FILOSOFIA COMO EXPERIÊNCIA E COMO EDUCAÇÃO
Descrição do Produto
FILOSOFIA COMO EXPERIÊNCIA E COMO EDUCAÇÃO* Marcos Sidnei Pagotto-Euzebio**
$)LORVR¿DpXPDLQYHQomRSODW{QLFD'HIDWR3ODWmRpWDOYH]R ~QLFRILOyVRIRDXWRUGHXPDREUDTXHVHVXVWHQWDLQWHLUDPHQWHSRUVL VHPDSHJRDQDGDTXHMiWHQKDH[LVWLGRHTXHSUHWHQGH±HFRQVHJXHHP JUDQGHSDUWH±WUDWDUde tudoGHWRGDDH[SHULrQFLDKXPDQD(P3ODWmR QyVTXHQRVGHGLFDPRVj)LORVR¿DWHPRVQRVVRVOLYURVVDJUDGRVnossas escriturasjVTXDLVVHPSUHQRVUHIHULPRVVHMDPRVQyV¿pLVVHJXLGRUHV GRHVStULWRGHVVHSDLIXQGDGRURXHQWmRKHUHJHVUHIRUPDGRUHVPDLVRX PHQRVUDGLFDLV3ODWmRHVFROKHXRVVHXVDQWHFHVVRUHVWUD]HQGRRVSDUDR WHUULWyULRGD)LORVR¿DSRUHOHFULDGDHinventandoXPDWUDGLomRDTXDOVH ¿OLDU QmRjWRDRV¿OyVRIRVSUpVRFUiWLFRVVmRDVVLPFKDPDGRV PHOKRU VHULDFKDPiORVQRHQWDQWRGHSUpSODW{QLFRVSRUTXH6yFUDWHVRXDR PHQRVR6yFUDWHVTXHQRVLQWHUHVVDIRLHOHWDPEpPHPJUDQGHPHGLGD XPDLQYHQomRSODW{QLFD 7RPHPRVGHVWHXQLYHUVRSRUWDQWRGXDVLPDJHQVGDVLQ~PHUDVTXH 3ODWmRQRVGHL[RXHPVXDVREUDV $SULPHLUDGHODVpDPDLVIDPRVDDPDLVFRQKHFLGDWmRH[DJHUD GDPHQWHFRQKHFLGDTXHWDOYH]LPDJLQHPRVVDEHURTXHHODQRVPRVWUD DQWHVPHVPRGHHQFRQWUDUPRQRVFRPHOD)DORGDalegoria da caverna DFpOHEUHLPDJHPTXHIRLWRPDGDQmRDSHQDVFRPRUHVXPRRXHPEOHPD
$XODLQDXJXUDOGRFXUVRGH)LORVR¿DGD8QLYHUVLGDGH0HWRGLVWDGH6mR3DXOR±80(63 UHDOL]DGDHPGHIHYHUHLURGH2WH[WRTXHVHVHJXHpDYHUVmRHVFULWDGDFRQIH UrQFLDTXHUHWpPDVPDUFDVGDRUDOLGDGHWtSLFDVGHXPDDSUHVHQWDomRGHVVHWLSR
3URIHVVRUGD)(863
60
FILOSOFIA COMO EXPERIÊNCIA E COMO EDUCAÇÃO
GD)LORVR¿DSODW{QLFDPDVGDSUySULD)LORVR¿DGHVGHHQWmR2TXHWHPRV DOL"1RLQtFLRGR/LYUR9,,GDRepúblicaQRSRQWRTXHpSRUDVVLPGL]HU RHL[RHPWRUQRGRTXDORUELWDDREUDSODW{QLFDQHVVHFRPHoRGR/LYUR 9,,6yFUDWHVDSUHVHQWDSDUD*ODXFRVHXLQWHUORFXWRUXPDKLVWyULD PRVWUD DHOHXPFHQiULRFRPDWRUHVHXPFHQiULRHPTXHXPFULYRIXQFLRQDUi FRPRGLVWLQomR &RPSDUDQRVVDQDWXUH]DFRQIRUPHVHMDRXQmRHGXFDGDFRPDVHJXLQ WHVLWXDomR LPDJLQDKRPHQVHPXPDPRUDGDVXEWHUUkQHDHPIRUPDGH FDYHUQDSURYLGDGHXPD~QLFDHQWUDGDFRPYLVWDSDUDDOX]HPWRGDD VXDODUJXUD(QFRQWUDPVHQHVVHOXJDUGHVGHSHTXHQRVSHUQDVHSHVFRoR DPDUUDGRVFRPFDGHLDVGHIRUPDTXHVmRIRUoDGRVDDOLSHUPDQHFHUHD ROKDUDSHQDVSDUDDIUHQWHLPSRVVLELOLWDGRVFRPRVHDFKDPSHODVFDGHLDV GHYLUDUDFDEHoD
