Estado de Direito e Responsabilidade jurisdicional na cooperação em face do regime de proibição global do terrorismo

May 24, 2017 | Autor: Raquel Scalcon | Categoria: Constitutional Law, Terrorism, Human Rights
Share Embed


Descrição do Produto

ANO XV – 2016 – Nº 63 Diretores Elton José Donato Fabio Roberto D’Avila Giovani Agostini Saavedra

Coordenadores Adjuntos Daniel Leonhardt dos Santos Letícia Bürgel

Conselho Editorial Alexandre Wunderlich (Pontifícia Universidade Católica/RS) Álvaro Sanchez Bravo (Universidade de Sevilha) Arndt Sinn (Universidade de Osnabrück, Alemanha) Davi de Paiva Costa Tangerino (Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro/RJ) David Sanchez Rúbio (Universidade de Sevilha/Espanha) Elizabeth Cancelli (Universidade de Brasília) Fabio Roberto D’Avila (Pontifícia Universidade Católica/RS) Fauzi Hassan Choukr (Universidade de São Paulo) Felipe Augusto Forte de Negreiros Deodato (Universidade Federal da Paraíba/PB) Fernando Machado Pelloni (Universidade de Buenos Aires/Argentina) Gamil Föppel El Hireche (Universidade Federal da Bahia) Geraldo Prado (Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro) Giovani Agostini Saavedra (Pontifícia Universidade Católica/RS) Helena Lobo da Costa (Universidade de São Paulo/SP) Heloisa Estellita (Fundação Getúlio Vargas/SP) Luiz Eduardo Soares (Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro) Rui Cunha Martins (Universidade de Coimbra) Ruth Maria Chittó Gauer (Pontifícia Universidade Católica/RS) Vittorio Manes (Universidade de Salento, Itália)

Conselho do Instituto Transdisciplinar de Estudos Criminais (www.itecrs.org) Andrei Zenkner Schmidt Alexandre Wunderlich Daniel Gerber Felipe Cardoso Moreira de Oliveira Fabio Roberto D’Avila Giovani Agostini Saavedra Jader da Silveira Marques Marcelo Machado Bertoluci Paulo Vinícius Sporleder de Souza Rodrigo Moraes de Oliveira Salo de Carvalho

© REVISTA DE ESTUDOS CRIMINAIS®

ISSN 1676-8698

Uma publicação do ITEC (Instituto Transdisciplinar de Estudos Criminais) e da SÍNTESE, uma linha de produtos jurídicos do grupo SAGE.

Os conceitos emitidos em trabalhos assinados são de responsabilidade de seus autores. Os originais não serão devolvidos, embora não publicados. Os artigos são divulgados no idioma original ou traduzidos. Os acórdãos selecionados para esta Revista correspondem, na íntegra, às cópias dos originais obtidas na Secretaria do Supremo Tribunal Federal e dos demais tribunais. Proibida a reprodução parcial ou total, sem autorização dos editores. E-mail para remessa de artigos: [email protected]

REVISTA DE ESTUDOS CRIMINAIS – ANO XV – Nº 63 Periodicidade trimestral – Tiragem 2.000 exemplares

ASSINATURAS: São Paulo: (11) 2188-7507 – Demais Estados: 0800.7247900 SAC e Suporte Técnico: São Paulo e Grande São Paulo (11) 2188-7900 Demais Estados: 0800.7247900 www.sintese.com

Telefones para Contatos Cobrança: São Paulo e Grande São Paulo (11) 2188.7900 Demais localidades 0800.7247900 IOB Informações Objetivas Publicações Jurídicas Ltda. R. Antonio Nagib Ibrahim, 350 – Água Branca 05036-060 – São Paulo – SP www.iobfolhamatic.com.br

SAC e Suporte Técnico: São Paulo e Grande São Paulo (11) 2188.7900 Demais localidades 0800.7247900 E-mail: [email protected] Renovação: Grande São Paulo (11) 2188.7900 Demais localidades 0800.7283888

SUMÁRIO

DOUTRINA ESTRANGEIRA 9

A Convenção do Conselho da Europa contra o Tráfico de Órgãos Humanos: Princípios e Bens Jurídicos Penalmente Protegidos (Carlos María Romeo-Casabona)

29

Reflexão Crítica da Relação entre o Direito Penal e a Globalização: o Ideal de Criação de uma Justiça Penal Global de “Liberdade” (Maria João Carvalho Vaz)

DOUTRINA NACIONAL 59

A Tipificação do Crime de Desaparecimento Forçado de Pessoas: Construção Jusinternacional e a Memória Como Categoria Criminológica Crítica (Bruno Amaral Machado e Eneida Orbage de Britto Taquary)

95

Criminal Compliance e Lavagem de Dinheiro: Tendências Político-Criminais Atuais Gestadas pelos Centros Legislativos Comunitários (Andressa Paula de Andrade, Érika Mendes de Carvalho e Pedro Paulo da Cunha Ferreira)

131

Análise dos Critérios do Tribunal de Justiça do Rio Grande do Sul para Reavaliar a Medida Socioeducativa de Internação (Ana Paula Motta Costa e Marcel di Carlo Osterlund Saldanha)

159

Estado de Direito e Responsabilidade Jurisdicional na Cooperação em Face do Regime de Proibição Global do Terrorismo (Eduardo Pitrez de Aguiar Corrêa e Raquel Lima Scalcon)

ESTADO DE DIREITO E RESPONSABILIDADE JURISDICIONAL NA COOPERAÇÃO EM FACE DO REGIME DE PROIBIÇÃO GLOBAL DO TERRORISMO RULE OF LAW AND JUDICIAL RESPONSIBILITY FOR COOPERATION IN FACE OF THE TERRORISM GLOBAL PROHIBITION REGIME

