*`'I1%'!#)*#'+'@#51)(@+>3#',+'"%+=(,+,%',%?%"]'&%"'%)*%),(,+',%'$#"5+',(&*()*+' ,+'@#51)(@+>3#',%'!"#N%@*#Ä'G#5#'()*%D"+"'+&',1+&'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&'@#5'#'#BN%@*(?#',%'+$%"("' #'([email protected]*#',+&'*"+)&$#"5+>a%&'1"B+)+&'I1%'&%'!"#!a%5Ä '

8!=(@+>a%&' @#5#' #' T##D=%' WQ%*@C1!qe ' ,%5#)&*"+5b)#&' @#5#' +' +!"#!"(+>3#' ,+&'

"%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,+' "%+=(,+,%' !+"+' ()*%D"+>3#' )+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%' !"#N%@*#' !#,%5' @#)&*(*1("' 15+'5+(&b?+=(+' !+"+'+'@#51)(@+>3#'%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'@(,+,%R' +#' 5%&5#' *%5!#' I1%' #!*(5(K+5' #' !"#@%&&#' ,%' !"#N%@*#/' ' !#"' (&&#' ?(*+=' 15+' %&*"+*`D(+' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' %' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%'!"#N%@*#' %',+'"%+=(,+,%' I1%'!%"5(*+' @#51)(@+"R',%'$#"5+' $:&11HE&=R'%&*+'@#5!=%L(,+,%'+#'@#)N1)*#'?+&*#',%'1*(=(K+,#"%&'I1%'@#)&*(*1%5'#'!^B=(@#b+=?#' ,+'8EG8/' '

H&&+' %&*"+*`D(+' ,%?%"]' +&&%)*+"R' %5' !"(5%("#' =1D+"R' )#' "%@#)C%@(5%)*#' ,+'

(5!#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%' +!"%%)&3#' *#*+=' ,+' "%+=(,+,%' %' )+' (5!#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,+' &1+' &1B&*(*1(>3#' *#*+='!#"'I1+=I1%"'*(!#',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#/'G#5'%$%(*#R'+'"%+=(,+,%'`',%5+&(+,#' @#5!=%L+'!+"+' !#,%"' &%"' @#51)(@+,+' +*"+?`&' ,%' I1+=I1%"' *(!#' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' X' !%=#' 5%)#&R' @#5' #' 5%&5#' D"+1',%'%V(@]@(+'?%"(V(@+,#' )+' %L!%"(5%)*+>3#' ,("%@*+' ,%&&+'"%+=(,+,%/' G#5#' "%$%"%' 7%*#' Y7%*#R' ejjeZR' +' !%"@%!>3#' ?+(' +=`5' ,+' 5+*%"(+=(,+,%' VA&(@+R' %)?#=?%),#' +&' ,(5%)&a%&' @#D)(*(?+R'%5#@(#)+='%'&(5BJ=(@+'X' ?+"(+),#R'!#"'(&&#R',%'@1=*1"+'!+"+'@1=*1"+'%',%'(),(?A,1#' qe'\'T##D=%'WQ%*@C1!'`'15+'$%""+5%)*+',%'5#,%=+>3#'*"(,(5%)&(#)+=/''YT##D=%R'ejdj$Z

IB

3#' I1%' )#&' @#=#@+' )15+' !%"&!%@*(?+' $%)#5%)#=JD(@+R' )+' I1+=' #' &%"' C15+)#' @#)*"(B1(' [email protected]*(?+5%)*%' )+' @#)&*"1>3#' 5%)*+=' ,+' "%+=(,+,%'I1%'!%"@%[email protected](#)+'X')3#'+'"%+=(,+,%'I1%'%L(&*%R'5+&'&(5'+'I1%'%&*%'@"(+''Y7%*#R'ejjeZ/' O#,#' #' @#)C%@(5%)*#R' ()@=1&(?%' #' ,+' "%+=(,+,%' %' #' ,+&' &1+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&R' `' @#5!=%L#' %' 51=*(,(5%)&(#)+=R' @#5#' +!#)*+' ;#"() qhR' %' +' )#&&+' 5%5J"(+' %[email protected](+=' `' 15' !"#@%&&#' @#5!=%L#'I1%'%)?#=?%',(?%"&#&'&%)*(,#&'!+"+'+=`5',+'?(&3#qi/ '

.+"+' +=`5' ,+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,+' "%+=(,+,%R' #&' ()&*"15%)*#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' %5'

!"#N%@*#' *+5B`5' &%"?%5' #' [email protected]*#' @"(+*(?#' %' !"#&!%@*(?#' ,#' +"I1(*%@*#qlR' ()V=1%)@(+,#' !%=+' &#@(%,+,%'%'!%=+'&1+' $#"5+>3#' [email protected]+,`5(@+'%'!"#V(&&(#)+=R'%'!#*%)@(+,#' @#5' +&')#?+&' $#"5+&' ,%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#' @#5!1*+,#"(K+,+/'0%?%5#&'*%"' %5' @#)&(,%"+>3#' I1%' %&*+&'?3#' !+"+'+=`5' ,+'5%"+'(5(*+>3#',+'"%+=(,+,%R'$#")%@%),#'+)*%&')#?+&'$#"5+&',%'?%"'+'$#"5+'1"B+)+''Y7%*#R' ejjeZ/ '

;%&5#' @#5' "%@1"&#' +#&' 5+(&' +?+)>+,#&' 5%(#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' "%+=(&*+' !#"'

()*%"5`,(#' ,#' @#5!1*+,#"R' I1%"' #' "%&1=*+,#R' I1%"' #' !"#@%&&#R' @#5#' "%&1=*+,#' ,%' 15' *"+B+=C#'@"(+*(?#R'@#)*M5'%5'&('+=D15'D"+1',%'&1BN%@*(?(,+,%!

*84449!,('!:$.!:(%6-2&#!E/1-$=/Q$2/(.!7&!2,&!(7O&:2!("!$!12$.0$#0!E$=/0$2/(.!6#(:&11x!84449!

/2!1&&%1!2,$2!7(2,!2,&!/%$;&1!2,$2!:(%&!"#(%!2,&!:(%6-2&#!%(0&=!$.0!2,&!:#&$2/(.!("!2,&!$:2-$=! %(0&=!/21&="!$#&!1-7O&:2/E&4>!!8^&2(3#' *`@)(@+' I1%' =C%&'!%"5(*+'%)*%),%"'*%"5()#=#D(+'%&!%@AV(@+'=(D+,+':'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'%'I1%'@+B%"]':&'OEG'%':&' +!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&'+'(5!#"*+)*%'*+"%$+',%'5%=C#"+"'+'@#51)(@+>3#'%'*#")+"'5+(&'@=+"#&' #&' 5#,%=#&' I1%' &%' !"%*%),%5' %L!=(@+"R' *"+)&$#"5+),#' #&' @#)*%^,#&' %' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%' qg'|Y///Z' *C%'"%+=' S#"=,'+),'+==' (*&',(5%)&(#)&'X' !CP&(@+=R' &#@(+=R'[email protected]#=#D(@+=R' %@#)#5(@R'+),'!#=(*(@+=' X'(&'*##' "(@C'+),'@#5!=%L' *#'B%'$1==P',%!(@*%,'BP'+)P'*P!%'#$'{"%+=(&*(@{'"%!"%&%)*+*(#)|''Y7%*#R'ejjeZ/ qh ' sY///Z' *#,#' #' [email protected]#)*%@(5%)*#' @#D)(*(?#' )%@%&&(*+' ,+' @#)N1)>3#' ,%' !"#@%&&#&' %)%"D`*(@#&R' %=`@*"(@#&R' I1A5(@#&R' V(&(#=JD(@#&R' @%"%B"+(&R' %L(&*%)@(+(&R' !&(@#=JD(@#&R' @1=*1"+(&R' =()D1A&*(@#&R' =JD(@#&R' (,%+(&R' (),(?(,1+(&R' @#=%@*(?#&R' !%&&#+(&R' *"+)&!%&&#+(&' %' (5!%&&#+(&R'I1%'&%'%)D"%)+5'1)&')#&'#1*"#&/t''Y;#"()R'dqnlZ qi ' sY///Z' #1"' &!+*(+=' 5%5#"P' (&' Y///Z' +' @#5!=%L' @#==%@*(#)' #$' @#D)(*(?%' !"#@%&&%&' +),' &Q(==&R' +),' )#*' N1&*' ,%!%),%)*' #)' ?(&(#)/t''Y7%*#R'ejjgZ ql 's8' @"(+*(?(,+,%R' !#"I1%' (5!=(@+' 15+',%&*"%K+' ,#' #=C+"'%' ,#' "%!"%&%)*+"R' )3#' `' )%@%&&+"(+5%)*%' %&!#)*+)%(,+,%t' ' Y2(&B#+R' dqqmZ

ESTADO DA ARTE

$#"5+'+'&%"%5',%'5+(&'$]@(='+!"%%)&3#'!+"+'#'!^B=(@#'%5'D%"+=/ *[=$../.;! 2((=1! :$.! 2#$.1=$2&! :(%6=&`! 6=$../.;! O$#;(.3#' %' +' *"+)&5(&&3#' ,%' (,%(+&' 15' !"#@%&&#'@#5!=%L#'I1%R'@"%5#&R'+&'OEG'!#,%"3#'+N1,+"'+'"%&#=?%"*q$:,! (.&! ("! 2,&1&! 0/1:/6=/.&1! ,$1! 84449! 0&E&=(6&0! /21! ('.! 6#("&11/(.$=! =$.;-$;&a%&' ,(&!#)(B(=(K+,#&'%'+'+1*#)#5(+'%'=(*%"[email protected](+'?(&1+=',#'1*(=(K+,#"')+' ?(&1+=(K+>3#' ,%&&%&' @#)*%^,#&-' #' !"(5%("#' N1&*(V(@+b&%' !#"I1%R' )+' (5!#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%' @#51)(@+"' ,%'$#"5+'%$%@*(?+' %'@#5!=%*+'+'"%+=(,+,%R'"%&*+b)#&' @#51)(@+"'$"+D5%)*#&' ,%&&+' "%+=(,+,%' X' "%@#""%),#' :&' 5+(&' ?+"(+,+&' *`@)(@+&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' @#5#' #' ,%&%)C#R' +' $#*#D"+V(+R' +'$#*#5#)*+D%5R' +' %[email protected]"(*+R' #&' 5#,%=#&' ?("*1+(&R' %'+#&' 5+(&' ,(?%"&#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#R' @#5#' !=+)*+&R' @#"*%&R' +=>+,#&R' "%),%"()D&R' %*@' X' $"+D5%)*#&' %&&%&' I1%' #' 1*(=(K+,#"'&%'%)@+""%D+"]',%'#"D+)(K+"')+'@#)&*"1>3#',+'&1+'"%+=(,+,%/ '

' )%@%&&]"(#' I1%'%&*%&' ,(?%"&#&' 5#,%=#&' ,+' "%+=(,+,%' %&*(51=%5' #' 5+(#"' )^5%"#'

!#&&A?%=',%'&%)*(,#&'C15+)#&R'*%),#' %5'@#)*+'I1%'+'!%"@%!>3#',#'1*(=(K+,#"'&%"]'5%=C#"+,+' &%' +' &1+' [email protected]*(?+>3#'$#"' &(51=*_)%+/'p(&1+=(K+"' 15' "%D(&*#' $#*#D"]V(@#' ,%' 15' =1D+"' %'+&&(&*("' +' 15+'"%!"#,1>3#' +1,(#' @+!*+,+')%&&%' =1D+"R' (&#=+,+5%)*%R'`'@#5!=%*+5%)*%',($%"%)*%' ,%'#&' !%"@%B%"' %5' @#)N1)*#/' H5' &A)*%&%R' +' 1*(=(K+>3#' &(51=*_)%+' ,%' ?]"(#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' !%"5(*%' 15+' 5%=C#"' @#51)(@+>3#9' @#)*1,#R' @#5#' +!#)*+' 7%*#R' +' ?(&3#' @#)*()1+'+' &%"' #' &%)*(,#' !"(5#",(+=')+'@#5!"%%)&3#' ,#' %&!+>#R' %'+' @#5B()+>3#' ,%' ?]"(#&' *(!#&',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'?(&1+='!%"5(*%'15+'&1+'5%=C#"'%L!%"(M)@(+D84449! :(%6-2&#! %(0&==/.;3#' ,+' +1*#)#5(+' %' =(*%"[email protected](+' ?(&1+=' ,#' 1*(=(K+,#"' )+'

a%&' X' N1&*(V(@+b&%' !#"' ?]"(+&' "+Ka%&-' !"(5%("#R' !#"I1%' "%@#)C%@%5#&' I1%'#'[email protected]*#'@"(+*(?#' ,+I1%=%'I1%'!%"@%[email protected](#)+' +' "%+=(,+,%' !+"*%'51(*#' ,+I1(=#' I1%'%=%' ,%&%N+'?%"' %')#'*%5!#' I1%' #' ,%&%N+'?%"9'&%D1),#R' !#"I1%'!"#5#?%"' %&*+'+1*#)#5(+' ,#'1*(=(K+,#"'(5!=(@+R'!+"+'#'+1*#"',+&'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&R'#'&%1',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#'@#5#'15'*#,#' +#' ()?`&' ,%'&%' $#@+"' +!%)+&' %5' ,%*%"5()+,+&' !+"*%&' X' #' I1%' !#,%"(+'=%?+"R' !#"'%L%5!=#R' :' 5+)(!1=+>3#',+&' !%"@%!>a%&R' )+'5%,(,+'%5' I1%R' *%),%)@(+=5%)*%R'%&&%'+1*#"'("(+'"%+=>+"'#&' +&!%@*#&'5+(&' !#&(*(?#&' %',(&&(51=+"'#&' )%D+*(?#&qm9'%R' V()+=5%)*%R' !#"I1%'*+='("]'@#),1K("':' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' ()#?+"' )+&' *`@)(@+&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#R' !"#5#?%),#' 15+' 5+(#"' ()*%"[email protected]*(?(,+,%' %' %)?#=?(5%)*#' &%)&#"(+=R' (),#' !+"+' +=`5' ,+&' %&*]*(@+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ?(&1+(&/ ''

G#5#' `' )+*1"+=R' #' "%@1"&#' :&' $%""+5%)*+&' *%@)#=JD(@+&' +&&%)*%&' )+&' OEG' %' :&'

"%!"%&%)*+>a%&' @#5!1*+,#"(K+,+&' !+"+' @#51)(@+"' #' !"#N%@*#' %' #' %&!+>#' ,%' ()*%"?%)>3#' "%?%=+b&%' %&&%)@(+=' )+' 5%,(,+' %5' I1%' %&*%' *(!#' ,%' ?(&1+=(K+>a%&' [email protected](=(*+' #' !"#@%&&#' @#51)(@+*(?#' +#' !%"5(*("' #' %)*%),(5%)*#' ,%'()$#"5+>3#' @#5!=%L+'&#B' 5^=*(!=#&'!#)*#&',%' ?(&*+9'@#)*1,#R'+'%,[email protected]+>3#'?(&1+=',#'!^B=(@#',%?%"]'&%"R'*+5B`5R'15+'!"(#"(,+,%DZ=2(-;,! '&!%-12! '(#)!2(! $:,/&E&!$! 1-::&11"-=! :(%%-./:$2/(.!("! 6=$../.;! $.0! 0&1/;.! "(#!$==3#',%&&+'"%+=(,+,%/''*+5B`5')%@%&&]"(#'+$%"("'I1+(&'#&'B%)%[email protected](#&'%' =(5(*+>a%&' ,#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' 1*(=(K+,#&' )#' I1%' ,(K' "%&!%(*#' :' &1+' @#""%@*+' +!"%%)&3#' !#"' 15' !^B=(@#' ?+&*#' %R' )+' &1+' 5+(#"(+R' ,%[email protected]#)C%@%,#"' ,#&' @J,(D#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#',#&'!"#N%@*#&R'!+"+'!#,%"5#&'()*%D"+"'%'+"*(@1=+"'+&'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&')+'8EG8'X' &J' +&&(5' !#,%"%5#&' #B*%"' 15+' $%""+5%)*+'@+!+K',%' !"#5#?%"' 15+' !+"*(@(!+>3#' @"A*(@+' %' ,%?(,+5%)*%'()$#"5+,+/ '

H&*%' ,%&AD)(#' =%?+)*+' 15+' ,^?(,+' $1),+5%)*+=' X' I1%5' ,%?%"]' &%"' #' +1*#"' ,+&'

"%!"%&%)*+>a%&',#&'!"#N%@*#&'&1N%(*#&'+',([email protected]&&3#'!^B=(@+Ä '

G#5#' !"(5%("+'C(!J*%&%R' !#,%"]'&%"' #' !"J!"(#' +1*#"' ,#' !"#N%@*#9'*+=' @#),1K("]' +#'

,%&%N#' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+"' +' &1+' #B"+' ,#' 5%=C#"' !#)*#' ,%' ?(&*+' !#&&A?%=R' "%+=>+),#' +&' &1+&' I1+=(,+,%&' %' #@1=*+),#' #&' &%1&' ,%$%(*#&' X' "%&1=*+),#R' )+*1"+=5%)*%R' )15+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' !+"@(+=/

qm ' \&' +!#(+)*%&' ,%' 15+' ,%*%"5()+,+' &#=1>3#' ("3#' I1%"%"'?Mb=+' !%=#&' &%1&' +&!%@*#&'!#&(*(?#&R' +#' !+&&#' I1%' #&' @"A*(@#&' ("3#' I1%"%"'?Mb=+'!%=#&')%D+*(?#&''Y7%*#R'ejjeZ/

ESTADO DA ARTE

!

*84449! #&6#&1&.2$2/(.1! :$.! =&$0! 2(! y0/12(#2/(.1u! 7&:$-1&! ("! 2,&! 0&1/;.&#u1! 6-#6(1&! (#!

/.2#&2$2/(.14>!!8^&2(3#'!#,%"]'&%"'5+(&'(5!+"@(+=9'%'+(),+R'!#"I1%'I1%"'#'@#)*%L*#' ,%' %?#=1>3#' ,+' !"#V(&&3#qn R' I1%"' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,%' +!=(@+>a%&' %&!%@(+=(K+,+&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' B+&%+,+&' )+&' =%(&' ,+' 6A&(@+qq R' !#*%)@(+5' %&*+' @"%[email protected]%)*%' s&16&:/$=/Q$TF(>' )+' +"I1(*%@*1"+/ '

[email protected]"%,(*+5#&' I1%R' @#5' %&*+' ^=*(5+' C(!J*%&%R' %&*+"]' +B%"*#' #' @+5()C#' !+"+' 15+'

%$%@*(?+'#&6#&1&.2$TF(!:(%(!%&/(!0&!:(%-./:$TF(!&P/:$Q/

qn ' f1%' !+"%@%' +!#)*+"' )#' &%)*(,#' ,%' 15+' ,(?(&3#' %)*"%' +"I1(*%@*#&' I1%' [email protected]#)&*"#%5t' %' +"I1(*%@*#&' I1%' "%!"%&%)*+5' +"I1(*%@*1"+/ qq'8'5+(&'"%@%)*%' D%"+>3#' ,%'+!=(@+>a%&'!+"+' @"(+>3#' ,%'(5+D%)&'"%+=(&*+&'+!#&*+' )#&'5`*#,#&',%'"%),%"(K+>3#' 8!>,(@")R' (&*#' `R' @[email protected]=+,#&'@#5'B+&%' %5'+=D#"(*5#&' '!"#,1K(,#&'&%D1),#' +&' =%(&' ,+' 6A&(@+9' *#,+' +' ()*%"[email protected]%' `'5%,(+,+'!#"' !+"_5%*"#&' "%+(&-' +' !#*M)@(+' ,+&' =1K%&' +"*(V(@(+(&' `' ,%V()(,+' %5' v+**&' %' +' ,(&!%"&3#' ,+' =1K' @[email protected]=+,+' @#5' B+&%' %5' 5%,(>a%&' -DE* F-338',!($,!G* D!G,!"".,!G* E&0,"$BH9' +'!#&(>3#' ,#' &#=' ,%' [email protected]#",#' #' *%5!#' %'+' =+*(*1,%o=#)D(*1,%' ,#' =1D+"9' #&' 5+*%"(+(&'&3#' ,%V()(,#&'@#5'B+&%' %5' !+"_5%*"#&' @#5#' #' -IJ' Y(),%L' #$' "%$"[email protected]*(#)Z9' +' !"J!"(+' @+!*1"+' ,+' (5+D%5' `' *"+*+,+' @#5#' 15+' $#*#D"+V(+R' &%),#' @#)V(D1"+,+'@#5'B+&%'%5'!+"_5%*"#&'@#5#'#'-EIR'+'?%=#@(,+,%',#'#B*1"+,#"R'+'+B%"*1"+'$#@+=R'%*@/

3#',+'5%)&+D%5'!#,%'&%"'@#5!"#5%*(,+'&%'+'@#51)(@+>3#')3#'$#"'%V(@+K/ '

G#5#' +&'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&',%'!"#N%@*#'%',+'"%+=(,+,%'&%"3#' !+"*%'()*%D"+)*%' ,+'8EG8R'

,%?%"]'&%"'%&*1,+,+'+'&1+'1*(=(K+>3#'@"(*%"(#&+',%'$#"5+'+'!"#5#?%"'15+'@#51)(@+>3#'%V(@+K/' 7%&*%' !#)*#' +B#",+5#&' ,1+&' I1%&*a%&' I1%' @#)&(,%"]5#&' %&&%)@(+(&-' #&' (7O&:2/E(1! %' +' $:&11/7/=/0$0&!,+&'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&/ '

8' !"(5%("+' ,(K' "%&!%(*#' :' V()+=(,+,%' ,+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#R' %' +I1(' @#)&(,%"+5#&' ,1+&'

C(!J*%&%&-'#1'+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' &%' ,%&*()+' +' !"#5#?%"' 15+',([email protected]&&3#' @"A*(@+' Y!#"' %L%5!=#R' @#5#'B+&%&',%'15'@#)@1"&#' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'#1'15+'+!"%&%)*+>3#' !^B=(@+',%'&#=1>a%&' !+"+' 15' ,%*%"5()+,#' =1D+"ZR' #1' +' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' &%' ,%&*()+' :' %$%@*(?+' @#)&*"1>3#' ,+' !%>+' "%!"%&%)*+,+R'&(*1+>3#' #),%'%&&+',([email protected]&&3#' @"A*(@+')3#'`R',%' *#,#R',%&%N]?%=R' 5+&'+)*%&'15+' =%(*1"+'@=+"+'%'#BN%@*(?+',+&'@+"[email protected]*%"A&*(@+&'%'5%,(,+&',#'#BN%@*#'+"I1(*%@*J)(@#'+'@#)&*"1("/ '

8' &%D1),+' ,(K' "%&!%(*#' +#&' ,%&*()+*]"(#&' ,+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#R' %' +I1(' @#)&(,%"]5#&R'

*+5B`5R' ,1+&' &(*1+>a%&b*(!#-' #' D"1!#' ,%' !"#V(&&(#)+(&' =(D+,#&' :'+"I1(*%@*1"+R' %)D%)C+"(+' %' @#)&*"1>3#R' I1%' =(,+5' @#5' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%' !"#N%@*#' I1+&%' ,(+"(+5%)*%9' %' #' D"1!#' ,%' !%&&#+&' )3#b%&!%@(+=(&*+&R' I1%' %5B#"+' )3#' @#)?(?+5' "%D1=+"5%)*%' @#5' %&*%' *(!#' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&R' &3#' *+5B`5R' !#"' ,(?%"&#&' 5#*(?#&R' #&' &%1&' ,%&*()+*]"(#&' X' #&' @=(%)*%&R' #&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&',#&'%,([email protected](#&R'#'D"+),%'!^B=(@#/ '

G#5' B+&%' )#' %&*1,#' ,%&*+&' ,1+&' I1%&*a%&' &%"]' !#&&A?%=R' +,(+)*%R' +$%"("' +&'

!#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%'()*%D"+>3#' )+'8EG8' ,#&' ?+"(+,#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' I1%'*%5#&' +#' ,(&!Å"R'!"#@1"+),#'+'&1+'()*%D"+>3#'@"A*(@+'%'+,%I1+,+':'&(*1+>3#'%'*(!#',%'()$#"5+>3#*84449!2,&!236&!("!/."(#%$2/(.! 2,$2! /1!/.2&.0&0!2(!:(%%-./:$2&!:$.!$.0!1,(-=0!&`6=$/.! 2,&!-1&!("! 0/""&#&.2!236&1!("!#&6#&1&.2$2/(.!%&2,(014>!!8^&2(3#djj 9' ("%5#&R' @#)*1,#R' !"#@1"+"' (,%)*(V(@]b=#&' !"#@1"+),#' +' &1+' +"*(@1=+>3#' @#5' &%(&' !+"%&' @#)@%!*1+(&' X' =JD(@#o%5#@(#)+=R' +B&*"[email protected]*#o "%+=(&*+R' +)+=JD(@#o,(D(*+=R' %&*]*(@#o()*%"[email protected]*(?#R' B(,(5%)&(#)+=o*"(,(5%)&(#)+=' %' @%)*"+=o !+"+=%=#'X'I1%')#&'+N1,+"3#'+'%[email protected]=+"%@%"'+&',1+&'I1%&*a%&'"%$%"(,+&/ djj 'H&&%&' 5`*#,#&'&%"3#' @+"[email protected]*%"(K+,#&' )#' @+!A*1=#' g-' 8EG8R' I1+),#' %L!=(@(*+"5#&'#&' @#)*%^,#&'I1%' +' +!=(@+>3#' ,%?%"]' &%"' @+!+K',%'+=#N+"/

3#',+'+"I1(*%@*1"+R',+'@(,+,%R',+&' &1+&'I1+=(,+,%&' %',%$%(*#&9'!#"' #1*"#' =+,#' &3#')%@%&&]"(+&' !+"+' +' %$%@*(?+' 5+*%"(+=(K+>3#' ,%&&+&' +=*%")+*(?+&9'%5' +5B#&' #&' @+&#&' +' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%?%'&%"'%)*%),(,+'@#5#' 15' 5%(#',%'@#51)(@+>3#R' I1%'&%'!"%*%),%' %V(@+KR'%')3#'@#5#'15'#BN%@*#'%&*`"(='%'%)@%""+,#'%5'&('!"J!"(#/ '

f1+),#'#'#BN%@*(?#',+'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'&%'!"%),%'@#5'+'%$%@*(?+'@#)@"%*(K+>3#',+'!%>+'

"%!"%&%)*+,+R'#&'5`*#,#&',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'5+(&'$712#$:2(1'"%?%=+5b&%'5+(&'%V(@+K%&' !+"+'+' @#51)(@+>3#',#' I1%'#&' "%+=(&*+&' )+'5%,(,+'%5' I1%'"%*("+5' ()$#"5+>3#' I1%'&%"(+'s"1A,#t'%' I1%' #&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' "%+=(&*+' )#"5+=5%)*%' @#)*M59' %5' +=*%")+*(?+R' !"#!a%5' 15+'?(&1+=(K+>3#'V(=*"+,+',+'()$#"5+>3#'X',%&*[email protected]+),#'+'()$#"5+>3#'%&&%)@(+='%',(&&(51=+),#' #1'#@1=*+),#'()$#"5+>3#'[email protected]%&&J"(+'X'%'+'&%D5%)*+>3#',+'!%>+'%5' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'!+"@%=+"%&' %'=N;/:$1/ D84449! 2,&3! $==('! $.! -.0 $.0/.;! ("! 2,&! -.0&#=3/.;! =(;/:! ("! 16$:&! $.0! 7-/=0/.;13#'5+(&'+B&*"[email protected]*#'X'+'!=+)*+'X'!%"5(*%R':'!+"*(,+R'+'@=+"+',%V()(>3#',+' =JD(@+' ,+' @#51)(@+>3#' %[email protected](+=' ,#' #BN%@*#' +' "%!"%&%)*+"' Y)%&*%' @+&#R' #' !"(5%("#' !(&#' ,+' C+B(*+>3#Z9' +' @#51)(@+>3#' ,+' =JD(@+' %[email protected](+=' ,#' !"#N%@*#' `' )%&*%' @+&#' 51(*#' (5!#"*+)*%-' @=+"(V(@+5b&%'+&'5%,(,+&R'+&'!"#!#">a%&R'+'5#,1=+>3#R'+'+"*(@1=+>3#'%)*"%'#&'%&!+>#&D84449!6=$.!E/&'1! ,$E&!7&&.! 6#&0(%/.$.2=3!&%6=(3&0! "(#! -.0 $.0/.;! 2,&!-.0&#=3/.;! =(;/:! ("! 16$:&4Da%&')+'[email protected]*1+=(,+,%'+(),+'%&!%=C+5'+&'5%&5+&'@+"[email protected]*%"A&*(@+&'

,+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' *"+,(@(#)+(&R'&%' B%5' I1%' +5!=(V(@+,+&' @#5' #'"%@1"&#' :'!"#,1>3#' ,(D(*+=' !#"' @#5!1*+,#"R' I1%' ?%(#' !%"5(*("' ,+"' 15+' 5%=C#"' "%&!#&*+' "%=+*(?+5%)*%' :&' %L(DM)@(+&' @+,+'?%K'5+(&'@#5!=%L+&'I1%'&3#'@#=#@+,+&':'+"I1(*%@*1"+/ '

8' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%' 15+' C+B(*+>3#' )+' ;+(+ djd ' ,%5#)&*"+' +' @#5!=%L(,+,%' ,+&'

"%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' D%"+,+&' !#"' @#5!1*+,#"' )+' I1+=' #&' ?]"(#&' &(&*%5+&' I1%' @#5!a%5' 15+' #B"+' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+'!#,%5' &%"' ()*%D"+,#&' ,%' $#"5+' =JD(@+'%' @#)*"#=+,+9' #' @#5!1*+,#"' %' +&' +!=(@+>a%&' ,%'G880' !%"5(*%5' +' @"(+>3#' ,+'"%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%' 15+'$#"5+' 5+(&'"]!(,+R'"%1*(=(K+),#'+'()$#"5+>3#'YB+)@#&',%',+,#&',(D(*+(&Z'%'%&*"1*1"+),#b+',%'$#"5+' =JD(@+'[email protected]#5R'!#"'%L%5!=#R'#&'=+P%"&Z'%'!%"5(*(),#'+'?(&1+=(K+>3#',+'()$#"5+>3#',%'15+'$#"5+' ,()_5(@+' Y+5!=(+),#' #1' "%,1K(),#' +' %[email protected]+=+R' =(D+),#' #1' ,%&=(D+),#' =+P%"&R' +=*%"+),#' +' %L!"%&&3#',+&'=()C+&'%'*%L*#&')#'%@"3Z/ '

G#5#' `'(),(@(+,#R'%&*%&' 5`*#,#&',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#' +,%I1+5b&%' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%':&'

$+&%&',%'%L%@1>3#'%'#B"+',#&'!"#N%@*#&R'#),%'`')%@%&&]"(#'@#51)(@+"'+'=JD(@+',#&'!"#N%@*#&'%' ()$#"5+>3#'!+"*(@1=+"'%'$+&%+,+'X'#&',%&%)C#&',%'%L%@1>3#'@#)*%5!=+5'+&&(5'+',(5%)&3#',#' 2&%6('+#'&%'!"#!#"%5' @#5#' 15',/12N#/:(',+'@#)&*"1>3#'$+&%+,+',%'15' %&!+>#' #1'%,([email protected](#/'\' &1!#"*%' ,(D(*+=' ?%(#' +D(=(K+"' +' @#)&*"1>3#' ,%&*+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' 5+&R' %)*"%' #' D+B()%*%' %' #' =#@+=' ,+' #B"+R' %=%' `R' $"%I1%)*%5%)*%R' &1B&*(*1A,#' !%=#' &1!#"*%' +)+=JD(@#' X' #' !+!%=' X' @"(&*+=(K+),#' %' *#")+),#' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' %&*]*(@+&R' (&*#' `R' &%5' +' !#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,+' ()$#"5+>3#'&%"'5+)(!1=+,+'!#"'!+"*%',%'I1%5'+'%&*]'+'?(&1+=(K+"/ '

f1+),#' #' #BN%@*(?#' )3#' `' +' @#)&*"1>3#' ,+' !%>+' "%!"%&%)*+,+' 5+&' 15+' ,([email protected]&&3#'

@"A*(@+' %5' *#")#' ,%=+' X' @#5' #' #BN%@*(?#' ,%' "%&#=?%"' #&' &%1&' !"#B=%5+&' %' 5%=C#"+"' +&' &1+&' I1+=(,+,%&' XR' #&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' 5+(&' +,%I1+,#&' I1%' !#,%5#&' 1*(=(K+"' &3#' 5^=*(!=#&' %'@#5!=%5%)*+"%&/'z]R'!#"'15'=+,#R' +')%@%&&(,+,%',%'@#5!"%%),%"' I1%"' +'=JD(@+' ,#&' !"#N%@*#&R' I1%"' +' &1+' %L!"%&&3#' &%)&#"(+=' %' %5#*(?+R' !"#@1"+),#' @#5!"%%),%"' +' !%>+' @#5#'15+'*#*+=(,+,%'%')3#'@#5#'15'+*J"(#',%'!+"*%&9'+'1*(=(K+>3#',%'15+'51=*(!=(@(,+,%' %' ?+"(%,+,%' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' Y+B&*"[email protected]*+&R' "%+=(&*+&R' B(,(5%)&(#)+(&R' *"(,(5%)&(#)+(&R' !+"+=%=+&' #1'@%)*"+(&Z' !%"5(*%R' +*"+?`&' ,+' +"*(@1=+>3#' 5%)*+=' ,%&*%&' $"+D5%)*#&R' @#)&*"1("' %&&+'*#*+=(,+,%R'!"#@%&&#R'@#5#'N]'?(5#&R'@"(+*(?#/

djd'G%,(,+'!#"'.=+"%)'."#N%@*#&R'2,+/R'D+B()%*%' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'#),%' #' +1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#' %$%@*1#1'#'%&*]D(#'!+"+'()D"%&&#' )+' \",%5',#&'8"I1(*%@*#&'%5'ejjn/

3#' ,+' !%>+' "%!"%&%)*+,+R' 5+&' *+5B`5' !+"+' +' &1+' !"J!"(+' @#)@%!>3#9' `' +' @#)[email protected](M)@(+',%&*%'[email protected]*#'I1%'5#*(?+'G#"B1&(%"'+'"%!"%&%)*+"R')+'5%&5+'$#=C+R'15+'!%"&!%@*(?+' +`"%+' Ys?(&*+' ,%' !]&&+"#tZR' ,1+&' !%"&!%@*(?+&' ()*%"(#"%&' +#' )A?%=' ,#' #=C+"R' 5%)#&' +B&*"[email protected]*+&dje R' %' ,1+&' +L#)#5%*"(+&' ,%' _)D1=#&' @#5!=%5%)*+"%&R' 5(&*1"+),#' +&&(5' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'5+(&' +B&*"[email protected]*+&'%'5+(&'"%+=(&*+&R'%',($%"%)*%&' &(&*%5+&' ,%'!"#N%@>3#R'&%),#'+' *"(,(5%)&(#)+=(,+,%'#' ,%)#5()+,#"' @#515/'8' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,+' +L#)#5%*"(+',%)#*+'+'!"#@1"+' ,%'15+'&#=1>3#',%'@#5!"#5(&&#'%)*"%'#'"%+=(&5#',%'15+'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'*"(,(5%)&(#)+='@#5' +'+B&*"[email protected]>3#',#'&(&*%5+',%'!"#N%@>3#'!+"+=%=#-' D5.!2,&!:$1&!("!2,&!%(0&#.!%(E&%&.23#' ()$#"5]*(@+' ()*%"[email protected]*(?+'@#5#'$#"5+',%'!"#5#?%"'15+'5%=C#"'@#5!"%%)&3#'%',%B+*%'&#B"%'#&'@#)*%^,#&' ,%'15'@#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+/ '

H5'&A)*%&%R'I1+),#' #' #BN%@*(?#' ,+'"%!"%&%)*+>3#' `'+'%$%@*(?+'@#)&*"1>3#',#'#BN%@*#'

+"I1(*%@*J)(@#' "%!"%&%)*+,#R' #' 5`*#,#' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' +,%I1+,#' @+5()C+R' *%),%)@(+=5%)*%R')#'&%)*(,#',+'=JD(@+'%',+'+B&*"[email protected]>3#R'!"(?(=%D(+),#'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&'%&*]*(@+&' %'#),%'#'&1!#"*%'+)+=JD(@#' +(),+'`'51(*#' 1*(=(K+,#R'I1%"'B(,(5%)&(#)+='#1'*"(,(5%)&(#)+=R'%' ,%'[email protected]#",#' @#5' #' &(&*%5+' ,%' !"#N%@>3#' !+"+=%=#/' 3#' +' 1*(=(K+"' ,%?%5' !%"5(*("' @#51)(@+"' I1%"' +' =JD(@+R' I1%"' +' %5#>3#' ,%&&%&' %&!+>#&/' .#"' *1,#' (&*#R' &%' I1%"%5#&' 15+' @#51)(@+>3#' "(@+' %' @#5!=%*+' ,%?%5#&' 1*(=(K+"' &(51=*+)%+5%)*%'5`*#,#&',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'5+(&'+B&*"[email protected]*#&'%'5+(&'"%+=(&*+&R'B(,(5%)&(#)+(&' %'*"(,(5%)&(#)+(&R' ,%'[email protected]#",#' @#5' #&'&(&*%5+&',%'!"#N%@>3#'!+"+=%=#'%'@%)*"+=R'%'15' &1!#"*%' ,(D(*+='%'()*%"[email protected]*(?#/

dje '|Y///Z' ,($$%"%)*'=%?%=&'#$' ,%*+(=' +),'+B&*"[email protected]*(#)'S(*C'*C%' B(",{&b%P%' ?(%S' 5#"%' +B&*"[email protected]*' *C+)' *C%' %P%b=%?%=' ?(%S' Y///Z|' ' Y7%*#R' ejjgZ

[email protected]

BD

Comunicação e Representação de Projecto

ESTADO DA ARTE

!"