2XVHMDSHUFHEDGL]6yFUDWHVD*ODXFRFRPRVRPRVnósVHUHVKX PDQRVFRQIRUPHQRVVDQDWXUH]DQRVVDphysisWHQKDVLGRRXQmRHGXFDGD 3ODWmRSHODERFDGH6yFUDWHVXWLOL]DRVWHUPRVpaideíaHapaideusíaRX VHMDHGXFDomRHLJQRUkQFLD RXPDLVULJRURVDPHQWH falta de educação ,PSRUWDQWHQRWDUTXHQHVVHSRQWRD[LDOGDRepública3ODWmRFRORFDFRPR IXQGDPHQWRGHWRGRRUHVWDQWHFODUDPHQWHDSUHVHQoDRXDDXVrQFLDGD HGXFDomRGHXPSURFHVVRIRUPDWLYR0DLVGRTXHDVGHVFULo}HVVREUHD HGXFDomRGRVJXDUGL}HVFRPWRGRVRVVHXVGHWDOKHVIRLHVVDIUDVHFXUWD TXHWDOYH]WHQKDIHLWR5RXVVHDXD¿UPDUQREmílioTXHDRepúblicaDR FRQWUiULRGRTXHSHQVDPRVTXHMXOJDPRVOLYURVDSHQDVSHODVFDSDVp RPDLVLPSRUWDQWHWUDWDGRGHHGXFDomRMiHVFULWR(HVVDGLYLVmRHQWUH LJQRUDQWHHilustradosLUiVHGHVGREUDUQRFHQiULRPRQWDGRSRU6yFUDWHV SDUD*ODXFR RVLJQRUDQWHVSUHVRVQRIXQGRGHXPDFDYHUQDQDGDVDEHP DFHUFDGD³YHUGDGHLUDUHDOLGDGH´HDLQGDTXHYLYDPHPXPPXQGRGH VLPXODFURVHLPDJHQVGHULYDGDVSHQVDPFRQKHFHURUHDOWDOFRPRHOHp 0DVGL]6yFUDWHVRTXHYHHPVmRVRPEUDVHLOXV}HVLQFDSD]HVGHVDLU SRUVLPHVPRVGHVVDFRQGLomRGHLJQRUkQFLD3DUDLVVRVHUiSUHFLVRD LQWHUYHQomRGHXPDIRUoDH[WHUQDTXHOLEHUWHHVVHVSULVLRQHLURV(ODDJH FRPHPSHQKRHYLROrQFLD RWH[WRSODW{QLFRIDODGH³IRUoDURSULVLRQHLUR
P/$72A RepúblicaDE7UDG&DUORV$OEHUWR1XQHV3DUi (GLWRUD
GD8QLYHUVLGDGHGR3DUi
Revista Páginas de Filosofia, v. 7, n. 1, p.59-‐70, jan./jun. 2015
REVISTA PÁGINAS DE FILOSOFIA
61
DYROWDUDFDEHoD´³REULJiORDROKDUSDUDDVDtGDGDFDYHUQD´³DUUDVWiOR SDUDIRUD´PHVPRFRQWUDVXDYRQWDGH 4XHPpHVVHTXHIRUoDHOLEHUWD"7XGROHYDDFUHUTXH3ODWmRIDOH DTXLGH6yFUDWHVGR6yFUDWHVTXHHOHFRQKHFHXHTXHPRUUHUDKDYLDYiULRV DQRVTXDQGRHVVDVOLQKDVIRUDPHVFULWDV1HVVHPHVPRVHQWLGRGLDQWHGR HVSDQWRGH*ODXFRFRPDGHVFULomRGHSHVVRDVSUHVDVGHPDQHLUDWmRHVWUD QKD6yFUDWHVDGLDQWDRHQUHGRHpiscandoSDUDROHLWRUGRGLiORJRTXDVH TXHVHGLULJLQGRGLUHWDPHQWHDRS~EOLFRTXHROrHTXHROHUi3ODWmRID] TXHHOHGLJDFRPRTXHIRUDGRWH[WR±HIRUDGRWHPSRHGRHVSDoRsub specie aeternitatis±TXHFRQWLQXDPRVDVHUGHVGHVHPSUHWDLVSULVLRQHLURV 2XVHMDSRGHPRVFRQFHEHUTXHHVVHTXHOLEHUWDRSULVLRQHLURpXP ¿OyVRIRPDVRSULVLRQHLURXPDYH]OLEHUWDGRXPDYH]IRUoDGRDVXELU D³tQJUHPHHQFRVWD´HPGLUHomRDRVROHOHPHVPRVHWRUQDILOyVRIRH UHWRUQDjVXDFDYHUQDSDUDOLEHUWDURVVHXVFRPSDQKHLURVPHUJXOKDGRV QRHUUReSRUDPRUTXHHOHYROWDpSRUDPRUTXHR¿OyVRIRLUiREULJDU VHXVFRPSDQKHLURVDYLUDUHPDFDEHoDHROKDUSDUDDVDtGDGDFDYHUQD2 ¿OyVRIRDPDDVSHVVRDVHSRULVVRDVLQFRPRGD2UHVXOWDGRSRUYH]HV