DiGRA 2017 Review Template.docx

Review (*). In writing your review please comment on some or all of the following:
Contribution: Provide a short paragraph outlining the major findings, argument and/or contributions of the paper.
Pre-amble: do the title, abstract and introduction clearly introduce and scope the paper?
Background: is the paper adequately located within the area of research and does it draw on appropriate literature?
Methods: are appropriate methods used and are they sufficient explained in the paper?
Findings and Analysis: Does the paper present logical and consistent analysis and argument?
Conclusions: Does the paper make appropriate and interesting conclusions?
Writing: Is the paper clear and concise?
Referencing: Have appropriate reference materials been cited and is the bibliography correct?
Formatting: Has the paper used the template?
Relevance: Is the paper relevant to the audience?