$,(22%%#$#("#$"1(.1(2(&0$)*+

'

8&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+'%' ,+' @(,+,%' &3#' !+&&A?%(&' ,%' &%"' =(,+&' !#"' ,#(&'

D"1!#&',(&*()*#&',%'!%&&#+&-'#&'!"#V(&&(#)+(&R'@1N+'$#"5+>3#'%'[email protected]*(?(,+,%'#B"(D+':'@#)?(?M)@(+' %' 5+)(!1=+>3#' "%D1=+"' ,%&*%' *(!#' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#' Y+"I1(*%@*#&R' %)D%)C%("#&R' %5!"%(*%("#&R' *"+B+=C+,#"%&' ,+' @#)&*"1>3#' @(?(=R' %*@/Z' %'#&' )3#b%&!%@(+=(&*+&' I1%R' %5' "%D"+R' )3#' !#&&1%5' $#"5+>3#' )+' ]"%+' )%5' ,%&%)?#=?%5' 15+' [email protected]*(?(,+,%' !"#V(&&(#)+=' I1%' (5!=(I1%' #' @#)*[email protected]*#' $"%I1%)*%'@#5'%&*+&'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&'Y#&'@=(%)*%&R'#&'1*(=(K+,#"%&R'#'D"+),%'!^B=(@#Z/' '

85B#&' #&' D"1!#&' !#&&1%5' ,($%"%)*%&' @[email protected](,+,%&' ,%' =%(*1"+' %' ()*%"!"%*+>3#' ,+&'

"%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%' !"#N%@*#R' %&*+),#' #' D"+),%' !^B=(@#' 5%)#&' *"%()+,#' !+"+' +&' !%"@%B%"R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' +&'5+(&' +B&*"[email protected]*+&' X'#' I1%')3#' &(D)(V(@+'I1%',%?+' !#"' (&&#' &%"'%[email protected]=1A,#',+' @#5!"%%)&3#' ,#&' !"#N%@*#&' ,%'*"+)&$#"5+>3#',+'"%+=(,+,%R'%'51(*#'5%)#&' ,+'!#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%'#&',([email protected]*("/ '

\' D"1!#' ,#&' !"#V(&&(#)+(&' !#&&1(R' )+*1"+=5%)*%R' 15+' 5+(#"' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%'

@#5!"%%)&3#',%&*%&'5`*#,#&',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'5+(&'+B&*"[email protected]*#&D84449!-1/.;! $712#$:2!#&6#&1&.2$2/(.!%&2,(01!2(! :(%%-./:$2&!0&1/;.!/1!.$2-#$==3!%(#&!=/.)&0!2(! 2,&!6&(6=&!/.E(=E&0!/.!2,&!%$)/.;!("!2,&!-#7$.!"$7#/:4>!!8^&2(3#'

I1%' !"%&&1!a%' #' @#)C%@(5%)*#' ,%' @#)?%)>a%&' X' @[email protected](,+,%' )%@%&&]"(+' !+"+' I1%5' @"(+' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' X' %R' !#"' #1*"#R' 15+' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' ,%[email protected]#,(V(@+>3#' ,%&&+' ()$#"5+>3#R' I1%' !"%&&1!a%' (D1+=' @#)C%@(5%)*#' ,+&' @#)?%)>a%&R' %' I1%' `' )%@%&&]"(+' !+"+' I1%5' =M' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&*84449!$#7/2#$#3!:(0&1!84449!$==('!:(%%-./:$2/(.!("!%-:,!%(#&!/."(#%$2/(.! /.!=&11!2/%&!$.0!16$:&! $.0!'/2,!=&11!&""(#2!84449!("2&.!'/2,!;#&$2!$::-#$:34>!!8d$=$33#' 5+(&' +B&*"[email protected]*#&R' +&&#@(+,+' +#' &%1' @#)C%@(5%)*#',([email protected](!=()+"R' !%"5(*%5b=C%&'=%"' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'5+(&' %5#*(?+&' ,%'15+'$#"5+' 5+(&' @"A*(@+' %' ()$#"5+,+/' \' %L%5!=#' ,%' 4#&&(' X' I1%' @#)*"+&*+' @#5' #' "(D#"' %' +' =JD(@+' ,+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,+' 4%&#"' z#1&%' X' "%?%=+' (&&#' 5%&5#-'15+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' I1%' ()*%D"+' 15+' (,%(+' ,%'!"#N%@*#' @#5' &%)&(B(=(,+,%'%' !#%&(+/' ;1(*+&' ?%K%&R' %&&+' !#%&(+' ,+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' `' 5+(&'*+",%'"%,%[email protected]#B%"*+')#'!"J!"(#'%&!+>#'@#)&*"1A,#/ '

'

H5'"%=+>3#' +#'D"1!#' ,+&'!%&&#+&')3#b%&!%@(+=(K+,+&R'+'&(*1+>3#'`',(&*()*+-'+'

()?%)>3#' ,+' !%"&!%@*(?+' )#' 4%)[email protected](5%)*#' X' +' !%"&!%@*(?+' +"*(V(@(+=(&! X' !%"5(*(1' 15+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,#' %&!+>#' 5+(&' !"JL(5+' ,+&' !%&&#+&' 5%)#&' %)*%),(,+&' )#&' @J,(D#&' ,+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'+B&*"[email protected]*+&D84449! 6&:2/E$! $#2/P/:/$=/1! 84449! $==('&0! =$3!6&(6=&! 8',(! =$:)&0! 2,&! 1)/==1! 2(! -.0 $.0! 2,&! %(#&! $712#$:2! :&.2#$=! 6#(O&:2/(.9! 2(! -.0 $.0! %(#&! &$1/=3! 2,&! 84449! #&6#&1&.2$2/(.! ("! 16$:&4D!!8^&2(3#' @%)*"+=R' !%"5(*(1' 15' 5`*#,#' ,%'

"%!"%&%)*+>3#'5+(&' "%+=(&*+'%'5%)#&' +B&*"[email protected]*#' +#' !"#!#"' 15+'*"(,(5%)&(#)+=(,+,%'B+&%+,+' )#&'!#)*#&' ,%'$1D+R' )+'=()C+',%'C#"(K#)*%R'%')+' !#&(>3#'V()(*+' %',%*%"5()+,+',#' #B&%"?+,#"R' "%?%=+),#b&%'+&&(5'@#5#'15'!#,%"#&#'()&*"15%)*#'!+"+'"%!"%&%)*+"'#'+5B(%)*%'@#)&*"1A,#' %'#'@#51)(@+"'+')3#b%&!%@(+=(&*+&D+,&! 6&:2/E&! %&2,(0! $.1'&#&0! 2,&! .&&0! 2(! 84449! $==('! 2,&! E/&'&#! 2(! ,$E&! $.! &`6&#/&.:&! :=(1&#!2(!2,&!84449!#&$=!'(#=0!84449D!!8^&2(3#'

!#"'@#5!1*+,#"R'+&&(&*(5#&' +' 15+' !"#=($%"+>3#',%' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' @+,+'?%K'5+(&' "%+=(&*+&' X' "%$%"(5#b)#&' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' +#&' "%),%"()D&R' I1%"' @#5#' $#*#D"+5+&' (&#=+,#&R' I1%"' @#5#' &%I1M)@(+&' +)(5+,+&' X' I1%' +&' *#")+5' @+,+' ?%K'5+(&' !"JL(5+&' ,+'@#5!"%%)&3#' !#"' !+"*%' ,%&*+&' !%&&#+&9' @#)*1,#R' &3#' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' I1%' @#51)(@+5' 5+(&' !%=#' =+,#' &%)&#"(+=' %' %5#*(?#' ,#' I1%'!%=#' =JD(@#R' &%),#' !#"' (&&#' @+!+K%&' ,%' 5+)(!1=+"' +&' !%"@%!>a%&R' #' I1%' +&' *#")+' ^*%(&' 5+&' ()&1V(@(%)*%&R' &%' 1*(=(K+,+&' (&#=+,+5%)*%' #1' ,%' $#"5+' %[email protected]%&&(?+' )+' @#51)(@+>3#',#&'!"#N%@*#&'%',+'"%+=(,+,%/

BG

BH

Comunicação e Representação de Projecto

6(D/'hj-'.%"&!%@*(?+',+'4%&#"'z#1&%R';(%&'?+)',%"'4#C%R'dqgmogn

6(D/'hd-'4%!"%&%)*+>3#',#'.+?(=C3#',%'y+"@%=#)+R'B+&%+,+'%5'5#,%=#',(D(*+=R'+"I1(?#'!%&&#+=R'ejjq

ESTADO DA ARTE

D84449!2,&! 6(2&.2/$=! ("! :(%6-2! "(#! :#&$2/.;! &.;$;/.;! %&0/$2&0! &.E/#(.%&.21! 2,$2! 1/%-=$2&! 0&1/;.!,$E&!2(!7&!-1&0!/.!$! 7$=$.:&0! '$3!/.! (#0&#! 2(!$:,/&E&!&""&:2/E&!0&1/;.! :(%%-./:$2/(.3#'%'#&'@J,(D#&' +' %=+&' +&&#@(+,#&9' @#)*1,#R' !+"+' +' @#51)(@+>3#' @#5' 15' @=(%)*%R' )#"5+=5%)*%' !#[email protected]#' %&!%@(+=(K+,#' )#' %)*%),(5%)*#' ,+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' +' +!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%' 15' ,%&%)C#'5+(&'"%+=(&*+R'*"(,(5%)&(#)+='%',%&%)C+,#',%'[email protected]#",#'@#5'+&'"%D"+&',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,#'&(&*%5+',%' !"#N%@>3#' @%)*"+=R'!%"5(*%'15+'@#51)(@+>3#' 5+(&' %V(@+K9'+'=+"%("+' %5' !=+)*+' ,+'4%&#"'z#1&%',]'=1D+"'+'15+'=+"%("+'5+(&'"%+=(&*+R'+(),+' I1%'#',%&%)C#',%';(%&'@#)*%)C+' 15' %=%?+,#' D"+1' ,%' +B&*"[email protected]>3#R' +#' %?(*+"' +' @#"' %' +' =1KR' $%)J5%)#&' I1%' +&' [email protected]*1+(&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'@#5!1*+,#"(K+,+&'@#)&%D1%5'&(51=+"',%'$#"5+'@+,+'?%K'5+(&'%V(@+K/ '

.+"%@%b)#&' %)*3#' )%@%&&]"(#R' :' =1K' ,+' %?#=1>3#' ,+&' OEGR' I1%' %&*+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'

&%N+5',#*+,+&',%'15'@+"]@*%"'5+(&'()*%"[email protected]*(?#'!+"+'!%"5(*("'+'&1+'5+)(!1=+>3#'!#"'!+"*%',%' I1%5'+&'?MR'!%"5(*(),#'+'=%(*1"+',#&'!"#N%@*#&'%',+'"%+=(,+,%',#'!#)*#',%'?(&*+'%[email protected]#=C(,#'!#"' +I1%=%'I1%'?(&1+=(K+R'%')3#'!#"'+I1%=%'I1%'@"(#1'+'"%!"%&%)*+>3#/ '

H5' &A)*%&%R' !#,%5#&' +V("5+"' I1%' +&' !%&&#+&' )3#b%&!%@(+=(&*+&' %&*3#R'

*%),%)@(+=5%)*%R' 5+(&' @[email protected](*+,+&' +' =%"' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' "%+=(&*+&R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'*"(,(5%)&(#)+(&' B+&%+,+&' )#'&(&*%5+',%'!"#N%@>3#'@%)*"+=R'#'I1%'*#")+'%&*+&' !%&&#+&' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' &%)&A?%(&' +#' ,#5A)(#' %5#*(?#' ,+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&R' ,+,#' I1%'%&*+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'*%),%5' +'$#@+"'5%)#&'+'=JD(@+',#&'#BN%@*#&' "%!"%&%)*+,#&9'@#)*1,#R'@"%5#&' I1%'#'&1!#"*%',(D(*+='%'()*%"[email protected]*(?#'!#,%"]'!%"5(*("b=C%&'15+'@#5!"%%)&3#',#&'!"#N%@*#&'%',+' "%+=(,+,%' !+"+' +=`5' ,%&*+' %5#*(?(,+,%-' +' !#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%' 5+)(!1=+"' #' 5#,%=#R' ,%' #' ?(&1+=(K+"' &#B' 5^=*(!=#&' !#)*#&' ,%' ?(&*+' ,%' [email protected]#",#' @#5' +' ?#)*+,%',%'I1%5' ?(&1+=(K+R' %',%' [email protected]"%[email protected]%)*+"'()$#"5+>3#'X',+,#&'X':&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' !%"5(*("]'+'%&*+&'!%&&#+&'@#5!"%%),%"' +'=JD(@+'&#B'+'@+!+',#'"%+=(&5#djg/

djg ' \' %L%5!=#' ,#' T##D=%' H+"*C' 'YT##D=%R' ejdj+Z' `' ,%' "%+=>+"-' &#B' +' @+!+' ,+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' "%+=(&*+' %' $#*#D"]V(@+' ,#' D=#B#' *%""%&*"%R'`' !#&&A?%=' =(D+"'%' ,%&=(D+"'15+' &`"(%' ,%' =+P%"&'%' "%&!%@*(?#&' ,+,#&'%' ,%[email protected]#B"("'+&' ?]"(+&' =JD(@+&'I1%R'%5B#"+'%&*%N+5' @#)*(,+&' )+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' #"(D()+=R' &3#' !#&&A?%(&' ,%' &%"%5' @#=#@+,+&' %5' %?(,M)@(+' !%=+' +!=(@+>3#' %' 5%,(+)*%' +' #!%"+>3#' ,#' 1*(=(K+,#"9' +&&(5R'`' !#&&A?%=' 1=*"+!+&&+"'#' !"(5%("#' ([email protected]*#' X' @=+"+5%)*%' %5#*(?#' X' ,#' @#)$"#)*#' @#5'+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' V(%=' ,#' )#&&#' !=+)%*+R' I1%' )#&' @#=#@+' (5%,(+*+5%)*%' $+5(=(+"(K+,#&' @#5' +' *#*+=(,+,%' ,+' !%>+' I1%' )#&' `' ,+,+R' !+"+' [email protected]+)>+"R' %5' [email protected]%&&(?+&'+!"#L(5+>a%&R'%',%'[email protected]#",#'@#5'#'"(*5#'%'+'?#)*+,%',#'1*(=(K+,#"R'+&'=JD(@+&'+'%=%'[email protected]%)*%&/

BI

B<

Comunicação e Representação de Projecto

D84449!2,&!0/;/2$=! 6=$2"(#%! (""! 84449!2,&!6(11/7/=/23!("!/.2&;#$2/.;! 1&E&#$=!236&1!("! /."(#%$2/(.! $.0!#&6#&1&.2$2/(.13#' X' &%N+' %=+' B(,(5%)&(#)+=' #1' *"(,(5%)&(#)+=R' B+&%+,+' )#&' &(&*%5+&',%'!"#N%@>3#'@%)*"+='#1'!+"+=%=+R'!#(&' *#,+&' %=+&'!#,%5'&%"'1*(=(K+,+&'+#'&%"?(>#',+' +B&*"[email protected]>3#'#1',#' "%+=(&5#R'%',+' =JD(@+'#1',+'%5#>3#/'\'5%&5#' !"()@A!(#' !#,%'&%"' +!=(@+,#' +#&' ,#5A)(#&' ,#' +)+=JD(@#o,(D(*+=' %' %&*]*(@#o()*%"[email protected]*(?#-' !%=+' &1+' )+*1"%K+R' %&*%&' !"#V(&&(#)+(&' 1*(=(K+5' I1%"' &1!#"*%&' +)+=JD(@#&' X' @#5#' #' !+!%='X' I1%"' &1!#"*%&' ,(D(*+(&' X' @#5#' #&' V(@C%("#&' ?%@*#"(+(&' ,(D(*+(&' X' !+"+' 5+*%"(+=(K+"' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&9' @#)*1,#R' #' &1!#"*%',(D(*+='`'+(),+'1*(=(K+,#'51(*#'+I1`5',+&' &1+&' !#*%)@(+=(,+,%&'X'+&'$%""+5%)*+&',%' ,"+$*()D' +(),+' ,#5()+5' &#B"%' +&' $%""+5%)*+&' ,%' 5#,%=+>3#' !+"+5`*"(@+R' #' *"+B+=C#' @#=+B#"+*(?#' `' "%&15(,#' :' *"#@+' ,%' &%$/=1R' #' @#)*"#=#' ,#' S#"QV=#SR' ,+&' ?%"&a%&' %' ,+&' !%"5(&&a%&' ,%'=%(*1"+o%,(>3#',#&'V(@C%("#&'`'$%(*+',%'$#"5+'+"@+(@+'"%@#""%),#' :',1!=(@+>3#' ,%'V(@C%("#&' %' +'15+' )#5%)@=+*1"+'!#[email protected]#' #"*#,#L+' X' #' I1%')#&' =%?+' +' @"%"' I1%R'+!%&+"',%' ,(D(*+=R'+'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'+(),+'`'5+)(!1=+,+',%'$#"5+'%&*]*(@+'%'!#[email protected]#'()*%"[email protected]*(?+/

ESTADO DA ARTE

!"6"6$)3$7/-5)7)[email protected]$,0$,4,+50-(%&%)*$6 ' '

H5' *0$! #&6#&1&.2$TF(! :(%(! $:2(! :#/$2/E(t' "%$%"(5#&' +' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' !%)&+"' )#&'

@#)*%^,#&' I1%' +' 8EG8' ,%?%"]' @#)*%"' )3#' +!%)+&' ,%' 15' !#)*#' ,%' ?(&*+' *%@)#=JD(@#' 5+&' *+5B`5'+"I1(*%@*J)(@#'%'@#51)(@+*(?#R',%'$#"5+'+'[email protected](=(*+"'+'&1+'@#5!"%%)&3#'%'!"#5#?%"'+' !+"*(@(!+>3#/ '

8'"%+=(,+,%'%'#'!"#N%@*#'@#)&1B&*+)@(+"+5b&%'+&&(5'@#5#'#&',#(&'*(!#&',%'@#)*%^,#&'

%&&%)@(+(&' @1N+' @#51)(@+>3#' +*"+?`&' ,+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ,%?%' &%"' %)*%),(,+' @#5#' 15' !"#@%&&#' @#5!=%L#' I1%' ,%!%),%' )3#' %)*%' ,+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' #1' ,%' I1%5' +' @"(+R' 5+&' *+5B`5',%'I1%5'+'=M'%'"%@#)&*"J(R',%'$#"5+'*+5B`5'@"(+*(?+R'+'!%>+'"%!"%&%)*+,+/ '

4%@#)C%@%5#&' *+5B`5' I1%'+&' ,($%"%)>+&' @1=*1"+(&' %)*"%' #&' ?]"(#&' =%(*#"%&' ,%&*+&'

"%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ()V=1%)@(+5' +' &1+' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' +&' @#5!"%%),%"R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' 5+(&' +B&*"[email protected]*+&' %'*`@)(@+&R' 5%)#&'[email protected]%&&A?%(&'+#' D"+),%' !^B=(@#9'+'8EG8' %' +&' OEG',%?%"3#'&%"?("'@#5#'()*%"5%,(]"(#&',%'$#"5+'+'[email protected](=(*+"'+'@#5!"%%)&3#' ,#&'@#)*%^,#&R'%' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' !#"' @#5!1*+,#"' ,%?%"3#' !"#!#"@(#)+"' )#?+&' $#"5+&' ,%' ?%"' +' $#"5+' 1"B+)+'!+"+'+=`5' ,+'(5(*+>3#' ,+'"%+=(,+,%/'4%@#)C%@%5#&' I1%' %&*+')%@%&&(,+,%R'!+"+'+=`5' ,#'!^B=(@#R'*+5B`5'&%'+!=(@+':&'%I1(!+&',%'!"#N%@*#R'@+,+'?%K'5+(&'51=*(,([email protected](!=()+"%&/ '

0%' $#"5+' +' @#)*"(B1("' !+"+' +' "%&#=1>3#' ,%&*%&' !"#B=%5+&' %' !+"+' 15+' 5%=C#"'

@#51)(@+>3#' %' @#5!"%%)&3#' ,+' @(,+,%R' (,%)*(V(@]5#&' ,#(&' !"()@A!(#&' $1),+5%)*+(&' !+"+' +' 8EG8-' +' ()*%D"+>3#' ,%' ?]"(#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' YI1%' @#51)(@+5' +' "%+=(,+,%' !#"' $"+D5%)*#&' @#5!=%5%)*+"%&' %R' !"%$%"%)@(+=5%)*%R' 51=*(b&%)&#"(+(&R' I1%' #' 1*(=(K+,#"' &%' %)@+""%D+"]',%'+"*(@1=+"'%)*"%'&(Z'%'+'!"#5#>3#',+'+1*#)#5(+',#'1*(=(K+,#"'%'()*%"[email protected]*(?(,+,%' ,#&' 5#,%=#&' %' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&R' I1%' @#)*"(B1("]' !+"+' 15+' 5%=C#"' @#51)(@+>3#' ,+' D=#B+=(,+,%' ,+' !%>+' "%!"%&%)*+,+' %' )3#' %)*%' ,#&' &%1&' +&!%@*#&' !+"*(@1=+"%&R' @#5#' [email protected]#)*%@%' @#5' +&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' %&*]*(@+&' I1%' *%),%)@(+=5%)*%' "%+=>+5' +&' I1+=(,+,%&' ,+&' !%>+&'"%!"%&%)*+,+&'+#'5%&5#'*%5!#'I1%',(&&(51=+5'#1'#@1=*+5'#&'&%1&',%$%(*#&/ '

' )#' &%)*(,#' ,%' %?(*+"' %&*%&' !"#B=%5+&' %' 5()(5(K+"' #&' %""#&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' I1%'

@#)&(,%"+5#&' +' C(!J*%&%' ,+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,#&' !"#N%@*#&' &1N%(*#&' +' ,([email protected]&&3#' !^B=(@+' &%"' %$%@*1+,+' !#"' %)*(,+,%&' %L*%")+&'+#&' 5%&5#&9'*+='&%"(+'15+'D+"+)*(+R'!#"'15' =+,#R' ,%'15+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' 5+(&' (5!+"@(+=9' !#"' #1*"#R' ,%' 15+' 5+(#"' [email protected](=(,+,%' ,%' @#5!+"+>3#' %)*"%' !"#N%@*#&/' H&*+' *%),M)@(+R' @"%5#&R' %&*]' %5' @"%[email protected](5%)*#' ,%?(,#' +#' )^5%"#' @"%[email protected]%)*%' ,%' %5!"%&+&'%',%'+!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&'I1%'()*%"?M5')%&*+']"%+/

BB

@CC

Comunicação e Representação de Projecto

6(D/'he-'0(+D"+5+b&A)*%&%-'s,+'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'@#5#'[email protected]*#'@"(+*(?#t

6(D/'hg-'0(+D"+5+b&A)*%&%-'s,+'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'@#5#'5%(#',%'@#51)(@+>3#'%V(@+Kt

ESTADO DA ARTE

'

H5' s0$! #&6#&1&.2$TF(! :(%(! %&/(! 0&! :(%-./:$TF(! &P/:$Qt' (,%)*(V(@]5#&' ,#(&'

!"()@A!(#&'+,(@(#)+(&'!+"+'+'!"#5#>3#',%'15+'@#51)(@+>3#'%V(@+K-'+'+,%I1+>3#',#&'5`*#,#&' ,%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'1*(=(K+,#&'+#&' #BN%@*(?#&' ,+'@#51)(@+>3#'%'+'+,%I1+>3#' :&' @[email protected](,+,%&',%' =%(*1"+',#&',%&*()+*]"(#&',%&&+'@#51)(@+>3#/ '

H5' "%=+>3#' +#' !"(5%("#R' (,%)*(V(@]5#&' ,1+&' &(*1+>a%&b*(!#-' +' @#)&*"1>3#' ,+' !%>+'

"%!"%&%)*+,+'X'#),%'#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'1&+,#&' ,%?%"3#'&%"R'*%),%)@(+=5%)*%R',#' ,#5A)(#' =JD(@#'%'+B&*"[email protected]*#'X'%'+',([email protected]&&3#'@"A*(@+'%5'*#")#' ,+'!%>+'"%!"%&%)*+,+'X'#),%'#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' 1&+,#&' ,%?%"3#' &%"' !=1"+(&R' "%@#""%),#' +#' &1!#"*%' ,(D(*+=' ()*%"[email protected]*(?#')#'&%)*(,#',%'!"#5#?%"'+'@#5!"%%)&3#'D=#B+=',+'!%>+'"%!"%&%)*+,+/ '

H5' "%=+>3#' +#' &%D1),#' (,%)*(V(@]5#&R' (D1+=5%)*%R' ,1+&' &(*1+>a%&b*(!#-' +'

@#51)(@+>3#'+'!"#V(&&(#)+(&'X'5+(&'@[email protected](*+,#&'%5'=%"'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&',%'I1+=I1%"')+*1"%K+R' 5+(&' +B&*"[email protected]*+&'#1'5+(&'"%+=(&*+&'X'%'+'@#51)(@+>3#' +' )3#b%&!%@(+=(&*+&' X' (),(?A,1#&'5%)#&' @+!+K%&' ,%' %)*%),%"' #&' 5`*#,#&' ,%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#' 5+(&' +B&*"[email protected]*#&R' %' I1%' %)@#)*"+"+5' )+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'"%+=(&*+&'!#"'()*%"5`,(#',#' @#5!1*+,#"'15+'$#"5+',%'!%"@%B%"%5' 5%=C#"'+' %L!"%&&3#' %L*%"(#"' ,#&' !"#N%@*#&' %' ,+' "%+=(,+,%9' @C+5]5#&' +' +*%)>3#R' @#)*1,#R' !+"+' +' )%@%&&(,+,%',%R'+*"+?`&',#' &1!#"*%',(D(*+='%',+'()*%"[email protected]*(?(,+,%R'!%"5(*("'+'%&*%&'(),(?A,1#&'+' @#5!"%%)&3#',+'=JD(@+'+'%=%&'()%"%)*%/ '

.#"'(&*#' @"%5#&' I1%R' !+"+'+=`5',#'@#)*%L*#' %',#'5#*(?#' !+"+'#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'

8EG8R' !#&&1A5#&' *+5B`5' +' @[email protected](,+,%' !+"+' ()*%D"+"' #&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,([email protected](!=()+"%&' )15+' !=+*+$#"5+' ,(D(*+=' %' ()*%"[email protected]*(?+R' @+!+K' ,%' !"#5#?%"' #' +N1&*%' ,%&&%&' @#)*%^,#&'I1%"'+#&'#BN%@*(?#&',+'@#51)(@+>3#R'I1%"'+#&'&%1&',%&*()+*]"(#&/ '

8'@[email protected](,+,%'+&&15%b&%'+&&(5'@#5#'+'!+=+?"[email protected]+?%',%&*%'[email protected]+!A*1=#' %'+'*%"@%("+'

#!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+'#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'8EG84

@[email protected]

@CD

*%),1681) */)1$>) *%&"&%$5&56

AICA

@CE

EA*!+2!88

EA*!+2!