E DUARDO P ITREZ DE A GUIAR C ORRÊA * R AQUEL L IMA S CALCON **

5(68022DUWLJRTXHVWLRQDRHVSDoRGHDGHUrQFLDHGHUHVLVWrQFLD GRVyUJmRVQDFLRQDLVHPIDFHGHXPFRQMXQWRGHQRUPDVLQWHUQDFLRQDLVLQWHUQDOL]DGDVSHOR%UDVLOTXHWUDWDPGLUHWDHLQGLUHWDPHQWHGR SUREOHPDGRWHUURULVPR3DUDWDQWRH[SORUDXPFRQMXQWRGHQRUPDV TXHFRQIRUPDPRWUDWDPHQWRGDVDo}HVTXDOLÀFDGDVFRPRWHUURULVWDVLGHQWLÀFDQGRQHVVHFRQMXQWRQRUPDWLYRXPUHJLPHGHSURLELomR JOREDO global prohibition regime TXHSHQHWUDGLUHWDHLQGLUHWDPHQWH QRVVLVWHPDVGHMXVWLoDFULPLQDOGRV(VWDGRV3RUVXDIRUoDHQDWXUH]DHVVHUHJLPHLQFLGHHPXPDVpULHGHHVSDoRVLQGLYLGXDLVSURWHJLGRVSRUGLUHLWRVKXPDQRVPHVPRVREUHLQGLYtGXRVTXHQmRWrP TXDOTXHU UHODomR FRP Do}HV TXDOLÀFDGDV FRPR WHUURULVWDV QHP VH HQFRQWUDPHPSDtVHVDOYRVGHDo}HVWHUURULVWDV3RUWDGRUGHFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGRGLUHLWRSHQDOGRLQLPLJRWDOUHJLPHLPS}HDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHGRV(VWDGRVHPkPELWRLQWHUQRHVSHFLDOPHQWHSRULQWHUPpGLRGHVHXV7ULEXQDLV&RQVWLWXFLRQDLVGHJDUDQWLUDSUHVHUYDomRGH SULQFtSLRVHVVHQFLDLVDR(VWDGRGH'LUHLWRFRPRDWXWHODGHGLUHLWRV KXPDQRVDVVHJXUDGRVHPFRQYHQo}HVLQWHUQDFLRQDLVHQDVFRQVWLWXLo}HVQDFLRQDLV2FXPSULPHQWRGHWDOWDUHIDQRPLQDGRGHresponsabilidade na cooperaçãopIXQGDPHQWDO'RFRQWUiULRRHQIUHQWDPHQWR DRWHUURULVPRSRUPHLRVGHGLUHLWRSHQDOSRGHVHWRUQDUPDLVHURVLYR jGHPRFUDFLDGRTXHDSUySULDYLROrQFLDTXHYLVDDHQIUHQWDU 3$/$95$6&+$9('LUHLWRVKXPDQRVUHJLPHGHSURLELomRJOREDO GRWHUURULVPRSROtWLFDFULPLQDOWUDQVQDFLRQDOFRQWUROHMXULVGLFLRQDO $%675$&77KHDUWLFOHLQYHVWLJDWHVWKHVSDFHRIFRQYHUJHQFHDQG UHVLVWDQFHRIQDWLRQDOERGLHVLQIDFHRIDVHWRILQWHUQDWLRQDOVWDQGDUGV LQWHUQDOL]HGE\%UD]LOWKDWGHDOGLUHFWO\DQGLQGLUHFWO\ZLWKWKHSUR-

*

**

3URIHVVRUGD)DFXOGDGHGH'LUHLWRGD8QLYHUVLGDGH)HGHUDOGR5LR*UDQGH )DGLU)XUJ H GR3URJUDPDGH3yV*UDGXDomRHP'LUHLWRH-XVWLoD6RFLDO 33*-'6)DGLU)XUJ  3URIHVVRUDGD)DFXOGDGHGH'LUHLWRGD8QLULWWHU3RUWR$OHJUH56H&DQRDV56'RXWRUDHP 'LUHLWRSHOD8)5*60HVWUHHP&LrQFLDV&ULPLQDLVSHOD38&56*UDGXDomRHP'LUHLWRSHOD 8)5*6 159

