Contra o Evangelismo na Criminologia Acadêmica: pela Criminologia como uma Arte Científica

 9!586" #        56!$6%" !9& 75'"48'6"(

012456789 6 58 789 )*+,-./01234-*-5201*64-7826294: 4;87?@.&"+.'&"8A)*")&'++"'*)+ '$)+''('+'&+%"+#'"#*"*'+$/&'"+""&7"+!&)#)$""!"*/&!"'")#0(!" !&)#B$!".'("&7,&)!"%+"*"*'+'C"7#*"*'*'("+!)&)&++)++)!))#0(!)+. +'"!&)#)$"!)&)%&""('!'(01!"*'2'('-%"#-%'+$1!"*)+)!"#.'%'+)+' &)("('-%'"+('+D'+'2"$'#0+(!"+"+!&)#)$"+!0(!".!%#(%"#'67#!"*'2'"& +'!) 1) ("*"+;E)&'%2'.'#"++A))+"+'!()+&')+*'+'CF2'+')('!"#&'('&"+ "%()'C%*!"+*)&'#G)*"!&)#)$""!"*/&!"!) ('&)H'";I

JK KLL

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`a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`-&+$7(&*(%+464)$-$94&*(%+804%&(,(%3-03+&-( Oab(%+4&04:&*7(,(&(%+464)$-$94&(1c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c9de9fcgchd-"!"%/&"01!$i"!"!##!"!+*3$(">"(%!+(#"1$"./#"$1*,/#" D!27/#"!"!B,&(/&.*+(&*($!+,!".*54'!*#"%&/)2!$(#"%&/DFD!*#".!"'/+5&/+,(&"01(201!&",!8&*'/" #/'*(2"01!"%&*D*2!3*("djkfjljmgchdnopqrjsqhd"'/$/"($)/#"/):!,/#"!"5!&&($!+,(#"$!,/./283*'(#" .!"%!#01*#(?"R1,&(#"01!#,=!#",($)>$"#1&3!$?"R+.!"'&*$*+/2/3*#,(#"'12,1&(*#"'/2/'($"!2!#" %&8%&*/#"!"#!1#"!#'&*,/#"!$"&!2(