@CF

Definição da matriz de análise

AICA

[email protected]?+J*K'&'-.!+()+,)$#'L+(*+)&M3'=* 6"#"#$%&$'&+&'5)+(?&9:,$%,7$5)3&7

'

\' @+!A*1=#' e' X' H&*+,#' ,+' 8"*%' X' "%?%=#1b)#&' #' @=(5+' ,%' #!#"*1)(,+,%' !+"+' #'

,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+' 8EG8' %' $#")%@%1b)#&' 15+' B+&%'@#)@%!*1+=' I1%' )%@%&&(*+' +D#"+' ,%' &%"' &(&*%5+*(K+,+' %' ,%5#)&*"+,+' @#5' "%$%"M)@(+' +' +!=(@+>a%&' @#)@"%*+&9' #' !"%&%)*%' @+!A*1=#' +!"%&%)*+R'!#"'(&&#R'15+'%&!%@(V(@(,+,%'"%&1=*+)*%',#'#BN%@*(?#'I1%')#&'5#?%/ '

\'!"(5%("#'!+&&#'!+"+'%&*+'&(&*%5+*(K+>3#'@#)&(&*(1')+',%V()(>3#',%'*%5+&'%&&%)@(+(&'

,%@#""%)*%&',%'15+'&A)*%&%',+'"%?(&3#'=(*%"]"(+'%$%@*1+,+9'#&'*%5+&'%)@#)*"+,#&'X'-2/=/Q$0(#a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+&R' ,%&,%' +' ()?%)>3#' ,#' @#5!1*+,#"R' %' +*`' ,+' !"J!"(+'+"I1(*%@*1"+/ '

f2/=/Q$0(#/' \' %&!+>#' #1' #B"+' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' )3#' `' 15' #BN%@*#' ,%' 51&%1R' `' 15'

#BN%@*#' !+"+' &%"' 1*(=(K+,#' %' "%&#=?%"' !"#B=%5+&' @#)@"%*#&9' #' 1*(=(K+,#"' `R' !+"+' +' #B"+' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' *3#' (5!#"*+)*%' I1+)*#' #' 1*(=(K+,#"' !+"+' 15+' +!=(@+>3#' ()$#"5]*(@+/' 8#' @#)@%B%"'15' !"#N%@*#R'#' 8"I1(*%@*#' ,%?%' *%"' %5' @#)*+'#&' $1*1"#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&',#' &%1'%&!+>#' #1' %,([email protected](#R' !"#@1"+),#' &+B%"' I1%5' &3#R' @#5#' &%' !#,%5' %&*"1*1"+"R' I1+(&' +&' &1+&' )%@%&&(,+,%&R' "%=+>a%&' %o#1' ()@#5!+*(B(=(,+,%&9' #' 5%&5#' ,%&+V(#' &%' @#=#@+' :' +!=(@+>3#' ()$#"5]*(@+/ '

q12#-2-#$-' W%' )#' @#5%>#' +' vvv! &%' "%&15(+' :' =()D1+D%5' C*5=R' #' (),(?A,1#' ,+' WE'

,(*#1' +' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' @#5B()+"' ,($%"%)*%&' =()D1+D%)&R' @"(+),#' 15+' %&*"1*1"+' @#5!=%L+' @#5!#&*+'!#"'?]"(#&'=+P%"&9'+)+=#D+5%)*%R'+&&(&*(5#&')+'+"I1(*%@*1"+'+'15+'@#5!=%L(V(@+>3#' ,#&'&(&*%5+&'@#)&*"1*(?#&R'%'+'!+"%,%R'I1%'+)*%&'&%'"%&15(+'+#' %=%5%)*#' !#"*+)*%R'+D#"+'`'X' $"1*#' ,+&' )%@%&&(,+,%&' ,#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' X' 15' &(&*%5+' @#5!=%L#' @#5!#&*#' !#"' ?]"(#&' %=%5%)*#&' @#)&*"1*(?#&/' \!%"+"' )+' @#5!=%L(,+,%' `' )%@%&&]"(#' !#(&' &J' %=+' )#&' !%"5(*("]' #$%"%@%"'+#'1*(=(K+,#"'#&'@#)*%^,#&'!"#5#?%),#'+'@#51)(@+>3#'%'+'()*%"[email protected]>3#*b$:&! $(! /.:#&%&.2(! 0$! :(%6=&`/0$0&!8q0;$#!R(#/.3#'@#5'#',%&%N#',+'&(5!=(@(,+,%R'5%&5#'I1%'+!+"%)*%*Z!0/11/%-=$TF(! 0&!1/12&%$1!:(%6=&`(1!"$Q&.0(g.(1!:#&#! .$!1-$! $6$#o.:/$! 1/%6=&1!#&E&=$! .(E$! :(.2#$0/TF(3#9' %=%@*"(@(,+,%R' ]D1+' !#*]?%=R' =1K'&3#' @#)*%^,#&' I1%' +' +"I1(*%@*1"+' $#")%@%9'+)+=#D+5%)*%R' +' 8EG8' !"#@1"+"]' "%&#=?%"' )%@%&&(,+,%&' %'!"#5#?%"' +'&#@(+=(K+>3#9'&%"]' )%@%&&]"(#' @=+"(V(@+"' I1+(&' #&' @#)*%^,#&' %' I1+=' +' $#"5+' ,%' #&' !"#?(,%)@(+"' +#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' ,+' +!=(@+>3#' ()$#"5]*(@+/ '

H5' &A)*%&%R' +' 8EG8' &%"]' 15+' %&*"1*1"+' )+' I1+=' #&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' !#,%"3#' [email protected]%,%"' +'

@#)*%^,#&R' 5%,(+,#&' !#"' 15+' ()*%"[email protected]%/' .#"' %&*+' +=*1"+R' N]' %&*+"]' @=+"+' +' (5!#"*_)@(+' ,#' %[email protected]=+"%@(5%)*#',%&*%&'*%5+&'@#5#'6(.2&'%)*"%'+'"%?(&3#'=(*%"]"(+'I1%'%$%@*1]5#&')#'&%D1),#' @+!A*1=#'%'+'%&!%@(V(@(,+,%',+'8EG8'I1%')#&'!"#!#5#&'+D#"+'+B#",+"/ '

\' %&*1,#' %$%@*1+,#' &%"]' +!"#$1),+,#' %' !+"*(@1=+"(K+,#' 5%,(+)*%' +' "%$%"M)@(+' +'

%L%5!=#&',%'+!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&'"%=%?+)*%&'%'I1%'%L!"%&&+5'$#"5+&'@"(+*(?+&',%'"%&#=?%"' +&'I1%&*a%&'I1%'%)1)@(]5#&/ '

8' "%1*(=(K+>3#' ,+' ()$#"5+>3#' $#(' 15+' @[email protected](,+,%' !"#5#?(,+' !%=#' @#5!1*+,#"R'

[email protected](=(*+,+' !%=+' E)*%")%*' %' +,%I1+,+' :&' )%@%&&(,+,%&' ,#' (),(?A,1#' ,+' WE9' +' +!=(@+>3#' ()$#"5]*(@+'I1%')#&'!"#!#5#&',%&%)?#=?%"')3#',%?%"]R'!#"'(&&#R',%[email protected]#)C%@%"'%&*%'[email protected]*#/

AICA

6"#"!$%&$A+&3)B,+C$&-&=(5('&

'

H$%@*1+,+' +'&A)*%&%' ,#&' I1+*"#' *%5+&' $1),+5%)*+(&' `' )%@%&&]"(#R' +D#"+R'()?%"*%"' #'

!"#@%&&#' ,%' @#)&*"1>3#' ,%' @#)C%@(5%)*#' %R' 5+)*%),#' +' !"%&%)>+' ,+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+R' +)+=(&+"' @+,+' 15' ,#&' *%5+&' *%),#' %5' @#)*+' +' &1+' !"J!"(+' %&!%@(V(@(,+,%/' .+"+' +1L(=(+"' #' !"#@%&&#' ,%' +)]=(&%' $#(' )%@%&&]"(+' +' @#)@%!>3#' ,%' 15+' $"+5%S#"Q' +)+=A*(@+dji ' @#5!#&*+' !%=#&'&%D1()*%&'@#)@%(*#&'+"*(@1=+,#&-'2&%$R'/.0/:$0(#R'E$#/XE&=R'"(.2&R'%'#&G-/1/2(!"-.:/(.$=/ '

+&%$-' #' *%5+' `' #' s+&&1)*#' I1%' &%' I1%"' ,%&%)?#=?%"t' ' Y.#"*#' H,(*#"+R' ejdjZ9'

$#"5+=5%)*%R' `' %)*%),(,#' @#5#' 15+' 1)(,+,%' =JD(@+' ,%' %)I1+,"+5%)*#' ,%' ,#(&' #1' 5+(&' (),(@+,#"%&/'0+,+' +' &1+')+*1"%K+R'#' *%5+'*%"]'15'@+"]@*%"'+B"+)D%)*%' 5+&'&()*`*(@#R'&%),#' !#"' (&&#' $#"5+=(K+,#' )15+' ^)(@+' !+=+?"+9' "%V("+b&%' I1%' #&' *%5+&' N]' $#"+5' %)@#)*"+,#&' Y"%@#",%b&%R'1*(=(K+,#"R'%&*"1*1"+R'()*%"[email protected]%'%'@#)*%^,#&Z'+*"+?`&',%'15+'&A)*%&%'@#5'B+&%')+' "%?(&3#'=(*%"]"(+'%$%@*1+,+9 '

5.0/:$0(#h'#' (),(@+,#"'s&%"?%',%' (),(@+>3#' #1'()$#"5+>3#t' 'Y.#"*#' H,(*#"+R'ejdjZ' %'

"%!"%&%)*+'15+'@+"[email protected]*%"A&*(@+',%'#",%5'I1+=(*+*(?+':'I1+='+'8EG8',%?%"]',+"'"%&!#&*+/'R'!#"' (&&#R' %L!"%&&#' )#&' *%"5#&' [email protected][email protected](,+,%' ,%///tR' s!#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%///tR' [email protected](=(,+,%' ,%///tR' %*@/R' %' @#)&*(*1('15'#BN%@*(?#'%&*"+*`D(@#'I1%'&%'!"%*%),%'[email protected]+)>+"'5+&'I1%'+(),+')3#'&%'&+B%'I1+='+' 5%=C#"' "%&!#&*+9' #&' (),(@+,#"%&' %&*3#' !"%&%)*%&' +#' =#)D#' ,%' *#,+' +' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+R' 5+&' &%"3#'+D#"+'(,%)*(V(@+,#&'%'%)I1+,"+,#&')#&'*%5+&9 '

b(.2&-' +'$#)*%' `'15+' s!%&&#+R' ()&*(*1(>3#' #1',#@15%)*#' I1%' @#)&*(*1(' +' #"(D%5' ,%'

15+'()$#"5+>3#t' ' Y.#"*#'H,(*#"+R'ejdjZ9')#' &%)*(,#' ,%' ,%*%"5()+"'+' 5%=C#"' "%&!#&*+' !+"+' 15'(),(@+,#"R'&%"3#'+&'$#)*%&'+'"%?%=+"'%'%L%5!=(V(@+"'+&'?]"(+&'"%&!#&*+&'!#&&A?%(&9'15+'$#)*%' !#,%"]',+"'#')^5%"#' ,%'"%&!#&*+&' '+#')^5%"#' ,%'(),(@+,#"%&'I1%',%&%N+"9'!+"+' +' !"%&%)*%' 0(&&%"*+>3#' &%"3#' @#)&(,%"+,#&' ,#(&' *(!#&' ,%' $#)*%-' +1*#"%&o%)*(,+,%&' %' +!=(@+>a%&' %L(&*%)*%&/ '

{$#/XE&=h!+'?+"(]?%='`'+I1%=+'I1%'s!#,%'*#5+"',($%"%)*%&'?+=#"%&'#1'+&!%@*#&t''Y.#"*#'

H,(*#"+R' ejdjZR'&%),#' +' "%&!#&*+'@#)@"%*+',%' 15+'$#)*%'+'15' ,%*%"5()+,#'(),(@+,#"9'`'!#"' (&&#'%L!"%&&+')#&'*%"5#&'s!%"5(*%///tR's!#&&(B(=(*+///tR's!"#5#?%///tR's,%$%),%///tR'%*@/ djl9

dji'G#)@%(*#'"%*("+,#',%' >

requisito funcional

variável variável

>

requisito funcional

variável

>

requisito funcional

variável

>

requisito funcional

variável

>

requisito funcional

variável

>

requisito funcional

variável

>

requisito funcional

variável

>

requisito funcional

variável

>

requisito funcional

variável

>

requisito funcional

variável

>

requisito funcional

requisito funcional

6(D/'hi-';+*"(K',%'+)]=(&%

AICA

!

]&G-/1/2(! b-.:/(.$=h!#'"%I1(&(*#' $1)@(#)+='`'15+',%V()(>3#'!"%@(&+',%'15' #BN%@*(?#' +'

@15!"("' )+'8EG8' %'&%"]' ,%*%"5()+,#' !+"+'@+,+'(),(@+,#"R' *%),#' %5' @#)&(,%"+>3#' *#,+&' +&' ?+"(]?%(&' !#&&A?%(&9' 15' "%I1(&(*#' $1)@(#)+=' &%"]' +&&(5' #' "%&1=*+,#' ,+' &%=%@>3#' ,+' 5%=C#"' "%&!#&*+'+' 15' (),(@+,#"9' !%=#' &%1' @+"]@*%"' !"#N%@*(?#R'&%"]' %L!"%&&#' )#&' *%"5#&' s,%?%"]///tR' s!%"5(*("]///tR's!"#5#?%"]///tR'%*@/ '

8',%V()(>3#',#&' "%I1(&(*#&'$1)@(#)+(&'@#)&*(*1('15',#&'#BN%@*(?#&',#' !"#N%@*#'084GR'

#' I1+=' ,%!%),%"]' ,+&' !#&&(B(=(,+,%&' *`@)(@+&R' V()+)@%("+&' %' C15+)+&' ,#' G#)&J"@(#/' W%"]' )%@%&&]"(+'15+'5+(#"',(&!#)(B(=(,+,%',%'*%5!#R'#' *"+B+=C#' @#=+B#"+*(?#' %'#' @"1K+5%)*#',%' ,+,#&' ,+'%I1(!+' ()*%",([email protected](!=()+"' ,#' 084GR'%' +' "%+=(K+>3#' ,%' !"#*J*(!#&' %'%)&+(#&/' .#"'%&*+' "+K3#R'+',%V()(>3#',#&'"%I1(&(*#&' $1)@(#)+(&')3#' &%'@#)&*(*1(1'@#5#'15'#BN%@*(?#' ,+'!"%&%)*%' 0(&&%"*+>3#-' !"%$%"(5#&' "%+=>+"' +' (5!#"*_)@(+' ,#&' (),(@+,#"%&' @#5#' %=%5%)*#&' @%)*"+(&' %' %&*"+*`D(@#&',+'$"+5%S#"Q' +)+=A*(@+-'!#"'15'=+,#R'&3#' &1N%(*#&'+'15' !"#@%&&#' ,%'&A)*%&%')#&' *%5+&9'!#"' #1*"#R' +' 15' !"#@%&&#' ,%' +)]=(&%' ,#),%' &%' %L*"+%5' +&' ?+"(]?%(&' ,+&' "%&!%@*(?+&' $#)*%&/'\'(),(@+,#"'`'15'"%I1(&(*#'$1)@(#)+='%5'!#*M)@(+/ '

.+&&+"%5#&' +D#"+'+#'=%?+)*+5%)*#',%'(),(@+,#"%&' !+"+'#' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'8EG8R'

I1%' &%"3#' !#&*%"(#"5%)*%' &()*%*(K+,#&' )+' 5+*"(K' ,%@#""%)*%' ,+' $"+5%S#"Q' +)+=A*(@+' I1%' [email protected]+B+5#&',%',%[email protected]"%?%"/ '

.%=+' )+*1"%K+' ,%[email protected]"(*(?+' ,+' *+"%$+' &%"]' 1*(=(K+,+' 15+' %&*"+*`D(+' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#'

,(&*()*+' ,+' 1&+,+' )+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+9' ("%5#&' (,%)*(V(@+"' %' %L%5!=(V(@+"' %&*%&' (),(@+,#"%&' "%@#""%),#' +' &A)*%&%&' %5' *%L*#R' %&*"1*1"+,+&' %5' *J!(@#&R' %' !"#@1"+),#' 1*(=(K+"' +' (5+D%5' &%5!"%'I1%'!#&&A?%=R' &#B"%*1,#' &%'+'@#51)(@+>3#' &%'"%!#"*+"' +' 15+'+!=(@+>3#'%L(&*%)*%')#' 5%"@+,#/' '

7#*%b&%' +(),+' I1%' )3#' *%5#&' +' !"%*%)&3#' YI1%' +' )#&&#' ?%"' &%"(+' ()D`)1+Z' ,%'

+!"%&%)*+"' #&' &%D1()*%&' (),(@+,#"%&' @#5#' ,%V()(*(?#&' %' @#5!=%*#&' X' +)*%&' !%=#' @#)*"]"(#-' "%@#)C%@%5#&' I1%R'+#'=#)D#',+'()?%&*(D+>3#'I1%'+(),+'*%5#&'!%=+'$"%)*%R'#1*"#&'(),(@+,#"%&' !#,%"3#'%',%?%"3#'&1"D("R'B%5'@#5#')#?+&'$#)*%&'%'?+"(]?%(&/ '

8&&(5R' "%+=>+5#&' #' @+"]@*%"' S#"Qb()b!"#D"%&&' ,+&' !]D()+&' I1%' &%' &%D1%5'

"%@#""%),#'+'15'!+!%='I1%')#&'"%5%*%'!+"+'+'%$%5%"(,+,%',%'15')%S&!+!%"'1*(=(K+,#R'+=(]&R' %5'*#,#'%&*%'@+!A*1=#/

@CB

@@C

Dez indicadores para a AICA

AICA

[email protected]+J*L+'&('0)(!#*=+")#)+)+;5H; ' '

G#5#' D1(3#' ,%' =%(*1"+R' +!"%&%)*+5#&' #' 5#,%=#' %' +' ]"?#"%' ,%' *%5+&o(),(@+,#"%&o

$#)*%&'I1%'$#"+5'!#"')J&'+)+=(&+,#&/'G+,+'15',#&'*%5+&'&%"]',%&(D)+,#'!#"'15+'=%*"+'YrZ'%' #&' "%&!%@*(?#&'(),(@+,#"%&'&%"3#' ,%&(D)+,#&' !#"'%&&+'=%*"+'+&&#@(+,+' +' 15')^5%"#' Yr)Z9'+&' $#)*%&' &%"3#' #",%)+,+&' ,%' [email protected]#",#' @#5' +' )15%"+>3#' "#5+)+/' 0%&*+' $#"5+' &%"]' !#&&A?%=' (,%)*(V(@+"'15+'?+"(]?%='%&!%@AV(@+'(),(@+),#'+&' "%&!%@*(?+&' @##",%)+,+&'Y(),(@+,#"R$#)*%Z'X' !#"'%L%5!=#R'Y8dR(/Z/'8'*"+,1>3#'D"]V(@+',#'5#,%=#'`'+'&%D1()*%-

D" 5)3& A&"

%&#%,$#+1 É,%V()(>3#',#'(),(@+,#"Ñ

(/

6#)*% É%L!=(@(*+>3#',+'?+"(]?%=Ñ'

((/

6#)*% É%L!=(@(*+>3#',+'?+"(]?%=Ñ

(((/

6#)*% É%L!=(@(*+>3#',+'?+"(]?%=Ñ

'

8']"?#"%',%'*%5+&o(),(@+,#"%&o$#)*%&'&%"]'+!"%&%)*+,+')+&'!]D()+&'&%D1()*%&/

@@@

@@D

Dez indicadores para a AICA

E" 05(=(?&%,+)7 48"

,$.$,%#$#("#("(201/0/1$)*+"#("B1/.+2"#("/0%>%C$#+1(2

(/

2%D(&=+>3#

((/

%#$#("#("%&0(B1$)*+"(-"2%20(-$2"#("%#(&0%F%,$)*+"(G%20(&0(2

(/

G%"*(V(@+,#'0(D(*+=

((/

\!%)E0

[email protected]"

,$.$,%#$#("#("(201/0/1$)*+"#(",%1,/%0+2"#$"%&E+1-$)*+

(/

.=#)%'G;W

((/

;[email protected]#=5'4%+,()D'G#)&1=*+)*&

(((/

E7GE

F"$(-5)+A&') H8"

,$.$,%#$#("#(".(12+&$>%C$)*+"#$"%&0(1E$,(

(/

81*#,%&Q'81*#@+,

((/

(T##D=%

HD"

E$,%>%#$#("#(",+-.1((&2*+"#$"%&0(1E$,("

(/

v#",!"%&&

((/

W%)*%

(((/

%p#=#

AICA

G"$)75+050+& 38"

,$.$,%#$#("#(",+-.+2%)*+"-+#/>$1

(/

3#'%'+&'$1)@(#)+=(,+,%&',%'I1%'%&&%&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&'("3#',(&!#"/' '

\'1*(=(K+,#"',+'8EG8' !%"*%)@%"]'+'15' )^5%"#',%*%"5()+,#',%'D"1!#&'X'#1'"%,%&R' :'

&%5%=C+)>+',#'(),(?A,1#',+'WE/

AICA

(/

2%D(&=+>3#

' '

8' 2%('gdoejjq's8!"#?+' #' "%D(5%'N1"A,(@#' I1%' %&*+B%=%@%' +' I1+=(V(@+>3#' !"#V(&&(#)+='

%L(DA?%=' +#&' *`@)(@#&' "%&!#)&]?%(&' !%=+' %=+B#"+>3#' %' [email protected]"(>3#' ,%' !"#N%@*#&' Y///Zt' ' YM&/! [email protected]#',#&'!"#N%@*#&')%@%&&]"(#&':'@#)@%!>3#',+'#B"+'@#5#'15'*#,#/

@@G

@@H

Dez indicadores para a AICA

((/

a%&' G;W'X'

:(.2&.2! %$.$;&%&.2! 1312&%1ZR' +!=(@+>a%&' I1%R' +!%&+"' ,%' D%)`"(@+&R' $#")%@%5b)#&' ,+,#&' (5!#"*+)*%&'&#B"%'5%@+)(&5#&' ,%'D%&*3#',%'1*(=(K+,#"%&/'a%&'%L(&*%)*%&/

djn 'G#)*1,#R' )3#' `' ,%' 5%)#&!"%K+"'+' !#&&(B(=(,+,%' ,%' 15'1*(=(K+,#"')3#' "%D(&*+,#' [email protected]%,%"'+' ]"%+&')3#[email protected]"A*(@+&',+' +!=(@+>3#' %' ?(&1+=(K+"' ,%*%"5()+,#&'@#)*%^,#&9' #' "%D(&*#' ,%' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' !+"%@%b)#&'%&&%)@(+=R' )#' %)*+)*#R' !+"+' !%"5(*("' +&' [email protected](=(,+,%&',%' @"(+>3#'%o#1'%,(>3#',%'@#)*%^,#&R'%',%'[email protected]%&&#'+']"%+&'"%&%"?+,+&',+'.=+*+$#"5+'0(D(*+=/

endangered species you are currently here: endangered species / log in

a) have you registered before?

AICA

if you have already filled out the registration form in the past please enter your details below to participate for this competition. your e-mail:

@@B

your password: log in wrongs email and/or password!

(/

0%&(D)B##5 you can edit your personal details here

'

8'0%&(D)B##5'Y0%&(D)B##5R' ejjnZ'$1)@(#)+')3#' &J' @#5#'!=+*+$#"5+',%',(?1=D+>3#'

,%' @#)@1"&#&' )%&*+&' ]"%+&R' @#5#' ,%&%5!%)C+' 15' !+!%=' _____________________________________________________ [email protected]*(?#' )+' &1+' !"#5#>3#R' b) first time to register?

$1)@(#)+),#' @#5#' ()*%"5%,(]"(+R' !%"5(*(),#' +#' 1*(=(K+,#"'please "%D(&*+"b&%' %5' ,(?%"&+&' complete the form below. by using our online system, you will be able to upload your entry @#5!%*(>a%&'%'&1B5%*%"'+&'&1+&'!"#!#&*+&9')#'V()+=R'+'!=+*+$#"5+'"%?%=+'#&'"%&1=*+,#&/ directly onto our server, which makes the jury process faster

register here

and more trasparent. you will also be able to publish, varify and modify

'

the lay-out of your entry's page. the system allows a larger number .+"+' [email protected]%,%"' +' %&*+&' $1)@(#)+=(,+,%&' `' )%@%&&]"(#' #' "%D(&*#' *%),#' +' giving of designs ,%' to be 1*(=(K+,#"R' visible to designboom readers, thus designboom web search designers greater visibility.

!=+*+$#"5+R' !+"+' #' %$%(*#R' &#=(@(*+,#' #&' &%D1()*%&' ,+,#&-' )#5%R' +!%=(,#R' %5+(=R' !+&&S#",' ---

your name Y,1!=(@+,#ZR']"%+'!"#V(&&(#)+='Y5%)1',"#!,#S)ZR',+*+',%'+)(?%"&]"(#R'D`)%"#R'5#"+,+R'@J,(D#' please do not use any capital letters --!#&*+=R'@(,+,%R'!+A&R'%')(@Q)+5%/

endangered species

--your surname please do not use any capital letters

industrial design today: courses, education, competitions, history and contemporary, shop, interviews, snapshots, design-aerobics, the intelligent hand competition

you are currently here: endangered species / log in

a) have you registered before?

your e-mail:

upcoming courses: spirituality tech gadgets

endangered species

your password: ball nogues

itivoli audio 10th anniversary

2010 courses: history & future cycle body & mind cycle

seoul cycle design

view index

view index

paul smith pei zhu michel rojkind

takashi murakami at versailles rupprecht geiger julien berthier: balcon additionnel

wrongs email and/or password! view index view index

design for all

toyo ito: wins praemium marc newson at imperiale + exhibition at gagosian gallery, new venice biennale 2010 york

log in

caruso st. john + thomas demand at venice 2010 korean pavilion at venice biennale 2010 view index

love ring

--choose a password (5 to 20 alfanumeric characters)

view index

--retype your password

browse a specific topic in depth

full

today

yesterday

+ week

+ month

+ all time

you can edit your personal details here

xavier lust 4 articles

brussels design september 2010 2 articles

studio visits 13 articles

london design week 2010 30 articles

rolf sachs 5 articles

ran amitai 5 articles

6(D/'hm-'.]D()+'()(@(+=',+'+!=(@+>3#'0%&(D)B##5

seoul cycle design 22 articles

_____________________________________________________

b) first time to register?

--what field do you work in? choose below.

constance guisset 3 articles

stefan sagmeister 6 articles

shanghai 2010 58 articles

jacques ferrier architectures 2 articles

parking area

design miami basel 2010 9 articles

hussein chalayan 4 articles

gwangju art biennale 2010 14 articles

LAN architecture 10 articles

sukkah city 4 articles

--your name please doseptember not use any xavier lust at design brussels 2010 capital letters

julian mayor: angle chair

/

--your gender M

F

--street address

takashi murakami at versailles rupprecht geiger

SHARE AND PROMOTE YOUR WORK since 1999, home of design culture. designboom has been the world's first online design magazine. with 4 million people reading us monthly, we are the most popular art, architecture and design destination - a perfect target audience for all creative businesses. we welcome readers to submit projects - you have a better chance of being featured if the work hasn’t been published before. more info.

--zip code

julien berthier: balcon additionnel view index

mail(at)designboom.com

--city

--your e-mail

--country

--choose a password (5 to 20 alfanumeric characters)

--retype your password

jasper morrison + punkt: DP01 telephone

--date of birth (dd) / (mm) / (yyyy) /

10 articles by using our online system, you will be able to upload your entry directly onto our server, which makes the jury process faster luis porem and more trasparent. you will also be able to publish, varify 3 articles and modify the lay-out of your entry's page. the system allows a larger number of designs to be visible to designboom readers, thus giving electric bikes 14 articles designers greater visibility.

marc newson at gagosian gallery, new york

view index

vienna design week 2010 5 articles

please complete the form below.

--your surname please do not use any capital letters

view index

leaf-it bookmark/post-it

jasper morrison + punkt: endless rain record DP01 telephone help bookmark julian mayor: angle chair view index

via

brief

caruso st. john + thomas demand at venice 2010 korean pavilion at venice biennale 2010

--your e-mail

if you have already filled out the registration form in the past please enter your details below to participate for this competition.

toyo ito: wins praemium imperiale + exhibition at venice biennale 2010

READ DESIGNBOOM CONTENT IN CHINESE LANGUAGE

--choose a nickname

ball nogues paul smith pei zhu

LAN architecture: ZAC saussure pont cardinet READ DESIGNBOOM CONTENT IN KOREAN LANGUAGE

6(D/'hn-'4%D(&*#',%'1*(=(K+,#"')+'+!=(@+>3#'0%&(D)B##5' ---

S ubmi t

view index

6(D/'hq-'4%D(&*#',%'1*(=(K+,#"')+'+!=(@+>3#'0%&(D)B##5'

what field do you work in? choose below.

JD on jinsop lee + justin kim: dreyfuss special: WOW!! Amazing~ ...

--date of birth (dd) / (mm) / (yyyy)

kaukau on bioarch formosana: taipei flora expo pavilions: Will this building, and other of ... sinaalashty on maurizio cattelan's middle finger displayed in milan: very genius ... filo on maurizio cattelan's middle finger displayed in milan:

Powerful PDF API Create PDF files dynamically.

@DC

Dez indicadores para a AICA

((/

y1&*=%"

'

8' y1&*=%"' Yy1&*=%"R' ejdjZ' (,%)*(V(@+b&%' @#5#' 15+' !=+*+$#"5+' #)=()%' ,%' )#*[email protected](+&R'

%?%)*#&' %' @#)@1"&#&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+/' 8#' @#)*"]"(#' ,+' 0%&(D)B##5R' #' &%1' ()*1(*#' `' 5+(&' +' ,(?1=D+>3#',#'I1%'+'!"#5#>3#',%'@#)@1"&#&9'+&&(5'&%),#'#'!"#@%&&#',%'()[email protected]"(>3#R'&1B5(&&3#' ,%'!"#!#&*+&R'%*@/'`'%$%@*1+,#')#'&(*%',#' !"#5#*#"'X'+'y1&*=%"'%)@+""%D+b&%',%'%)@+5()C+"'#' 1*(=(K+,#"')%&&%'&%)*(,#/ '

\'"%D(&*#' )+'y1&*=%"' `' %$%@*1+,#' 5%,(+)*%' #' !"%%)@C(5%)*#' ,#&' @+5!#&-')#5%' ,%'

%L(B(>3#R'1&%")+5%R'%5+(=R'!+&&S#",'Y,1!=(@+,#ZR'=#@+=(K+>3#R'#@1!+>3#/

competitions events News & Results:

Featured Competitions:

news & results Search News:

+ submit!

keyword search...

about / contact advertising subscribe Register: Sep 15 / Submit: Sep 30

Register: Oct 22 / Submit: Oct 22

my picks You're not logged in! Login

Search Competitions:

Members

keyword search... There are 1575 competitions in the Bustler database. Browse all | Most Popular | Most Recently Added Competition Twitter Feed

Register: Oct 1 / Submit: Oct 15

Featured Events:

2009/2010 Leading Edge Competition Winners

Comments: 0

Posted: Monday, September 27, 2010

Winners have been announced for the 2009/2010 Leading Edge Student Design Competition. The annual contest seeks to support and enhance the study of sustainable and energy-efficient building practices in architectural education. This year, the competition focused on the coastal city of Long Beach, California. Students entering Challenge 1…

September 25

September 20

Search Events:

View this Article

keyword search...

There are 2358 events in the Bustler calendar.

6(D&/'ij-'.]D()+'()(@(+=',+'+!=(@+>3#'y1&*=%"' Browse all | Most Popular | Most Recently Added

Winning M9 Competition Entry by Sauerbruch Hutton

Comments: 0

Posted: Monday, September 27, 2010

The entry by Anglo-German practice Sauerbruch Hutton has recently won the M9 International Architectural Design Competition, the new cultural pole that will open in Venice-Mestre, Italy in 2014. View this Article

www.amen.pt/dominio Ads by Google Advertisement

Recent comments:

http://www.rosenbergs.se/projektarkiv/flat-iron-building-fast-istockholm/ J in LAN Architecture Wins Cardinet-Chalabre Mixed-Use Project

The Rio Islands Are Protect. This Project Never Will Be Accept . Bruce in Solar City Tower for Rio Olympics 2016

This Island Is Protect. It's A Natural Reserve. Bruce in Solar City Tower for Rio Olympics 2016

Looks pretty nice. I don't know about the local ordinances and building codes, but I t's crazy if they get away with that proposed stairwell.

6(D&/'id-'4%D(&*#',%'1*(=(K+,#"')+'+!=(@+>3#'y1&*=%"' sullka in LAN Architecture Wins Cardinet-Chalabre Mixed-Use Project

underwhelming david in MVVA Team Moves Forward in City+Arch+River 2015 Competition

i just have two words to say ...... it's Awesome .... pAwAn in Libeskind Wins $20B Seoul Master Plan Competition

LAN Architecture Wins Cardinet-Chalabre Mixed-Use Project

Comments: 2

Posted: Thursday, September 23, 2010

Paris-based firm LAN has won the competition organized by ICF Novedis to design the block 4.2 of the new Cardinet-Chalabre urban development zone in Paris, France. The project sits at a sensitive transition point between two Parisian urban areas and will act as a fulcrum between the… View this Article

Amazing works Australia, I was particularly impressed by the Ian Thorpe Aquatic Centre and the Darling Point Apartment 2. The interior design there is just on another level. Keep it… S.Rushmore in Australian NSW Architecture Awards Announced

Kudos! Kelly Katharyne Goshulak Katharyne Goshulak in Kelly Nelson Doran Wins Prix de Rome in Architecture for Emerging Practitioners

AICA

(((/

8"I1(*%@*15

'

\' 8"I1(*%@*15' ' Y8"I1(*%@*15R' ejdjZ' `' 15+' !=+*+$#"5+' #)=()%' ,%' ,(?1=D+>3#' ,%'

)#*[email protected](+&' %' !"#5#>3#' ,%' @#)@1"&#&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+/' \$%"%@%' 15+' ,%[email protected]"(>3#' *(!(V(@+,+' ,#&' @#)@1"&#&'I1%'!"#5#?%'%'()*%"?`5'@#5#'5%,(+,#"')#'!"#@%&&#',%'()[email protected]"(>3#R'$#")%@%),#'15' $#"51=]"(#b*(!#'I1%'@#)&(&*%')#&'&%D1()*%&'@+5!#&-'!"(5%("#')#5%R'^=*(5#')#5%R'(,+,%R'!+A&R' %5+(='%'@#)*[email protected]*#'*%=%$J)(@#/ '

H&*%'"%D(&*#'`'$%(*#'N]')+'I1+=(,+,%',%'!+"*(@(!+)*%')#'@#)@1"&#'&%=%@@(#)+,#/

6(D&/'ie-'.]D()+'()(@(+=',+'+!=(@+>3#'8"I1(*%@*15''

6(D&/'ig-'4%D(&*#',%'1*(=(K+,#"')+'+!=(@+>3#'8"I1(*%@*15'

@[email protected]

@DD

Dez indicadores para a AICA

AICA

47"

E$,%>%#$#("#("%&0(B1$)*+"(-"2%20(-$2"#("%#(&0%F%,$)*+"(G%20(&0(2

' '

H&*%' (),(@+,#"' !"#@1"+' ,+"' "%&!#&*+'+' ,1+&' )%@%&&(,+,%&' ,+' 8EG89'!#"' 15' =+,#R' +'

)%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' (,%)*(V(@+"' #' 1*(=(K+,#"' ,+' $#"5+' 5+(&' %L!%,(*+' !#&&A?%=-' )%&*%' &%)*(,#R' ?%"%5#&'15+'C(!J*%&%',%'(,%)*(V(@+>3#'I1%')3#'@+"%@%',%'"%D(&*#',#'1*(=(K+,#"')+'!=+*+$#"5+R' )+'5%,(,+'I1%'+'(,%)*(V(@+>3#' !#,%"]' &%"'%$%@*1+,+' !#"' 15' ()*%"5%,(]"(#' X' 15' &%"?(>#' #1' +!=(@+>3#' I1%' #' 1*(=(K+,#"' N]' 1*(=(K%9' !#"' #1*"#R' :' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' ?+=(,+>3#' ,#&' V(@C%("#&' ,(D(*+(&'%'@#)V("5+>3#',+'&1+'#"(D%5'%'+1*#"(+/

@DE

@DF

Dez indicadores para a AICA

6(D&/'ih-'8!=(@+>3#'s8&&()+".06t'!+"+'+&&()+*1"+',(D(*+=',%',#@15%)*#&'%5'$#"5+*#'.06/'

GOVERNO

CIDADÃOS

EMPRESAS

Login com Certificado Digital

Se possui um certificado digital qualificado, ou cartão com certificado digital (ex: Cartão do Cidadão necessita de registar um utilizador e poderá aceder a este serviço aqui:

Certificado Digital

6(D&/'ii-'[email protected]%&&#'+']"%+'"%&%"?+,+',%'!#"*+=',#'T#?%")#'+*"+?`&',#'@%"*(V(@+,#',%'+1*%)*(@+>3# © 2009 AMA - Agência para a Modernização Administrativa, IP

AICA

(/

G%"*(V(@+,#'0(D(*+=

'

\' G%"*(V(@+,#' 0(D(*+=' !%"5(*%' +' +&&()+*1"+' ,(D(*+=' ,%' ,#@15%)*#&' %' +' +1*%)*(@+>3#'

(.=/.&!!8ZRZ3#' ,#&' !"#N%@*#&R' )+' 5%,(,+' %5' I1%' %&*%&' !#,%"3#' &1B5%*%"' :' +!=(@+>3#'V(@C%("#&',(D(*+(&'+&&()+,#&',(D(*+=5%)*%R'+&&%D1"+),#'+'?+=(,+,%',+'$#)*%/ '

8' 8&&()+*1"+' 0(D(*+=' ,#' G+"*3#' ,%' G(,+,3#' +!"%&%)*+R' ,%&,%' =#D#R' +' ?+)*+D%5' ,%'

!#,%"'+B"+)D%"'*#,+'+'!#!1=+>3#'!#"*1D1%&+R')+'5%,(,+'%5' I1%'#',#@15%)*#' `'#B"(D+*J"(#9' +' &1+' 1*(=(K+>3#' "%I1%"R' @#)*1,#R' +=D15' @#)C%@(5%)*#' )+' #!%"+>3#' ,#' @#5!1*+,#"' %' %I1(!+5%)*#' %&!%@AV(@#' X' +'+I1(&(>3#',%'15',(&!#&(*(?#' ,%'=%(*1"+'Y,$#0'$#&Z'%'+'()&*+=+>3#' ,%'15+'+!=(@+>3#'()$#"5]*(@+'Y1("2'$#&Z'!+"+'D%&*3#',#'@+"*3#',%'@(,+,3#/ '

c*(=(K+),#' %&*%' 5%&5#' %I1(!+5%)*#R' `' +(),+' !#&&A?%=' +' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,#' G+"*3#' ,%'

G(,+,3#' !+"+' +1*%)*(@+>3#' ,#' 1*(=(K+,#"' %5' !=+*+$#"5+&' ()$#"5]*(@+&' )+' 5.2&#.&2R' %5' !+"*(@1=+"' +&' "%[email protected](#)+,+&' @#5' &%"?(>#&' !^B=(@#&9' @#)*1,#R' +' &1+' 1*(=(K+>3#' %5' +!=(@+>a%&' !"(?+,+&'!#,%"]'&%"'%[email protected](#)+,+R',%&,%'I1%'"%1)(,#&',%*%"5()+,#&'"%I1(&(*#&*Z!:(%6(.&.2&!&=&:2#N./:$!0(!:$#2F(!0&!:/0$0F(!/#X!6&#%/2/#!$(!#&16&:2/E(!2/2-=$#!$-2&.2/:$#g1&! 6&#$.2&! 1/12&%$1! /."(#%X2/:(1! &! 1&#E/T(1! /."(#%$2/Q$0(1! 0$! $0%/./12#$TF(! 6j7=/:$! &! 0&! &.2/0$0&1!6#/E$0$13#' ,#' G+"*3#' ,%' G(,+,3#' @#5#'

5%@+)(&5#' ,%'+1*%)*(@+>3#',#'1*(=(K+,#"'5+&R'@"%5#&R'+!%)+&' )+&'&(*1+>a%&' %5' I1%'&%'%L(N+' 15+'5+(#"'"%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%9',%'#1*"+'$#"5+'!#,%"]R'!%=+'"%=+*(?+'@#5!=%L(,+,%',#'!"#@%&&#R' +$+&*+"'#&'1*(=(K+,#"%&/

@DG

@DH

Dez indicadores para a AICA

Register

FIND AND DEVELOP OPEN SOURCE SOFTWARE

Find Software SourceForge.net >

Develop

Create Project

Blog

Site Support

Search

enter keyword

About

Log In

Log in

Log in with a SourceForge account

Log in with

OpenID

Enter your account info:

Please click your account provider:

Username: Password:

Remember Me ?