REVISTA

DE

ESTUDOS CRIMINAIS 63 DOUTRINA NACIONAL

OUTUBRO/DEZEMBRO 2016

EOHPRIWHUURULVP7KHUHIRUHH[SORUHVDVHWRIOHJDOUXOHVWKDWIUDPHV WKHWUHDWPHQWRIDFWLRQVTXDOLÀHGDVWHUURULVWVLGHQWLI\LQJWKLVVHWRI UXOHVDVDJOREDOSURKLELWLRQUHJLPHWKDWSHQHWUDWHVGLUHFWO\DQGLQGLUHFWO\LQWKHFULPLQDOMXVWLFHV\VWHPVRIVWDWHV)RUWKHLUVWUHQJWKDQG QDWXUHWKLVUHJLPHDIIHFWVDVHULHVRIKXPDQULJKWVRIFLWL]HQVWKDWDUH QRWWHUURULVWVLQFRXQWULHVWKDWDUHQRWWDUJHWRIWHUURULVP4XDOLÀHG DVHQHP\FULPLQDOODZVXFKUHJLPHLPSRVHVWRWKHGRPHVWLFERGLHV RIWKH6WDWHVHVSHFLDOO\&RQVWLWXWLRQDO&RXUWVWKHEXUGHQRIWKHGHIHQVHRIIXQGDPHQWDOSULQFLSOHVRI5XOHRI/DZDVWKH\DUHVHWRQ ,QWHUQDWLRQDO+XPDQ5LJKWWUHDWLHVDQGQDWLRQDO&RQVWLWXWLRQV:H FDOO WKLV EXUGHQ responsibility in cooperation 2WKHUZLVH WKH ZDU RQ WHUURUE\PHDQVRIFULPLQDOODZFRXOGEHFRPHPRUHKDUPIXORIRXU GHPRFUDFLHVWKDQWKHYLROHQFHWKDWVHHNVWRDYRLG .(@ DSUHVHQWDPRV XP SURMHWR TXH EXVFD DFROKHU QD VXD UHGDomR RV SULQFLSDLVGHEDWHVPXQGLDLVHQDFLRQDLVVREUHRWHPDUHVSHLWDQGRVHPSUHRV GLUHLWRVHJDUDQWLDVIXQGDPHQWDLVFRPRÀPGHFULDUXPDOHLTXHSURWHMD RLQGLYtGXRDVRFLHGDGHFRPRXPWRGREHPFRPRVHXVGLYHUVRVVHJPHQWRV VHMDP HOHV VRFLDO UDFLDO UHOLJLRVR LGHROyJLFR SROtWLFR RX GH JrQHUR >@ 'HVVD IRUPD EXVFDVH FULDU XPD OHL TXH DGHTXH QRVVR RUGHQDPHQWR DRV WUDWDGRV LQWHUQDFLRQDLV DVVLQDGRV SHOR %UDVLO PDV UHVSHLWDQGR QRVVD &RQVWLWXLomR)HGHUDOHRVGLUHLWRVHJDUDQWLDVGHWRGRVRVEUDVLOHLURVHHVWUDQJHLURV

4XDQWRDRVPHLRVSDUDDWLQJLUWDLVREMHWLYRVYHULÀFDVHTXHIRUDPHOHLWRVHVSHFLDOPHQWHRVVHJXLQWHV L FULPLQDOL]DomRGHDWRVSUHSDUDWyULRVVHP

RX QXOR SRWHQFLDO GH VROXFLRQDU R SUREOHPD 6,(+5 $QJHOLND ´2EMHNWLYLWlWµ LQ GHU *HVHW]JHEXQJ" 6\PEROLVFKH *HVH]WJHEXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ 5DWLRQDOLWlWVDQVSUXFK GHV *HVHW]HV XQGGHPRNUDWLVFKHP0HKUKHLWSULQ]LS$UFKLYIU5HFKWV²XQG6R]LDOSKLORVRSKLH6WXWWJDUWY FDGHUQRSSVV+$66(0(5:LQIULHG'HUHFKR3HQDOVLPEyOLFRH SURWHFFLyQGHELHQHVMXUtGLFRV6DQWLDJRGR&KLOHS'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSSHUVR XQLIUFKGHUHFKRSHQDODVVHWVÀOHVREUDVSRUWDOHVRSBBSGI! 1R 'LUHLWR EUDVLOHLURFRQIHULU&267$+HOHQD5HJLQD/RERGDProteção penal ambiental.9LDELOLGDGH HIHWLYLGDGHWXWHODSRURXWURVPHLRV6mR3DXOR6DUDLYDS  

./$770DWWKLDV0(,67(50RULW]The Constitutional Structure of ProportionalityRSFLW S



$-XVWLÀFDWLYDGR3URMHWRGH/HLQžHVWiGLVSRQtYHOHPKWWSZZZFDPDUD JRYEUSURSRVLFRHV:HESURSBPRVWUDULQWHJUDMVHVVLRQLG &$'$$$%)% ('&SURSRVLFRHV:HE"FRGWHRU  ÀOHQDPH 3/! 179

REVISTA

DE

ESTUDOS CRIMINAIS 63 DOUTRINA NACIONAL

OUTUBRO/DEZEMBRO 2016

TXHLVVRFRQÀJXUHXPGHOLWRDXW{QRPR LL FULPLQDOL]DomRGRDOLFLDPHQWR GHSHVVRDVSDUDDSUiWLFDGHDWRVWHUURULVWDVQR%UDVLORXIRUDGHOH LLL FULPLQDOL]DomRGRUHFHELPHQWRGHWUHLQDPHQWRSDUDSUDWLFDUDWRVGHWHUURULVPRQR H[WHULRU LY FULPLQDOL]DomRGRÀQDQFLDPHQWRDRWHUURULVPR Y H[SUHVVD H[FOXVmRGRFRQFHLWRGHDWRWHUURULVWDGHPDQLIHVWDo}HVSROtWLFDVVRFLDLVRX VLQGLFDLVPRYLGDVSRUSURSyVLWRVVRFLDLVRXUHLYLQGLFDWyULRVHÀQDOPHQWH YL HVWLSXODomRGHSHQDVGHUHFOXVmRPXLWRHOHYDGDVGHWDOPRGRTXHD SHQDPtQLPDLPSRVVLELOLWHDDWULEXLomRGHUHJLPHGLVWLQWRGRIHFKDGRDXP HYHQWXDOFRQGHQDGRHDRPi[LPRDOFDQFHRPDLRUSDWDPDUSRVVtYHOQRRUGHQDPHQWREUDVLOHLUR DQRV  1RSODQRSURFHVVXDOGHVWDFDVHDGHVLJQDomRGD3ROtFLD)HGHUDOHGD -XVWLoD )HGHUDO FRPR FRPSHWHQWHV UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH SDUD D LQYHVWLJDomR R SURFHVVDPHQWRHRMXOJDPHQWR0HUHFHDWHQomRSRUÀPDGHWHUPLQDomRGH DSOLFDomRLPHGLDWDGHLQVWUXPHQWRVGHLQYHVWLJDo}HVSUHYLVWDVQD/HLGDV2UJDQL]Do}HV&ULPLQRVDV /HLQž FRPRDFRODERUDomRSUHPLDGD