SRGHVHUGHVDJUDGiYHOSDUDHVVHKHUyLGDFRQVFLrQFLD RLQtFLRGR/LYUR 9,,ID]PHQomRjPRUWHGH6yFUDWHVTXDQGRGL]TXHPXLWRVYmRGHVHMDU GDUFDERGHXPVXMHLWRWmRLUULWDQWHHRIHQVLYR (PVXPDHVVDpDKLVWyULDRFOLFKr¿ORVy¿FRFHOHEUDGRHPWRGROX JDURQGHVHIDOHGD)LORVR¿D+iQRHQWDQWRDOJXQVSRQWRVTXHHXJRVWDULD GHGHVWDFDUGHVVHHQUHGR RSULPHLURpDTXHOHTXHDSUHVHQWDRLQRPLQDGR FRPRUHVSRQViYHOSHODOLEHUWDomRGRSULVLRQHLUR ³&RQVLGHUD´GL]R6yFUDWHVSODW{QLFR³RTXHDFRQWHFHULDVHXP GHVVHVSULVLRQHLURVIRVVHOLEHUWDGRGHVXDVFDGHLDVHIRUoDGRDYLUDUD FDEHoD´2VXMHLWRGDDomRpLQGHWHUPLQDGRHSDVVDPRVFUHLRHXPXLWR UDSLGDPHQWHSRUVREUHHVVHGHWDOKH(PVXPDSRGHPRVSHUJXQWDUTXHPRX RTXHOLEHUWRXRSULPHLURSULVLRQHLURRXHQWmRTXHPOLEHUWRXROLEHUWDGRU ,VVRQmRpGHSRXFDLPSRUWkQFLD1RMênonQR¿QDOGRGLiORJR6yFUDWHV HVHXLQWHUORFXWRUDFDEDPHPDSRULDGLDQWHGDSRVVLELOLGDGHRXQmRGHVH HQVLQDUDYLUWXGH8PDGDVVDtGDVpDSRVWDUHPXPDgraça divinaXPSUH VHQWHGRVGHXVHV±theia moira±TXHGrDRKRPHPDaretéDSDUHQWHPHQWH LPSRVVtYHOGHDOFDQoDUSHORHQVLQRRXSHODHGXFDomR 6HQDAlegoriaDRFRPSDUDUDVLWXDomRGRLJQRUDQWHSUHVRQDFDYHU QDFRPDGRViELRRXDSUHQGL]GHViELRRXVHMDR¿OyVRIR6yFUDWHVFRQ¿D HPXPpercurso formativoTXHOHYHjYHUGDGHHDRFRQKHFLPHQWRGRUHDO Revista Páginas de Filosofia, v. 7, n. 1, p.59-‐70, jan./jun. 2015
62
FILOSOFIA COMO EXPERIÊNCIA E COMO EDUCAÇÃO
QmRVDEHPRVDLQGDTXHPOLEHUWRXHVVHPHVWUHRULJLQiULR1DApologiaR PDJLVWpULRVRFUiWLFRWHPLQtFLRTXDQGRHOHMipXPKRPHPGHTXDVH DQRVHHVVHLQtFLRpGDGRSHODSDODYUDGRGHXV HOHFRPHoDVXDWDUHIDGH LQYHVWLJDomRSDUDFRPSUHHQGHURRUiFXORTXHGLVVHUDVHU6yFUDWHVRPDLV ViELRGHWRGRVRVKRPHQV2XVHMDQRFRPHoRWHPRVDJUDoDGLYLQDRXVH TXLVHUPRVGDUOKHRXWURQRPHRacasoRXDfortunaTXHJHUDXP¿OyVRIR OHJtWLPRJHUDGRUGHRXWURV¿OyVRIRV 2UDQyVSURIHVVRUHVGH)LORVR¿DXVDPRVGHVVDVLPDJHQVLQ~PH UDVYH]HVHTXDVHVHPSUHTXDQGRDSUHVHQWDPRVDAlegoria da Caverna SDUDRVQRVVRVDOXQRVDSRQWDPRVDHOHVDQHFHVVLGDGHGHVDLUGRkPELWR GRVHQVRFRPXPPDOGLVIDUoDQGRFHUWRSUD]HULQWHOHFWXDOSRUHVWDUPRV ID]HQGRLVVRSRUHOHV $¿QDODWXDPRVDOLQRSDSHOGHTXHPYROWDSDUDDFDYHUQDD¿PGH VDOYDUFRQVFLrQFLDV1RHQWDQWRUHVWDDSHUJXQWD HDQyVTXHPOLEHUWRX" &RPRLPDJLQDUTXHQRVVDVDtGDGDFDYHUQDQmRIRLDSHQDVDHQWUDGDHP RXWUD"(VVDpXPDGL¿FXOGDGHTXHDAlegoriaSODW{QLFDFDUUHJDHPVLH TXHHVWiOLJDGDDRVHJXQGRDVSHFWRTXHHXJRVWDULDGHLQGLFDU 