Remember Me ?

Log in

Log in

Forgot your username/password? Need an account on SourceForge.net? Create Account

Problems logging in with OpenID? OpenID eliminates the need for multiple usernames across different websites. Learn more - Get an OpenID

6(D&/'il-'.]D()+'()(@(+=',+'+!=(@+>3#'E&8.0"/&.G"R'@#5'!#&&(B(=(,+,%',%'3&G,!'?(+'@#)*+')#"5+='#1'?(+'I2"!-6

About SourceForge About SourceForge Contact Us Jobs @ Geeknet Advertising

Find Software Find Software Most Popular Overall Most Active Overall

Develop Software

Community

Create Project Project Help Wanted New Projects

The Blog @sourceforge on Twitter

Help Site Documentation Submit Support Requests Site Outages

© 2010 Geeknet, Inc. Terms of Use Privacy Policy

6(D&/'im-'E)[email protected](#',#'3&G,!*@#5'#'!"#?%,#"',%'I2"!-6'N&&G3"

6(D&/'in-'G#)V("5+>3#',#'!"#@%&&#',%'=#D()')+'+!=(@+>3#'E&8.0"/&.G"'+*"+?`&',#&',+,#&'()&%"(,#')#'!"#?%,#"',%'I2"!-6*N&&G3":

AICA

((/

\!%)E0

'

\' \!%)E0' ' Y\!%)E0' 6#1),+*(#)R' ejdjBZ' `' 15' 5%@+)(&5#' ,%' +1*%)*(@+>3#' ,%'

1*(=(K+,#"%&'"%@#""%),#'+'15+'^)(@+'@#)*+'\!%)E0'@"(+,+')15'6#(E&0(#!0&!V6&.5\9'+!J&'%&*%' "%D(&*#R' %&&+' @#)*+' !#,%"]' &%"' 1*(=(K+,+' !+"+' +1*%)*(@+"' #' 1*(=(K+,#"' )#&' S%B&(*%&' I1%' &1!#"*%5' %&&%' 5%@+)(&5#/' ' 15' 5%@+)(&5#' I1%' !"#@1"+' ,+"' "%&!#&*+R' !#"' 15' =+,#R' :' @#)&#=(,+>3#' ,+'(,%)*(,+,%' (.=/.&' ,#' 1*(=(K+,#"' %R' !#"'#1*"#R' +#' [email protected]*#' ,%=%'!%"*%)@%"' +' 15' )^5%"#'@+,+'?%K'5+(#"',%'"%,%&',(D(*+(&'X'@#5#'N]'"%$%"(5#&')+'"%?(&3#'=(*%"]"(+/ '

8&'?+)*+D%)&',#'\!%)E0'!+"+'#'1*(=(K+,#"'&3#''Y\!%)E0'6#1),+*(#)R'[email protected]

b'1&#',%'15'!+"'-1&#.$%&i6$11'(#0'!+"+'(,%)*(V(@+>3#'%5'5^=*(!=#&'S%B&(*%&9 b'+'6$11'(#0'&%"]'$#")%@(,+'+!%)+&'+'15+'%)*(,+,%'X'#'!"#?%,#"',%'\!%)E09 b',(&!#)(B(=(,+,%',+'*%@)#=#D(+-'#'\!%)E0'`'#$%"%@(,#'D"+*1(*+5%)*%'!#"'?]"(+&'%)*(,+,%&'%'#' )^5%"#',%'S%B&(*%&'I1%'&1!#"*+5'#'5%@+)(&5#'%)@#)*"+b&%'+'+15%)*+"9' b'*%@)#=#D(+' ,%[email protected]%)*"+=(K+,+'%' )3#' !"#!"(%*]"(+-'[email protected](=(,+,%'%5' 1*(=(K+"' #1'@"(+"'15' !"#?%,#"' ,%'\!%)E0'!"J!"(#djq/ '

\'$1)@(#)+5%)*#',#'5%@+)(&5#'`'&(5!=%&'%'@#)&(&*%R'%&&%)@(+=5%)*%R')+'()@=1&3#',%'

15'()*%"5%,(]"(#')#'!"#@%&&#',%'+1*%)*(@+>3#'X'(!6#(E&0(#!0&!V6&.5\b'#'1*(=(K+,#"'[email protected]%,%'+#'S%B&(*%'s8t'!"%!+"+,#'!+"+'+1*%)*(@+>3#'+*"+?`&',%'\!%)E09 b'#'1*(=(K+,#"'(),(@+'#'!"#?%,#"',%'\!%)E0'I1%',%&%N+'1*(=(K+"'X'#'S%B&(*%'syt9 b'#' 1*(=(K+,#"'`',("%@@(#)+,#'#' S%B&(*%'syt'I1%'=C%'("]'!%,("' #&',+,#&' ,%'[email protected]%&&#'Y-1&#.$%&i 6$11'(#099 b#' 1*(=(K+,#"' @#)V("5+' +' ()*%)>3#' ,%' &%' +1*%)*(@+"' )#' S%B&(*%' s8t' @#5' #&' ,+,#&' ,%' (,%)*(V(@+>3#',#'v%B&(*%'syt9 b#'1*(=(K+,#"'`'"%,("%@@(#)+,#'!+"+'#'S%B&(*%'s8t'%'+1*%)*(@+,#/ '

8'1*(=(K+>3#',#'\!%)E0')+'.=+*+$#"5+'0(D(*+='!#,%"]'$1)@(#)+"'@#5#'15'5%@+)(&5#'

!+"+' !"#5#?%"' %' +D(=(K+"' +' ()*%"[email protected]>3#' ,#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&-' %&*%&' )3#' !"%@(&+5' +&&(5' ,%' @"(+"' 15+')#?+'@#)*+R'5+&'!#,%5' 1*(=(K+"'15+'@#)*+'\!%)E0'G-&!OX!6(11-$%/'H'`'+I1('I1%' "%&(,%' 15+'!+"*(@1=+"(,+,%'(5!#"*+)*%',%&*+'*%@)#=#D(+-'I1%5'N]'1*(=(K+' ,%*%"5()+,#&'&%"?(>#&')+'

djq ' 7#*%b&%R' )#' %)*+)*#R' I1%' !+"+' D+"+)*("'+' @"%,(B(=(,+,%' ,%' 15'\!%)E0' `' )%@%&&]"(#R' %5' !"(5%("#' =1D+"R' @#)V(+)>+' )#' &%1' !"#?%,#"/

@DI

@D<

Dez indicadores para a AICA

&tS%B'N]'*%5R'!"#?+?%=5%)*%R'15+'\!%)E0'+&&#@(+,+':'&1+'@#)*+/'G#5' %$%(*#R'%5!"%&+&'@#5#' +' T##D=%R' +' w+C##R' #' 6=(@Q"R' #' ;[email protected]%R' #' [email protected]%B##QR' #' v#",!"%&&R' +' p%"(&(D)' %'+' 8\2' N]' &%' %)@#)*"+5' +' 1*(=(K+"' +' \!%)E0' ' Y\!%)E0' 6#1),+*(#)R' ejdj+ZR' #' I1%' &(D)(V(@+' I1%' 15' 1*(=(K+,#"' I1%R' !#"' %L%5!=#R' 1*(=(K%' #' &%"?(>#' ,%' %5+(=' ,+' T##D=%R' !#,%' %$%@*1+"' +' &1+' +1*%)*(@+>3#'%5'I1+=I1%"'&(*%'I1%'&1!#"*%'\!%)E0'@#5'#&',+,#&',%&&+'@#)*+/ '

7#*%b&%R'@#)*1,#R'I1%'#'\!%)E0'`' 15'5%@+)(&5#',(&*()*#' ,+'8&&()+*1"+'0(D(*+=9'%=%'

&%"?%'!+"+'+1*%)*(@+"'#'1*(=(K+,#"')15'&(&*%5+R'+#'!+&&#'I1%'+'8&&()+*1"+'0(D(*+='&%"?%'!+"+' +*%&*+"' +' +1*#"(+' ,%' ,#@15%)*#&' ,(D(*+(&/' 8&&(5R' #' \!%)E0' !#,%"]' $1)@(#)+"' @#5#' 15' ()*%"%&&+)*%' 5%@+)(&5#' ,%' +1*%)*(@+>3#' !+"+' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' I1%' !"%*%),+5' [email protected]%,%"' +' ]"%+&' 5+(&' "%&*"(*+&' #1'%,(*+"' @#)*%^,#&' Y!#"' %L%5!=#R'?(&1+=(K+"' @#)*%^,#&' ,%'15' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' #1' @#5%)*+"' +&' !"#!#&*+&' +!"%&%)*+,+&ZR' 5+&' )3#' !#,%"]' $1)@(#)+"' @#5#' 5%@+)(&5#'',%'?+=(,+>3#',%',#@15%)*#&'Y!#"'%L%5!=#R'!+"+'&1B5%*%"'!"#!#&*+&'+'G#)@1"&#' &#B'$#"5+',%'V(@C%("#&',(D(*+(&'s+&&()+,#&t/

AICA

[email protected]"

,$.$,%#$#("#("(201/0/1$)*+"#(",%1,/%0+2"#$"%&E+1-$)*+

'

8'!+=+?"+'()D=%&+''(#)P=(''&%"?%'!+"+',%&(D)+"'15'@#)N1)*#',%'!+&&#&'#1'!"#@%&&#&'

%=%5%)*+"%&' @#5' ?(&*+' :' @#)@"%*(K+>3#' ,%' 15' !"#@%&&#' 5+(#"/' .#,%5#&' %&*+B%=%@%"' 15' !+"+=%=#' @#5' +' )#>3#' ,%' +=D#"(*5#' %' @#5' +' 5]I1()+' ,%' O1"()D' I1%' "%$%"(5#&' )+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+/' 7+' 5]I1()+' ,%' O1"()DR' @#5#' )+' 8EG8R' +' $#"5+=(K+>3#' ,#' !"#@%&&#' %' &1+' ,%@#5!#&(>3#' %5' &1B!"#@%&&#&' `'$1),+5%)*+=' !+"+'+'"%&#=1>3#' ,#' !"#B=%5+'X'#' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+-' `' )%@%&&]"(#' ,%V()("' #&' !+&&#&' %=%5%)*+"%&R' I1+(&' #&' %=%5%)*#&' I1%' &3#' 5+)(!1=+,#&' %5' @+,+' 15' ,%=%&R' %' I1%5' #&' 5+)(!1=+/' .#,%5#&R' !#"' %L%5!=#R' ,%V()("' I1%' !+"+'+'@#)@"%*(K+>3#',#'!"#@%&&#'!"()@(!+='X'+'"%+=(K+>3#',%'15'@#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+'!#"' ?(+' ,(D(*+=' X' &3#' )%@%&&]"(#&' ,%*%"5()+,#&' &1B!"#@%&&#&' Y#' "%D(&*#' ,#' @#)@#""%)*%R' +' +!"#?+>3#',#'@#)@#""%)*%R'#',%[email protected]+""%D+5%)*#',%'5+*%"(+='B+&%R'#'%[email protected]=+"%@(5%)*#',%',^?(,+&R' +' &1B5(&&3#' ,+&' !"#!#&*+&///Z/' 8' ,%V()(>3#' ,%&*%' '(#)P=('' `R' !#"*+)*#R' %&&%)@(+=' !+"+' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+'8EG8R' %'%)@#)*"+b&%'()*"()&%@+5%)*%'=(D+,#' +#&' D"1!#&',%'1*(=(K+,#"%&' ,+'+!=(@+>3#'%':&'&1+&'!%"5(&&a%&/

@DB

@EC

Dez indicadores para a AICA

6(D&/'iq-'H=%5%)*#&'@#)&*(*1()*%&',#'@("@1(*#',%'()$#"5+>3#',+'+!=(@+>3#'.=#)%:

6(D&/'lj-'HL%5!=#',%'+!=(@+>3#'!"]*(@+')+'8EG8/

AICA

(/

.=#)%'G;W

'

\'.=#)%'`'15'G;W'I1%'&%'+!"%&%)*+'@#5#'15'&(&*%5+',%'D%&*3#',%'@#)*%^,#&'#)=()%'

%&!%@(+=5%)*%' ?#@[email protected](#)+,#' !+"+' #' *%@(,#' %5!"%&+"(+=9' ()&*(*1(>a%&' @#5#' +' 7+&+R' #' %y+PR' +' c)(?%"&(,+,%',%'c*+C'%'#'T#?%")#' ,+'7#?+'Ü%=_),(+R'%)*"%'#1*"#&R'1*(=(K+5'#' .=#)%',%?(,#':&' &1+&' @+"[email protected]*%"A&*(@+&' ,%'&%D1"+)>+R'%[email protected]+=+B(=(,+,%'%'[email protected]%&&(B(=(,+,%R' %)*"%'#1*"+&' 'YOC%' .=#)%' 6#1),+*(#)R' ejdjZ/' H&*%' ,%&%5!%)C#' `' %5' !+"*%' ,%?(,#' :' =()D1+D%5' ,%' !"#D"+5+>3#' 1*(=(K+,+' X' #' .P*C#)' X' I1%' +!"%&%)*+' +&' "%$%"(,+&' ?+)*+D%)&' &#B"%' #1*"+&' =()D1+D%)&' 5+(&' @#51)&R'@#5#'#'.C!/ '

\'.=#)%'()*%"%&&+b)#&' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%'!%=+' &1+'D%&*3#' ,#&':/#:-/2(1!0$! /."(#%$TF(9'

*%),#' %5' @#)*+' #&' ?+=#"%&' ,+' @#=+B#"+>3#' %' !+"*(@(!+>3#' I1%' %L!"%&&+5#&' )+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+R' $+K' &%)*(,#' I1%' )+' 8EG8' +' ()$#"5+>3#' @("@1=%' !%=#&' ?]"(#&' ()*%"?%)(%)*%&' )#' !"#@%&&#R' !#,%),#' &%"' &1N%(*+' +' +=*%"+>a%&R' &%"' +!"#?+,+' #1' "%!"#?+,+R' &%"' ,%?#=?(,+' +#' "%5%*%)*%R'%*@/''!+"+'"%&!#),%"'+'%&*%'!"#B=%5+'I1%'`')%@%&&]"(+'+',%V()(>3#',%'15'@("@1(*#' ,+'()$#"5+>3#R'@("@1(*#'%&&%'I1%'!#,%"]'&%"',($%"%)*%',%'G#)@1"&#'!+"+'G#)@1"&#/ '

\' .=#)%' D%"%' #&' @("@1(*#&' ,+' ()$#"5+>3#' @#5' B+&%R' %&&%)@(+=5%)*%R' )#&' &%D1()*%&'

%=%5%)*#&-' #' #BN%@*#' YI1%' @#)*`5' +' ()$#"5+>3#ZR' #' %&*+,#' Y,%V()%' @#),(>a%&' ,%' [email protected]%&&#' %' 5+)(!1=+>3#' ,+' ()$#"5+>3#ZR' #' 1*(=(K+,#"' Y+#' I1+=' `' +&&#@(+,#' 15' 6$6&=a%&'Y"%D"+&' !+"+' +=*%"+>3#',#'%&*+,#',#&'#BN%@*#&Z/ '

\',(+D"+5+'+#'=+,#'@#)*`5'15'%L%5!=#R'%=+B#"+,#'!#"')J&'%'+,%I1+,#' +#' @#)*%L*#'

,#' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' I1%' +N1,+"]' +' @=+"(V(@+"' %&*%&' @#)@%(*#&-'#' -2/=/Q$0(#' sG=(%)*%t' @"(+' 15+' !"(5%("+' ?%"&3#' ,#' !"#D"+5+' !"%=(5()+"' ,%' 15' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' Y#' (7O&:2(Z' %'@#)$%"%b=C%'#' &12$0(' s."(?+,#t' Y+!%)+&' %&*%' 1*(=(K+,#"' *%5' [email protected]%&&#Z9' I1+),#' %&*]' !"#)*#' !+"+' "%?(&3#R' #' 1*(=(K+,#"' [email protected]*(?+' 15+' 2#$.1/TF(' %' 51,+' #' (7O&:2(! !+"+' #' &12$0(' s.^B=(@#tR' !+&&+),#' %&*%' +' &%"' [email protected]%&&A?%=' +#' -2/=/Q$0(#' Y#1' D"1!#' ,%' 1*(=(K+,#"%&Z' s.^B=(@#t9' %&*%' "%?M'#' ,#@15%)*#' %R' @+&#' )3#' %L(&*+' )%)C15+' ()@#5!+*(B(=(,+,%R' [email protected]*(?+' +' 2#$.1/TF(' %' 5#?%' #' (7O&:2(!!+"+' #' &12$0(' s0"+$*tR'[email protected]%&&A?%=' +#' -2/=/Q$0(#! sT%&*#"' ,#' G#)@1"&#' )+' 8EG8tR' I1%'+!J&'*"+*+5%)*#' ()*%")#' ,%&&%'(7O&:2(' Y!#"'%L%5!=#R' )#"5+=(K+>3#',#'@#)*%^,#Z'[email protected]*(?+' )#?+' 2#$.1/TF(! %' 5#?%' #' (7O&:2(' !+"+' #' &12$0(! s6()+=t9' +' *"+)&(>3#' V()+=' @#)&*(*1("(+' )+' !+&&+D%5' ,%&&%' (7O&:2('!+"+'#' &12$0('s.1B=(@+,#tR' #' I1+=' %&*+"(+'[email protected]%&&A?%=')+'8EG8' !+"+'#&' -2/=/Q$0(#&1',#'D"1!#'s8"I1(*%@*#&t/

@[email protected]

@ED

Dez indicadores para a AICA

6(D&/'ld-'G("@1(*#',%'()$#"5+>3#',%'15'G#)@1"&#',%'8"I1(*%@*1"+

AICA

((/

;[email protected]#=5'4%+,()D'G#)&1=*+)*&

' '

8' ;[email protected]#=5' 4%+,()D' G#)&1=*+)*&' ' Y;[email protected]#=5' 4%+,()D' G#)&1=*+)*&' 2(5(*%,R' ejdjZR'

%5!"%&+' ,%' @#)&1=*#"(+' "%&!#)&]?%=' !%=+' !"#5#>3#' %' [email protected]#5!+)C+5%)*#' ,%' !"#@%&&#&' ,%' @#)@1"&#&',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+')#'4%()#'c)(,#R',%V()(1'#'@("@1(*#',%'()$#"5+>3#')15'@#)@1"&#',%' +"I1(*%@*1"+R'#'I1+='+!"%&%)*+5#&'@#5#'"%$%"M)@(+/ '

G#)*%5!=+R'%&&%)@(+=5%)*%R'+&'&%D1()*%&'$+&%&''Y4%+,()DR'ejjqZ-

b',%V()(>3#',#'_5B(*#'%'"%I1(&(*#&',#'G#)@1" b',(?1=D+>3#',#'G#)@1" b'%)*"%?(&*+'!"%=(5()+"'+'@+),(,+*#&9 b'%)*"%D+',%',#@15%)*+>3#'+'@+),(,+*#&'&%=%@@(#)+,#&9 b'%)*"%?(&*+&'+,(@(#)+(&'o'?(&(*+'+#&'=1D+"%&9 b'%)*"%D+',+&'!"#!#&*+&'+'G#)@1" b'?(&(#)+5%)*#',+&'!"#!#&*+&'%)*"%D1%&9 b'+?+=(+>3#',+&'!"#!#&*+&'%'&%=%@>3#',%'?%)@%,#"9 b',(?1=D+>3#',+'!"#!#&*+'?%)@%,#"+/ '

8#' @#)*"]"(#' ,+' $#)*%' +)*%"(#"R' %&*+' +!"%&%)*+b)#&' 15+' ?(&3#' 5+(&' %&!%@AV(@+' %'

,("%@@(#)+,+'+#'5%"@+,#'I1%')#&' ()*%"%&&+/'7#'%)*+)*#R'@#5#'N]'&%'?(1')#1*"#&' (),(@+,#"%&R' @"%5#&')%@%&&]"(+'+'+!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%'$#)*%&' I1%'+B#",%5' #&'!"#B=%5+&'I1%"',%'$#"5+'5+(&' D%)`"(@+R'I1%"',%'$#"5+'5+(&'%&!%@AV(@+/

@EE

@EF

Dez indicadores para a AICA

6(D/'le-'6=1L#D"+5+',#'G#)@1"&#',%'G#)@%!>3#

AICA

(((/

E7GE

'

\'@#)@1"&#',%'@#)@%!>3#'`'15+'5#,+=(,+,%',#'@#)@1"&#'!^B=(@#9'@#5#'N]'"%$%"(5#&'

)+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+R' %&*+' `' 15+' 5#,+=(,+,%' I1%' )#&' ()*%"%&&+' !#"' ,#(&' 5#*(?#&-' +' &1+' +,%I1+>3#' +#' 5%"@+,#' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %' #' &%1' @+"]@*%"' ,%' +B%"*1"+' :' !+"*(@(!+>3#' Y!"%&&1!a%'#'*"+B+=C#'@#)N1)*#',%'?]"(+&'%)*(,+,%&'@#5'?(&*+':'%=+B#"+>3#',#'!"#N%@*#Z/ '

8&&(5R'+!"%&%)*+5#&'#'V=1L#D"+5+',#'@#)@1"&#',%'@#)@%!>3#''YE7GER'ejjnBZ'I1%')3#'

"%!"%&%)*+' 5+(&' ,#' I1%' 15' @("@1(*#' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#' @#5' ?(&*+' :' %&*"1*1"+>3#' ,%' *#,#' #' !"#@%&&#/ '

\' !"#@%&&#' N]' $#(' ,%[email protected]"(*#' )+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+R' 5+&' %$%@*1+5#&' +I1(' 15+' B"%?%'

&A)*%&%',+&'&1+&'$+&%&b'+)^)@(#',#'G#)@1"&#'%5'04'%')#'3#',+'@[email protected](,+,%'*`@)(@+'%'@#)?(*%':'!+"*(@(!+>3#')#'G#)@1" b'+!"%&%)*+>3#',+&'!"#!#&*+&9 b'+!"%@(+>3#',+&'!"#!#&*+&'%'"%=+*J"(#'V()+=9 b'+)^)@(#',%'?%)@%,#"'%'!"%5(+>3#9 b'+!"%&%)*+>3#',%',#@15%)*#&',%'C+B(=(*+>3#/

@EG

@EH

Dez indicadores para a AICA

6"!"!"$5)[email protected]$(-5)+A&')

H8"

,$.$,%#$#("#(".(12+&$>%C$)*+"#$"%&0(1E$,(

'

H&*%' (),(@+,#"' "%?%=+' 15+' %&*"+*`D(+' ,%' +!"#L(5+>3#' ,#' 1*(=(K+,#"' :' +!=(@+>3#R'

!%"5(*(),#' +' %&*%' 5#=,+"' +' $#"5+' @#5#' %=+' &%' =C%' +!"%&%)*+9' +#' @#)$%"("' +#' 1*(=(K+,#"' +' C(!J*%&%',%'!%"&#)+=(K+"'#' ()*%"[email protected]%' %&*+5#&' +'@#)*"(B1("' !+"+'I1%'%&*%' &%'(,%)*(V(I1%' 5+(&' @#5'+'+!=(@+>3#R'!"#N%@*+),#b&%')%=+R'%'!+"+'+15%)*+"'+'&1+'[email protected](=(,+,%',%'#!%"+>3#'!#"'!+"*%' ,#' 1*(=(K+,#"9' "%@#",%b&%' +' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+' %5' *#")#' ,+' rf5! c! ;#$6,/:$=! -1&#! /.2&#"$:&! X' @"(+,+'!"%@(&+5%)*%'!+"+'!%"5(*("'15+'5%=C#"',%5#@"+*(K+>3#',#'1&#',#'@#5!1*+,#"/ '

8' %"+',+'e&7! J4K! !#,%' &%"' ,%V()(,+' @#5#' 15' 5#5%)*#' %5' I1%' #&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' &%'

*#")+"+5R' ,%' 15+'$#"5+'$"+)@+' %' [email protected]%&&A?%=R' @+!+K%&' ,%'@"(+"' #&' &%1&' @#)*%^,#&' %' ()*%"+D("' @#5'#&'@#)*%^,#&'@"(+,#&'!#"'#1*"#&'1*(=(K+,#"%&/ ' '

'

'

z#N%'#'1*(=(K+,#"'*+5B`5'@"(+'+'&1+'!"J!"(+'+!=(@+>3#/

AICA

(/

81*#,%&Q'81*#@+,

'

\'81*#@+,'`'15+'+!=(@+>3#',%',%&%)C#'+&&(&*(,#'!#"'@#5!1*+,#"R'1*(=(K+,+'%5'?]"(+&'

]"%+&' !"#V(&&(#)+(&' Y%)*"%' +&' I1+(&' +' +"I1(*%@*1"+Z' @1N+' #!%"+>3#' "%I1%"' @#)C%@(5%)*#&' *`@)(@#&'%&!%@AV(@#&/'8')+*1"%K+',+'*+"%$+'%'+'@"%[email protected]%)*%'@#5!=%L(,+,%',+'I5a%&'@+,+'?%K'5+(&'@#5!=%L+&'%'%5'5+(#"')^5%"#/ '

H&*+&'+!=(@+>a%&'*#")+5b&%'+&&(5'@+,+'?%K'5+(&'@#5!=%L+&',%'#!%"+"'%'&1"D%'+&&(5'+'

)%@%&&(,+,%',%'&(5!=(V(@+"'#'/.2&#"$:&!,#'1*(=(K+,#"/ '

\' Z-2(:$0! U(.2&`2-$=! ]/77(.' `' 15+' B+""+' ,%' $%""+5%)*+&' C#"(K#)*+=' I1%' !"#@1"+'

%L(B("'+!%)+&'+&' $%""+5%)*+&' )%@%&&]"(+&':'%L%@1>3#',%' 15+' *+"%$+' !#"' !+"*%' ,#' 1*(=(K+,#"9' +&&(5R'&%'#'1*(=(K+,#"'&%=%@@(#)+'+'#!>3#'s%[email protected]"%?%"'*%L*#tR'%&*%'#/77(.! ,%?#=?%'+&'$%""+5%)*+&' "%[email protected](#)+,+&' @#5' +'%,(>3#' ,%' *%L*#' %' #@1=*+' +&' "%&*+)*%&/' H&*+' !%"&#)+=(K+>3#' ,#' /.2&#"$:&' #@#""%'+'15'!"(5%("#')A?%=R'%',%'$#"5+'@#5!=%*+5%)*%'*"+)&!+"%)*%'!+"+'#'1*(=(K+,#"/ '

8'15' &%D1),#')A?%='`'!#&&A?%='!%"&#)+=(K+"'#'@#5!#"*+5%)*#',#'#/77(.R'%[email protected]#=C%),#'

I1%'$%""+5%)*+&'#'1*(=(K+,#"',%&%N+'?%"' )#' %@"3'I1+),#' &%=%@@(#)+'15' *%L*#R'15+'=()C+R'%*@/' B%5'@#5#'"%5#?%"'sB=#@#&t',%'$%""+5%)*+&',#'#/77((.'%'#",%)]b=#&')#'%@"3',%'[email protected]#",#'@#5'+' ?#)*+,%',#'1*(=(K+,#"/

6(D/'lg-'-!$"./(0"*,+'+!=(@+>3#'81*#G80

@EI

@E<

Dez indicadores para a AICA

((/

(T##D=%

'

\' (T##D=%' `' 15+' !]D()+' )+' e(#=0e/0&e&7' @1N+' V()+=(,+,%' `' $1)@(#)+"' @#5#' 15+'

,(%&6$;&' @+!+K' ,%' "%1)("R' ,%' 15+' $#"5+' @%)*"+=(K+,+R' @#)*%^,#&' !%"&#)+=(K+,#&' !%=#' 1*(=(K+,#"/ '

G#5#' ?(5#&')+'"%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+R'#'(),(?A,1#' ,+'I5' '!%"*%)@%'+'15' )^5%"#' @+,+'?%K'

5+(#"' ,%'"%,%&' ,(D(*+(&R' 1*(=(K+' 15' )^5%"#' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(#"' ,%' &%"?(>#&' (.=/.&! X'#' %5+(=R' #' @C+*R'$J"1)&R',(%&7$.)/.Da%&'I1%'#'(),(?A,1#' ,+'I5' '1*(=(K+9'@+,+'+!=(@+>3#'!#,%'&%"' Web Imagens Vídeos Mapas Notícias Livros Gmail mais ! [email protected] | Página inicial clássica | De +,(@(#)+,+'#1'"%5#?(,+'@#)&#+)*%'+'?#)*+,%',#'1*(=(K+,#"R'%'+'&1+'!#&(>3#' )#'%@"3'*+5B`5'`' « Regressar à página inicial do iGoogle

!%"&#)+=(K]?%=/ Miniaplicações Ordenar por » Mais quente Maioria dos utilizadores Mais recente

Adicioná-lo agora

Temas Meteorologia

Por

Veja a previsão meteorológica de várias localidades na sua página.

77.847.357 utilizadores

http://www.google."com/

Pesquisar miniaplicaçõ

Pro

2971 classificações

Saiba mais sobre o iGo

Limitar por idioma » Todos os idiomas

Google Notícias

Por

Fazer do iGoogle a sua pá

Português (Portugal)

Miniaplicação de notícias personalizável que mostra secções de notícias diferentes em vários separadores.

53.563.334 utilizadores

Para programadores (em in

262 classificações

Para proprietários de feeds

Restringir por categoria » Todas as categorias

Adicioná-lo agora

http://www.google."com/

Notícias Ferramentas Comunicação Diversão e jogos Finanças Desporto

Adicioná-lo agora

Google Tradutor

Por

A miniaplicação Google Translation pode efectuar a tradução entre os idiomas mais comuns no mundo

25.865.003 utilizadores 244 classificações

http://www.google."com/

Estilo de vida Tecnologia

6(D/'lh-'2(&*+D%5',%'%L*%)&a%&'!+"+'+'+!=(@+>3#',N&&G3"*

abola.pt - últimas Desporto abola.pt - A BOLA on-line (últimas Desporto) - RSS 2.0

Adicionar feed ou miniaplicação

http://www.abola.pt/

De abola.pt 30.697 utilizadores 0 classificações

Adicioná-lo agora

Publico.pt - Geral Últimas 10 notícias do canal "Geral" do PUBLICO.PT http://www.publico."clix.pt/

De publico.cli... 43.471 utilizadores 3 classificações

Adicioná-lo agora

Previsão do Tempo

Por Joaquim Pereira

Previsão do tempo para 33.259 utilizadores 6(D/'li-'.]D()+'()(@(+=',+'+!=(@+>3#',N&&G3"'%?(,%)@(+),#'#'@+"]@*%"'!%"&#)+=(K]?%=',+'()*%"[email protected]%' Portugal. Previsão para 3 dias, com base na informação do 43 classificações Instituto de Meteorologia. Adicioná-lo agora http://home.joaquim."org/

AICA

HD"

E$,%>%#$#("#(",+-.1((&2*+"#$"%&0(1E$,("

'

c5+' ()*%"[email protected]%R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' +' ,%' 15+' +!=(@+>3#' '&7g7$1&0R' ,%?%' *%"'

,%*%"5()+,+&' @+"[email protected]*%"A&*(@+&' ,%' $#"5+' +' !%"5(*("' 15+' =%(*1"+' @=+"+' ,#&' @#)*%^,#&' %' 15+' )+?%D+>3#'%V(@+K'!%=+&',(?%"&+&']"%+&'I1%'@#5!a%5'+'+!=(@+>3#/'')%@%&&]"(+'15+'C(%"+"I1(+' ?(&1+='%)*"%'#&'?]"(#&'%=%5%)*#&'Y(/%/R'!%"5(*(),#'+#'1*(=(K+,#"'&%"'@+!+K',%'!%"@%B%"'"$%H=/$1' %'+',($%"%)>+'%)*"%'%=%5%)*#&'!"()@(!+(&o&%@1),]"(#&Z'%'15+'"%=+>3#'@1(,+,+'%)*"%'#' %&!+>#' @C%(#o?+K(#'Y!+"+')3#'!"#5#?%"')%5'#'%[email protected]%&&#R')%5'+'$+=*+',%'()$#"5+>3#Z/ '

H&*%'(),(@+,#"'!"#@1"+"]'(,%)*(V(@+"'!+,"a%&',%',(&*"(B1(>3#',#&'@#)*%^,#&')#'%@"3'%'

&1+'"%=+>3#'@#5'+'[email protected]>3#'%&!%"+,+'!#"'!+"*%',#'1*(=(K+,#"/

@EB

@FC

Dez indicadores para a AICA

(/

v#",!"%&&

'

\'v#",!"%&&' `R' @#5#' N]' ?(&*#R' 15' URI! ,("%@@(#)+,#' !+"+' #' 5%"@+,#' ,#&' 7=(;1' )+'

vvvh!=#@+(&' #),%' +1*#"%&' @#=#@+5' "%D1=+"5%)*%' @#)*%^,#&R' #$%"%@%),#' 15+' !=+*+$#"5+' !+"+'%&*%&'&%"%5'@#5%)*+,#&'%R'+&&(5R'!"#5#?%"'+'()*%"[email protected]>3#/ '

73#' )#&' ()*%"%&&+' #' +5B(%)*%' ,#' "#(.2g&.0' ,+' +!=(@+>3#' 5+&' &(5' +' &1+' ]"%+'

+,5()(&*"+*(?+R' #),%'%)@#)*"+5#&'15' /.2&#"$:&'&(5!=%&' %'@#5'15' #BN%@*(?#' @=+"#-'!%"5(*("' +#' !"#!"(%*]"(#' ,#' 7=(;'D%"("'#&' &%1&' @#)*%^,#&' %'$1)@(#)+=(,+,%&R'I1%')%@%&&+"(+5%)*%' &%' %)@#)*"+5',(&!%"&+&'!#"'?]"(#&'5J,1=#&R'&%5'!%",%"'+'(,%(+',#'*#,#/ '

8&&(5R' #' ()*%"[email protected]%' +,5()(&*"+*(?#' ,#' v#",!"%&&' `' @#)&*(*1A,#R' %&&%)@(+=5%)*%R' !#"'

15+'B+""+'=+*%"+=R'?%"*(@+=R'@#5!#&*+'!#"'=()Q&',#&'?]"(#&'5J,1=#&'I1%'@#5!a%5'+'+!=(@+>3#R' %'15+']"%+'@%)*"+=',%'@#)*%^,#&R'@1N#' @#)*%^,#'?+"(+'%5' $1)>3#',#' 5J,1=#'&%=%@@(#)+,#/'\' @+"]@*%"'&()*`*(@#',#&' =()Q&',+'B+""+'=+*%"+='!%"5(*%R'+&&(5R',(&!#)(B(=(K+"'5+(&'%&!+>#'!+"+'+' ]"%+'!"()@(!+=',+'+!=(@+>3#/

Editar Posts ‹ Bruno Moreira – Art and Technology. — WordPress

Bruno Moreira – Art and Technology… Painel

Posts Editar Novo Post

Novo Post

Ver o Site

Olá, Bruno Moreira | Turbo | Terminar Sessão Opções Deste Écran

WordPress 3.0.1 está disponível! Por favor notifique o administrador deste site.