/HL Qž  DUW ž ´5HDOL]DU DWRV SUHSDUDWyULRV GH WHUURULVPR FRP R SURSyVLWR LQHTXtYRFRGHFRQVXPDUWDOGHOLWR3HQD²DFRUUHVSRQGHQWHDRGHOLWRFRQVXPDGRGLPLQXtGD GHXPTXDUWRDWpDPHWDGH>@µHDUW´0HVPRDQWHVGHLQLFLDGDDH[HFXomRGRFULPHGH WHUURULVPRQDKLSyWHVHGRDUWžGHVWD/HLDSOLFDPVHDVGLVSRVLo}HVGRDUWGR'HFUHWR /HLQžGHGHGH]HPEURGH²&yGLJR3HQDOµ



/HLQžDUWž†Ož´,QFRUUHQDVPHVPDVSHQDVRDJHQWHTXHFRPRSURSyVLWRGH SUDWLFDUDWRVGHWHUURULVPR,²UHFUXWDURUJDQL]DUWUDQVSRUWDURXPXQLFLDULQGLYtGXRVTXH YLDMHPSDUDSDtVGLVWLQWRGDTXHOHGHVXDUHVLGrQFLDRXQDFLRQDOLGDGHRX,,²IRUQHFHURX UHFHEHUWUHLQDPHQWRHPSDtVGLVWLQWRGDTXHOHGHVXDUHVLGrQFLDRXQDFLRQDOLGDGHµ



9HUQRWDGHURGDSpDQWHULRU



/HLQžDUWž´5HFHEHUSURYHURIHUHFHUREWHUJXDUGDUPDQWHUHPGHSyVLWR VROLFLWDU LQYHVWLU GH TXDOTXHU PRGR GLUHWD RX LQGLUHWDPHQWH UHFXUVRV DWLYRV EHQV GLUHLWRVYDORUHVRXVHUYLoRVGHTXDOTXHUQDWXUH]DSDUDRSODQHMDPHQWRDSUHSDUDomRRXD H[HFXomRGRVFULPHVSUHYLVWRVQHVWD/HL3HQDUHFOXVmRGHTXLQ]HDWULQWDDQRVµ



/HLQžDUWž†ž´2GLVSRVWRQHVWHDUWLJRQmRVHDSOLFDjFRQGXWDLQGLYLGXDORX FROHWLYDGHSHVVRDVHPPDQLIHVWDo}HVSROtWLFDVPRYLPHQWRVVRFLDLVVLQGLFDLVUHOLJLRVRVGH FODVVHRXGHFDWHJRULDSURÀVVLRQDOGLUHFLRQDGRVSRUSURSyVLWRVVRFLDLVRXUHLYLQGLFDWyULRV YLVDQGR D FRQWHVWDU FULWLFDU SURWHVWDU RX DSRLDU FRP R REMHWLYR GH GHIHQGHU GLUHLWRV JDUDQWLDVHOLEHUGDGHVFRQVWLWXFLRQDLVVHPSUHMXt]RGDWLSLÀFDomRSHQDOFRQWLGDHPOHLµ



/HL Qž  DUW  ´3DUD WRGRV RV HIHLWRV OHJDLV FRQVLGHUDVH TXH RV FULPHV SUHYLVWRVQHVWD/HLVmRSUDWLFDGRVFRQWUDRLQWHUHVVHGD8QLmRFDEHQGRj3ROtFLD)HGHUDOD LQYHVWLJDomRFULPLQDOHPVHGHGHLQTXpULWRSROLFLDOHj-XVWLoD)HGHUDORVHXSURFHVVDPHQWR HMXOJDPHQWRQRVWHUPRVGRLQFLVR,9GRDUWGD&RQVWLWXLomR)HGHUDOµ 180