'HIDWRDVDtGDGDFDYHUQDpDDVFHQVmRDRSODQRGRLQWHOLJtYHO $LQGDTXHQROLPLWHQXQFDDOFDQoDGRSOHQDPHQWH 3ODWmRFRQVLGHUDYDTXH SRXTXtVVLPRVVHULDPRVFDSD]HVGHDOFDQoDUDFRQWHPSODomRGDV)RUPDV DIDVWDGRGDeikasiaHGDdóxaHSUy[LPRGDepistemeHGDnoesisHVVHFR QKHFLPHQWRSRVWXODVHUXPVDEHUVREUHRPXQGRHRKRPHPFDSD]GHGDU FRQWDGHDPERV1yVFRQKHFHPRVHVVDSUHWHQVmRGD)LORVR¿DHDLQGDTXH RSHQVDPHQWRGH3ODWmRQmRSRVVDQHPGHORQJHVHUFKDPDGRGHVLVWHPD KiQHOHRHVStULWRJHRPpWULFR±TXHpRHVStULWRVLVWHPiWLFR±GDVJUDQGHV FRQVWUXo}HVGRVJUDQGHVHGLItFLRV¿ORVy¿FRVHVSHUDQoRVRVGHGDUFRQWD GHWXGR2SUREOHPDpTXHHVVDSUHWHQVmRKRMHQmRVHVXVWHQWDPDLV 'HSRLVGH1LHW]VFKHSHORPHQRVGHSRLVGH.LHUNHJDDUGDHVSHUDQoDGH XPGLVFXUVR¿ORVy¿FRFDSD]GHDOFDQoDUXPDYHUGDGHLQFRQWRUQiYHOTXH IRVVHDRPHVPRWHPSRXPDYHUGDGHDFHUFDGRPXQGRHVREUHRKRPHP LVWRpTXHLQFOXDQDVSUHVFULo}HVGDpWLFDHGDSROtWLFDDGHVFREHUWDGH FRPRDVFRLVDVVmRKDUPRQL]DQGRKRPHPHFLGDGHKRPHPHPRUDOD SDUWLUGHXPDFRQH[mRQHFHVViULDHQWUHVDEHUHGHYHUVHUHVVDSUHWHQVmR DFDERXeRTXH/\RWDUGFKDPRXGH¿PGDVPHWDQDUUDWLYDVGRVGLVFXUVRV WRWDOL]DQWHVRXVHTXLVHUPRVGHpós-moderno Revista Páginas de Filosofia, v. 7, n. 1, p.59-‐70, jan./jun. 2015
REVISTA PÁGINAS DE FILOSOFIA
63
0DVHXJRVWDULDGHYROWDUD3ODWmR (XGLVVHQRFRPHoRTXHLULDWRPDUHPSUHVWDGRGH3ODWmRGXDVLPD JHQV$SULPHLUDIRLHVVDGDAlegoria da Caverna$JRUDWRPRRXWUDTXH HQFRQWUDPRVHPXPGLiORJRHVFULWRPXLWRSURYDYHOPHQWHQRFRPHoRGD FDUUHLUDGH3ODWmRSRGHQGRPHVPRWHUVLGRRSULPHLURGLiORJRHVFULWRSRU HOHDOJXQVDQRVDQWHVGDApologiaTXHDRTXHWXGRLQGLFDpGH D& )DORGRPrimeiro AlcibíadesTXHGXUDQWHWRGDDDQWLJXLGDGHIRLFRQVLGHUDGD XPDREUDDXWrQWLFDGH3ODWmRPDVTXHSDVVRXDVRIUHUFRPDVG~YLGDVGRV HGLWRUHVGDHUDPRGHUQDDSDUWLUGR5HQDVFLPHQWR+RMHQRHQWDQWRVXD DXWRULDpSRXFRFRQWHVWDGDHYRXFRQVLGHUiORXPDREUDVHQmRHVFULWD GLUHWDPHQWHSRU3ODWmRDRPHQRVSURGX]LGDQRkPELWRGD$FDGHPLD 3RLVEHPRTXHHQFRQWUDPRVQRPrimeiro Alcibíades"&RPRHUDGH VHHVSHUDURSHUVRQDJHPTXHGiQRPHDRGLiORJRHVWiDOLMXQWRGH6y FUDWHVFRPTXHPFRQYHUVD$OFLEtDGHVIRLXPSHUVRQDJHPLPSRUWDQWHGD KLVWyULDGH$WHQDVDPDGRHRGLDGRQDPHVPDPHGLGDGRWDGRGHWDOHQWRV LQTXHVWLRQiYHLVPDVWDPEpPGHYtFLRVHYLGHQWHV)LOKRGDDOWDQREUH]D GHVXDFLGDGHSDUWLFLSRXGDSROtWLFDGXUDQWHD*XHUUDGR3HORSRQHVRH FRPDQGRXDPDOIDGDGDH[SHGLomRFRQWD6LUDFXVDQD6LFtOLDTXDQGRD 