RESEARCH FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF ALABAMA AT BIRMINGHAM
Assessment of Aortic Regurgitation by Live Three-Dimensional Transthoracic Echocardiographic Measurements of Vena Contracta Area: Usefulness and Validation Ligang Fang, M.D., Ming Chon Hsiung, M.D.,∗ Andrew P. Miller, M.D., Navin C. Nanda, M.D., Wei Hsian Yin, M.D.,∗ Mason S. Young, M.D.,∗ and Dasan E. Velayudhan, M.B.B.S. Division of Cardiovascular Diseases, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, Alabama ∗ Division of Cardiology, Cheng-Hsin Medical Center, Taipei, Taiwan, Republic of China In this report, we evaluate 56 consecutive adult patients who underwent standard two-dimensional (2D) and live three-dimensional transthoracic echocardiography (3D TTE), as well as left heart catheterization with aortography (45 patients) or cardiac surgery (11 patients), for evaluation of aortic insufficiency. Similar to the method we previously described for mitral insufficiency, aortic regurgitant vena contracta area (VCA) was obtained by 3D TTE by systematic and sequential cropping of the acquired 3D TTE data set. Assessments of aortic regurgitation (AR) by aortography and surgery are compared to measurements of VCA by 3D TTE and to 2D TTE measurements of vena contracta width (VCW). Aortographic or surgical grading correlated well with 2D TTE measurements of VCW (r = 0.92), but correlated better with 3D TTE measurements of VCA (r = 0.95), with improved dispersion between angiographic grades demonstrated by the 3D TTE technique. Live 3D TTE color Doppler measurements of VCA can be used for accurate assessment of AR and are comparable to assessment by aortography. (ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY, Volume 22, October 2005) aortic regurgitation, vena contracta area, vena contracta width, live three-dimensional echocardiography Introduction Assessing severity of aortic regurgitation (AR) accurately has been challenging using various qualitative and quantitative twodimensional transthoracic (2D TTE) color Doppler techniques.1 Most commonly, the ratio of AR jet width immediately below the aortic valve to the inner left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) width taken in the same frame is employed.2,3 Proximal jet width is taken on the ventricular aspect of the aortic valve and essentially represents the vena contracta, which is the size of the jet within the leaflets Address for correspondence and reprint requests: Navin C. Nanda, M.D., University of Alabama at Birmingham, Heart Station SWB/S102, 619 19th Street South, Birmingham, Alabama 35249. Fax: 205-934-6747; E-mail:
[email protected]
Vol. 22, No. 9, 2005
and extending for a small but variable extent into the LVOT.1 Quantitative assessment using the volumetric approach and proximal flow convergence methods have been described, but are limited in use because they require assumptions that are mostly inaccurate.1,4–7 Despite a large number of investigational studies, the assessment of AR quantification by various echocardiographic modalities remains challenging without a perfect technique, and current guidelines suggest an integrative approach.1 Proximal jet or vena contracta width (VCW) is the most time honored of the 2D TTE approaches and has good correlation with angiographic grading and regurgitant orifice area.2,3,6,7 If the exact size and shape of the vena contracta were available, it would be easy
ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY: A Jrnl. of CV Ultrasound & Allied Tech.
775
FANG, ET AL.
to measure the regurgitant volume by multiplying the vena contracta area (VCA) with the velocity time integral (VTI) of the continuous wave Doppler waveform of the AR jet. However, in the parasternal long-axis or apical views, only one dimension of the AR jet is visualized, and hence its size or area cannot be measured unless an assumption is made regarding its shape. Generally, VCA is considered circular or elliptical, but this is mostly an incorrect assumption.8 A short-axis view taken at the level of the aortic valve leaflets on 2D TTE color Doppler would probably delineate the VCA in 3D, but because of cardiac motion, it is difficult to be certain one is not measuring the jet size further downstream where it tends to be larger. Also, it is difficult to be certain that the shortaxis echo plane is exactly parallel to the vena contracta. On the other hand, a pyramidal data set, acquired with live or real-time 3D echo, can be cropped at any desired angle and the plane aligned exactly parallel to the vena contracta in a short-axis plane. Thus, 3D echo obviates the limitations of 2D TTE color Doppler, is a relatively simple technique, and represents a useful supplement to 2D TTE. In the present study, we examine the usefulness of 3D TTE as an alternative modality in assessing AR severity using an improved and comprehensive visualization of vena contracta geometry. Methods This study included 56 patients (36 females, age 58.3 ± 16.6 years) who were referred for echocardiography for evaluation of AR to our institutions and who subsequently underwent cardiac catheterization with aortography and/or cardiac surgery within 72 hours of 3D TTE. Patients included in the study had at least mild AR by 2D TTE. The etiology of AR varied widely and was endocarditis in eight, prolapse in six, bicuspid morphology in seven, rheumatic in four, degenerative in 20, secondary to aortic dilatation or aneurysm in eight and unknown in three. Most had normal left ventricular systolic function (ejection fraction >55% in 50, 45–55% in one, and 33–45% in five) and AR was central in 37 and eccentric in 19. Echocardiography A standard examination was completed on each patient in the left lateral decubitus position using both apical and parasternal views. 2D TTE studies were performed using a 3.5 776