REVISTA

DE

ESTUDOS CRIMINAIS 63

DOUTRINA NACIONAL OUTUBRO/DEZEMBRO 2016

RDJHQWHLQÀOWUDGRDDomRFRQWURODGDHRDFHVVRDUHJLVWURVGDGRVFDGDVWUDLV GRFXPHQWRVHLQIRUPDo}HVHWF ,VVRSRQWXDGRTXHVWLRQDVH7DLVPHLRVVHUmRGHIDWRDPSODPHQWHHÀFD]HVQDSURPRomRGRÀPRXpSURYiYHOTXHVHWUDWDUiGHXPDOHJLVODomR SHQDOFXMRVHIHLWRVSUHSRQGHUDQWHVVHUmRRVVLPEyOLFRV"&RQVLGHUDQGRTXHD OHLHPTXHVWmRLQJUHVVRXKiSRXFRWHPSRQRRUGHQDPHQWRMXUtGLFREUDVLOHLUR QmRpSRVVtYHOYDOHUVHGHHVWXGRVHPStULFRVVREUHRVVHXVHIHLWRVFRQFUHWRV DÀPGHUHVSRQGHUDLQGDJDomRDQWHULRU&RQWXGRXPODQoDUGHROKRVjGHOLEHUDomROHJLVODWLYDGDTXDOHODpSURGXWRSRGHPXLWRDX[LOLDUQDUHDOL]DomR GHVVDLQYHVWLJDomR (PRXWUDVSDODYUDVGHIHQGHVHTXHDVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVFRQFUHWDVGRSURFHVVROHJLVODWLYRVHUYHPGHLQGLFDGRUHVGRVHXJUDXGHracionalidadeLVWRp GDVXDFRHUrQFLDFRPRVGDGRVGDUHDOLGDGHVRFLDOHGDVXDFDSDFLGDGHGHHÀFD]PHQWHFRQIRUPiODjOX]GRVÀQV FRQVWLWXFLRQDLV DPELFLRQDGRV7DOYHULÀFDomRQR kPELWR SHQDO p GH H[WUHPD LPSRUWkQFLD KDMD YLVWD VH WUDWDU GR PHLR PDLV UHVWULWLYRDGLUHLWRVIXQGDPHQWDLVHKXPDQRVGHTXHGLVS}HR(VWDGRQDSHUVHFXomR GH VHXV REMHWLYRV 1HVVH VHQWLGR VXJHUHPVH WUrV SDUkPHWURV SDUD UHDOL]DUDDYDOLDomRVXJHULGD L UDFLRQDOLGDGHno impulso GRSURFHVVROHJLVODWLYR LL UDFLRQDOLGDGHno tempo GRSURFHVVROHJLVODWLYRH LLL UDFLRQDOLGDGH no modo GHFRQGXomRGRSURFHVVROHJLVODWLYR ,QLFLDQGRVHSHORSULPHLURLQGLFDGRUSRGHVHREVHUYDUjOX]GDEUHYtVVLPD -XVWLÀFDWLYD DSUHVHQWDGD QR 3URMHWR GH /HL Qž  TXH VHX SURSRQHQWH QmR WHP SOHQD FODUH]D TXDQWR DR SUREOHPD TXH GHVHMD VROYHU $ÀUPDLQLFLDOPHQWHTXH´DVRUJDQL]Do}HVWHUURULVWDVFDUDFWHUL]DUDPVHQRV ~OWLPRV DQRV HP XPD GDV PDLRUHV DPHDoDV SDUD RV GLUHLWRV KXPDQRV H R IRUWDOHFLPHQWR GD GHPRFUDFLDµ $ VHJXLU DGX] TXH R %UDVLO SHOD VXD LPSRUWkQFLD SROtWLFD H HFRQ{PLFD QR FHQiULR PXQGLDO ´GHYH HVWDU DWHQWR DRV



/HLQžDUW´$SOLFDPVHDVGLVSRVLo}HVGD/HLQžGHDJRVWRGH SDUDDLQYHVWLJDomRSURFHVVRHMXOJDPHQWRGRVFULPHVSUHYLVWRVQHVWD/HLµ



6&$/&215DTXHO/LPD&RQWUROHFRQVWLWXFLRQDOGHÀQVQRGLUHLWRSHQDO7HVH 'RXWRUDGR  ²)DFXOGDGHGH'LUHLWRGD8QLYHUVLGDGH)HGHUDOGR5LR*UDQGHGR6XO3URJUDPDGH3yV *UDGXDomRHP'LUHLWRIS



6REUHRFRQWH~GRGHWDOKDGRGHWDLVSDUkPHWURVFRQIHULU6&$/&215DTXHO/LPDControle FRQVWLWXFLRQDOGHÀQVQRGLUHLWRSHQDORSFLWS



$-XVWLÀFDWLYDGR3URMHWRGH/HLQžHVWiGLVSRQtYHOHPKWWSZZZFDPDUD JRYEUSURSRVLFRHV:HESURSBPRVWUDULQWHJUDMVHVVLRQLG &$'$$$%)% ('&SURSRVLFRHV:HE"FRGWHRU  ÀOHQDPH 3/! 181

REVISTA

DE

ESTUDOS CRIMINAIS 63 DOUTRINA NACIONAL

OUTUBRO/DEZEMBRO 2016

IDWRVRFRUULGRVQRH[WHULRUHPTXHSHVHQXQFDWHUVRIULGRQHQKXPDWRHP VHXWHUULWyULRµ /RJRDSyVUHLWHUDGDVYH]HVUHSHWHTXHDOHJLVODomRDQWLWHUURULVWDSURSRVWDpFRPSDWtYHOFRPRVGLUHLWRVIXQGDPHQWDLVFRQVDJUDGRVQD&RQVWLWXLomREHPFRPRTXHVXDUHGDomRpVXÀFLHQWHPHQWHFODUDSDUDLPSHGLURVHX PDQHMRLQGHYLGRFRQWUDPRYLPHQWRVVRFLDLV1HVVHVHQWLGRDÀUPDTXH´XPD LPSRUWDQWH LQFOXVmR p D H[LVWrQFLD GH XPD FDXVD H[FOXGHQWH SDUD DV PDQLIHVWDo}HV SROtWLFDV VRFLDLV RX VLQGLFDLV PRYLGDV SRU SURSyVLWRV VRFLDLV RX UHLYLQGLFDWyULRVµ'HIHQGHDLQGDTXHVHEXVFD´FULDUXPDOHLTXHDGHTXH QRVVR RUGHQDPHQWR DRV WUDWDGRV LQWHUQDFLRQDLV DVVLQDGRV SHOR %UDVLO PDV UHVSHLWDQGRQRVVD&RQVWLWXLomR)HGHUDOHRVGLUHLWRVHJDUDQWLDVGHWRGRVRV EUDVLOHLURVHHVWUDQJHLURVµ7DPDQKDLQVLVWrQFLDSRUVLVyMiJHUDHVWUDQKH]DHLQGLFDTXHWDOYH]RSURSRQHQWHHVWHMDWHQWDQGRFRQYHQFHUHPSULPHLUR OXJDUDVL 4XDQWRDRWHPSRGRSURFHVVROHJLVODWLYRVDOWDDRVROKRVDUDSLGH]FRP TXHKRXYHDDSURYDomRGHWmRUHOHYDQWHHSROrPLFRUHJUDPHQWR1mRpSUHFLVRJUDQGHHVIRUoRSDUDGHGX]LUTXHDUHDOL]DomRGDV2OLPStDGDVGH QD&LGDGHGR5LRGH-DQHLURSUDWLFDPHQWHREULJRXR%UDVLODHPXPSLVFDU GHROKRVLQWHUQDOL]DUDVPHGLGDVWtSLFDVGDSURLELomRJOREDOGRWHUURULVPR 3RUWDOUD]mRRUHJLPHGHWUDPLWDomRDGRWDGRIRLRGHurgênciaFDUDFWHUtVWLFD FRPSDUWLOKDGDFRPRXWUDVDOWHUDo}HVOHJLVODWLYDVSHQDLVEUDVLOHLUDVTXHVHUHYHODUDPQRIXWXURFDWDVWUyÀFDV,QIHOL]PHQWHWUDWDVHGHPDLVXPFDVRQR TXDO´RWHPSRGRSRGHUSROtWLFRDWURSHODRWHPSRGDUHÁH[mRµ