Editar Posts

Novo Post Pesquisar Posts

Tudo (10) | Publicados (10) | Lixo (1) Edição em Massa

Ajuda

Ver todas as categorias

Filtro

Post

Aplicar Autor

Ver todas as datas Categorias

Tags

Idiomas

Desenho – arquitectura 1

Bruno Moreira

Arquitectura,

chaves, church,

Português, English

Desenhos

história, history,

4

igreja, matriz,

Publicado

Tags do Post Categorias

Media Biblioteca Novo Ficheiro

Links Editar

Desenho – figura humana 1

Bruno Moreira

Desenhos, Figura

desenho, drawing,

Humana

figura, figure,

9

human, humano,

Português, English

Publicado

0

2010/07/2

lápis, pencil

Categorias de Links

Páginas

2010/08/2

portugal

Novo Link

Editar

Data 2

19º Concurso Ibérico “Soluções para Construção PLADUR”

Bruno Moreira

Arquitectura,

pladur, porto,

Concursos

reconversão,

8

renovação,

Português

Publicado

1

2010/07/0

renovation, ruína

Nova Página

Comentários

Perfil

Concurso de Fotografia FAUP 2008

Bruno Moreira

Arquitectura,

composição,

Fotografia

composition,

8

escada, escultura,

Publicado

Opções

0

2010/06/2

função, function,

Ferramentas

WP-ZoomImage

Português, English

sculpture, stair

Concurso de Renderização “Indigo”

Bruno Moreira

Porto Water Tanks

Bruno Moreira

Concursos,

competition,

Rendering 3D

concurso, indigo,

5

olympus, render

Português, English

Publicado

0

2010/06/2

Contact Português English

20º Concurso Ibérico “Soluções para Construção PLADUR”

Bruno Moreira

Software de Rendering “Thea Render”

Bruno Moreira

Feed do Twitter

Bruno Moreira

Arquitectura,

água, competition,

Concursos

concurso, porto,

5

water

Português

Publicado

0

2010/06/2

Arquitectura,

competition, Português 2010/06/2 0 6(D/'ll-'-!$"./(0"'+,5()(&*"+*(?#',+'+!=(@+>3#'A&.)2."@@ Concursos concurso, pladur 3 Publicado

Software,

3d, kerkythea,

Tecnologia

rendering, thea

English

2

2010/06/2 3 Publicado

Notícias, Notícias

communication,

do Site

comunicação,

1

integração,

Português, English

Publicado

0

2010/06/2

integration, network, rede, twitter

Um novo sítio web

Bruno Moreira

Notícias, Notícias

abertura, analytics,

do Site

change, mudança,

Português, English

6

openness,

Publicado

0

2010/06/1

renovação,

renovation 6(D/'lm-'-!$"./(0"'+,5()(&*"+*(?#',+'+!=(@+>3#'A&.)2."@@*O*"@P8"'( Post Edição em Massa

Autor

Categorias

Tags

Idiomas

Data

Aplicar

Obrigado por criar com o WordPress | Documentação | Feedback

Versão 2.9.2

AICA

((/

W%)*%

'

W%)*%'`'+'+!=(@+>3#' ,%'D%&*3#' B(B=(#D"]V(@+'1*(=(K+,+')%&*+' 0(&&%"*+>3#R' @#)$#"5%' N]'

$#('%L!=(@(*+,#'%5'%W2(0(/'8'+!=(@+>3#'$#")%@%'?]"(#&'()*%"[email protected]%&'!+"+'D%&*3#' ,+&'"%$%"M)@(+&R' %)*"%'#&'I1+(&'#'I1%'+!"%&%)*+5#&'+#'=+,#'X'+')+?%D+>3#'!"#D"%&&(?+'!#"'@#=1)+&/ '

H&*+' /.2&#"$:&' !%"5(*%' 15+' V(=*"+D%5' !"#D"%&&(?+' ,#&' "%&1=*+,#&' %' +' &1+'

+!"%&%)*+>3#' (5%,(+*+' )+' ]"%+' @%)*"+=' ,%' @#)*%^,#&/' 7#' %L%5!=#' +#' =+,#' $#(' &#=(@(*+,#' :' +!=(@+>3#'I1%'%L(B(&&%R'!"(5%("#R'*#,#&' #&'"%D(&*#&'B(B=(#D"]V(@#&'@#5',+*+',%'!1B=(@+>3#',%' ejdj-' +' ]"%+'@%)*"+=' ,%' @#)*%^,#&' $#(' [email protected]*1+=(K+,+' +1*#5+*(@+5%)*%' ,%' $#"5+' +'+!"%&%)*+"' +!%)+&' +&' "%$%"M)@(+&' I1%' @15!"(&&%5' #' "%I1(&(*#/' \1*"#&' V(=*"#&' $#"+5' &%),#R' &%I1%)@(+=5%)*%R'+!=(@+,#&/ '

H&*%' *(!#' ,%'()*%"[email protected]%'!#,%"(+' &%"'^*(='!+"+' ,%*%"5()+,+&' $1)@(#)+=(,+,%&' ,+'8EG8R'

@#5#'!#"'%L%5!=#'+'!%&I1(&+',%'@#)@1"&#&9'#' 1*(=(K+,#"'!#,%"(+'("'&#=(@(*+),#' :'+!=(@+>3#'+' =(&*+D%5',%'@#)@1"&#&'I1%'@#""%&!#),%&&%'+',%*%"5()+,#&'"%I1(&(*#&'[email protected]#)@1"&#&'+',%@#""%"' %5' *%""(*J"(#' )[email protected](#)+=R' &%5' @1&*#&' ,%' ()[email protected]"(>3#R' @#5' %)*"%D+' %5' !"+K#' &1!%"(#"' +'`'5%&%&R' %*@/Z/

6(D/'ln-'-!$"./(0"',+'+!=(@+>3#'E"!$"

6(D/'lq-'-!$"./(0"',+'+!=(@+>3#'E"!$"*O*"@P8"'(

@[email protected]

@FD

Dez indicadores para a AICA

(((/

%p#=#

'

\'%p#=#' ' YH?#=#R' 22GR' ejdjZ' `' 15+' !=+*+$#"5+' #)=()%' ,%' ,(?1=D+>3#' ,%' @#)*%^,#&'

"%[email protected](#)+,#&' @#5' +' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %' #' ,%&(D)9' &3#' +(),+' "%&!#)&]?%(&' !#"' 15+' !1B=(@+>3#' +)+=JD(@+' X'+'%p#=#' 5+D+K()%' X' %'!%=+'#"D+)(K+>3#' +)1+=',%'15' @#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+'X' %p#=#'[email protected]"+!%"'G#5!%*(*(#)/ '

8'!=+*+$#"5+'#)=()%'X'5+(&'!"%@(&+5%)*%'#' &%1'/.2&#"$:&!X'`'I1%')#&' (5!#"*+'"%+=>+"'

)%&*%'5#5%)*#/' 8#' @#)*"]"(#' ,#&'%L%5!=#&' +)*%"(#"%&R'#),%'[email protected]+B+?+' !#"' C+?%"' &%5!"%'15' &%)*(,#' ,%' C(%"+"I1(+R'+'%p#=#' +!"%&%)*+b)#&' 15+' %&*"+*`D(+'%5'I1%'#' @#)*%^,#' !"()@(!+='`' ,(&*"(B1A,#' !#"' *"M&'$+(L+&' C#"(K#)*+(&R' @#""%&!#),%)*%&' :&' )#*[email protected](+&R':'"%?(&*+'+)+=JD(@+'%' +#' G#)@1"&#/' \'^)(@#' &%)*(,#' ,%'C(%"+"I1(+' `' ,+,#' !%=+'*"+,(>3#' #@(,%)*+=' ,%' =%(*1"+' ,%'@(5+' !+"+'B+(L#'%',+'%&I1%",+'!+"+'+',("%(*+9',%'"%&*#R' #&'@#)*%^,#&'&3#'%L(B(,#&'Y%5' 5()(+*1"+Z! )15+'%&!`@(%',%'%(.2#$'#),%'#'1*(=(K+,#"'`'@#)?(,+,#'+'%=%D%"'+I1%=%'I1%'I1%"'?%"/ '

H&*%'*(!#',%'/.2&#"$:&!!%"5(*%',+"'(5%,(+*+5%)*%'15+'=%(*1"+'D=#B+=',#&' @#)*%^,#&9'

)+'8EG8'!#,%"(+'&%"'1*(=(K+,#'!+"+R'!#"'%L%5!=#R'+!"%&%)*+"'+&'!"#!#&*+&'@#)@#""%)*%&/

6(D/'mj-'-!$"./(0"',+'+!=(@+>3#'"Q&3&*

6(D/'md-'-!$"./(0"',+'+!=(@+>3#'"Q&3&*O*"@P8"'(

AICA

6"!"6$5)[email protected]$)75+050+&

38"

,$.$,%#$#("#(",+-.+2%)*+"-+#/>$1

'

\'5J,1=#'`'15'@#)@%(*#'$1),+5%)*+='%5'+"I1(*%@*1"+-'%=%'"%!"%&%)*+'15+'"%D"+'I1%'

`' ,%V()(,+' %5' @#)[email protected](M)@(+' @#5#' B+&%' %' !+,"3#' ,%' "%!%*(>3#' ,%' 15+' @#5!#&(>3#' +"I1(*%@*J)(@+R' !+,"3#' %&&%' I1%' ,%?%' &%"' &1V(@(%)*%5%)*%' V=%LA?%='!+"+' *#=%"+"' ?+"(+>a%&' %' %[email protected]%!>a%&':'"%D"+/'\'5J,1=#' ,%V()%R'!#"*+)*#R'15+'%&*"1*1"+'D=#B+=/'G"%5#&'I1%'`'!#&&A?%='%' ,%&%N]?%='*"+)&!#"' %&*%'@#)@%(*#'!+"+'+'.=+*+$#"5+'0(D(*+='I1%')#&'!"#!#5#&' "%+=(K+"9'5+(&' +(),+-'@#5#'&%',%5#)&*"+"]'@#5' #'%&*1,#',%'@+&#&R'?%"(V(@+"%5#&'I1%'%&*%'@#)@%(*#'%&*]'N]'+' &%"'+!=(@+,#')15')^5%"#'@#)&(,%"]?%=',%'+!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&/ '

8' (5!#"*_)@(+' ,%&*%' (),(@+,#"' "%5%*%b)#&' !+"+' #&' @#)@%(*#&' ,%' $1)@(#)+=(,+,%' %'

%L!+)&3#9'15+'+!=(@+>3#'@#5!#&*+'!#"'5J,1=#&'(),%!%),%)*%&'!#,%'+D(=(K+"'+'!"#D"+5+>3#R' [email protected](=(*+"' +' D%&*3#' ,+' +!=(@+>3#' %' !%"5(*("' 15+' "]!(,+' [email protected]*(?+>3#o,%[email protected]*(?+>3#' ,%' $1)>a%&' +,(@(#)+(&/ '

@FE

@FF

Dez indicadores para a AICA

6(D/'me-*.]D()+'()(@(+=',+'+!=(@+>3#'8)1]"(+'0(D(*+='Y%5',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#Z

6(D/'mg-*4%!#&(*J"(#'&!3,!"',%'%L*%)&a%&'R&&'3('

AICA

(/

3#' 5#,1=+"' %&*]' !"%&%)*%' )%&*+' +!=(@+>3#' &#B' $#"5+' ,%' %L*%)&a%&'

#[email protected](#)+(&'I1%'+15%)*+5'+'$1)@(#)+=(,+,%',+'+!=(@+>3#'#"(D()+=/'\'3#'%'+&')%@%&&(,+,%&',#&'&%1&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&R'%'15+'B(B=(#*%@+'#)=()%'@#5' 5J,1=#&' #[email protected](#)+(&/' \' +'"%&(,%')#'D"+1',%'@#5!=%L(,+,%',+'$1)@(#)+=(,+,%',%&%N+,+/'8'&1+' ,%V()(>3#'`''Y\!%)'W#[email protected]%';+**%"&R'E)@R'ejdjBZ%)/"),6,14M *U(.2&.2!&=&%&.21!(#!$66=/:$2/(.1!2,$2! $#&!-1-$==3!0/16=$3&0! /.! 2,&!:&.2&#!("!2,&!%$/.!:(.2&.2! $#&$!("!$!2&%6=$2&4!84449!U(%6(.&.21!$#&!:(#&!&=&%&.21!("!v((%=$~u1!"-.:2/(.$=/234> /)53#64M *R(0-=&1!&`2&.0! 2,&!:$6$7/=/2/&1!("!v((%=$~!;/E/.;!2,&!1("2'$#&!.&'! "-.:2/(.$=/234!R(0-=&1!$#&! 1%$==!:(.2&.2!/2&%1!2,$2!:$.!7&!0/16=$3&0!$.3',&#&!84449> "#3Q$,4M *Z! 6=-;/.! (#! %$%7(2! /1! $! 1%$==3#'%'"%1*(=(K+),#'"%@1"&#&'!"`b%L(&*%)*%&/'H&*+'"%1*(=(K+>3#'!%"5(*%'+D(=(K+"' #'!"#@%&&#',%'!"#D"+5+>3#'%'1*(=(K+"'"%@1"&#&'I1%',%R'#1*"#'5#,#R'&%"(+5'!#&&A?%(&',%'#B*%"' @#5'@1&*#&'5+(&'%=%?+,#&/ '

73#'&%"(+'?(]?%='+'8EG8',%&%)?#=?%"'15'+=D#"(*5#'!"J!"(#'!+"+'%L(B(>3#',%',%&%)C#&'

?%@*#"(+(&' I1+),#' %&*%'N]'%L(&*%')#' 5%"@+,#R'`'[email protected](=5%)*%'[email protected]%&&A?%='%')3#'+!"%&%)*+')%)C15' @1&*#' !+"+' +=`5' ,#' *"+B+=C#' ,%' !"#D"+5+>3#' [email protected](=(*+,#Z' )%@%&&]"(#' !+"+' #' ()*%D"+"' )+' +!=(@+>3#/' \'5#,#' ,%' $1)@(#)+5%)*#' ,%&*%&' #!%"+,#"%&' %L*%")#&' `' (,M)*(@#-' #&' ,+,#&' &3#' $#")%@(,#&'!%=#'1*(=(K+,#"'%'&3#'!"#@%&&+,#&'!%=#'&%"?(,#"',%&&%'#!%"+,#"R'I1%')#&',%?#=?%'#' "%&1=*+,#'!"#)*#'+'&%"'%L(B(,#')+')#&&+'+!=(@+>3#/ '

H&*%' (),(@+,#"' !"#@1"+"]' (,%)*(V(@+"' #!%"+,#"%&' %L*%")#&' @1N+' $1)@(#)+=(,+,%' #&'

*#")%'!+&&A?%(&',%'()*%D"+>3#')+'8EG8/

@FB

@GC

Dez indicadores para a AICA

6(D&/'mlomm-*N&&G3"K([email protected]*R(S(@0.,2$*1M-*

AICA

(/

T##D=%';+!&

'

8'T##D=%';+!&' `'15' #!%"+,#"'%L*%")#'"%=%?+)*%'!+"+'8EG8/'\'()*%"%&&%'`'N1&*(V(@+,#'

!#"' ?]"(#&' [email protected]*#"%&-' $1)@(#)+=(,+,%' Y!%"5(*%' @#51)(@+>3#' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#' D%#D"]V(@+' %5' $#"5+*#'#$12&#!Y#"*#$#*#5+!+&Z'%'?%@*#"(+=R'B%5' @#5#' ,+,#&'+'%=+'+&&#@(+,#&Z9'[email protected](=(,+,%',%' (5!=%5%)*+>3#' Y+' T##D=%' $#")%@%' +' 8.E'ddd ' )%@%&&]"(+Z9' %' @1&*#' )1=#R' ,%&,%' I1%' #' ?(&(#)+5%)*#',%&*%&'@#)*%^,#&'&%N+'D"+*1(*+'!+"+'I1+=I1%"'1*(=(K+,#"dde/ ' 68$9$'()*56*/&"&*64101$%)M*0'+')1"2+%3"456M *+,&!r((;=&! I2$2/:! R$61! Z[5! =&21!3(-! &%7&0! $! r((;=&!R$61! /%$;&! (.! 3(-#! '&76$;&!'/2,(-2! #&G-/#/.;!v$E$I:#/62! (#!$.3!03.$%/:!6$;&!=($0/.;4!+,&!r((;=&!I2$2/:!R$6! 1&#E/:&!:#&$2&1!3(-#! %$6! 7$1&0! (.! f]M!6$#$%&2!1&.2!2,#(-;,! $! 12$.0$#0!t++[!#&G-&12!$.0!#&2-#.1!2,&!%$6! $1! $.!/%$;&!3(-!:$.!0/16=$3!(.!3(-#![X;/.$!0$!5.2&#.&24>!!8r((;=&3#',#'1*(=(K+,#"9'$#")%@%R'!#(&R'()$#"5+>3#'&#B"%'15'=#@+='!"`b,%*%"5()+,#/ 68$9$'()*56*/&"&4*5$,S/$%)4M*T&"4*U&>&4%.$"1*!R+*6*T&"4*!R+*-).*V#&4WM *+,&!r((;=&!R$61!v$E$1:#/62!Z[5!=&21!3(-!&%7&0!r((;=&!R$61!/.! 3(-#!('.![X;/.$!0$!5.2&#.&214! +,&!Z[5! 6#(E/0&1! $! .-%7&#! ("! -2/=/2/&1! "(#!%$./6-=$2/.;! %$61!84449!$.0! $00/.;! :(.2&.2! 2(! 2,&! %$6! 2,#(-;,! $! E$#/&23! ("! 1&#E/:&1!!8r((;=&3#' `' ?]=(,+' !+"+'+5B#&' #&' @+&#&R'%' +5B+&' +&' 8.E' !%"5(*%5' %L(B("' 15' 5+!+'

,()_5(@#R'@+!+K',%' &%"' 5+)(!1=+,#' !%=#' 1*(=(K+,#"' Y+=*%"+>3#' ,%' =#@+=(K+>3#R' Q((%R' *(!#' ,%' ?(&*+'X'(5+D%5'#$12&#!,%'&+*`=(*%R'5+!+'?%@*#"(+=R'(5+D%5'CAB"(,+'%'?(&*+',%'"1+ddg/ ddd'E)*%"%&&+' @=+"(V(@+"'+' ,%V()(>3#',%' 8.E-'s8)'8.E' (&'+)'E)*%"[email protected]%' SC(@C'(&'1&%,'$#"'[email protected]@%&&()D'+)'+!!=(@+*(#)'#"'+'&%"?(@%'$"#5'+' !"#D"+5/' 8)' 8.E' 5+Q%&'(*'!#&&(B=%'*#' 1&%' !"#D"+5&' $"#5'S(*C()'!"#D"+5&R'*C%"%$#"%'(*' (&'*C%'$#1),+*(#)' $#"'5#,1=+"' &P&*%5&' S(*C'@=%+"=P',%V()%,'E)*%"[email protected]%&'B%*S%%)'&%!+"+*%'@#5!#)%)*&/t''Yv(=,%R'ejdjZ dde 'c5+' #!>3#' @#5%"@(+=' %)@#)*"+b&%' *+5B`5',(&!#)A?%=-' sOC%' ;+!&' 8.E' (&' +' $"%%' &%"?(@%R' +?+(=+B=%' $#"'+)P' S%B'&(*%' *C+*' (&' $"%%'*#' @#)&15%"&/'.=%+&%' &%%'*C%'*%"5&'#$'&%"?(@%' $#"' 5#"%' ()$#"5+*(#)/' y1&()%&&%&'*C+*'@C+"D%'$%%&' $#"'[email protected]@%&&R' *"[email protected]' +&&%*&'#"' B1(=,' ()*%")+=' +!!=(@+*(#)&' 51&*' 1&%' T##D=%' ;+!&' 8.E' ."%5(%"R' SC(@C' !"#?(,%&' %)C+)@%,' $%+*1"%&R' *%@C)(@+=' &1!!#"*' +),' +' &%"?(@%b=%?%='+D"%%5%)*/t''YT##D=%R'[email protected] ddg ' 8' p(&*+' ,%' 41+R' #1' W*"%%*' p(%SR' `' 15+' *%@)#=#D(+' I1%' +' T##D=%' ,%&%)?#=?%1' I1%' !%"5(*%' +&&#@(+"' !#)*#&' ,%' 15+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' B(,(5%)&(#)+=' X' 15' 5+!+' X' +' (5+D%)&' $#*#D"]V(@+&' ,(D(*+(&' !%"5(*(),#R' !#"' %L%5!=#R' !%"@#""%"' 15+' "1+R' #B&%"?+"'15'!#)*#',%'?(&*+R'%*@/

@[email protected]

@GD

Dez indicadores para a AICA

6(D&/'mn-*N&&G3"D(.$=*1M-

6(D&/'mq-*K([email protected]($(*1M-*

AICA

68$9$'()*56*/)56#)*1.$5$/6,4$),&#*5)*Q#)9)*16..641.6M*X))Q#6*L&.1W*!R+M *+,&!r((;=&!q$#2,! [=-;g/.!$.0!/21!v$E$I:#/62!Z[5!=&2! 3(-!&%7&0! r((;=&!q$#2,!!8r((;=&+'%5'

"%=+>3#'+#&' ,#(&' 8.EU&' +)*%"(#"%&' !"%),%b&%' @#5' #' *(!#',%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#-'+#'()?`&' ,%'?(&*+&' %5' !=+)*+' #1' [email protected]%&&a%&' ,%' $#*#D"+V(+&R' +I1(' `b)#&' +!"%&%)*+,#' #' D=#B#' *%""%&*"%' ,%' 15+' $#"5+'*"(,(5%)&(#)+=/'W%),#'15+'*%@)#=#D(+')3#b)+*(?+')#&'7#('1'[email protected]*1+(&R'+'&1+'1*(=(K+>3#' [email protected]+""%*+'15'@1&*#'!+"+'#'1*(=(K+,#"R')3#' %@#)J5(@#' 5+&'$1)@(#)+=-'`')%@%&&]"(+'+'()&*+=+>3#' ,%'15' 6=-;/.' +,(@(#)+=' )#' 7#('1&#'!+"+' &%' !#,%"'*("+"' !+"*(,#' ,%&*+'$1)@(#)+=(,+,%R'#' I1%' !#,%'+$+&*+"'1*(=(K+,#"%&'5%)#&'%L!%"(%)*%&ddh / $,16Q.&'()*56*5&5)4*6/*/&"&4*5$,S/$%)4M*T&"4*N&1&*!R+M *+,&!r((;=&!R$61!\$2$!Z[5!$==('1!:=/&.2!$66=/:$2/(.1!2(!E/&'a%&' &%"3#' *"+*+,+&' %5' &%@>3#' !"J!"(+' ,%&*+' 0(&&%"*+>3#',%';%&*"+,#/

@GE

@GF

Dez indicadores para a AICA

((/

81*#,%&Q'6"%%SC%%=

'

8' 81*#,%&Q'!"#,1KR'%)*"%'#1*"+&R' +'+!=(@+>3#' 81*#@+,'X' 15+'+!=(@+>3#' ,%',%&%)C#'

+&&(&*(,#' !#"' @#5!1*+,#"' 1*(=(K+,+'%5' ?]"(+&' ]"%+&' !"#V(&&(#)+(&' @#5#' +' +"I1(*%@*1"+'%' +&' %)D%)C+"(+&9' %&*+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' 1*(=(K+5' $#"5+*#&' ?%@*#"(+(&' I1%' $1)@(#)+5' ,%' $#"5+' ,(&*()*+' ,#&' $#"5+*#&' "+&*%"-')3#' &3#' @#5!#&*+&' !#"' !(L%=&' 5+&' !#"' "%=+>a%&' 5+*%5]*(@+&' I1%'1)%5' !#)*#&' +'@+5()C#&'X'!+*C&9'&3#'(),%!%),%)*%&' ,+'"%&#=1>3#R' !#"' (&&#' !#,%5' &%"' +5!=(+,+&' #1' "%,1K(,+&' &%5' !%",%"' I1+=(,+,%/' O+=' )3#' &(D)(V(@+' I1%' 15' $#"5+*#' &%N+' &1!%"(#"' +#' #1*"#' X' &3#R' &(5!=%&5%)*%R' +,%I1+,#&' +' 1*(=(K+>a%&' ,(&*()*+&-' #' "+&*%"' %5' $#*#D"+V(+',(D(*+=R'#'?%@*#"(+='%5',%&%)C#'*`@)(@#'%',%&(D)'D"]V(@#/ '

H&*%' *(!#' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' ?%@*#"(+(&' @#)&*(*1%5' @#)*%^,#&' (5!#"*+)*%&' !+"+' +'

8EG8R' 5+&' +' &1+' %L(B(>3#' )15+' S%B!+D%' "%I1%"(+' +' ()&*+=+>3#' ,%' !=1D()&' +,(@(#)+(&' +#&' B"#S&%"&'!+"+'!%"5(*("%5'+'=%(*1"+',#'$#"5+*#'!"#!"(%*]"(#',+'81*#,%&Q'X'#',S$R',%&(D)'S%B' $#"5+*'X'1*(=(K+,#'!+"+'!+"*(=C+"'%&*%'*(!#',%'V(@C%("#&'?%@*#"(+(&/ '

\'81*#,%&Q' 6"%%SC%%='' Y81*#,%&QR' E)@/R'ejjqZ'&1"D(1'%5'ejjq'!+"+'!%"5(*("' +'$]@(='

()@=1&3#',%'@#)*%^,#&'?%@*#"(+(&'Y%5'$#"5+*#',S$Z')+&'!]D()+&',+'vvv/

6(D&/'nj-*18$&)"@T*U.""?=""3*"#,>,!)&*8'*'&)"3&*)?/*96*

6(D&/'nd-*18$&)"@T*U.""?=""3*"#,>,!)&*8'*'&)"3&*)?/*V6*

AICA

(((/

E&&11

'

\' E&&11' `' 15+' !=+*+$#"5+' ,%' !1B=(@+>a%&' #)=()%' %' 15+' "%,%' &#@(+=' +&&#@(+,+9' #'

1*(=(K+,#"' @"(+' 15+' @#)*+' ,%' $#"5+'D"+*1(*+' %' !#,%'$+K%"' #' -6=($0' ,%' V(@C%("#&' %5' $#"5+*#' [\b' !+"+' #' &%"?(,#"' #)=()%' ,%&*%' #!%"+,#"R' #!*+),#' !#"' 5+)*%"' #' V(@C%("#' !"(?+,#' #1' ,(&!#)(B(=(K]b=#')+'"%,%'&#@(+=/ '

8' &%D1),+' C(!J*%&%' D+"+)*%' 15+' 5+(#"' ?(&(B(=(,+,%' +#' ,#@15%)*#' %' +#' +1*#"R' %'

()&%"%b#' )15+' !=+*+$#"5+' #),%' !#,%' ?%"R' @#5%)*+"R' +&&()+=+"' %' +?+=(+"' #&' ,#@15%)*#&' &1B5%*(,#&'!#"' #1*"#&'1*(=(K+,#"%&/'H&*+'$1)@(#)+=(,+,%'!#,%"]'&%"'(5!#"*+)*%'!+"+'+'8EG8R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%')+'+?+=(+>3#',%'!"#!#&*+&'+'@#)@1"&#/ '

Ö' &%5%=C+)>+' ,#&' #!%"+,#"%&' +)*%"(#"%&R' #&' @#)*%^,#&' @#=#@+,#&' )#' E&&11' &3#'

!#&&A?%(&' ,%' &%"%5' %5B%B(,#&' )#1*"+&' +!=(@+>a%&' '&7' 5%,(+)*%' +'()&%">3#' ,%' 15' &(5!=%&' @J,(D#/

6(D&/'ne-*8!=(@+>3#'[email protected]@88'%L(B(),#'15+'!1B=(@+>3#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+

@GG

@GH

Dez indicadores para a AICA

AICA

6"!"I$5)[email protected]$',-5);%,7

58"

,$.$,%#$#("#("(G%3#',%',(?1=D+>3#',%'@#)@1"&#&'X'\8W47'

6(D&/'nh-*8!=(@+>3#',%',(?1=D+>3#',%'@#)@1"&#&'X'\8W47

AICA

(/

\8W47

'

8' \8W47' X' \",%5' ,#&' 8"I1(*%@*#&R' W%@>3#' 4%D(#)+=' 7#"*%' X' `' +' %)*(,+,%' I1%'

"%D1=+5%)*+' #' %L%"@[email protected](#' !"#V(&&(#)+=' ,+' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %5' .#"*1D+=9' )#' I1%' ,(K' "%&!%(*#' +' @#)@1"&#&',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'+'()&*(*1(>3#'`'"%&!#)&]?%='!%=+'+)]=(&%',+'&1+'@#)$#"5(,+,%'!+"+' @#5'+&')#"5+&',+'B#+'!"]*(@+'!"#V(&&(#)+=9'5+&R'+=`5' ,(&&#R' %'!+"+',%*%"5()+,#&' @#)@1"&#&' I1%' &#=(@(*%5' +' &1+' +&&%&&#"(+' *`@)(@+R' +' \8W47' ,%&%)?#=?%1' 15' %/:#(g1/2&' I1%' $1)@(#)+' @#5#'15'2&%6=$2&'%'I1%'$#")%@%'()$#"5+>a%&'+'%?%)*1+(&'!+"*(@(!+)*%&/ '

E)*%"%&&+b)#&'(,%)*(V(@+"R'%)*3#R'I1%'@#)*%^,#&'&3#' ,(&!#)(B(=(K+,#&R'*%),#' &(,#'!+"+'

#'%$%(*#'+)+=(&+,#&',#(&'%/:#(g1/2&1'"%=+*(?#&'+',#(&'@#)@1"&#&',%'@#)@%!>3#b ."#N%@*#',%'4%+B(=(*+>3#',+'[email protected]#=+'."#V(&&(#)+='8D"[email protected]#=+'G#),%',%'W/'y%)*#R'W+)*#'O(" b ."#N%@*#',%'4%I1+=(V(@+>3#',#'H,([email protected](#',#';1&%1',#'G+""#'H=`@*"(@#'b'.#"*#/ '

8'!]D()+'()(@(+=',%'@+,+'%/:#(g1/2&!+!"%&%)*+'#&'&%D1()*%&'=()Q&-',(%&3#'D=#B+=',#'@#)@1"&#R'C(&*J"(+',#'#BN%@*#'%'%L!%@*+*(?+&9 b 4$,)"46'5)'%),%3.4)-'+!"%&%)*+',+,#&'%&!%@AV(@#&',#'!"#@%,(5%)*#-'%)*(,+,%'+,N1,(@+)*%R' *(!#' ,%' !"#@%,(5%)*#R' #BN%@*#R' #BN%@*(?#R' @#)@#""%)*%&' +,5(&&A?%(&R' @#5!#&(>3#' ,#' N^"(R' !"`5(#&'%'@+=%),+"(K+>3#9 b ".)%644)' 5)' %),%3.4)-' $#")%@%' =()Q&' !+"+' ,#@15%)*#&' ,%[email protected]+""%D]?%(&' !#"' ?(+' ,(D(*+=R' @#5!"%%),%),#-'+)^)@(#&' Y04' %' 3#' ,%' +=*%"+>a%&' +#' 5(@"#b&(*%' %' !%,(,#' ,%' @J,(D#'&%@"%*#R'!+"+'%$%(*#',%'!+"*(@(!+>3#'+)J)(5+')#'@#)@1"&#/

@GB

@HC

Dez indicadores para a AICA

Tivoli Audio 10th anniversary design challenge designboom

web

search

n55: walking house toyo ito: wins praemium imperiale + exhibition at venice biennale 2010 caruso st. john + thomas demand at venice 2010 view index

rolf sachs studio visit marc newson at gagosian gallery, new york

CALL-FOR-ENTRIES designboom and TIVOLI AUDIO international graphic design competition. participation is open to applicants from every country in the world, to professionals, students, and design-enthusiasts. free registration required.

jasper morrison + punkt: DP01 telephone view index

01 - the subject of the international competition is

Tivoli Audio 10th anniversary design challenge TIVOLI AUDIO is a world leader in the design and manufacture of table radios. the company was founded in 2000 with the goal of bringing beautifully designed, simple-to-use, high quality audio products to the consumer. for the past 10 years, TIVOLI AUDIO has become world renowned by introducing some of the finest and highly acclaimed audio products ever made. from the beginning, exceptional design has defined the brand so in honor of its 10th anniversary, TIVOLI AUDIO is inviting designers, illustrators, and photographers from around the world to participate in a special International competition celebrating the design, creativity and success of the audio company. you are asked to prepare a poster to celebrate TIVOLI AUDIO's 10th anniversary, using the medium of your choice: illustration, photography, painted, hand drawn or computer aided etc. all entries need to include an image of the new 1 - TIVOLI AUDIO MODEL 10 radio, 2 - the TIVOLI AUDIO LOGO and 3 - the TIVOLI AUDIO LOGO 10TH ANNIVERSARY in your poster design. you can download the required images

here

maurizio cattelan : omnia munda mundis takashi murakami at versailles rupprecht geiger view index

--02 – awards the designers of 3 winning entries will win a cash prize of: - first prize $ 3000 USD - second prize $ 2000 USD - third prize $ 1000 USD the winning artist’s work will be featued on a billboard at 1535 marriott marquis rotunda mesh face in times square, NYC for the month of December 2010. ball nogues paul smith pei zhu view index

Venice Paintings Buy and Sell 19th Century Art 2010 Painting Auctions at Bonhams

www.bonhams.com/19thcentury

each one of the TIVOLI AUDIO distributors will select a local winner from their country (about 30 countries worlwide) to be featured on regional billboards. and as always designboom will publish an exhaustive results report.