0DULQKDDWHQLHQVHIRLGHUURWDGDGHPDQHLUDTXDVHGH¿QLWLYD$FXVDGRSRU HVVHGHVDVWUHDVVRFLDGRMiDXPDSpVVLPDIDPD$OFLEtDGHVSDVVDSDUDR ODGRGRVHVSDUWDQRVWUDLQGRDSiWULDHWHUPLQDQGRVXDYLGD±QmRVHPDQWHV WHUYROWDGRSDUD$WHQDV±QRLQFrQGLRGDFDVDRQGHHVWDYDTXHHUDWDPEpP DFDVDGHVXDDPDQWHLPSHGLGRGHVDLUSHORPDULGRTXHHUDWDPEpPSRU DFDVRXPViWUDSDGR*UDQGH5HL 2XVHMD$OFLEtDGHVIRLXPD¿JXUDSROrPLFDHPXOWLIDFHWDGDFRPR QRVpDSUHVHQWDGRQRBanqueteSODW{QLFRSRUH[HPSORGHVGHVXDHQWUDGD QDFDVDGH$JDWmRDFRPSDQKDGRGHWRFDGRUHVGHÀDXWDGHMRYHQVHGH ÀRUHVDWpRHQFRQWURFRPXP6yFUDWHVFRQVWUDQJLGRDTXHPHOHGHFODUD VHXDPRU$OFLEtDGHVSRUWDQWRIRLXPKRPHPGDVSDL[}HVGDLQFRQVWkQ FLDGDGHVPHGLGD'LUtDPRVKRMH XPKHUyLURPkQWLFRmaior que a vida 1RHQWDQWRR$OFLEtDGHVFRPTXHP6yFUDWHVGLDORJDQHVVDREUDGH MXYHQWXGHGH3ODWmRpXP$OFLEtDGHVMRYHPDQVLRVRSRULQJUHVVDUQDYLGD S~EOLFDQRVGHEDWHVSROtWLFRVDOPHMDQGRFRPHoDUVXDFDUUHLUDGHOtGHU GDFLGDGH2UDQHVVHSRQWR6yFUDWHVLQWHUYpPHID]DSHUJXQWDTXHQRV LQWHUHVVD desejoso de comandar a cidade, os homens, seria Alcibíades Revista Páginas de Filosofia, v. 7, n. 1, p.59-‐70, jan./jun. 2015
64
FILOSOFIA COMO EXPERIÊNCIA E COMO EDUCAÇÃO
capaz de governar a si mesmo"(PRXWURVWHUPRVcomo exercer o mando, como guiar os outros, se não se domina a si mesmo, se não conhece a si mesmo"2conhece-te a ti mesmoTXH6yFUDWHVYDLEXVFDUQDLQVFULomRGR WHPSRGH$SRORHP'HOIRVIUDVHDWULEXtGDSRUYH]HVD6yORQRXWUDVYH]HV DRXWURGRV6HWH6iELRVHVVDIUDVHVXUJHQRGLiORJRFRPRDPDUFDGHXP impedimentoGHXPbloqueioRXbarreiraTXH6yFUDWHVFDUDFWHULVWLFDPHQWH FRORFDYDGLDQWHGHVHXVLQWHUORFXWRUHV³1mRWmRUiSLGR´SDUHFHHOHGL]HU TXDQGRSHUJXQWDD$OFLEtDGHVSHORSUHFHLWRGpO¿FR9HPRVLVVRDFRQWHFHU YiULDVYH]HV RH[DPHVRFUiWLFRpTXDVHVHPSUHXPLPSHGLPHQWRHXP EORTXHLRRTXHGL]PXLWRDQyVRFXSDGRVFRP)LORVR¿DSURIHVVRUHVGH )LORVR¿D RHVStULWRWXWHODUGHQRVVDDWLYLGDGHpDQWHVGHWXGRRHVStULWR GDEDUUHLUDHGDOHQWLGmRGDPDUFKDVXVSHQVDGRintervalo±HVSDoRHP TXHRSHQVDPHQWRSRGHDFRQWHFHU 0DVYROWHPRVDRPrimeiro AlcibíadesHjLPDJHPGDTXDOOKHVID ODYD 6yFUDWHVSHUJXQWDVH$OFLEtDGHVVHFRQKHFHDSRQWRGHVHUFDSD]GH FRPDQGDUDVLPHVPR2UD$OFLEtDGHV¿FDFRQIXVRFRPDSHUJXQWDTXH OKHID]SHQVDUHSHUFHEHUDGL¿FXOGDGHTXHH[LVWHHPVXDSUHWHQVmRGH FRPDQGDUDFLGDGH3DUDFRQKHFHUPRVDQyVPHVPRVGL]6yFUDWHVVHUi SUHFLVRVDEHURTXHVRPRVHRTXHSDUHFHHYLGHQWHFRQWLQXD6yFUDWHV