,GHP



,GHP



,GHP



23URMHWRGH/HLQžIRLDSUHVHQWDGRDR&RQJUHVVR1DFLRQDOSHOR3RGHU([HFXWLYR HP  )RL DSURYDGR Mi HP  HQWUDQGR LPHGLDWDPHQWH HP YLJRU VRE D IRUPDGD/HL2UGLQiULDQž



$V /HLV Qž  /HL GRV &ULPHV +HGLRQGRV  Qž  /HL 'DQLHOOD 3HUH]  H DLQGDDQž /HLGD)DOVLÀFDomRGH0HGLFDPHQWRV VmRGLVVRH[HPSORLQHTXtYRFR 6REUHRWHPDFRQVXOWDU3$,9$/XL]*XLOKHUPH0HQGHVGHA fábrica de penas. 5DFLRQDOLGDGH OHJLVODWLYDHDOHLGRVFULPHVKHGLRQGRV5HYDQSVV



3,5(60DULD&RHOL6LP}HV3DLQHO'LiORJRVHFRQÁLWRVQRSURFHVVRGHHODERUDomRGDVOHLV FRQIHUrQFLDUHGX]LGDDWHUPR ,Q&2(/+2$OEHUWR3LQWR 2UJ Congresso internacional de legísticaTXDOLGDGHGDOHLHGHVHQYROYLPHQWR%HOR+RUL]RQWH$VVHPEOHLD/HJLVODWLYDGR (VWDGRGH0LQDV*HUDLVS 182

REVISTA

DE

ESTUDOS CRIMINAIS 63

DOUTRINA NACIONAL OUTUBRO/DEZEMBRO 2016

4XDQWRjUDFLRQDOLGDGHQRPRGRGHFRQGXomRGRSURFHVVROHJLVODWLYR Dforma FRPRDVOHLVVmRHODERUDGDVSRGHWDQWRLQFUHPHQWDUTXDQWRUHGX]LU VXDYDOLGDGHFRQVWLWXFLRQDO1mRSRUDFDVR+DEHUPDVVXVWHQWDTXHSDUFHOD GDOHJLWLPLGDGHGDVQRUPDVMXUtGLFDVGHULYDGRFXPSULPHQWRGHFHUWDVH[LJrQFLDVPtQLPDVGHUDFLRQDOLGDGHSHORSURFHVVROHJLVODWLYRTXHDVDQWHFHGHX HDVSURGX]LX1HVVHVHQWLGRHPUD]mRGRFRQWH~GRQRUPDWLYRGRSULQFtSLR GHPRFUiWLFR VXVWHQWDVH TXH R SURFHVVR OHJLVODWLYR GHYH HVWDU VHPSUH DPSDUDGR HP DUJXPHQWRV S~EOLFRV LVWR p ´H[SOtFLWRV GHÀQLGRV H VXMHLWRV D FRQWHVWDomRµ 2FRQFUHWRFXPSULPHQWRGHWDOH[LJrQFLDSDVVDULDSRUVXDYH]SHOR UHVSHLWRDWUrVGHYHUHVIXQGDPHQWDLV L ´GHYHUGHGDUUD]}HVµ LL ´GHYHU GHLQIRUPDUµH LLL ´GHYHUGHLQFOXLUHGHFRQVXOWDUDVSDUWHVLQWHUHVVDGDVµ 1HVVHFRQWH[WRRVOHJLVODGRUHVHVWDULDPREULJDGRVD L MXVWLÀFDUVXEVWDQFLDOPHQWHRSRUTXrGDVDOWHUDo}HVOHJLVODWLYDVSURSRVWDV LL GDUDPSODWUDQVSDUrQFLDDRSURFHVVRGHOLEHUDWLYRH LLL RIHUHFHUPDLRUHVSDoRGHPDQLIHVWDomR DPLQRULDVSDUODPHQWDUHVHVREUHWXGRDWHUFHLURVnão parlamentares LQWHUHVVDGRVHRXDIHWDGRV $QDOLVDQGRVHDWUDPLWDomRGR3URMHWRGH/HLQžREVHUYDVH TXHWDLVGHYHUHVIRUDPSDUFDPHQWHFXPSULGRV1mRKiMXVWLÀFDomRFODUDGDV FULPLQDOL]Do}HVUHDOL]DGDVPHQRVDLQGDGDDWULEXLomRGRVFRUUHODWRVSDWDPDUHVGHSHQDTXHGHWmRHOHYDGRVQmRHQFRQWUDPSDUQR'LUHLWREUDVLOHLUR $GHPDLVRSURFHVVRGHOLEHUDWLYRSURSULDPHQWHGLWR²VHKRXYH²HPQDGDIRL WUDQVSDUHQWH(PTXHVWmRGHWDPDQKDUHOHYkQFLDFDXVDLQFUHGXOLGDGHDQmR UHDOL]DomRGHDXGLrQFLDVS~EOLFDVGHPRGRDSRVVLELOLWDUDSDUWLFLSDomRWDQWR GHHVSHFLDOLVWDVTXDQWRGDSRSXODomRHPJHUDO