--03 - design criteria projects should be original. designs that have been commercialized or published/exhibited before the competition will not be accepted. participants must ensure that images, people, places, monuments used for artworks in relation with this competition are either free of rights or owned by participants. it is important that you keep your design(s) confidential until the results of the competition are published by designboom.

--04 – registration deadline application registration will be accepted through september 30th, 2010.

--05 - registration registrations are open now, please fill in the form. teams register with one name only - when submitting works you should add all team member’s names.

register here

--06 - submit your entry / entries whether you're an individual or group, you can only submit a maximum of 3 works.

1 . for each entry you are required to prepare a hi-res file of your poster design to be used as horizontal format, 300dpi.

6(D&/'ni-*8!=(@+>3#',%'!"#5#>3#',%'@#)@1"&#&'X'0%&(D)B##5

AICA

((/

0%&(D)B##5

' '

8' 0%&(D)B##5' !"#5#?%' @#)@1"&#&' )+' ]"%+' ,#' 0%&(D)' T"]V(@#' %' ,%' HI1(!+5%)*#'

+*"+?`&' ,+' &1+' !=+*+$#"5+' #)=()%9' +' !=+*+$#"5+' `' "%&!#)&]?%=' !#"' ()$#"5+"' #&' %?%)*1+(&' @#)@#""%)*%&R'!"#!#"@(#)+b=C%&' 15' 5%(#' ,%'"%D(&*#' (.=/.&'%',%[email protected]+""%D+5%)*#',#&' 5+*%"(+(&' ,%'"%$%"M)@(+R' %'+(),+'15' 5%(#' !+"+' &1B5%*%"' +&' !"#!#&*+&' !#"' ?(+',(D(*+=/' 8' &%=%@>3#' ,#&' ?%)@%,#"%&' `',%*%"5()+,+'!%=#'N^"('%R' %5' ,%*%"5()+,#&' @+&#&R'!#"' 15+',%@(&3#'@#)N1)*+',#' N^"(' %' !^B=(@#' Y#' !"(5%("#' ,%V()%' 15+' 1,(#2g=/12' %' #' ^=*(5#' !+"*(@(!+' )+' ?#*+>3#' #)=()%' !"#5#?(,+'!%=+'!"J!"(+'!=+*+$#"5+Z/ '

H&*%' '(#)P=('' `R' !#"' &(' &JR' ()*%"%&&+)*%R' )+' 5%,(,+' %5' I1%' +' !=+*+$#"5+' ,(D(*+='

+&&15%' 15+' !#&*1"+' ,()_5(@+' %5' *#,#' #' !"#@%&&#/' 8&&(5R' +!%&+"' ,+' !=+*+$#"5+' )3#' &%' "%!#"*+"':']"%+',+'+"I1(*%@*1"+R')3#',%(L+',%'@#)&*(*1("'15'@+&#',%'%&*1,#'()*%"%&&+)*%/ '

O#5]5#&' @#5#' @+&#' ,%' %&*1,#' #' @#)@1"&#' sO(?#=(' 81,(#' dj*C' +))(?%"&+"P' ,%&(D)'

@C+==%)D%t9'+'!=+*+$#"5+',(&!#)(B(=(K#1'#&'&%D1()*%&'@#)*%^,#&R'%&*"1*1"+,#&'%5'de'!#)*#&b &".646,1&'()-'+!"%&%)*+>3#'D=#B+=',#'@#)@1"&#R'C(&*J"(+',#'#BN%@*#'%'%L!%@*+*(?+&9 b ".?/$)4-'()$#"5+>3#'&#B"%'#')^5%"#'%'?+=#"',#&'!"`5(#&9 b %.$1?.$)4-'()$#"5+>3#'&#B"%'@#5#'+&'!"#!#&*+&'&%"3#'+?+=(+,+&9 b 5&1&*#$/$16*56*.6Q$41)9 b .6Q$41)*),#$,6-'=()Q'!+"+'%$%@*1+"'#'"%D(&*#')#'@#)@1"&#',("%@*+5%)*%')+'!=+*+$#"5+9 b 439/$44()* 56* ".)")41&4-' @#)*`5' ()$#"5+>3#' &#B"%' #&' @#)*%^,#&' I1%' #&' @#)@#""%)*%&' ,%?%5'+!"%&%)*+"'%'$#")%@%'15'=()Q'!+"+'&1B5(&&3#',%&&%&'@#)*%^,#&'!#"'?(+',(D(*+=9 b 5&1&*#$/$16*"&.&*439/$44()*5&4*".)")41&49 b &,K,%$)*5)4*.643#1&5)4-'(),(@+>3#',+',+*+',%'+)^)@(#',#&'?%)@%,#"%&9 b 5$.6$1)4* 56* ".)".$65&56* $,16#6%13&#-' @=+"(V(@+>3#' ,+' +1*#"(+' %' ,("%(*#&' ,%'1*(=(K+>3#' ,#&' *"+B+=C#&'&1B5%*(,#&'+'@#)@1" b %.$1?.$)4*56*&5/$44()-'()$#"5+>3#'&#B"%'#'!%"V(=',%'@#)@#""%)*%'[email protected]%(*%9 b $,-)./&'()*4)9.6*)*".)/)1).9 b 64%#&.6%$/6,1)*56*5K>$5&4-'(),(@+>3#',#'@#)*[email protected]*#',#'!"#5#*#"/

@[email protected]

@HD

Dez indicadores para a AICA

(((/

8"I1(*%@*15

'

'

'

8' 8"I1(*%@*15'`'15+'!=+*+$#"5+'#)=()%'!+"+',(?1=D+>3#' ,%')#*[email protected](+&' %'@#)@1"&#&' ,%'

+"I1(*%@*1"+/'8' &1+' @#51)(@+>3#'`'$%(*+'5%,(+)*%' +' +!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%'*"M&' $+(L+&'C#"(K#)*+(&R' @#5#' N]' ?(5#&' )+' *%5]*(@+'5.2&#"$:&9' %&&+&' $+(L+&' !#&&1%5R' )+' %L*"%5(,+,%'%&I1%",+R' 15+' @+(L+'@#5'=/.)1!!+"+'#&'@#)*%^,#&'I1%')#&'()*%"%&&+'+D#"+'%[email protected]=+"%@%"b 43/0.$)-' +!"%&%)*+>3#' D=#B+=' ,#' @#)@1"&#R' C(&*J"(+' ,#' #BN%@*#' %' %L!%@*+*(?+&R' ()@=1(),#' @+),(,+,#&'+,5(&&A?%(&'%'"%&*"(>a%&9 b =K.$-'()$#"5+>3#'&#B"%'+'@#5!#&(>3#',#'N^"(9 b ".?/$)4-'()$#"5+>3#'&#B"%'#')^5%"#'%'?+=#"',#&'!"`5(#&9 b %,5&.$P&'()9 b %341)* 56* "&.1$%$"&'()-' ()$#"5+>3#' &#B"%' @1&*#' ,%' %)*"+,+' )#' @#)@1"&#' %' ()$#"5+>3#' "%[email protected](#)+,+9 b V!Z-''=(&*+D%5'@#5'!%"D1)*+&'$"%I1%)*%&'%'"%&!%@*(?+&'"%&!#&*+&9 b 5)\,#)&54M* $#")%@%' 15' =()Q' !+"+' V(@C%("#' ,%[email protected]+""%D]?%=' @#)*%),#' +&' B+&%&' ,#' @#)@1"&#' Y,%&%)C#&'?%@*#"(+(&R'$#*#D"+V(+&'+`"%+&R'%*@/Z9 b .6Q$41)-' =()Q' !+"+' %$%@*1+"' #' "%D(&*#' )#' @#)@1"&#' ,("%@*+5%)*%' )+' !=+*+$#"5+' 5%,(+)*%' !+D+5%)*#',#'@1&*#',%'!+"*(@(!+>3#/

6(D&/'nl-*8!=(@+>3#',%',(?1=D+>3#',%'@#)@1"&#&'X'8"I1(*%@*15-'$+(L+'C#"(K#)*+='

6(D&/'nm-*8!=(@+>3#',%',(?1=D+>3#',%'@#)@1"&#&' 8"I1(*%@*15-'!#"5%)#"',+'@+(L+',%'3,[email protected]

AICA

5D"

,$.$,%#$#("#("(201/0/1$)*+"(".(2J/%2$"#(",+&0(I#+2

'

H&*%' (),(@+,#"' "%?%=+b&%' @+,+' ?%K'5+(&' (5!#"*+)*%' )+' %"+' ,+' I5/' G#5#' "%$%"(,#' )+'

"%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+R' #' (),(?A,1#' ,+'I5! `'"%&!#)&]?%=' !%=+'@"(+>3#' ,%'15+' I1+)*(,+,%'@+,+' ?%K' 5+(#"' ,%' ()$#"5+>3#' I1%' "+!(,+5%)*%' `' ,(&&%5()+,+' )+' 5.2&#.&2R' ,+,+&' +&' [email protected](=(,+,%&' !"#5#?(,+&'!%=+'e&7!J4K/ '

8'8EG8'("]'+=#N+"',(?%"&#&'@#)*%^,#&'I1%'&%'I1%"%5',(?%"&#&'%'@#5!=%5%)*+"%&'X'&J'

+&&(5'&%"%5#&'@+!+K%&',%'@#51)(@+"'+'@#5!=%L+'"%+=(,+,%'%'#&'!"#N%@*#&R'@#5#'N]'"%$%"(5#&/' z]' !#"' (&&#' #' !%"(D#' ,%R' "+!(,+5%)*%R' +'8EG8' &%' *#")+"' )15' "%!#&(*J"(#' ,%&#"D+)(K+,#' ,%' (5+D%)&R' V(=5%&' %' ,#@15%)*#&R' @#5' *#,+&' +&' (5!=(@+>a%&' I1%' (&&#' [email protected]+""%*+' %5' *%"5#&' ,%' [email protected]%&&(B(=(,+,%'%'%L!%"(M)@(+',#'1*(=(K+,#"/ '

' )%@%&&]"(#R' !#"' (&&#R' +$%"("' %&*"+*`D(+&' ,%' @+*+=#D+>3#' %' !%&I1(&+' ()*1(*(?+' ,%'

@#)*%^,#&/

@HE

@HF

Dez indicadores para a AICA

6(D&/'nn-*8!=(@+>3#'6"3,0,[email protected]*(,%)*(V(@+>3#',%'>&&T'([email protected]*(),(?(,1+(&**

6(D&/'nq-*8!=(@+>3#'6"3,0,[email protected]*(,%)*(V(@+>3#',#&'$([email protected]'+&&#@(+,#&'+#' >&&T'(.T*%',#')^5%"#',%'1*(=(K+,#"%&'@#5'#'5%&5#'>&&T'(.T

6(D&/'qj-*8!=(@+>3#'6"3,0,[email protected]*,!$"./(0"

6(D&/'qd-*8!=(@+>3#'6"3,0,[email protected]*)+?%D+>3#'&%I1%)@(+='!#"'$([email protected]*

6(D&/'qe-*8!=(@+>3#'6"3,0,[email protected]*=(&*+D%5',%'$([email protected]* +&&#@(+,+&'+#&'>&&T'([email protected]*,#&'1*(=(K+,#"%&

AICA

(/

0%=(@(#1&

' '

G#5#' ?(5#&R'+'vvv'`'15+'!+"*%',+'5.2&#.&2' :'I1+='#'1*(=(K+,#"'*%5'[email protected]%&&#' +*"+?`&'

,%' 15+' +!=(@+>3#' %&!%@AV(@+' X' #' 7#('1! \&' &%1&' @#)*%^,#&' &3#' ?1=D+"5%)*%' ,%&(D)+,#&' @#5#'6X;/.$1!0$!5.2&#.&2/ '

W%' )#' ()[email protected](#' +' @"(+>3#' ,%&*%&' @#)*%^,#&' %&*+?+' "%&%"?+,+' +' I1%5' !%"@%B%&&%' ,%'

!"#D"+5+>3#R' [email protected]*1+=5%)*%R'%'@#5'#'&1!#"*%',+&'+!=(@+>a%&'e&7!J4KR' +'@"(+>3#',%' !]D()+&')+' 5.2&#.&2'`'15' !"#@%&&#' 5+(&'&(5!=%&' %'"]!(,#' X'%' #' "%&1=*+,#'$#('#'@"%[email protected](5%)*#' %L!#)%)@(+=' ,#&'@#)*%^,#&/ '

H)@#)*"+"' +' ()$#"5+>3#' @%"*+R' )%&*+&' !]D()+&' e&7R' "%?%=+b&%' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&'

$1),+5%)*+=/' W%' )15' !"(5%("#' 5#5%)*#' +' @+*+=#D+>3#' ,%&*+&' !]D()+&' %"+' %$%@*1+,+' !#"' !"#D"+5+&'()$#"5]*(@#&'X'#&'5#*#"%&',%'!%&I1(&+R'@#5#' #'r((;=&!X'+'*%),M)@(+'[email protected]*1+='`'I1%' %&&+' @+*+=#D+>3#' &%N+' %$%@*1+,+' !%=#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&R' )15' %&$#">#' @#=+B#"+*(?#' @#515R' %5' !=+*+$#"5+&'#)=()%',%'[email protected]%&&#'=(?"%'%'D"+*1(*#/ '

\'0%=(@(#1&' 'Yw+C##xR'ejdjZ'`'15+',%&*+&' !=+*+$#"5+&'I1%'!%"5(*%'15+'#"D+)(K+>3#'

&%5_)*(@+',+&'!]D()+&',+'5.2&#.&2-'$1)@(#)+'@#5#'15+'+!=(@+>3#' &#@(+=R'#),%'@+,+'!%&&#+'`' 15'1*(=(K+,#"'I1%'$+K'!+"*%',%'15+'"%,%',%'@#51)(@+>3#9'@+,+'1*(=(K+,#"'!#,%'+,(@(#)+"' +#' &(&*%5+'#' %),%"%>#' X' f#=!X' ,%' I1+=I1%"'!]D()+',+'5.2&#.&2' Y#' 7(()%$#)Z' +#' 5%&5#' *%5!#' I1%' =C%' +&&#@(+' 15+' B"%?%' ,%[email protected]"(>3#' %' !+=+?"[email protected]+?%' X' +&' 2$;1/' 8I1(' "%&(,%' +' ,($%"%)>+' $1),+5%)*+='%5' "%=+>3#' +#&' 5#*#"%&' ,%' !%&I1(&+' +1*#5+*(K+,#&-'+'2$;' @#)*`5' %5' &('15+' ,(5%)&3#'&%5_)*(@+'%'15+'&A)*%&%'I1%'15'@#5!1*+,#"')3#'!+"%@%'&%"'@+!+K',%'%$%@*1+"/ '

\' 1*(=(K+,#"' ,%&*+' +!=(@+>3#' !#,%' +&&(5' )+?%D+"' !%=#&' 7(()%$#)1' ,%' #1*"#&'

1*(=(K+,#"%&' Y!#,%"]' &%"' ^*(=' &%' !+"*(=C+"%5' #' 5%&5#' 7$:);#(-.0' #1' ()*%"%&&%&Z' #1' !%=#&' 2$;1R'!#,%),#'()@=1&(?%'("'"%V()+),#'+'!%&I1(&+'&%I1%)@(+=5%)*%/

@HG

@HH

Dez indicadores para a AICA

6(D&/'qg-*8!=(@+>3#'E$8'>3"82&!W*5%@+)(&5#&',%'$1)@(#)+5%)*#

AICA

((/

W*15B=%c!#)

'

\' W*15B=%c!#)' ' YW*15B=%c!#)R' ejdj+Z' `' 15+' +!=(@+>3#' ,%' %&*"1*1"+>3#' ,#&'

@#)*%^,#&',+'vvv'I1%'!+"*%',%'15'!"()@A!(#',(+5%*"+=5%)*%'#!#&*#',#' %L%5!=#'+)*%"(#"-' +I1(' `' +' +!=(@+>3#' I1%' &1D%"%' #&' @#)*%^,#&' +#&' 1*(=(K+,#"R' 1*(=(K+),#' !+"+' (&&#' 15+' @#5B()+>3#',%'*"M&'5%@+)(&5#&R'@#)$#"5%'+!"%&%)*+,#')+'(5+D%5'+#'=+,#/ '

\' !"(5%("#' 5%@+)(&5#' "%!#"*+b&%' +' 15+' 5+)%("+' s*"+,(@(#)+=t' ,%' #B*%)>3#' ,%'

@#)*%^,#&R'I1%'*%5'+'?%"'@#5'+'&1+'*%5]*(@+9'!#"'%&&%'5#*(?#R'+#'1*(=(K+,#"',#'W*15B=%c!#)' `'&#=(@(*+,#'I1%'@=+"(V(I1%R'!"(5%("#R'#&'&%1&'()*%"%&&%&'X'+"*%R'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'*%@)#=#D(+R'%*@/9 '

\'&%D1),#' 5%@+)(&5#'"%!#"*+b&%'+'15+'+)]=(&%',%'!+,"a%&' ,%'1*(=(K+,#"%&9'@#5#'#'

1*(=(K+,#"' ,#' W*15B=%c!#)'`' ()*%D"+,#' )+'"%,%'&#@(+='()*%")+' ,+' +!=(@+>3#R' *#")+b&%'+&&(5' !#&&A?%=' +' @#5!+"+>3#' ,%' ()*%"%&&%&' ,%' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' %' +' @#)&*(*1(>3#' ,%' D"1!#&' ,%' 1*(=(K+,#"%&'@#5'()*%"%&&%&'&(5(=+"%&9 '

\'^=*(5#'5%@+)(&5#'"%$%"%b&%'5+(&',("%@*+5%)*%':'"%,%'&#@(+=R'!#,%),#'#'1*(=(K+,#"'

&%D1("'#1*"#&'1*(=(K+,#"%&'%'?(&1+=(K+"'#&'&%1&'@#)*%^,#&R'@#5%)*+"'#'&%1'!%"V(=R'%*@/ ' '

*I2-%7=&f6(.! :(%7/.&1! :(==$7(#$2/E&! ,-%$.! (6/./(.1! '/2,! %$:,/.&! =&$#./.;! ("!

6(.$=! 6#&"&#&.:&!2(! :#&$2&!E/#2-$=! :(%%-./2/&1!("!=/)&g%/.0&0! '&71-#"! ]$2/.;! '&71/2&1! -60$2&1! $! 6(.$=! 6#(P/=&! 8'&7=(;9! $.0! ;&.&#$2&1! 6&&#! .&2'(#)1! ("! '&71-#"! =/.)&0! 73! :(%%(.! /.2&#&124!+,&1&! 1(:/$=! .&2'(#)1!:((#0/.$2&! 2,&!0/12#/7-2/(.!("! '&7! :(.2&.2+"tZ' #' 1*(=(K+,#"' `' (5%,(+*+5%)*%'

@#),1K(,#' +'15' '&71/2&'s+=%+*#"(+5%)*%t'D%"+,#' @#5' B+&%')#&' *"M&' 5%@+)(&5#&' "%$%"(,#&R' !#,%),#' @#5%)*]b=#' )+'"%,%' &#@(+=R'?%"' @#5%)*]"(#&' ,%'#1*"#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&R'?%"'1*(=(K+,#"%&' I1%'"%@#5%),+5'#''&71/2&R'%*@/

@HI

@H<

Sistematização de Indicadores na matriz da AICA

AICA

[email protected]+4'=$*,)$'L)-.!+(*+'&('0)(!#*=+&)+,)$#'L+()+;5H;

'

8'5+*"(K'I1%'+D#"+'+!"%&%)*+5#&'@#)&*(*1('15+'&A)*%&%R'@#5'15+'$#"*%'@#5!#)%)*%'

D"]V(@+R',#' @#)C%@(5%)*#'+,I1("(,#' +#' =#)D#' ,#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',#' *"+B+=C#R'+V("5+),#b&%' &(51=*+)%+5%)*%'@#5#' 15+'!%>+',%'%)@%""+5%)*#',+'0(&&%"*+>3#'%'!#)*#' ,%'&(*1+>3#' !+"+' !"#&&%D1(5%)*#',+'()?%&*(D+>3#',#'@#)&J"@(#'084G/ '

\&' (),(@+,#"%&' I1%' "%$%"(5#&' )#' !#)*#' +)*%"(#"' &%"3#' ,(&!#&*#&' +#' =#)D#' ,#' %(L#'

?%"*(@+=',#'5#,%=#',%'5+*"(K'@#)@%B(,#'!+"+'%&&%'%$%(*#'%'+&'$#)*%&'&%"3#',(&!#&*+&'+#'=#)D#' ,#'%(L#'C#"(K#)*+=9')#'@"1K+5%)*#',#&'%(L#&',%[email protected]"%?%"%5#&'+&'?+"(]?%(&/

@HB

@IC

Sistematização de Indicadores na matriz da AICA

Joomla!

Legislação

A1

A1 Capacidade de Estruturação de Grupos de Utilizadores

Distinção directamente relacionada Distinção generalista com base na com mercado de arquitectura: autor, capacidade de manipulação de coordenador, dono de obra. conteúdos: convidado, registado, autor, editor, publicador.

A. Utilizadores

A2

Capacidade de Registo de Utilizadores

Por determinar.

A3

Facilidade de Integração em Sistemas de Identificação Existentes

Por determinar.

A4

Capacidade de Estruturação de Circuitos de Informação

B. Interface

Não aplicável.

B1

Capacidade de Personalizaçã o do Interface

Não aplicável.

B2

Facilidade de Compreensão do Interface

C. Estrutura

Não aplicável.

C1

Capacidade de Composição Modular

Não aplicável.

C2

O utilizador pode registar-se no sistema utilizando os dados: nome, nome de utilizador, email, password (duplicado).

Mediante instalação de extensões adicionais, é possível a integração com sistemas de identificação externa tais como OpenID, LDAP, Facebook Connect e Twitter.

Mecanismo interno em que autor cria conteúdos, editor faz alterações e publicador publica o artigo para o público. Mediante instalação de extensões adicionais (workflow extension) é possível a configuração de circuitos de informação.

Designboom

Bustler

Distinção generalista com base na capacidade de manipulação de conteúdos: administrador, editor, autor, contribuinte, subscritor.

Distinção em função da área profissional: architecture, art direction, interactive design, industrial or craft design, interior design, illustration, graphic design, fashion, film and tv, fine art, photography, marketing and promotion, sound/music, digital art, education, other.

Distinção simples entre convidados e utilizadores registados. Os últimos têm acesso à rede social interna e a funcionalidades adicionais como: criação de perfil pessoal; canais de comunicação com outros membros do Bustler; sinalização de concursos e eventos favoritos.

Dados para registo nos concursos: nome, apelido, email, password (duplicado), área profissional, data de aniversário, género, morada, código postal, cidade, país, nickname.

Dados para acesso a capacidades de Dados para registo nos concursos: Não aplicável. i n t e r a c ç ã o n o s i t e : n o m e d e primeiro nome, último nome, idade, e x i b i ç ã o , u s e r n a m e , e m a i l , país, email, contacto telefónico. password (duplicado), localização, ocupação.

O utilizador pode registar-se no sistema utilizando os dados: nome, apelido, nome de utilizador, email, website, password (duplicado)

Mediante instalação de extensões Não existe integração com sistemas Por determinar. adicionais, é possível a integração de identificação externos. com sistemas de identificação externa tais como OpenID, LDAP, Facebook Connect e Twitter.

Contém um mecanismo interno em Não aplicável. que os autores submete conteúdos para revisão pelo editor. Através da instalação de plugins adicionais (como o Edit Flow) é possível estender a funcionalidade e criar circuitos de informação personalizados.

Não aplicável.

Arquitectum

OpenID

Certificado Digital

Distinção simples entre convidados e Distinção simples entre convidados e Distinção simples entre convidados e Por determinar. utilizadores registados (Membros pessoas autenticadas. pessoas autenticadas. do Arquitectum). Aos últimos é oferecida a hipótese de promoverem o seu trabalho no website.

Os dados de registo para utilizar o Por determinar. OpenID corresponderão aos dados solicitados pelo provedor de OpenID específico.

INCI

Distinção entre cliente, consultor Por determinar. principal, consultor(es) secundário (s), equipas técnicas multidisciplinares, equipas de avaliação, e público.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Autodesk Autocad Por determinar.

Não aplicável.

Mediante instalação de extensões Não aplicável. adicionais, é possível a integração com sistemas de identificação externa tais como OpenID, LDAP, e single sign-on (autenticação usando credenciais da máquina).

Não existe integração com sistemas Não aplicável. de identificação externos.

Não aplicável.

Definição genérica do mecanismo de funcionamento do circuito da informação com base nos seguintes elementos: utilizador, estado, objecto e transição.

Definição específica do mecanismo de funcionamento do circuito de informação num Concurso de Arquitectura: definição do âmbito e requisitos, divulgação do concurso, entrevista preliminar, entrevistas adicionais, visita aos lugares, entrega, avaliação, selecção do vencedor, divulgação do vencedor.

Definição específica do mecanismo Por determinar. de funcionamento do circuito de informação num Concurso de Arquitectura: anúncio, avaliação da capacidade, consulta aos termos, comprovação da capacidade, avaliação da capacidade e convite, apresentação das propostas, apreciação e relatório, anúncio de vencedor e premiação, demonstração da habilitação.

Não permite essa funcionalidade.

Não permite essa funcionalidade.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Não permite essa funcionalidade.

O interface administrativo é constituído por uma um menu horizontal (no topo, em drop-down, constituída por links aos vários módulos da aplicação), e uma área central de conteúdos, que varia em função do módulo seleccionado.

O interface administrativo é constituído por uma barra lateral, vertical, constituída por links aos vários módulos da aplicação, e uma área central de conteúdos, que varia em função do módulo seleccionado.

Constituído por header, barra lateral Por determinar. de conteúdos acessórios, área central de conteúdos (em duas colunas) e footer.

O interface é constituído por três Não aplicável. faixas horizontais com igual importância; ausência de hierarquia para além do sentido ocidental de leitura; permite leitura global dos conteúdos.

Não aplicável.

A composição modular encontra-se presente sob forma de components (sub-aplicações complexas geridas no back-end); modules (dispositivos para apresentação de conteúdos); e plugins (tarefas simples, normalmente com poucos parâmetros editáveis).

A composição modular encontra-se I m p o s s í v e l a c e s s o à á r e a I m p o s s í v e l a c e s s o à á r e a I m p o s s í v e l a c e s s o à á r e a Não aplicável. presente sob forma de plugins que administrativa. administrativa. administrativa. cumprem as mais variadas tarefas, independentemente da complexidade.

Não aplicável.

Múltiplas possibilidade mediante Múltiplas possibilidade mediante Não integra * (impossível acesso à Por determinar. instalação de extensões adicionais. instalação de extensões adicionais. área administrativa)

Malcolm Reading C.

Não existe integração com sistemas Integração com certificado de I n t e g r a ç ã o c o m s i s t e m a d e de identificação externos. autenticação: autenticação legal na autenticação existente: dispensa de p l a t a f o r m a ; i n t e g r a ç ã o c o m criação de registo na plataforma. certificado de assinatura: assinatura digital de documentos submetidos à plataforma.

Interface personalizável pelo utilizador Por determinar. mediante instalação de extensões adicionais como: Template Chooser (possibilidade de alterar aspecto visual do website) e dragdrop (permitindo aos utilizadores alterar a posição dos elementos – módulos – no ecrã)

Não permite essa funcionalidade.

Plone CMS

Não permite essa funcionalidade.

Não aplicável.

Visível a integração com as redes Não aplicável. sociais do facebook e twitter.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Por determinar.

Por determinar.

Por determinar.

iGoogle

Não aplicável.

Capacidade D1 de Exibição de Conteúdos

Não aplicável.

Capacidade de D2 Estruturação e Pesquisa de Conteúdos

Múltiplas possibilidades: search-box, pesquisa de conteúdos por secções e categorias; possibilidade de estruturação de conteúdos por tags.

Plataforma revela os seguintes Por determinar. conteúdos: apresentação, prémios, critérios, data limite de registo, registo online, submissão de propostas, data limite para submissão de propostas, anúncio dos resultados, direitos de propriedade intelectual, critérios de admissão, informação sobre o promotor, esclarecimento de dúvidas.

Plataforma revela os seguintes Não aplicável. conteúdos: sumário, júri, prémios, calendarização, custo de participação, FAQ, downloads, registo.

Múltiplas possibilidades: search-box, Múltiplas possibilidades: search-box, Por determinar. pesquisa de conteúdos por pesquisa de conteúdos por c a t e g o r i a s ; p o s s i b i l i d a d e d e categorias e tópicos. estruturação de conteúdos por tags.

Não permite pesquisa de conteúdos. Não aplicável. Impossibilidade de analisar estrutura (impossibilidade de aceder a área administrativa)

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

O interface é constituído por um O interface é constituído por dois menu (topo da página), área central menus (topo), área central de de conteúdos e footer. conteúdos, barra lateral esq. e barra lateral dir.

Possibilidade de personalização do interface modificando a visibilidade, posição e contexto das barras de ferramentas.

O interface é constituído por uma barra de ferramentas horizontal no topo – ribbon –, command-lineinterface – CLI – no fundo, área central de conteúdos e barras de ferramentas reposicionáveis.

I m p o s s í v e l a c e s s o à á r e a I m p o s s í v e l a c e s s o à á r e a Não aplicável. administrativa. administrativa.

Não aplicável.

Google Maps

Distinção simples entre convidados e Não efectua distinção de grupos de Não efectua distinção de grupos de Por determinar. utilizadores registados. Os últimos utilizadores. utilizadores. têm a possibilidade de guardar o interface por eles personalizado.

Utiliza os dados de registo do Google: Não aplicável. email, password (duplicado), localização.

Não existe integração com sistemas Não aplicável. de identificação externos.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Por determinar.

Autodesk Freewheel

OASRN

Delicious

StumbleUpon

Não efectua distinção de grupos de Efectua distinção entre convidados, utilizadores. membro regular e membro profissional. O último tem acesso à utilização do site com maior capacidade de armazenamento de conteúdos e de tráfego, e sem publicidade.

Efectua distinção entre arquitectos e convidados. Oferece uma área pessoal para o grupo dos arquitectos que lhe permite o acesso à área “Procura Arquitecto?”

Distinção simples entre convidados e utilizadores registados. Embora ambos possam aceder aos conteúdos, apenas os últimos têm a possibilidade de criar um directório de conteúdos pessoais e integrar esses conteúdos na rede social interna.

Distinção simples entre convidados e utilizadores registados. Apenas os utilizadores registados podem utilizar as funcionalidades da aplicação.

Não aplicável.

Para acesso á área pessoal é necessário: nome completo, número de membro da OA, estatuto, BI, nacionalidade, naturalidade, nascimento, sexo, morada, cód. postal, concelho, telefone, telemóvel, fax, email, website.

Não aplicável.

Issuu

Os dados de registo para utilizar o Issuu são: primeiro nome, último nome, nome de perfil, email, password, género, idade.

>

Para aceder ao Delicious é necessária Para aceder ao StumbleUpon é uma conta Yahoo!, logo os seguintes n e c e s s á r i o : u s e r n a m e , e m a i l , dados: primeiro nome, último nome, password, género, aniversário. género, aniversário, país, código postal, username, password (duplicado), email alternativo, pergunta secreta 1 e 2, resposta secreta 1 e 2.

>

Integração com mecanismo de Não existe integração com sistemas I n t e g r a ç ã o c o m o s i s t e m a d e I n t e g r a ç ã o c o m o s i s t e m a d e identificação existente: facebook de identificação externos. identificação externa yahoo! ID identificação externa facebook connect. (obrigatório) connect.

>

requisito funcional

requisito funcional

requisito funcional

Múltiplas possibilidade mediante Não integra * (impossível acesso à Não integra * (impossível acesso à Não aplicável. instalação de extensões adicionais. área administrativa) área administrativa)

Não aplicável.

eVolo

Sente

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Circuito de informação básico: o autor Não aplicável. dos conteúdos faz a sua publicação pública.

Circuito de informação básico: o autor Não aplicável. dos conteúdos faz a sua publicação pública.

>

requisito funcional

Possibilidade de selecção de miniaplicações a exibir no ecrã; possibilidade de ajuste da posição relativa das mini-aplicações no ecrã.

O interface é constituído por: header, barra lateral esquerda, e área central de conteúdos com módulos reposicionávels.

Possibilidade de personalizar a Não permite essa funcionalidade. interface: visibilidade/invisibilidade das barras de ferramentas, ícones e painéis da aplicação.

O interface de navegação progressiva por colunas é constituído por uma área central, cujos conteúdos vão sendo actualizados automaticamente à medida que se vão aplicando “filtros” na área de navegação por colunas.

Não aplicável.

O interface é constituído por três Não aplicável. faixas horizontais com igual importância; ausência de hierarquia para além do sentido ocidental de leitura; permite leitura global dos conteúdos.

As mini-aplicações constituem-se O Sente, como gestor bibliográfico, é I m p o s s í v e l a c e s s o à á r e a Não aplicável. como módulos que podem ser capaz de formatar bibliografia numa administrativa. acrescentados à plataforma. série de normas, cada uma delas funcionando como módulo; efectua ainda ligações a repositórios online, e cada repositório é, também, instalado como um destes módulos.

Múltiplas possibilidade mediante Não aplicável. instalação das miniaplicações.

Capacidade de Integração de Operadores Externos

Não aplicável.

D. Conteúdos

Matriz AICA

Não aplicável.

Wordpress

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Possibilidade de personalizar o Não permite essa funcionalidade. interface da publicação, quando disponibilizada em servidores externos; possibilidade de personalização de: exibir/ocultar botões de navegação, layout (slide, livro, página única em scroll-down).

O interface é constituído por menu O interface é constituído por header horizontal (barra de ferramentas no (funcionalidades do Issuu), área topo) e área central de conteúdos. central de conteúdos (para exibição da publicação), barra lateral direita (para exibição de publicações relacionadas) e footer (para informações adicionais).

Não aplicável.

Não permite essa funcionalidade.

Não permite essa funcionalidade.

requisito funcional

O interface do microsite é constituído O interface é constituído por header, O interface é constituído apenas por por coluna esq. com links para área central de conteúdos e barra um menu horizontal (no topo, com conteúdos específicos e coluna dir. lateral dir. opções de navegação e interacção) e com esses conteúdos aprofundados. área central de conteúdos.

>

requisito funcional

Impossível acesso à área Impossível acesso à área Impossível acesso à área Impossível acesso à área administrativa. administrativa. administrativa. administrativa.

>

requisito funcional

Não integra * (impossível acesso à Possível integração de informação Possível integração de dwf 2D e 3D. área administrativa) geográfica: mapas estáticos (static maps API); mapas dinâmicos (Maps Javascript API e Maps API for Flash); modelo 3D do globo terrestre (Google Earth API); mapas dinâmicos com dados associados (Maps Data API).

Possível integração de publicações Não integra * (impossível acesso à Não integra * (impossível acesso à Não integra * (impossível acesso à d i g i t a i s e m f o r m a t o P D F ; área administrativa) área administrativa) área administrativa) integração na rede social do Issuu.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

Não aplicável.

>

Não aplicável.