GLDORJDQGRFRP$OFLEtDGHVpTXHVRPRVIRUPDGRVGHFRUSRHDOPDH TXHDDOPDYLDGHUHJUDFRPDQGDRFRUSR6HQGRDVVLPRTXHVRPRV IXQGDPHQWDOPHQWHpDDOPDDpsyché $TXLQmRWHPRVDWHRULDGDDOPDFRPRYDPRVHQFRQWUDUQRFedroRX QDRepúblicaRXPHVPRQRTimeu DDOPDpXPWRGRHUHVXPHRKRPHP 3RGHPRVGL]HUTXHHVVDDOPDpDYLGDPHQWDODFRQVFLrQFLD(PRXWUDV SDODYUDVVHUYHQRVSHQVDUTXHHVVDDOPDpDVHGHGRHXRXVHTXLVHUPRV o self3RLVEHPVHQGRRKRPHPDQWHVGHWXGRVXDDOPDFRPRFRQKHFr ODFRPRVDEHUTXHPVHp"eQHVVHSRQWRTXH3ODWmRXVDDLPDJHPTXH HXJRVWDULDGHFRORFDUDRODGRGDTXHODGDFDYHUQD Sócrates 5DFLRFLQDFRPLJR6HQRVGLULJtVVHPRVDRVROKRVFRPRVH WUDWDVVHGHSHVVRDVHOKHVDSUHVHQWiVVHPRVRSUHFHLWRµ&RQKHFHWHDWL PHVPR¶GHTXHPRGRFRPSUHHQGHUtDPRVRFRQVHOKR"1mRVHULDQRVHQWLGR
&I*86'25)*Professores para quê?/LVERD 0RUDHV(GLWRUD S 2EYLDPHQWHHVVDHDVD¿UPDo}HVVHJXLQWHVQHFHVVLWDULDPGHXPDH[SOLFDomRPDLVGH PRUDGDHFXLGDGRVD3DUDRVSURSyVLWRVGDFRQIHUrQFLDQRHQWDQWRHODVVmRVX¿FLHQWHV
Revista Páginas de Filosofia, v. 7, n. 1, p.59-‐70, jan./jun. 2015
REVISTA PÁGINAS DE FILOSOFIA
65
GHOHYDURVROKRVDGLULJLUVHSDUDDOJXPREMHWRHPTXHHOHVSXGHVVHPYHU DVLSUySULRV" Alcibíades eFODUR Soc (TXDOpRREMHWRHPTXHQRVYHPRVTXDQGRRFRQWHPSODPRV" Alc 2HVSHOKR6yFUDWHV Soc $FHUWDVWH3RUpPQRVROKRVFRPTXHYHPRVQmRVHHQFRQWUDDOJR GRPHVPRHVWLOR" Alc 3HUIHLWDPHQWH Soc &RPRMiGHYHVWHUREVHUYDGRRURVWRGHTXHPROKDSDUDRVROKRVGH DOJXpPTXHVHOKHGHIURQWHUHÀHWHVHQRTXHGHQRPLQDPRVSXSLODFRPR QXPHVSHOKRDLPDJHPGDSHVVRDTXHROKD Alc eFHUWR Soc $VVLPTXDQGRXPROKRROKDSDUDRXWURHVH¿[DQDSRUomRPDLV H[FHOHQWHGHVWHMXVWDPHQWHDTXHODTXHYrHOHYrVHDVLPHVPR" Alc eHYLGHQWH
2ROKRTXHQRVID]YHUWXGRRTXHSRGHVHUYLVWRHTXHQRVSHUPLWH FRQKHFHURUHDO DTXLQmRKiSHORPHQRVQmRGHPDQHLUDH[SOtFLWDDGHV FRQ¿DQoDHPUHODomRDRPXQGRHPStULFR 6yFUDWHVH$OFLEtDGHVFRPSDU WLOKDPGD³FUHQoDLQJrQXDQRPXQGRH[WHULRU´ RROKRTXHQRVSHUPLWH YHUpLQFDSD]GHHQ[HUJDUDVLPHVPR'HTXHPRGRHOHSRGHHQWmRVH FRQKHFHU"$OFLEtDGHVSURS}HGHLPHGLDWRXPHVSHOKRHSURS}HRyEYLRH RDFHUWDGRPDV6yFUDWHVYDLLQGLFDUDOJRTXHQmRpDSHQDVPDLVSRpWLFR PDVVREUHWXGRPXLWRH¿FD]SDUDRVVHXV¿QV VHRROKRTXHUFRQKHFHUD VLPHVPRGHYHHOHROKDUpara a melhor parteSDUDD³PHQLQD´ koré GH RXWURolho DOLHOHHQ[HUJDUiDVLPHVPRDRPHVPRWHPSRHPTXHYrR ROKRGRRXWURGLDQWHGHOHIDFHjIDFHFRPHOH2UDDVLWXDomRpLGrQWLFD jGDDOPDTXHpFDSD]GHFRQKHFHUWXGRRTXHVHSRGHFRQKHFHUH[FHWR DVLPHVPDVHPRUHFXUVRDRRXWUR HSRULVVRRHVSHOKRQmRVHUYHDRV ¿QVVRFUiWLFRVSRUTXHHOHQmRUHVSRQGHDRFRQWUiULRGRVHVSHOKRVGDV IiEXODV VHpSUHFLVRYHUSDUDVHFRQKHFHUWDPEpPpSUHFLVRRXYLURTXH pGLWRVREUHDVQRVVDVDOPDV