+$%(50$6 -UJHQ Facticidad y validez 6REUH HO GHUHFKR \ HO (VWDGR GHPRFUiWLFR GH GHUHFKRHQWpUPLQRVGHWHRUtDGHOGLVFXUVRHG7UDG0DQXHO-LPpQH]5HGRQGR0DGULG 7URWWDSVV



&$59$/+21(7720HQHOLFNGH3DLQHO$FRQWULEXLomRGD/HJtVWLFDSDUDXPDSROtWLFD GHOHJLVODomRFRQFHSo}HVPpWRGRVHWpFQLFDV FRQIHUrQFLDUHGX]LGDDWHUPR ,Q&2(/+2 $OEHUWR3LQWR 2UJ Congresso internacional de legísticaTXDOLGDGHGDOHLHGHVHQYROYLPHQWR %HOR+RUL]RQWH$VVHPEOHLD/HJLVODWLYDGR(VWDGRGH0LQDV*HUDLVS



92(50$16:LP4XDOLW\RI(8/HJLVODWLRQXQGHU6FUXWLQ\ZKDWNLQGRI3UREOHPE\ ZKDW NLQG RI 6WDQGDUGV" ,Q 0$'(5 /X]LXV 7$9$5(6 '( $/0(,'$ 0DUWD 2UJ  Quality of Legislation3ULQFLSOHVDQG,QVWUXPHQWV3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH1LQWK&RQJUHVVRIWKH ,QWHUQDWLRQDO$VVRFLDWLRQRI/HJLVODWLRQ ,$/ %DGHQ%DGHQ1RPRVS



6&$/&215DTXHO/LPD&RQWUROHFRQVWLWXFLRQDOGHÀQVQRGLUHLWRSHQDORSFLWS 183

REVISTA

DE

ESTUDOS CRIMINAIS 63 DOUTRINA NACIONAL

OUTUBRO/DEZEMBRO 2016

(PRXWURVWHUPRVQmRKRXYHFRQYLWHDRGLiORJRjUHÁH[mRjGLVFXVVmRVpULDDEHUWDHFRQVFLHQWHGHFDGDXPGRVWLSRVSHQDLV1mRKRXYHPHGLWDomRVREUHVXDVSRVVtYHLVREVFXULGDGHVDVTXDLVDGHSHQGHUGRtPSHWR SXQLWLYRGRLQWpUSUHWHSHUPLWHPPDLRUHVRXPHQRUHVDUELWUDULHGDGHV)DWR pTXHTXDQWRPHQRURQtYHOGHMXVWLÀFDomRGHSXEOLFLGDGHHGHLQFOXVmRQRV SURFHVVRVOHJLVODWLYRVWDQWRPDLVSURYiYHOTXHXPDGDGD&RUWH&RQVWLWXFLRQDOVHMDXWLOL]DGDFRPR´WHUFHLUDµDUHQDSROtWLFDSRUDTXHOHVTXHQmRWLYHUDP YR] 0XLWR HPERUD WUDQVSDUHoD QD -XVWLÀFDWLYD DSUHVHQWDGD XPD LPHQVD SUHRFXSDomR HP IRPHQWDU GLUHLWRV KXPDQRV H HP HYLWDU D FULPLQDOL]DomR GH PRYLPHQWRV VRFLDLV LVVR QmR HQFRQWURX DPSDUR SRU RFDVLmR GR SURFHVVROHJLVODWLYR$SUiWLFDFRQIURQWDRGLVFXUVRRSURMHWRHPTXHVWmRGHOLEHUDGDPHQWHQmRIRLVXEPHWLGRGXUDQWHVHXWUkPLWHj&RPLVVmRGH'LUHLWRV +XPDQRVH0LQRULDVGD&kPDUDPDVDSHQDVjV&RPLVV}HVGH5HODo}HV([WHULRUHV H GH 'HIHVD 1DFLRQDO GH 6HJXUDQoD 3~EOLFD H &RPEDWH DR &ULPH 2UJDQL]DGRHSRUÀPGH&RQVWLWXLomRH-XVWLoDHGH&LGDGDQLD7DOH[FOXVmR GLÀFXOWRXHPXLWRDGHIHVDGHXPDLQWHUSUHWDomRFUtWLFDGHVHXVGLVSRVLWLYRV RULHQWDGD D LPSHGLU GHVYLRV GH ÀQDOLGDGH 3RU LURQLD R TXH aparentemente WDQWRVHSUHWHQGLDHYLWDU²RPDQHMRGDOHLFRPRLQVWUXPHQWRGHFRPEDWHD GHWHUPLQDGDVLGHRORJLDV²MiJDQKDDVQRWtFLDVGHMRUQDLV )LQDOPHQWHDSRSXODomREUDVLOHLUDHPJHUDOSDUHFHGHVFRQKHFHUDOHL HSRXFRVHSUHRFXSDUFRPRWHPD)DWRpTXHQmRKRXYHTXDOTXHUHPSHQKR SRUSDUWHGRV3RGHUHVSDUDIRPHQWDURGHEDWHFUtWLFRLQWHUQR1HVVHVHQWLGRD /HLQžVXUJHPDLVSDUDGDUVDWLVIDo}HVjFRPXQLGDGHLQWHUQDFLRQDOGRTXHSURSULDPHQWHSDUDWXWHODURVGLUHLWRVIXQGDPHQWDLVHKXPDQRVQR WHUULWyULREUDVLOHLUR$RTXHWXGRLQGLFDWHPVHXPUHJUDPHQWRQmRDSHQDV SRWHQFLDOPHQWHLQHÀFD]IUHQWHDRVREMHWLYRVGHFODUDGRVPDVWDPEpPSHULJRVDPHQWH~WLODREMHWLYRVODWHQWHVREVFXURVHSRXFRGHPRFUiWLFRV 