>

requisito funcional

M i c r o s i t e r e v e l a o s s e g u i n t e s Não aplicável. conteúdos: apresentação, sinopse, processo, notícias, resultados, contactos, FAQ, avisos + código.

Não aplicável.

>

requisito funcional

Não aplicável.

Por determinar.

Não permite pesquisa de conteúdos. Impossibilidade de analisar estrutura (impossibilidade de aceder a área administrativa)

Permite pesquisa por search-box. Não aplicável. Impossibilidade de analisar estrutura (impossibilidade de aceder a área administrativa)

Não aplicável.

Permite pesquisa e estruturação de conteúdos por: estado da referência (citado, não citado, etc.); classificação; tag; keywords bem como por cada item de campo bibliográfico (nome do autor, data de publicação, editora, etc.)

Não permite pesquisa de conteúdos. Por determinar. Impossibilidade de analisar estrutura (impossibilidade de aceder a área administrativa)

Não aplicável.

Permite estruturação de conteúdos Por determinar. por tipo (portfolio, revista, etc.); keywords, categoria, língua da publicação e destino da publicação; permite pesquisa de conteúdos com base nestes campos e noutros adicionais potenciados pela rede social interna: melhores classificados, novas adições, maior número de favoritos, mais populares e mais debatidos.

Estruturação dos conteúdos por URL, síntese, tags (constitui o bookmark); pesquisa por tags, tag bundles (associações de tags), e por utilizador – integração em rede social interna.

Estruturação dos conteúdos por áreas de interesse; pesquisa por utilizador – integração em rede social interna; e por área de interesse.

>

requisito funcional

CONCLUSÃO

@IE

FA*2),%#34()88

FA*2),%#34()

@IF

CONCLUSÃO

'

.+"+' +' !"%&%)*%' @#)@=1&3#' !+"%@%1b)#&' +,%I1+,#' +,#!*+"' #' 5%&5#' !"()@A!(#'

#",%)+,#"' I1%'%&*%?%' !"%&%)*%' )+' %=+B#"+>3#' ,+' 0(&&%"*+>3#' ,%' ;%&*"+,#' %' I1%'@#)&(&*(1R' %5' !"(5%("#' =1D+"R' )15+' "%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+' %5' *#")#' ,%' *%5]*(@+&' "%=%?+)*%&' !+"+' #' %&*1,#' YH&*+,#' ,+' 8"*%Z' I1%' )#&' @#),1K(1' :' +$%"(>3#' ,%' I1+*"#' *%5+&' %&&%)@(+(&' %' ,%' 15+' $"+5%S#"Q' %' 5+*"(K' ,%' +)]=(&%R' #' I1%' !#"' &1+' ?%K' )#&' @#),1K(1' :' ,%*%"5()+>3#' %' %&*"1*1"+>3#')%&&+'5+*"(K',%',%K'(),(@+,#"%&'(5!#"*+)*%&'!+"+'#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',+'8EG8/ '

8&&(5R' %5' H&*+,#' ,+'8"*%R'@+!A*1=#' #),%' $#"+5'+B#",+,+&' +&' *%5]*(@+&'sW#@(%,+,%'

,+' ()$#"5+>3#' %' ,+' @#51)(@+>3#tR' sG#)@1"&#' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' %' !+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+t' %' sG#51)(@+>3#' %'"%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,%'!"#N%@*#tR'@#5%>]5#&' !#"' ()*"#,1K("'#' @#)@%(*#',%'"%,%'%' @#)@=1A5#&' I1%' %&*%' &%' %)@#)*"+' @+,+' ?%K' 5+(&' !"%&%)*%' )#&' !"#@%&&#&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#R' %&*"1*1"+>3#R'5+)(!1=+>3#'%'*"+)&5(&&3#',%'()$#"5+>3#R'+"*(@1=+),#b&%'@#5'+'&#@(%,+,%'%'+&' "%=+>a%&' &#@(+(&' %&*+B%=%@(,+&' %)*"%' #&' (),(?A,1#&R' I1%' &%' @#)&*(*1%5' %&&%)@(+(&' !+"+' +' @#)&*"1>3#'I1+=(V(@+,+',#'*%@(,#'1"B+)#',+'@(,+,%/ '

4%@#)C%@%5#&' I1%' +&' "%,%&' ,(D(*+(&' %' +)+=JD(@+&' @#)*"(B1%5' ,%' $#"5+'

@#5!=%5%)*+"' !+"+'+'@#)&*"1>3#' ,#' *%@(,#'1"B+)#' ,+'@(,+,%R'5+&' I1%'+&' !"(5%("+&R' [email protected]%':&' @"%[email protected]%)*%&'[email protected](=(,+,%&',%'(5!=%5%)*+>3#R'&%'%)@#)*"+5'@+,+'?%K'5+(&'!"%&%)*%&'%5'*#,+&'+&' [email protected]*(?(,+,%&'C15+)+&R'&%N+5'%=+&'&#@(+(&R'%@#)J5(@+&'%'!#=A*(@+&-'#'(),(?A,1#' ,+'WEG'%L!"%&&+' +&&(5' @+,+'?%K'5+(&' )%@%&&(,+,%' %' ,%!%),M)@(+',#' ,(D(*+=R'!%"*%)@%),#' +' 15')^5%"#' @+,+' ?%K'5+(#"' ,%'"%,%&',(D(*+(&R' [email protected]%,%),#R'!"#,1K(),#'%'5+)(!1=+),#'15+'I1+)*(,+,%'@+,+'?%K' 5+(#"' ,%' @#)*%^,#&' 51=*(5%,(+R' @[email protected](,+,%&' !%"5(*(,+&' !%=+' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,%' +!=(@+>a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+&'@+,+'?%K'5+(&'!#,%"#&+&'%'$]@%(&',%'1*(=(K+"/ '

G#)*1,#R' @#)&*+*]5#&' I1%' +' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,%&*+&' +!=(@+>a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+&' %' ,+&' "%,%&'

,(D(*+(&' @#)&*(*1%5' &(51=*+)%+5%)*%' 15' B%)%[email protected](#' %' 15' !%"(D#' !+"+' #' (),(?A,1#' ,+'WEG')+' 5%,(,+' %5' I1%R' &%' !#"' 15' =+,#R' !%"5(*%5' 15+' 5+(#"' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' %' %L!"%&&3#R'!#"'#1*"#'!#,%5'!"#5#?%"'#' (&#=+5%)*#'%'+'5+)(!1=+>3#-'#'!"(5%("#R',%@#""%)*%' ,%'15+' !"#@1"+' %[email protected]%&&(?+' ,+'(,%)*(,+,%'#)=()%R'%'#' ^=*(5#' ,%@#""%)*%',+'@[email protected](,+,%'I1%'`' )%@%&&]"(+'!+"+'#!%"+"'+&'OEGR')%5'&%5!"%'[email protected]%&&A?%='+#'!^B=(@#'%5'D%"+=/ '

G#)@=1A5#&' I1%' #' @#)*%L*#' [email protected]*1+=' `' !"#[email protected](#' +#' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,%' $%""+5%)*+&'

*%@)#=JD(@+&'5+&'@#5!"%%),%5#&R'&#B"%*1,#R'I1%'*+='@#5#'15+'@(,+,%')3#'&%'@#)&*"J(')15' ,(+'X')%5'*3#' !#[email protected]#' &%',%&%)C+')15' 5#5%)*#' X'%&*%'@#)*%L*#' )3#' &1"D(1',#' )+,+R'5+&' $#(' +)*%&' #' "%&1=*+,#' ,%' 15+' [email protected]%&&3#' ,%' @#)I1(&*+&' )#&' ,#5A)(#&' ,+' @#51)(@+>3#' %' ,+' @#5!1*+>3#'I1%'*M5'?(),#'+'+=*%"+"'D"+,1+=5%)*%'#&'!"#@%&&#&'!"#,1*(?#&'%5'!"+*(@+5%)*%' *#,+&' +&' [email protected]*(?(,+,%&' C15+)+&R'()@=1&(?%')+'!%&+,+'5+I1()+'!"#,1*(?+',+'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'',+' @#)&*"1>3#/

@IG

@IH

'

8&&(5R'@#)&*+*]5#&'I1%'#'!"#D"%&&#')+']"%+',+'@#5!1*+>3#'&J'$#('!#&&A?%='5%,(+)*%'

15+' [email protected]%&&3#' ,%' ()?%)>a%&R' ,%&,%' #' 5#,%=#' *%J"(@#' ,+' ;]I1()+' ,%' O1"()D' :' &1+' 5+*%"(+=(K+>3#' )#' H0p8GR':'%?#=1>3#',#'()*%"[email protected]%',+&' =()C+&' ,%'@#5+),#' YG2EZ'+#' ()*%"[email protected]%' D"]V(@#'YTcEZ'%R' )#'5%"@+,#',+'+"I1(*%@*1"+R' )#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',%'+!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&' G80'%'yE;9'!+"+=%=+5%)*%R'?%"(V(@]5#&'I1%'#'!"#D"%&&#')+']"%+',+'E)*%")%*'&J'$#('(D1+=5%)*%' !#&&A?%='5%,(+)*%'(D1+='[email protected]%&&3#',%'()?%)>a%&R' ,%&,%'+'*%@)#=#D(+',%'@#51)(@+>3#',%',+,#&' !#"' [email protected]#*%&R' :' @"(+>3#' ,+&' !"(5%("+&' "%,%&' ,%' @#5!1*+,#"%&' Y+' 84.87HOZR' :'51=*(!=(@+>3#' ,%&&+&' "%,%&' %' !#&*%"(#"' +"*(@1=+>3#' YD"+>+&' +#' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,#' !"#*#@#=#' OG.ZR' :' ()?%)>3#',+'vvv'%R'[email protected]*1+=5%)*%R'+#'I1%'%)*%),%5#&'!#"'v%B'e/j-'+'@[email protected](,+,%',%'*#,#&'#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&',+'vvv'&%"%5' &(51=*+)%+5%)*%'#&' !"#,1*#"%&',#'&%1'@#)*%^,#R'!#&&(B(=(,+,%' @#)@%,(,+'!%=+&'+!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&'@+,+'?%K'5+(&',(&!#)A?%(&R'()*1(*(?+&'%'%V(@+K%&/ '

G#)@=1A5#&'+&&(5'I1%'?(?%5#&'15'@#)*%L*#'$+?#"]?%=')3#'&J'+#',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#',%'

+!=(@+>a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+&' @#5' %=%?+,+&' @[email protected](,+,%&' 51=*(5`,(+' YD"+>+&' +#&' +?+)>#&' *%@)#=JD(@#&' %' D%)%"+=(K+>3#' ,#' 1&#' ,#' @#5!1*+,#"' !%&&#+=Z' 5+&' *+5B`5' :' &1+' (5!=%5%)*+>3#'%5'"%,%R'&1!#"*+,+'!%=+'E)*%")%*'%'!%=+'&1+',(&!#)(B(=(,+,%R'!#"*+B(=(,+,%'%' @[email protected](,+,%',%'%L(B(>3#' ,%'@#)*%^,#&9'%$%@*(?+5%)*%R'+&' +!=(@+>a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+&R'*+='@#5#' +' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' &J' &%' %)*%),%5' !=%)+5%)*%' I1+),#' @#)$"#)*+,+&' @#5' #' @#)*%L*#' #),%' &%' ()&%"%5-'`'%=%'I1%',(*+'+&' #!#"*1)(,+,%&' %'+&' +5%+>+&R' %'#' 5#5%)*#' #!#"*1)#' !+"+'#' &%1' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#/ '

\'@#)*%L*#R'C#N%R' `'+I1%=%' #),%'#' @#5!1*+,#"' `' 15' #BN%@*#' ,#' I1#*(,(+)#/' \),%' +'

E)*%")%*' `' 15' #BN%@*#' ,#' I1#*(,(+)#/' \),%' +&' D%"+>a%&' 5+(&' N#?%)&' N]' )3#' @#)@%B%5' +' "%+=(,+,%' &%5' +5B#&/' H' #),%' #' @"%[email protected]%)*%' ()*%"%&&%' )+' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,%' !=+*+$#"5+&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#'D%)%"+=(&*+' )+' E)*%")%*' %'+' ,%B(=(,+,%'%@#)J5(@+'&1"D%5' @#5#' #!#"*1)(,+,%' !+"+'"%!%)&+"'+'=(D+>3#'%)*"%'+'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%'+'&#@(%,+,%/ '

G#)*1,#R'@#5#'?(5#&R')3#'`'+',(&!#)(B(=(,+,%',%'15+'*%@)#=#D(+'I1%'@#),1KR'!#"'&('

&JR'+#'&%1'[email protected]%&&#-'`')%@%&&]"(#R' &#B"%*1,#R' 15'5#*(?#'I1%'N1&*(V(I1%'+'&1+'1*(=(K+>3#/'HR')#' @+&#',+'8EG8R' @#)@=1A5#&'I1%' %&&%'5#*(?#' `'+'#!*(5(K+>3#' ,#&' !"#@%&&#&' %' +"*(@1=+>3#' ,+&' %I1(!+&'51=*(,([email protected](!=()+"%&')#&'@#)@1"&#&' ,%'+"I1(*%@*1"+R'@#5'?(&*+'*+5B`5' :'()*%D"+>3#',+' &#@(%,+,%'@(?(='%'@#)&%I1%)*%'!"#5#>3#',+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+/ '

H&*+' @#)@=1&3#' &J' $#(' !#&&A?%=' 5%,(+)*%' #' "%@#)C%@(5%)*#' ,+' @"%[email protected]%)*%'

@#5!=%L(,+,%'I1%'%)?#=?%'+'&#@(%,+,%'@#)*%5!#"_)%+'%'I1%' &%'"%V=%@*%'()%?(*+?%=5%)*%')+' +"I1(*%@*1"+R' 5#*(?+,+' !%=+&' 5+(#"%&' )%@%&&(,+,%&' ,%' @#)$#"*#R' &%D1"+)>+'%' I1+=(,+,%')3#' &J' ,+' #B"+' %5' &(R' 5+&' *+5B`5' ,+'&1+' %)?#=?%)*%/' G#5' %$%(*#R' @#)&*+*]5#&' I1%' +' #B"+',%' +"I1(*%@*1"+' `' @+,+' ?%K'5%)#&' %)*%),(,+' @#5#' !%>+' (&#=+,+' !+"+' &%"' @+,+' ?%K'5+(&' ?(&*+' @#5#'!+"*%',#'@#5!=%L#' &(&*%5+',+'@(,+,%R'@1N#'%I1(=AB"(#' ,%!%),%',+'[email protected]>3#' @##",%)+,+',%' *#,#&'#&'[email protected]*#"%&'%)?#=?(,#&')+'&1+'@#)&*"1>3#/

CONCLUSÃO

'

6#('+&&(5'I1%'%)*%),%5#&'#'@#)@1"&#',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+-'@#5#'15+'#!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+'

!"#5#?%"'%&*+'[email protected]>3#'()*%D"+,+'%'#',%B+*%'%5' *#")#' ,+&'!#&&A?%(&' &#=1>a%&R' !+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' )%@%&&]"(#')#&'!"#N%@*#&'I1%'+)*%?M%5'D"+),%&'*"+)&$#"5+>a%&' ,#'%&!+>#'!^B=(@#/'6#(')%&*%' ,#5A)(#'I1%'"%@#)C%@%5#&'+'@"%[email protected]%)*%'?#)*+,%'%5'()*%D"+"'+'&#@(%,+,%'@(?(=')+&',([email protected]&&a%&' &#B"%'#'+5B(%)*%'@#)&*"1A,#R' +'"%&!#)&+B(=(,+,%',+&'+&&#@(+>a%&' %'!"]*(@+&' !"#V(&&(#)+(&')+' !"#5#>3#',%&&+'()*%D"+>3#'%R'&#B"%*1,#R'+')%@%&&(,+,%',%'"%@#)C%@%"'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+' @#5#' 15' !"#@%&&#' ?+)*+N#&#' !+"+' *#,+&' +&' !+"*%&' %)?#=?(,+&' @+!+K',%' +N1,+"' +' !"#5#?%"' 15+'5%=C#"'I1+=(,+,%',+'+"I1(*%@*1"+'%',#'+5B(%)*%'@#)&*"1A,#/ '

0%' [email protected]*#R' @#)&*+*]5#&' I1%' +' !"#5#>3#' ,+' !+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+' `' ,%$%),(,+' !#"'

?]"(#&' +1*#"%&' I1%' "%@#)C%@%5' )%=+' +' 5+(&b?+=(+' I1%' "%$%"(5#&/' 7#' %)*+)*#R' @#)&*+*]5#&' *+5B`5'I1%'%&&%'"%@#)C%@(5%)*#')3#'&%'*"+,1K')+'&1+'%$%@*(?+'+!=(@+>3#'!"]*(@+/ '

4%?%=#1b&%'+&&(5')%@%&&]"(#',%*%"5()+"'#&'@#),(@(#)+)*%&':'%$%@*(?+'(5!=%5%)*+>3#'

,+'!+"*(@(!+>3#'!^B=(@+R'B%5' @#5#' !#&&A?%(&'"%&!#&*+&' @+!+K%&',%'#&'5()(5(K+"'#1'%=(5()+"/' 8$%"(5#&' +&&(5' +' %L(&*M)@(+' ,%' ?]"(#&' %)*"+?%&' :' !+"*(@(!+>3#R' @#5#' #' @+"]@*%"' N#?%5' ,+' ,%5#@"[email protected](+' %' ,+'!"#V(&&3#',%'+"I1(*%@*#' %5' .#"*1D+=R'#'%=(*(&5#' %'#' (&#=+5%)*#'!"#V(&&(#)+=' ,+',([email protected](!=()+' [email protected]%'+'#1*"+&' ]"%+&' ,#' @#)C%@(5%)*#' %' +#'!^B=(@#R' +' +1&M)@(+',%' 15' @#)*%L*#' !#=A*(@#' %' ()&*(*[email protected](#)+=' +,%I1+,#R' +' $+=*+' ,%' %L!%"(M)@(+' ,#' !^B=(@#' %5' 5+*`"(+' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+'%'+'&1+',%[email protected]"%)>+')+&'%&*"1*1"+&'"%&!#)&]?%(&'!%=+'!"#5#>3#',+'!+"*(@(!+>3#R'#' "%@%(#' ,%' +*"+&#&' )#' &(&*%5+' !"#,1*(?#' %' +' %[email protected]%&&(?+' C(%"+"I1(K+>3#' ,+' @#51)(@+>3#/' H5' "%&!#&*+' +' %&*%&' !"#B=%5+&' (),(@]5#&' !#&&A?%(&' 5%,(,+&' +' *#5+"R' @#5#' +' +,#!>3#' ,%' 15' 5#,%=#' ,%' %L%"@[email protected](#' !"#V(&&(#)+=' @%)*"+,#' )+' ()?%&*(D+>3#' 51=*(,([email protected](!=()+"R' +' $#"5+>3#' ,#' @=(%)*%')#' &%)*(,#',%'=C%'+!"%&%)*+"'+'!+"*(@(!+>3#' @#5#'15' ()?%&*(5%)*#'+'=#)D#'!"+K#R' '+' @#""%@*+'+,%I1+>3#',#&'!"#@%&&#&',%'!+"*(@(!+>3#'+#'*(!#',%'%,([email protected](#'#1'%&!+>#'+'!"#N%@*+"R'+' ()*%D"+>3#' ,+' !+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+' %5' *#,+&' +&' $+&%&' ,%' !"#N%@*#R' %' +' +,#!>3#' ,%' 15+' %&*"+*`D(+' ,%' @#=+B#"+>3#' V=%LA?%=' %)*"%' !"#5#*#"%&' %' #' !^B=(@#R' %&*+),#' %&*%' +' !+"' ,#&' "%@1"&#&R'@#),(@(#)+)*%&'%'#BN%@*(?#&',#'!"#@%&&#',+'!+"*(@(!+>3#/ '

E,%)*(V(@]5#&' #&' !"#B=%5+&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#'@#5#' 15+' "+K3#'!+"+' #' !+"@#'%&!A"(*#'

!+"*(@(!+*(?#'I1%'5#?%'+'&#@(%,+,%'I1+),#'&%'!"#@1"+'#',%B+*%'&#B"%'+'G(,+,%/'7#'%)*+)*#R'`' %&&+'5%&5+'&#@(%,+,%'I1%'1*(=(K+'%5'=+"D+'%[email protected]+=+'+!=(@+>a%&'()$#"5]*(@+&',%'@+"]@*%"'=^,(@#R' %' $+K%5b)#' !#"I1%' %=+&' !%"5(*%5' 15+' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' %' ,%' ()*%"[email protected]>3#' @+*(?+)*%&/ '

4%D"%&&]5#&' +&&(5' :&' +!=(@+>a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+' %' :' 8EG8' !+"+' @#)@=1("' I1%' +'

!+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+' !#,%' &%"' %$%@*(?+5%)*%' @#)&%D1(,+' 5%,(+)*%' +' 1*(=(K+>3#' ,%' $%""+5%)*+&' ,%' @#51)(@+>3#' +&&%)*%&' )+&' OEG' %' )+' E)*%")%*' @+!+K%&' ,%' ()*%D"+"' +' @#5!=%L(,+,%',#&'!"#@%&&#&R'+&'()#?+>a%&')+'5%*#,#=#D(+',%'!"#N%@*#'%'#&')#?#&'5`*#,#&',%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#'%'@#51)(@+>3#',%'!"#N%@*#R'@#)*%^,#&'%&&%)@(+(&',+'8EG8/

@II

@I<

'

.+"+' +=`5' ,#' @#)*%L*#' %' ,#' 5#*(?#R' +' @[email protected](,+,%' "%?%=#1b&%' +' *%"@%("+' %' ^=*(5+'

!+=+?"[email protected]+?%',+'"%?(&3#' =(*%"]"(+'%$%@*1+,+')#'@+!A*1=#' H&*+,#',+'8"*%/' W#B' %=+'@#)@=1A5#&' I1%'+' 8EG8' ,%?%"]'&%"' @+!+K' ,%'@#51)(@+"' @#)*%^,#&',15' !#)*#',%'?(&*+' +"I1(*%@*J)(@#' %' )3#' +!%)+&' *%@)#=JD(@#R' ,%' $#"5+' +' [email protected](=(*+"' +' &1+' @#5!"%%)&3#' !#"' !+"*%' ,%' 15' !^B=(@#' +=+"D+,#/' G#)@=1A5#&' I1%' +' @#51)(@+>3#' ,%' !"#N%@*#' %' ,#' &%1' @#)*%L*#' `' 15' $%)J5%)#' @#5!=%L#'I1%')3#',%!%),%'+!%)+&',%'I1%5'@"(+'+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'5+&'*+5B`5',%'I1%5'+&' =MR'%')%&&%'&%)*(,#' "%@#)C%@%5#&' I1%'+&' ,($%"%)>+&' @1=*1"+(&'%'!"#V(&&(#)+(&'%)*"%'#&' ?]"(#&' =%(*#"%&',%&*+&'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&'()V=1%)@(+5'+'&1+'@[email protected](,+,%',%'+&' !%"@%B%"R'!+"*(@1=+"5%)*%' +&' 5+(&' +B&*"[email protected]*+&' %' *`@)(@+&' @#5#' +&' !=+)*+&R' @#"*%&' %' #&' +=>+,#&/' 0%*%"5()]5#&' +&&(5' +' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,+' 8EG8' &%"' @+!+K' ,%' ()*%D"+"' ?]"(#&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' @#5!=%5%)*+"%&R' @+!+K%&' ,%' %&*(51=+"' #&' ?]"(#&' &%)*(,#&' C15+)#&' %' ,%' !"#5#?%"' +' +1*#)#5(+',#'1*(=(K+,#"'+*"+?`&',%'15+'5+(#"'()*%"[email protected]*(?(,+,%',#&'5#,%=#&'%'"%!"%&%)*+>a%&/' 4%$%"(5#&' *+5B`5' +' (5!#"*_)@(+' ,+' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' ,#&' !"#N%@*#&' &1N%(*#&' +' ,([email protected]&&3#' !^B=(@+' &%"' $%(*+'!#"' %)*(,+,%&' %L*%")+&R' !%"5(*(),#' +&&(5' 15+' =%(*1"+'5+(&' (5!+"@(+=',+&' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&'%'15+'@#5!+"+>3#'5+(&'%I1(*+*(?+'%)*"%'#&'!"#N%@*#&/ '

.#"' ^=*(5#R' @#)@=1A5#&' I1%' #&' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' +' 1&+"' ,%?%5' &%"'

+,%I1+,#&' +#&' #BN%@*(?#&' ,+' @#51)(@+>3#R' ,%?%),#b&%' 1*(=(K+"R' *%),%)@(+=5%)*%R' "%!"%&%)*+>a%&' 5+(&' =JD(@+&' %' +B&*"[email protected]*+&' I1+),#'&%' !"#@1"+' ()$#"5+"' +'@#)&*"1>3#' ,%'15+' #B"+',%'+"I1(*%@*1"+R' %' 1*(=(K+"'?+"(+,#&' *(!#&',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#' @#5!=%5%)*+"%&'I1+),#' &%' !"%*%),%'=+)>+"'15+',([email protected]&&3#'@"A*(@+'%5'*#")#',+&'&#=1>a%&'!"#!#&*+&9'@#)@=1A5#&'*+5B`5' I1%' %&&%&' 5`*#,#&' ,%?%5' &%"' +,%I1+,#&' +#&' ,%&*()+*]"(#&' ,+' @#51)(@+>3#R' ,%?%),#b&%' 1*(=(K+"' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' !=1"+(&' %' @#5!=%5%)*+"%&' I1+),#' +' @#51)(@+>3#' `' ,("(D(,+' +' %&!%@(+=(&*+&R' %' 1*(=(K+"' 5`*#,#&' ,%' "%!"%&%)*+>3#' 5+(&' "%+=(&*+&' I1+),#' +' @#51)(@+>3#' `' ,%&*()+,+' +' )3#b%&!%@(+=(&*+&R' !"#@1"+),#' +' &1+' +"*(@1=+>3#' @#5' #1*"#&' 5`*#,#&',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'5+(&'@+!+K%&',%'%L!=(@+"'+'=JD(@+',#&'!"#N%@*#&/ '

G#5!"%%),%5#&'+&&(5'I1%'+'+"I1(*%@*1"+',(&!a%',%'5`*#,#&',%'"%!"%&%)*+>3#'@+,+'

?%K' 5+(&' %V(@+K%&' %' I1%' %&&%&' 5`*#,#&' !#,%5' %' ,%?%5' &%"' 1*(=(K+,#&' %5' +!=(@+>a%&' ()$#"5]*(@+&'I1%'=C%&'+15%)*%5'+'()*%"[email protected]*(?(,+,%/'3#' %' +"*(@1=+>3#' ,#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' ,+' +!=(@+>3#' ()$#"5]*(@+ZR' #' ()*%"[email protected]%' YI1%' %)D=#B+"(+' (),(@+,#"%&' "%=+*(?#&' :'%L!"%&&3#' 5+(&' ,("%@*+',+' +!=(@+>3#R' B%5' @#5#' +' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' +' @#5!"%%),%"' %' !%"&#)+=(K+"ZR' +' %&*"1*1"+' YI1%' %)D=#B+"(+' (),(@+,#"%&' "%=+*(?#&' +#' $1)@(#)+5%)*#' %&*"1*1"+=' ,+' +!=(@+>3#' ()$#"5]*(@+R' ,%&(D)+,+5%)*%'+'&1+'@[email protected](,+,%',%'@#5!#&(>3#'!#"'5J,1=#&'%'!#&&(B(=(,+,%',%'+"*(@1=+>3#' @#5'#!%"+,#"%&' %L*%")#&'%L(&*%)*%&Z'%'#'@#)*%^,#'YI1%'%)D=#B+"(+' (),(@+,#"%&' "%=+*(?#&' +#' *(!#R' %&*"1*1"+' %'@[email protected](,+,%',%' !%&I1(&+' ,+'()$#"5+>3#' I1%'+'8EG8' ,%?%"(+' ,(&!#)(B(=(K+"Z/' G#)@=1A5#&' +&&(5' +' (5!#"*_)@(+' ,#' 1*(=(K+,#"' Y+' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%&*%' @#)&*(*1("' +' &1+' (,%)*(,+,%' #)=()%' %' #' &%1' &%)*(,#' ,%' !%"*%)>+' :' "%,%ZR' +' (5!#"*_)@(+' ,+' ()*%"[email protected]%' Y+' &1+' @[email protected](,+,%',%'+*"+("'#1'+$+&*+"'#&'1*(=(K+,#"%&ZR' +'(5!#"*_)@(+',+'%&*"1*1"+'Y+'@#)@%!>3#',%' 15+' +!=(@+>3#' @#5#' 15' #BN%@*#' s?(?#t' @+!+K' ,%' %?#=1("' %' &%' "%[email protected](#)+"' @#5' #1*"+&' +!=(@+>a%&Z'%'+'(5!#"*_)@(+',#'@#)*%^,#'Y&%5' #' I1+=')3#' !#,%'%L(&*("'8EG8R' %'I1%',%?%' &%"' %)*%),(,#' )#' @#)*%L*#' ,+'v%B' e/jR'#),%' %=%'`'!"#,1K(,#'!%=#&' !"J!"(#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' I1%' &%' "%[email protected](#)+5'%)*"%'&('%'@#5'#&'&%1&'@#)*%^,#&Z/ '

H&*%&' I1+*"#' *%5+&' $#"+5' %)*3#' ()*%D"+,#&' )15+' $"+5%S#"Q' ,%' +)]=(&%' I1%' &%'

*"+,1K(1' )15' 5#,%=#' ,%' 5+*"(K' !+"+' #' "%D(&*#' ,+&' "%&!#&*+&' +#&' (),(@+,#"%&' !+"+' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+' 8EG8/' H&&+' $"+5%S#"Q' !%"5(*(1' +' +"*(@1=+>3#' ,%' ,(?%"&#&' @#)@%(*#&R' @#5#'#'N]'"%$%"(,#' *%5+'Y%)*%),(,#' @#5#' 15+'1)(,+,%'=JD(@+',%'%)I1+,"+5%)*#',%',#(&'#1' 5+(&' (),(@+,#"%&ZR' #' (),(@+,#"' Y%)*%),(,#' @#5#' 15+' @+"[email protected]*%"A&*(@+' ,%' #",%5' I1+=(*+*(?+' :' I1+=' +' 8EG8' ,%?%"(+' ,+"' "%&!#&*+ZR' +' $#)*%' Y%)*%),(,+' @#5#' +' #"(D%5' ,%' 15+' #1' 5+(&' "%&!#&*+&'@#)@"%*+&'+'15'#1'5+(&'(),(@+,#"%&ZR'+'?+"(]?%='Y%)*%),(,+'@#5#'%&&+'"%&!#&*+Z'%'#' "%I1(&(*#' $1)@(#)+=' Y%)*%),(,#' @#5#' 15+' ,%V()(>3#' !"%@(&+' ,%' 15+' $1)@(#)+=(,+,%' +' (5!=%5%)*+"' )+' 8EG8R' ,%*%"5()+,+' !+"+' @+,+' (),(@+,#"' %' *%),#' %5' @#)&(,%"+>3#' +&' !#&&A?%(&'?+"(]?%(&Z/

@IB

@3#' ,%' +!=(@+>a%&' %L(&*%)*%&' @#5#'

B+&%R' $#(' !#&&A?%=' @#)@=1("' ,%K' (),(@+,#"%&' %&&%)@(+(&' !+"+' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+' 8EG8-' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' "%D(&*#' ,%' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' YI1%' &%' !"%),%' @#5' +' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' !%"5(*("' +#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' "%D(&*+"%5b&%')+'+!=(@+>3#R'@"(+),#' +A'+'&1+'(,%)*(,+,%'#)=()%')%@%&&]"(+'!+"+'+' ?(&1+=(K+>3#' %' ()*%"[email protected]>3#' @#5' #&' @#)*%^,#&' %' #1*"#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&Z9' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' %&*"1*1"+>3#' ,%' D"1!#&' ,%' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' YI1%' ,(K' "%&!%(*#' :' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' %&*"1*1"+"' #&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' !#"' D"1!#&R' !%"5(*(),#' +&&(5' +' ,(&*"(B1(>3#' ,%'@[email protected](,+,%&' %'!%"5(&&a%&R' %' +' +,%I1+>3#' ,#&'@#)*%^,#&'+',%*%"5()+,#&' *(!#&' ,%'1*(=(K+,#"%&Z9'[email protected](=(,+,%',%'()*%D"+>3#' %5' &(&*%5+&',%' (,%)*(V(@+>3#'%L(&*%)*%&' YI1%'&%'"%$%"%':')%@%&&(,+,%',%R'!#"' 15'=+,#R'[email protected](=(*+"' #' [email protected]%&&#' :' +!=(@+>3#R' %R' !#"' #1*"#R' @#5' +' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' !"#5#?%"' 15+' 1*(=(K+>3#' &`"(+' ,+' 5%&5+R' ,%&(D)+,+5%)*%' )#' @15!"(5%)*#' ,%' $1)>a%&' I1%' %L(N+5' +' "%&!#)&+B(=(K+>3#' ,#&' &%1&' +D%)*%&Z9' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' %&*"1*1"+>3#' ,%' @("@1(*#&' ,+' ()$#"5+>3#' YI1%' &%' "%!#"*+' :' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' %&*+B%=%@%"' #&' !"#@%&&#&' %' +' !+&&+D%5' ,+' ()$#"5+>3#' %)*"%' D"1!#&' ,%' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' )#' ,%@#""%"' ,%&&%' !"#@%&&#Z9' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' !%"&#)+=(K+>3#' ,+' ()*%"[email protected]%' YI1%' @#5!"%%),%' +' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' @+*(?+"' #' 1*(=(K+,#"' %'$#")%@%"b=C%' 15' !"#,1*#' +,%I1+,#' :&' &1+&' )%@%&&(,+,%&R' !%"5(*(),#b=C%' +=*%"+"' ,%*%"5()+,#&' +&!%@*#&' ,+' !"J!"(+' +!=(@+>3#Z9' [email protected](=(,+,%' ,%'@#5!"%%)&3#',+'()*%"[email protected]%' YI1%'"%5%*%'!+"+'+' )%@%&&(,+,%',%'!"#!#"@(#)+"' +#' 1*(=(K+,#"' 15+' +!=(@+>3#' @+!+K' ,%' *"+)&5(*("' #&' @#)*%^,#&' @#5' @=+"%K+' %' &%5' "1A,#' #1' ,(&*"[email protected]>a%&' I1%' (5!%>+5' #1' !"%N1,(I1%5' +' *"+)&5(&&3#' ,+' 5%)&+D%5Z9' @[email protected](,+,%' ,%' @#5!#&(>3#'5#,1=+"'YI1%'(),(@(+'+')%@%&&(,+,%',%',%&%)?#=?%"'15+'+!=(@+>3#'@#5!#&*+'!#"' #BN%@*#&' ()*%"=(D+,#&' 5+&' !#&&A?%(&' ,%' @#)V(D1"+"' +1*#)#5+5%)*%R' @#)@%B%),#' +' +!=(@+>3#' ()$#"5]*(@+' @#5#' 15' *#,#' @#5!#&*#' !#"' ,(?%"&+&' !+"*%&' ()*%"=(D+,+&' I1%' !#,%5R' +' ,+,#' 5#5%)*#R' &%"' "%5#?(,+&' #1' +,(@(#)+,+&' &%5' !"%N1AK#' ,+' +!=(@+>3#' D=#B+=Z9' @[email protected](,+,%',%' ()*%D"+>3#' ,%' #!%"+,#"%&' %L*%")#&' YI1%' &%' "%[email protected](#)+' @#5' +' )%@%&&(,+,%' ,%' +"*(@1=+"' ,%*%"5()+,#&' &%"?(>#&' ,(&!#)(B(=(K+,#&' !#"' %)*(,+,%&' %L*%")+&' )+' E)*%")%*' %' @+!+K%&' ,%' %L%@1*+"' %V(@+K5%)*%' ,%*%"5()+,+&' *+"%$+&R' %?(*+),#' +&&(5' #' ,%&!%",[email protected](#' ,%' *%5!#' %' "%@1"&#&')#' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,%'$%""+5%)*+&'I1%'N]' &%'%)@#)*"+5' ,(&!#)A?%(&'%'[email protected]%&&A?%(&Z9' @[email protected](,+,%',%'%L(B(>3#' ,%'@#)*%^,#&' YI1%' &%'*"+,1K')+')%@%&&(,+,%',%',%*%"5()+"'I1+(&'#&' @#)*%^,#&'I1%'+'8EG8',%?%"]',(&!#)(B(=(K+"'+#&'&%1&'1*((K+,#"%&Z9'%R'V()+=5%)*%R'@[email protected](,+,%' ,%'%&*"1*1"+>3#' %' !%&I1(&+' ,%' @#)*%^,#&' YI1%' &%'5+)($%&*+' )+' )%@%&&(,+,%',%'#$%"%@%"' #&' @#)*%^,#&' +#&' 1*(=(K+,#"%&' ,+' $#"5+' 5+(&' [email protected]%&&A?%=' !#&&A?%=R' 1=*"+!+&&+),#' +' B+""%("+' ,+' 5%"+' #"D+)(K+>3#' !#"' ,("%@*#"(+&' %' #$%"%@%),#' @#)*%^,#&' %&*"1*1"+,#&' )15+' "%,%' ,%' @#)@%(*#&Z/ '