3/$72 Primeiro AlcibíadesGD7UDG&DUORV$OEHUWR1XQHV3DUi
(GLWRUDGD8QLYHUVLGDGHGR3DUi
Revista Páginas de Filosofia, v. 7, n. 1, p.59-‐70, jan./jun. 2015
66
FILOSOFIA COMO EXPERIÊNCIA E COMO EDUCAÇÃO
$DOPDSDUDFRQKHFHUDVLPHVPDSUHFLVDSRUWDQWRFRORFDUVHHP UHODomRjRXWUDDOPDHPXPPHVPRSODQRIUHQWHDIUHQWH'LIHUHQWHGR SODQRLQFOLQDGRHDVFHQGHQWHGDAlegoriaHPTXHDOJRRXDOJXpPOLEHUWD RSULVLRQHLURGDVLOXV}HVDSDUWLUGHFLPDXPDFLPDTXHSHUPDQHFHUi VHPSUHFRPRDUHDOLGDGHSULYLOHJLDGDDTXLDH[SHULrQFLDVHGiHPXP PHVPRSODQRHQRFKmRFRPXPKDELWDGRSRUTXHPVHFRORFDQDEXVFD SHORFRQKHFLPHQWRGHVLSHORFXPSULPHQWRGRRUiFXOR(VVHFRQWUDVWHHQWUH DVGXDVLPDJHQVpEDVWDQWHHVTXHPiWLFRPDVWDOYH]VLUYDSDUDLQGLFDUD SUHVHQoDGHGXDVPDQHLUDVGHVHFRQFHEHUD)LORVR¿DDPEDVQDREUDSOD W{QLFD$LQGDTXHVHVDLEDTXHH[LVWHPWDQWDV)LORVR¿DVTXDQWRV¿OyVRIRV HTXHHVVDVGXDVFRQFHSo}HVQmRVmRQHPGHORQJHXPUHVXPRGDVIRUPDV TXHD)LORVR¿DDVVXPHHP3ODWmRHODVVmR~WHLVSDUDRQRVVRDUJXPHQWR 'HXPDSULPHLUDLPDJHPDGDFDYHUQDQDVFHDFRQFHSomRGH)LOR VR¿DFRPRVHQGRDQWHVGHWXGRXPDHSLVWHPRORJLDRXVHMDXPGLVFXUVR VREUHRFRQKHFLPHQWRHVXDYDOLGDGH$YHUGDGHTXHSHUPDQHFHIRUDGD FDYHUQDHTXHMXVWL¿FDDH[LVWrQFLDGHFDYHUQDVHSULVLRQHLURVH¿OyVRIRV HVVDYHUGDGHSHUPDQHFHFRPRtélosHDOYRGD)LORVR¿DHWRGRVRVGLVFXU VRVTXHVHSURQXQFLDUHPsobreRPXQGRHnoPXQGRSRGHPVHUDYDOLDGRV DSDUWLUGHVVHSULYLOHJLDGRSRQWRGHYLVWDRSRQWRGHYLVWDGLUtDPRVGR ROKRGH'HXV(PVXPDXPSRQWRGHYLVWDLQFRQGLFLRQDGRHSRULVVR YHUGDGHLUROLEHUWRGDVLOXV}HVGDFDYHUQD 9ROWDQGRDRTXHMiIRLGLWR HVVHPRGRGHSHQVDUD)LORVR¿DPHVPR GHSRLVGDVFULVHVSHODVTXDLVSDVVRXRSHQVDPHQWR¿ORVy¿FRHPWHPSRVGH GLVVROXomRGDVPHWDQDUUDWLYDVGDFUtWLFDSURIXQGDGDPHWDItVLFDGRUHODWL YLVPRJDORSDQWHDLQGDDVVLPHVVHPRGRGHVHSHQVDUD)LORVR¿DSHUVLVWH HPPXLWDVGDVQRVVDVDWLYLGDGHVHSUiWLFDVHPUHODomRDHOD,QIHOL]PHQWH LQVLVWLUKRMHTXHD)LORVR¿DLUiOLEHUWDURKRPHPGD³DOLHQDomR´UHYHODUD HOHRVJULOK}HVTXHRRSULPHPID]rORFRQKHFHUD³UHDOLGDGHYHUGDGHLUD´ WXGRLVVRVRDGHVORFDGRSDWpWLFRHPHVPRXPSRXFRULGtFXOR6LPSOHVPHQWH SRUTXHQmRKiFRPRJDUDQWLUPRVHPUHODomRDRXWURVGLVFXUVRVDSRVLomR