MHz probe and a commercially available ultrasound system [Philips Sonos 7500 (n = 31 patients), or IE33 (n = 25 patients), Andover, MA]. Vena contracta width was measured as the smallest neck of flow at the level of the aortic valve.1 ,9 In patients with more than one AR jet (three cases), the VCW was taken as the sum of all individual vena contracta widths. After completion of the standard 2D TTE in each patient, live and real-time 3D TTE was then performed in all patients using the same ultrasound system and a 4 MHz 4X transducer capable of providing real-time B-mode and color Doppler 3-dimensional images in apical and parasternal views. Factory defaults on the echocardiographic system were used for acquisition of all images and the Nyquist limit was selected between 42–69 cm/s as discussed previously.10 Approximately 5–7 seconds of breath-holding were needed to collect each 3D TTE data set. The 3D data sets were transferred to an offline QLab system for analysis in all 56 patients. Data were stored digitally and subsequently evaluated by two echocardiographers. Measurement of VCA by 3D TTE As shown in Figure 1 and as described previously for mitral regurgitation,10 systematic cropping of the acquired 3D TTE data set was used to measure VCA. First, from a parasternal long-axis view (55 cases) or from an apical view when the parasternal window was poor (one case), the best AR jet in long axis was obtained by posterior-to-anterior cropping of the 3D TTE data set. Second, the 3D TTE color Doppler data set was cropped from the aortic side to the level of the vena contracta, at or just below the aortic valve leaflets, in a plane that was exactly perpendicular to the AR jet viewed in long axis. The image was then tilted en face, and the cropped portion of the data set was added back to obtain the maximum area of vena contracta viewed in short axis in systole. In patients with multiple AR jets (five cases) the VCA was taken as the sum of all individual vena contracta areas. Measurements of VCA were obtained by off-line analysis on Q-LAB software in all patients. In addition, in 17 patients, VCA was also measured by planimetry via the trace function using the VCR functions on an echocardiographic system and the depth markers for calibration. Aortography AR grading by aortography was performed using the method of Hunt et al.11
ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY: A Jrnl. of CV Ultrasound & Allied Tech.
Vol. 22, No. 9, 2005
3D TTE VENA CONTRACTA AREA FOR AR
Figure 1. Live three-dimensional color Doppler transthoracic echocardiographic technique for assessment of aortic regurgitation (AR) vena contracta. The three-dimensional color Doppler data set showing AR (A) is cropped using an oblique plane to the level of the vena contracta (arrowhead, B) and tilted to view it en face (C, D). The vena contracta is then planimetered. AO = aorta; LA = left atrium; LV = left ventricle; RV = right ventricle.
Figure 4. Live three-dimensional transthoracic echocardiographic assessment of aortic valve perforations in two patients with endocarditis. Left: Two perforations (numbered 1 and 2) demonstrated by cropping of the three-dimensional color Doppler data set. Right: Arrowheads demonstrate multiple perforations in a patient with almost totally destroyed aortic cusps at surgery. Vol. 22, No. 9, 2005
ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY: A Jrnl. of CV Ultrasound & Allied Tech.
777
FANG, ET AL.
Statistics Statistical calculations were performed using the program Statistica (Statsoft, Tulsa, OK). Spearman rank correlations between TTE measurements and aortographic grading of AR were calculated. Measurements by two echocardiographers blinded to each others’ results and the aortographic and surgical findings, and by one echocardiographer after a 1 month time delay with blinding to previous results were compared to obtain interobserver and intraobserver variability, respectively. For all measurements a P-value of less than 0.05 was considered significant. Results Aortography revealed grade I AR in 12 patients, grade II in 8, grade III in 14, and grade IV in 11 patients. An additional 11 patients underwent surgery without angiography, during which severe AR was verified by direct inspection. 2D TTE measurements of VCW were obtained in all patients and ranged from 0.14 to
1.2 cm. 3D TTE measurements of VCA were likewise obtained in all participants and ranged from 0.07 to 1.53 cm2 . Comparisons of AR assessment by 3D and 2D TTE with aortography revealed highest agreement for the 3D TTE measurements. VCA from 3D TTE closely correlated with angiographic grading (rs = 0.95, P < 0.001; Fig. 2), with little overlap evident between grades of AR. When criteria of 0.6 cm2 for grade IV AR were utilized, only two patients did not match angiographic and VCA grades. Whether the regurgitant jet was central or eccentric did not affect VCA grading. VCW by 2D TTE correlated well (rs = 0.92, P < 0.001; Fig. 3), but with more overlap between aortographic grades of AR. Interobserver and intraobserver variability was very low for 3D TTE measurements of VCA (r = 0.95 and r = 0.95). Further, consistent with our past results,10 the on-line processing procedure for calculating VCA was valid and reproducible. Measurements of 3D TTE VCA obtained on the echocardiographic
1.6 n=56 rs=0.947 p