8&' "%&!#&*+&' @#)@"%*+&' +' %&*%&' (),(@+,#"%&' $#"+5' %)*3#' "%D(&*+,+&' )+' 5+*"(K' @1N+'

@#)V(D1"+>3#',%@#""%1R'@#5#'?(5#&R',+'"%&*"1*1"+>3#' %5'D"%=C+',#&' @#)@%(*#&',%*%"5()+,#&' )+'$"+5%S#"Q'+)+=A*(@+/

CONCLUSÃO

'

0%*%"5()+5#&' +&&(5' (),(@+,#"%&' !+"+' #' ,%&%)?#=?(5%)*#' ,+'+!=(@+>3#' ()$#"5]*(@+'

5+&R'&#B"%*1,#R' @"(+5#&' 15+'5+*"(K' @+!+K' ,%'D1(+"' #' )#&&#' !%"@1"&#' )+' !"#@1"+' ,%' 5+(&/' ;%,(+)*%'+'+)]=(&%',%'?]"(+&'+!=(@+>a%&' %L(&*%)*%&')#'5%"@+,#'+$%"(5#&'%'"%D(&*]5#&'+&'&1+&' "%&!#&*+&'+'%&&%&'5%&5#&'(),(@+,#"%&/ '

8' 8EG8'*%5' I1%'+!"%),%"' @#5' %&*+&' +!=(@+>a%&R' !#(&' #&' !"J!"(#&' !"()@A!(#&' I1%'+&'

5#?%5' &3#' +I1%=%&' ,%' I1%' )%@%&&(*+5#&/'73#' $#('!#"'[email protected]+&#'I1%' %&*+&' +!=(@+>a%&' D%)`"(@+&' $#"+5'@#=#@+,+&' =+,#' +'=+,#'@#5'+!=(@+>a%&' %&!%@AV(@+&',("(D(,+&' +#'5%"@+,#',#'@#)@1"&#',%' +"I1(*%@*1"+9'+'%&*"+*`D(+'&%"?(1'!+"+' @#)&*+*+"'I1%'+&'^=*(5+&' +(),+'$1)@(#)+5' +I1`5' ,+&' !#&&(B(=(,+,%&' I1%' #' @#5!1*+,#"'%' +' E)*%")%*' !%"5(*%5-')+'5+(#"(+' ,#&' @+&#&R' +'+!=(@+>3#' !+"+' @#)@1"&#&' ,%' +"I1(*%@*1"+'+,#!*+' 15' !+!%='!+&&(?#'!+"+' @#5' #' 1*(=(K+,#"R'$#")%@%b=C%' #&' @#)*%^,#&' ,%'$#"5+'!#[email protected]#' ()*1(*(?+R' %')3#'=C%'#$%"%@%'C(!J*%&%&',%' @#51)(@+"' !+"+'+=`5' ,%'15'%),%"%>#',%'%5+(=/ '

O%"5()+5#&' %&*+' 0(&&%"*+>3#' +V("5+),#' +' )#&&+' @"%)>+' ,%' I1%' +&' +!=(@+>a%&'

()$#"5]*(@+&' @#)*()1+"3#'+'()V=1%)@(+"'+'$#"5+',%'@#)@%B%"'%'@#51)(@+"'+"I1(*%@*1"+R',%&*+' ?%KR' ,%'$#"5+' 5+(&' [email protected]%&&A?%=' %' +' 15' !^B=(@#' 5+(&' +=+"D+,#/' W%5' !%",%"' +&' I1+=(,+,%&' %' +' +1*#)#5(+' ,+' ]"%+' ,([email protected](!=()+"' ,%' #),%' #&' #"(D()]"(#&R' ,%?%5#&' +B"+>+"' +' 51=*(,([email protected](!=()+"(,+,%'@#5#'15+'#!#"*1)(,+,%'!+"+'@"(+"'&#=1>a%&'%'"%&!#&*+&'+#&'!"#B=%5+&' ,+'&#@(%,+,%' @#)*%5!#"_)%+/' 8' !+"*(@(!+>3#' !^B=(@+' !#&&1(R' %5' %&&M)@(+R'+',(&!#)(B(=(,+,%' !+"+'+'+B"+>+"/ '

[email protected]"%,(*+5#&'I1%R'!+"+'#'[email protected]%&&#',#'084GR'*%#"(+'%'!"]*(@+',%?%5'&%"'*"+B+=C+,+&'%5'

@#)N1)*#-'%&*+'%&*"+*`D(+'N]'&%'"%?%=#1'!"#?%(*#&+'!+"+'+'!"%&%)*%'0(&&%"*+>3#' )+'5%,(,+'%5' I1%'+'%L!%"(5%)*+>3#'!"]*(@+',%'+=D15+&' ,+&'+!=(@+>a%&'I1%'%&*1,]5#&R')#5%+,+5%)*%')+' @"(+>3#' ,#&' !"#*J*(!#&' !+"+' +' !=+*+$#"5+' @#=+B#"+*(?+' ,#' !"#N%@*#' ,#' Hb2%+")()D' G+$`' )#' !8[&11($$&13.&4

REFERÊNCIAS

@3#' $#"*%{' %' {+&&()+*1"+' ,(D(*+=' I1+=(V(@+,+{Ä' /' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/@+"*+#,%@(,+,+#/!*o(),%L/!C!Ä' #!*(#)á@#5à@#)*%)*F*+&Qá?(%SF(,ágnFE*%5(,' ágiF=+)Dá!* 8=B%"*R'F'.+&&5#"%/'YejjnZ/![-7=/:!E$=-&!$.0!6$#2/:/6$2/(.h!Z!=/2&#$2-#&!#&E/&'!"(#!2,&!1:(22/1,! ;(E&#.%&.2/'[email protected]#*=+),-'W@#**(&C'T#?%")5%)*'W#@(+='4%&%+"@C/ 8=%L+),%"/' YdqmjZ/' ^(2&1! (.! 2,&! 13.2,&1/1! ("! "(#%4! G+5B"(,D%R' ;[email protected]&%**&-' z+"?+",' c)(?%"&(*P'."%&&/'Y\"(D()+='S#"Q'!1B=(&C%,'dqlhZ 8=?%&/'YejjdZ/'[=$.&$%&.2(!:(=$7(#$2/E(!&%!:(.2&`2(1!0&!#&;&.&#$TF(! -#7$.$4!.#"*#-'68c.'o' 6Hc.'Y;%&*"+,#'%5'.=+)%+5%)*#'%'."#N%@*#',#'85B(%)*%'c"B+)#Z/ 8")&*%()/' YdqlqZ/' 8' =+,,%"' #$' @(*(K%)' !+"*(@(!+*(#)/' v(-#.$=! ("! 2,&! Z%&#/:$.! 5.12/2-2&! ("! [=$..R'nCYhZ/ 8"I1(*%@*15/' YejdjZ/' 8"I1(*%@*15-' 8"@C(*%@*1"%' @#5!%*(*(#)&' +),' %?%)*&/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/+"I1(*%@*15/@#5o(),%L/!C! [email protected]%"/'YdqqlZ/'R&2$6(=/1h!Z:&#:$!0(!"-2-#(!0$!:/0$0&4!\%("+&-'G%=*+/ 81"(D(/' YejjeZ/' 2(,+),#' @#5' +' @(,+,%' ,(D(*+=' ,%///' f1%' $1*1"#Ä' E)' 8$#)&#' F' 61"*+,#' YH,&/ZR' Z#G-/2&:2-#$!&!1(:/&0$0&!0$!/."(#%$TF(4!.#"*#-';()(&*`"(#',+'G1=*1"+/ 81*#,%&QR' E)@/' YejjqZ/' 81*#,%&Q' $"%%SC%%=/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo $"%%SC%%=/+1*#,%&Q/@#5o 81*#,%&QR' E)@/' Yejdj+Z/' 81*#,%&Q' +"@C(*%@*1"%' B1(=,()D' ()$#"5+*(#)' 5#,%=()D' &#$*S+"%/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo1&+/+1*#,%&Q/@#5o+,&Qo&%"?=%*[email protected](),%LÄ &(*%E0ádegddeF(,ágmndngd 81*#,%&QR' E)@/' YejdjBZ/' 81*#,%&Q' b' +1*#,%&Q' B1KK&+S/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo1&+/+1*#,%&Q/@#5o+,&Qo&%"?=%*[email protected](),%LÄ&(*%E0ádegddeF(,áehjmnqn y+"Q%"b.=155%"/'YejjhZ/'O1"()D'[email protected]()%&'Y&*+)$#",'%)@[email protected]=#!%,(+'#$'!C(=#&#!CPZ/'É.]D()+',+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-oo!=+*#/&*+)$#",/%,1o%)*"(%&o*1"()[email protected]()%o y%+1"%D+",/'YdqqlZ/'y%*S%%)'5#,%")(*P'+),'!#&*5#,%")(*P/'E)'G+5!B%=='F'6+()&*%()'YH,&/ZR' ]&$0/.;1!/.!6=$../.;!2,&(#34!\L$#",R'c[-'[email protected]%=='.1B=(&C()D/ y%)*=%P'WP&*%5&'E)@#"!#"+*%,/'YejdjZ/'y1(=,()D'()$#"5+*(#)'5#,%=()D'b'B%)*=%P'+"@C(*%@*1"%/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/B%)*=%P/@#5o%)b1&o!"#,[email protected]*&oB%)*=%P â+"@C(*%@*1"%o y#P,R'F'GC+)/'YejjeZ/'[email protected]%5+Q()D'*##=&'$#"'@#551)(*P'[email protected]*(#)/'É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#' ,%'C**!-ooSSS/&1&*+()+B=%/#"[email protected]%5+Q()Dà?d/!,$

REFERÊNCIAS

y1=5%"/' YejjdZ/' z#S' @+)' @#5!1*%"' &(51=+*%,' ?(&1+=(K+*(#)&' #$' *C%' B1(=*' %)?("#)5%)*' [email protected](=(*+*%' B%**%"' !1B=(@' !+"*(@(!+*(#)' ()' *C%' !=+))()D' !"#@%&&Ä' \)=()%' .=+))()D' 3#'@(?(='/'E)'8$#)&#'F' 61"*+,#'YH,&/ZR'8"I1(*%@*1"+'%'&#@(%,+,%',+'()$#"5+>3#/'.#"*#-';()(&*`"(#',+'G1=*1"+/ E7GE/' Yejjn+Z/' y8WH' /' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/B+&%/D#?/!*oB+&%o .+D()+&o,%$+1=*/+&!L E7GE/'YejjnBZ/'G#)@1"&#',%'@#)@%!>3#'b'V=1L#D"+5+/'É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#' ,%'C**!-oo SSS/B+&%/D#?/!*oG#)C%@+GG.o6=1L#D"+5+&oGG.àG#)@1"&#äejG#)@%[email protected]+#/!,$ E7GE/'[email protected]/'\'I1%'`' 15'@#)@1"&#',%'@#)@%!>3#Ä' É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%' C**!-oo SSS/B+&%/D#?/!*o$+I&o.+D()+&o$+I0%*+(=/+&!LÄ(,$+Iáge 3#' !^B=(@+/' .#"*#-' [email protected]=,+,%' ,%' 8"I1(*%@*1"+' ,+' c)(?%"&(,+,%' ,#' .#"*#' Y."#?+' 6()+=' !+"+' 2(@%)@(+*1"+' %5' 8"I1(*%@*1"+Z/ .%"%("+R' F' O#S)&%),/' YejdjZ/' G+&%' &*1,(%&' #)' *C%' 1&%' #$' !+"*(@(!+*#"P' @#5!1*%"bB+&%,' *%@C)(I1%&/' E)' 3#/' E)' 8$#)&#' F' 61"*+,#' YH,&/ZR' Z#G-/2&:2-#$! &! 1(:/&0$0&! 0$! /."(#%$TF(4! .#"*#-' ;()(&*`"(#',+'G1=*1"+/ W#=(,' E"(&' O%@C)#=#D(%&/' YejdjZ/' OC%+' "%),%"' $"#)*!+D%/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/*C%+"%),%"/@#[email protected]&o W!(==%"/' YejjlZ/' G#"!#&R' %&!+>#&' %' "%V=%L(?(,+,%/' E)' 8$#)&#' F' 61"*+,#' YH,&/ZR' Z#G-/2&:2-#$! g! %XG-/.$!&!:(#6(!g!.(2$1!1(7#&!$1!.(E$1!2&:.(=(;/$1!.$!$#G-/2&:2-#$4!.#"*#-'68c.'.1B=(@+>a%&/ W*15B=%c!#)/' Yejdj+Z/' W*15B=%1!#)/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo SSS/&*15B=%1!#)/@#5o&*15B=%"&o5+PQ)#SoÄ!"%á=#D() W*15B=%c!#)/' YejdjBZ/' W*15B=%1!#)' *%@C)#=#DP/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo SSS/&*15B=%1!#)/@#5o*%@C)#=#DPo OC%' .=#)%' 6#1),+*(#)/' YejdjZ/' vC+*' (&' !=#)%Ä' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo !=#)%/#"Do+B#1*o

REFERÊNCIAS

OC%'W1),+P'O(5%&/'YejjnZ/'v+(*()D'$#"'*C%'()*%")%*'5%=*,#S)/'É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#' , %' C * * ! - o o * % @ C ) # = # D P/ * ( 5 % & # ) = ( ) % / @ # / 1 Q o * # = o ) % S & o * % @ C à + ) , à S% B o * C % à S% B o +"*(@=%hemdnmq/%@% OC(",' W*"%%*' W#*S+"%' E)@/' Y)/,/Z/' W%)*%-' OC%' [email protected]+,%5(@' "%$%"%)@%' 5+)+D%"' $#"' [email protected]' \W' r/' É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/*C(",&*"%%*&#$*S+"%/@#5o&(*%o,#S)=#+,/C*5= O(==/' YejjiZ/' OC%' )%D#*(+*(#)' #$' C#!%/' E)' 3#',%'D%&*3#'B(B=(#D"]V(@+'W%)*%/ 6(D/'jg-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'%,(>3#',%'*%L*#'.+D%&/ 6(D/'jh-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'%,(>3#',%'*%L*#'.+D%&/ 6(D/'ji-'E)*%"[email protected]%',#'&(&*%5+'#!%"+*(?#';[email protected]'\Wr/ 6(D/'jl-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'@"(+>3#',%'5+!+&'5%)*+(&'r;(),/ 6(D/'jm-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'@"(+>3#',%'5+!+&'5%)*+(&'r;(),/ 6(D/'jn-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'@"(+>3#',%'5+!+&'5%)*+(&'r;(),/ 6(D/'jq-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'@"(+>3#',%'5+!+&'5%)*+(&'r;(),/ 6(D/'dj-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'@"(+>3#',%'5+!+&'5%)*+(&'r;(),/ 6(D/'dd-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'@"(+>3#',%'5+!+&'5%)*+(&'r;(),/ 6(D/' de-' 6"(%,"(@C' ;(%[email protected]%"' E)&*(*1*%' $#"' y(#5%,(@+=' 4%&%+"@C' YejjqZ/' 7%1"#)' ()' *C%' +5PD,+=+R'*C%'$%+"' @%)*%"' ()'*C%'B"+()/'É.]D()+',+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#' ,%'C**!-ooSSS/$5(/@Co )%S&o"%=%+&%&o+"*(@=%&o,#@&o=1*C(/jqjqdmo6;Eà)%1"#)à+5PD,+=+/N!D 6(D/'dg-'\.OH'."#N%@*'YejjgZ/'E)*%")%*'5+!/'É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-oo#!*%/#"Do 5+!&o 6(D/' dh-' z(DCS+PR' y+)DQ#QR' OC+(=+),/' YejdjZ/' z(DCS+PR' B+)DQ#QR' *C+(=+),/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-oo$+"5h/&*+*(@/V=(@Q"/@#5ogdhioeqgnggdilgàdmhg,[email protected]à#/N!D 6(D/' di-' 01))%' YejjeZ/' ;]I1()+' ,%' *1"()D/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo SSS/%@&/&P"/%,[email protected]=*[email protected]%**oC+),#1*&oS%B!+D%[email protected]#"%*%@C)#=#D(%&/C*5 6(D/' dl-' 0+?%P' Y)/,/Z/' ;]I1()+' ,%' *1"()D/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo +*1"()[email protected]()%/@#5o(),%L/!C! 6(D/' dm-' v(Q(5%,(+' Y)/,/Z/' H0p8G/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo 1!=#+,/S(Q(5%,(+/#"DoS(Q(!%,([email protected]#55#)&ohoh%oH0p8G/!)D 6(D/' dn-' 7#"*C' G+"#=()+' W*+*%' 7#"*C' G+"#=()+' c)(?%"&(*P' Y)/,/Z/' ;&b0#&/.)D/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/%#&/)@&1/%,1o%ddio*%&*o(5+D%&o5&b,#&/!)D 6(D/' dq-' ;1==%"b."#?%' Y)/,/Z/' WQ%*@C!+,/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo SSS/5!"#?%/,%o,(!=#5oà5%,(+oV(Dg/dàWQ%*@C!+,/N!D 6(D/'ej-'z1"=%P'Y)/,/Z/'81*#@+,'e/dn'$"#5' dqni/'É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'$"#5' C**!-oo SSS/V=(@Q"/@#5o!C#*#&oB*=ogqmenmnlmho()o&%*bmedimljjdhjqehqemo 6(D/' ed-' [+=+P' YdqnmZ/' v#"=,?(%S-' 8)' ()*%D"+*%,' D%#5%*"(@b5#,%=()Do' ,"+$*()D' &P&*%5/' G#5!1*%"'T"+!C(@&'+),'8!!=(@+*(#)&R'EHHHR'mYeZ/

REFERÊNCIAS

6(D/' ee-' 81*#,%&Q' Y)/,/Z/' 81*#,%&Q' "%?(*' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ/' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo SSS/51),#+"I1(*%@*#)(@#/@#[email protected]#)*%)*o1!=#+,&oejjqojlo(5+D%jjq/N!D 6(D/' eg-' y+"+)' YdqlhZ/' G%)*"+=(K%,R' ,%@%)*"+=(K%,' +),' ,(&*"(B1*%,' )%*S#"Q&/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' $"#5' C**!-oo&(*%&/D##D=%/@#5o+o!"%#@@1!+*(#)&/#"Doh*Cb$#"5b(@*o z#5%oh*Cäej6#"5äejEGOäg8äej=%&&#)äejh 6(D/' eh-' 8,?+)@%,' 4%&%+"@C' ."#N%@*&' 8D%)@P' Y84.8Z' YdqmmZ/' 84.87HO' =#D(@+=' 5+!' @("@+' dqmm/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-oo+"@C(?%/@#5!1*%"C(&*#"P/#"Do"%"@%&o&*(==b (5+D%o8"!+)%*o84.8)%*2#D(@+=dqlqbmq/djelhlmjho 84.8)%*S#"Q=#D(@+=;+"@Cdqmm/djelmegiq/=D/N!D 6(D/'ei-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/'el-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/' em-'E7GE'YejjnZ/'G#)@1"&#',%'@#)@%!>3#' b' V=1L#D"+5+/'É.]D()+' ,+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%' C**!-ooSSS/B+&%/D#?/!*oG#)C%@+GG.o6=1L#D"+5+&oGG.àG#)@1"&#äejG#)@%[email protected]+#/!,$ 6(D/'en-'0+?(,&#)'YdqqnZ/'W!())()D'*C%'SC%%='#$'%5!#S%"5%)*/'É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooQ(*@C%)*+B=%&1&*+()+B(=(*P/@#[email protected]#)*%)*o1!=#+,&oejjqojlo0+?(,&#)b W!())()DbSC%%=b+"*(@=%dqqn/!,$ 6(D/'eq-'8")&*%()'YdqlqZ/'8'=+,,%"'#$'@(*(K%)'!+"*(@(!+*(#)/'3#/ 6(D/'gd-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/'ge-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'5#,%=+>3#'T##D=%'WQ%*@C1!/ 6(D/'gg-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'5#,%=+>3#'T##D=%'WQ%*@C1!/ 6(D/'gh-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'5#,%=+>3#'T##D=%'WQ%*@C1!/ 6(D/'gi-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'5#,%=+>3#'T##D=%'WQ%*@C1!/ 6(D/'gl-'2+5B%"*'YejjdZ/';(%&'()'85%"(@+/';#)*"`+=-'GG;' 6(D/'gm-'8"I1(?#'!%&&#+=R'@%,(,#'!#"'.284H7R'8"I1(*%@*1"+R'H)D%)C+"(+'%'G#)&*"[email protected]>a%&R'2,+/ 6(D/'gn-'6"+5!*#)'YejjeZ/'2%'G#"B1&(%"-'+"@C(*%@*' #$'*C%'*S%)*(%*C'@%)*1"P/' 7%S'w#"Q-'z+""P' 7/'8B"+5& 6(D/'gq-'T%"5+)#'YejjnZ/'8=,#'4#&&(-',"+S()D&/';(=+)#-'WQ("+ 6(D/'hj-'2+5B%"*'YejjdZ/';(%&'()'85%"(@+/';#)*"`+=-'GG; 6(D/'hd-'E5+D%5'@"(+,+'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/'he-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/'hg-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/'hh-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/

@[email protected]

@BD

6(D/'hi-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/' hl-' 0%&(D)B##5' YejjnZ/' 0%&(D)B##5' @#5!%*(*(#)&/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/,%&(D)B##5/@#5o%)Do 6(D/' hm-' 0%&(D)B##5' YejjnZ/' 0%&(D)B##5' @#5!%*(*(#)&/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/,%&(D)B##5/@#5o%)Do 6(D/' hn-' 0%&(D)B##5' YejjnZ/' 0%&(D)B##5' @#5!%*(*(#)&/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/,%&(D)B##5/@#5o%)Do 6(D/' hq-' 0%&(D)B##5' YejjnZ/' 0%&(D)B##5' @#5!%*(*(#)&/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/,%&(D)B##5/@#5o%)Do 6(D/' ij-' y1&*=%"' YejdjZ/' y1&*=%"-' 8"@C(*%@*1"%' @#5!%*(*(#)&R' %?%)*&' F' )%S&/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/B1&*=%"/)%*o 6(D/' id-' y1&*=%"' YejdjZ/' y1&*=%"-' 8"@C(*%@*1"%' @#5!%*(*(#)&R' %?%)*&' F' )%S&/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/B1&*=%"/)%*o 6(D/'ie-'8"I1(*%@*15'YejdjZ/'8"I1(*%@*15-'8"@C(*%@*1"%'@#5!%*(*(#)&'+),'%?%)*&/' É.]D()+',+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/+"I1(*%@*15/@#5o(),%L/!C! 6(D/'ig-'8"I1(*%@*15'YejdjZ/'8"I1(*%@*15-'8"@C(*%@*1"%'@#5!%*(*(#)&'+),'%?%)*&/' É.]D()+',+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/+"I1(*%@*15/@#5o(),%L/!C! 6(D/'ih-'G_5+"+' ;1)(@(!+=',#' .#"*#'YejjqZ/'T1(+',%'+!#(#-'W1B5(&&3#' #)=()%',#&'!"#@%&&#&/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!&-oo#)=()%/@5b!#"*#/!*o+*%),(5%)*##)=()%o 0#@15%)*#&oT1(+äej,%äej+&&()+*1"+äej,%äej,#@15%)*#&äej%5äej.06/!,$ 6(D/'ii-'8DM)@(+'!+"+'+';#,%")(K+>3#'8,5()(&*"+*(?+R'E./'YejjqZ/'.#"*+=',+'%5!"%&+/'É.]D()+' ,+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!&-ooSSS/!#"*+=,+%5!"%&+/!*[email protected]?%o2#D()/+&!LÄ!+D%ád 6(D/' il-'T%%Q)%*R'E)@/' YejdjZ/' W#1"@%$#"D%'b' =#D()/' É.]D()+',+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#' ,%'C**!&-oo "@%$#"D%/)%*[email protected]@#1)*o=#D()/!C! 6(D/' im-' T##D=%' YejdjZ/' G#)*+&' ,#' T##D=%/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!&-oo SSS/D##D=%/@#5o 6(D/' in-'T%%Q)%*R'E)@/' YejdjZ/' W#1"@%$#"D%'b' =#D()/' É.]D()+',+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#' ,%'C**!&-oo "@%$#"D%/)%*[email protected]@#1)*o=#D()/!C! 6(D/'iq-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/'lj-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/' ld-' 4%+,()D' YejjqZ/' ;+Q()D' ,%&(D)' @#5!%*(*(#)' S#"Q' S(*C()'!"#@1"%5%)*' &*"[email protected]*1"%&/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/@+B%/#"D/1Qo+"*(@=%&oS#"Q()DbS(*C()b !"#@1"%5%)*b&*"[email protected]*1"%& 6(D/' le-'E7GE'YejjnZ/'G#)@1"&#',%'@#)@%!>3#' b' V=1L#D"+5+/'É.]D()+' ,+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%' C**!-ooSSS/B+&%/D#?/!*oG#)C%@+GG.o6=1L#D"+5+&oGG.àG#)@1"&#äejG#)@%[email protected]+#/!,$ 6(D/' lg-'81*#,%&QR'E)@/' YejjnZ/' 81*#@+,'@#)*%L*1+='"(BB#)/'É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%' C**[email protected]#551)(*(%&/+1*#,%&Q/@#5o+5+o#"(DoB"àV(=%&o81*#G80djo81*#G80bejdjà(5Dàl/N!D

REFERÊNCIAS

6(D/' lh-' T##D=%' YejdjZ/' 8,(@(#)+"' 5()(+!=(@+>a%&' :' !]D()+' ()(@(+=/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/D##D=%/!*o(Do,("%@*#"PÄC=á!*b.OF"##*áo(DF(D*+Bá.]D()+ â()(@(+=F,!#&á*#! 6(D/' li-'T##D=%' YejdjZ/' ED##D=%/' É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#' ,%'C**!-ooSSS/D##D=%/!*o(DÄ C=á!*b.O 6(D/'ll-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#'v#",!"%&& 6(D/'lm-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/'ln-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#',%'D%&*3#'B(B=(#D"]V(@+'W%)*%/ 6(D/'lq-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/' mj-'H?#=#R' 22G' YejdjZ/' H?#=#-' 8"@C(*%@*1"%' 5+D+K()%/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/%?#=#/1&o 6(D/'md-'0(+D"+5+'@"(+,#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#/ 6(D/'me-'v%B&(*%',+'8)1]"(+'#)=()%'Y%5',%&%)?#=?(5%)*#'!%=#'+1*#"',+'0(&&%"*+>3#Z 6(D/' mg-' \!%)' W#[email protected]%' ;+**%"&R' E)@' YejdjZ/' z#5%' b' N##5=+x' HL*%)&(#)&' ,("%@*#"P/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-oo%L*%)&(#)&/N##5=+/#"Do 6(D/' mh-' .=+*+$#"5+' @#=+B#"+*(?+' ,#' Hb2%+")()D' G+$`' y#*_)(@#' Y,%&%)?#=?(,+' !%=#' +1*#"' ,+' 0(&&%"*+>3#Z 6(D/' mi-' ;#"%("+' YejdjZ/' y"1)#' 5#"%("+/7%*' b' *+=Q&' +B#1*' +"*&' +),' *%@C)#=#DP/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/B"1)#5#"%("+/)%*o 6(D/'ml-'T##D=%'YejdjZ/'OC%'D##D=%'5+!&'[email protected]"(!*' 8.E' pg'b'D##D=%'5+!&' [email protected]"(!*'8.E'pg'b' D##D=%' @#,%/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**[email protected]#,%/D##D=%/@#5o()*=o!*b.Oo+!(&o 5+!&o,#@15%)*+*(#)[email protected]"(!*o 6(D/'mm-'T##D=%'YejdjZ/'OC%'D##D=%'5+!&'[email protected]"(!*' 8.E' pg'b'D##D=%'5+!&' [email protected]"(!*'8.E'pg'b' D##D=%' @#,%/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**[email protected]#,%/D##D=%/@#5o()*=o!*b.Oo+!(&o 5+!&o,#@15%)*+*(#)[email protected]"(!*o 6(D/' mn-' T##D=%' YejdjZ/' T##D=%' %+"*C' 8.E' b' D##D=%' @#,%/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**[email protected]#,%/D##D=%/@#5o()*=o!*b.Oo+!(&o%+"*Co 6(D/'mq-'T##D=%'YejdjZ/'T##D=%'5+!&',+*+'8.E'b'D##D=%'@#,%/'É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%' C**[email protected]#,%/D##D=%/@#5o()*=o!*b.Oo+!(&o5+!&o,#@15%)*+*(#)o5+!&,+*+o 6(D/'nj-'81*#,%&QR'E)@/'YejjqZ/'81*#,%&Q'$"%%SC%%=/' É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%' C**!-oo $"%%SC%%=/+1*#,%&Q/@#5o 6(D/'nd-'81*#,%&QR'E)@/'YejjqZ/'81*#,%&Q'$"%%SC%%=/' É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%' C**!-oo $"%%SC%%=/+1*#,%&Q/@#5o 6(D/'ne-'0+"@#';+D+K()%'YejdjZ/'0+"@#'5+D+K()%'jn/'É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-oo (&&11/@#5o,+"@#5+D+K()%o,#@&o,+"@#jn 6(D/'ng-'\8W47'YejdjZ/'H,([email protected](#',#'51&%1',#'@+""#'%=`@*"(@#/'É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%' C**!-ooSSS/@#)@1"&#&#+&")/@#[email protected]#)@1"&#/+&!ÄE,á[email protected]*(#)áC#5%

@BE

@BF

6(D/'nh-'\8W47'YejdjZ/'[email protected]#=+'!"#$/'8D"[email protected]#=+'@#),%'W/'y%)*#/'É.]D()+',+'E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%' C**!-ooSSS/@#)@1"&#&#+&")/@#[email protected]#)@1"&#/+&!ÄE,á[email protected]*(#)áC#5% 6(D/' ni-' 0%&(D)B##5' YejdjZ/' O(?#=(' +1,(#' dj*C' +))(?%"&+"P' ,%&(D)' @C+==%)D%/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/,%&(D)B##5/@#5o*(?#=(+1,(#/C*5= 6(D/'nl-'8"I1(*%@*15'YejdjZ/'8"I1(*%@*15-'8"@C(*%@*1"%'@#5!%*(*(#)&'+),'%?%)*&/' É.]D()+',+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/+"I1(*%@*15/@#5o(),%L/!C! 6(D/'nm-'8"I1(*%@*15'YejdjZ/'8"I1(*%@*15-'8"@C(*%@*1"%'@#5!%*(*(#)&'+),'%?%)*&/' É.]D()+',+' E)*%")%*Ñ'4%*("+,#',%'C**!-ooSSS/+"I1(*%@*15/@#5o(),%L/!C! 6(D/'nn-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#'0%=(@(#1&'[email protected]%&&A?%='%5'C**!-ooSSS/,%=(@(#1&/@#5o 6(D/'nq-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#'0%=(@(#1&'[email protected]%&&A?%='%5'C**!-ooSSS/,%=(@(#1&/@#5o 6(D/'qj-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#'0%=(@(#1&'[email protected]%&&A?%='%5'C**!-ooSSS/,%=(@(#1&/@#5o 6(D/'qd-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#'0%=(@(#1&'[email protected]%&&A?%='%5'C**!-ooSSS/,%=(@(#1&/@#5o 6(D/'qe-'E)*%"[email protected]%',+'+!=(@+>3#'0%=(@(#1&'[email protected]%&&A?%='%5'C**!-ooSSS/,%=(@(#1&/@#5o 6(D/' qg-' W*15B=%c!#)' YejdjZ/' W*15B=%1!#)' *%@C)#=#DP/' É.]D()+' ,+' E)*%")%*Ñ' 4%*("+,#' ,%' C**!-ooSSS/&*15B=%1!#)/@#5o*%@C)#=#DPo

REFERÊNCIAS

[email protected]+;2#*D')$%#)= yE;'b'y1(=,()D'()$#"5+*(#)'5#,%=()D G80'b'G#5!1*%"b+(,%,',"+$*()D G880'b'G#5!1*%"b+(,%,'+"@C(*%@*1"+=',%&(D) G8;'b'G#5!1*%"b+(,%,'5+)[email protected]*1"()D GG.'b'GJ,(D#',#&'G#)*"+*#&'.^B=(@#& 04'b'0(]"(#',+'4%!^B=(@+ TEW'b'T%#D"+!C(@'E)$#"5+*(#)'WP&*%5 3# WE'b'W#@(%,+,%',+'E)$#"5+>3# OEG'b'O%@)#=#D(+&',+'E)$#"5+>3#'%'G#51)(@+>3# vvv'b'v#"=,'v(,%'v%B

@BG

Lihat lebih banyak...

Comentários

Copyright © 2017 DADOSPDF Inc.