(1*(/&KULVWRSK7KH&RQVWLWXWLRQDO&RXUW²DSSO\LQJWKHSURSRUWLRQDOLW\SULQFLSOH²DV D VXEVLGLDU\ DXWKRULW\ IRU WKH DVVHVVPHQW RI SROLWLFDO RXWFRPHV ,Q *HPHLQVFKDIWVJWHU 5HFKW 3ROLWLN XQG gNRQRPLH 3UHSULQWV DXV GHU 0D[3ODQFN3URMHNWJUXSSH 5HFKW GHU *HPHLQVFKDIWVJWHU%RQQS



7UDWDVH GH SULVmR UHDOL]DGD QR (VWDGR GH *RLiV FRQWUD LQWHJUDQWHV GR 0RYLPHQWR GRV 7UDEDOKDGRUHV5XUDLV6HP7HUUD 067 FRPEDVHQDVDOWHUDo}HVTXHD/HLQž SURPRYHXQRDUWž†žGD/HLQž /HLGDV2UJDQL]Do}HV&ULPLQRVDV 9DULDGRV YHtFXORVGHFRPXQLFDomRQRWLFLDUDPRFDVR9HULOXVWUDWLYDPHQWHDVVHJXLQWHVUHSRUWDJHQV KWWSJJORERFRPJRLDVQRWLFLDLQWHJUDQWHGRPVWHVWDSUHVRFRP EDVHQDOHLDQWLWHUURULVPRHPJRLDVKWPO! H KWWSSROLWLFDHVWDGDRFRPEUQRWLFLDV JHUDOMXVWLFDPDQWHPVHPWHUUDSUHVRVFRPEDVHQDOHLDQWLWHUURULVPR! 184

REVISTA

DE

ESTUDOS CRIMINAIS 63

DOUTRINA NACIONAL OUTUBRO/DEZEMBRO 2016

)UHQWHDRH[SRVWRQmRKiUD]}HVSDUDRWLPLVPR1mRVHDFUHGLWDTXH QRVVD6XSUHPD&RUWHSRVVDVLPSOHVPHQWHUHVLVWLUDRWUDQVSODQWHGRUHJLPH GH SURLELomR JOREDO GR WHUURULVPR SDUD R RUGHQDPHQWR LQWHUQR (VSHUDVH FRQWXGR TXH HOD H[HUoD VXD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH QD FRRSHUDomR SURPRYHQGR D FRPXQLFDELOLGDGH SRVVtYHO PDV SUHVHUYDQGR R TXH Ki GH LUUHQXQFLiYHO &RQFUHWDPHQWHLVVRVLJQLÀFDHPQRVVDRSLQLmR L GHFODUDULQFRQVWLWXFLRQDLV LQWHUSUHWDo}HVTXHFRQGX]DPDGHVYLRVGHÀQDOLGDGHGD/HLQž DTXL FDUDFWHUL]DGRV SHOR VHX PDQHMR FRQWUD GHWHUPLQDGDV LGHRORJLDV H LL  HYLWDU TXH GLUHLWRV KXPDQRV H IXQGDPHQWDLV SHUHoDP HP QRPH LURQLFDPHQWHGDVXDSUySULDSURWHomRHWXWHODSHODQRYDOHJLVODomRHPIDFHGD DPHDoDWHUURULVWD CONCLUSÃO e SUHFLVR HQFRQWUDU R SRQWR HQWUH GXDV SHUVSHFWLYDV H[DFHUEDGDV GH XPODGRDGRVDWRUHVQDFLRQDLVFRPRDSOLFDGRUHVFHJRVGRGLUHLWRLQWHUQDFLRQDOGRWDGRGHVXSUHPDFLDHGHRXWURDGHVXDSHUFHSomRFRPRDWLYLVWDV HQJDMDGRVHPXPDUHVLVWrQFLDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOQDFLRQDO1HPFRPRchauffeurs GDVQRUPDVLQWHUQDFLRQDLVOHYDGDVDWUDQVLWDUSHORGLUHLWRLQWHUQRHPYLUWXGH GH VXD UHVSHLWDGD RULJHP QHP FRPR cães-de-guarda GDV QRUPDV QDFLRQDLV SURWHJLGDV GH XPD VXSRVWD DPHDoD GH LQYDVmR WHUULWRULDO (P XP (VWDGR &RQVWLWXFLRQDOFRRSHUDWLYR +DEHUOH TXHSRUFHUWRGHYHHVWDUFRPSURPHWLGRFRPRHQIUHQWDPHQWRGDYLROrQFLDVHPUHQXQFLDUDR(VWDGRGH'LUHLWRp SUHFLVRFRPSUHHQGHURVDWRUHVQDFLRQDLVHVSHFLDOPHQWHRV7ULEXQDLVFRPR ´]HODGRUHV GR SRUWmR GH HQWUDGDµ JDWHNHHSHUV  iUELWURV GH XP UHODFLRQDPHQWR TXH GHYH VHU DR PHVPR WHPSR GH EDL[R SDUD FLPD H GH FLPD SDUD EDL[R$UHVSRVWDDRVWHUPRVHjDSOLFDomRGDOHLDQWLWHUURULVPREUDVLOHLUDVHUi XPLPSRUWDQWHLQGLFDGRUGHFRPRDMXULVGLomRQDFLRQDOSUHWHQGHH[HUFHUVXD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGHQDFRRSHUDomRchauffeursFmHVGHJXDUGDRX]HODGRUHV" REFERÊNCIAS $/(;
Lihat lebih banyak...

Comentários

Copyright © 2017 DADOSPDF Inc.