SULYLOHJLDGDGRGLVFXUVR¿ORVy¿FRYD]DGRQDIRUPDGDLPDJHPGDFDYHUQD $LGHLDGD)LORVR¿DFRPRepistemeFRPRGLVFXUVRTXHVHSURQXQFLDGH PRGRLQFRQGLFLRQDGRVREUHRPXQGRHVVDLGHLDQmRVHSRGHPDLVVXVWHQWDU ,VVRpPDLVGRTXHFODURFUHLRHXSDUDWRGRVQyV6HQGRDVVLPpQD RXWUDLPDJHPSODW{QLFDTXHQRVUHVWDEXVFDUXPVHQWLGRSDUDD)LORVR¿D Revista Páginas de Filosofia, v. 7, n. 1, p.59-‐70, jan./jun. 2015
REVISTA PÁGINAS DE FILOSOFIA
67
TXDQGRDFRPSUHHQGHPRVQmRFRPRepistemePDVFRPRaskesis2XVHMD VHWRPDUPRVFRPRIXQGDPHQWRSDUDD)LORVR¿DDLPDJHPGRROKRTXHVH FRQKHFHDVLPHVPRHPRXWURROKRGDDOPDTXHVHFRQKHFHDVLPHVPD HPRXWUDDOPDQHVVHDSHORGHUHÀH[mR TXHVHGiQDSUySULDIRUPDGD IUDVHUHÀH[LYD HQFRQWUDUHPRVDH[LJrQFLDSRUXPexercícioTXHpXPD GDVWUDGXo}HVGRWHUPRaskesis8Pexercício ascético FRPRSHUGmRGR SOHRQDVPR TXHQmRVHFRQIXQGHFRPRLVRODPHQWRRXFRPRDIDVWDPHQ WRGRPXQGR VHKiXPDSDUDGDXPDUHWHQomRHXPUHWUDLPHQWRVREUHVL PHVPRHOHVySRGHDFRQWHFHUGLDQWHGRRXWURGRVRXWURVTXHSHUPLWDj PLQKDLPDJHPUHÀHWLGDPHDOFDQoDU +iHVSHUDQoDTXHRPrimeiro AlcibíadesHDApologiaSRUVHUHPRV WH[WRVTXH3ODWmRPXLWRSURYDYHOPHQWHSULPHLURHVFUHYHXUHWHQKDPDOJR GRHVVHQFLDOGD¿JXUDGR6yFUDWHVKLVWyULFRDTXHOH6yFUDWHVTXHDFDERX SRULQÀXHQFLDURGHVHQYROYLPHQWRGHFRQFHSo}HV¿ORVy¿FDVSDUDOHODVjV GH3ODWmRH$ULVWyWHOHVPDVGDVTXDLVSRXFRVDEHPRV2TXHPHLQWHUHV VDDTXLQRHQWDQWRpSHUPDQHFHUXPSRXFRQDLPDJHPGDDOPDTXHVH FRQKHFHDSDUWLUGHRXWUDDOPDHGDQHFHVVLGDGHGHUHFRQKHFHUGLDQWHGH VLRXWURem um mesmo planoSDUDTXHD)LORVR¿DDVVLPFRQFHELGDSRVVD FRPHoDU(VVDexperiênciapRTXHPHLQWHUHVVDHJRVWDULDGHSHQVDUWHU VLGRHVVDDSULQFLSDOFRQWULEXLomRGR6yFUDWHVKLVWyULFRSDUDDOpPGRTXH QRVGiDREUDSODW{QLFDHHPPHQRUPHGLGDDVREUDVGHRXWURVTXHDHOH VHUHIHULUDPHTXHFKHJDUDPDWpQyV(VHXVRRWHUPRH[SHULrQFLDDTXL QmRpVHPPRWLYR2VHQWLGRTXHGRXjSDODYUDQHVVHSULPHLURPRPHQWR pRPDLVDPSORHWDPEpPRPDLVVLPSOHVHPSUHVWDGRGD)LORVR¿DGH-RKQ 'HZH\HGRSUDJPDWLVPR experiência é tudo o que acontece2XQLYHUVR GHVVDPDQHLUDQmRpPDLVTXHXPFRQMXQWRLQFHVVDQWHGHH[SHULrQFLDVXP ÀX[RVHPWHUPRGHHYHQWRV+iQRHQWDQWRXPVXEFRQMXQWRGHH[SHULrQ FLDVDTXHODVGDVTXDLVSDUWLFLSDPRV'DPHVPDIRUPDTXHRXQLYHUVRp XPFRQMXQWRGHH[SHULrQFLDVQHVVDGH¿QLomRHPQyVRFRUUHWDPEpPXP Q~PHURHQRUPHGHDo}HVHUHDo}HVGDVTXDLVQmRHVWDPRVFRQVFLHQWHVRX DYLVDGRV KiDH[SHULrQFLDGDUHVSLUDomRHGDFLUFXODomRVDQJXtQHDSRU $LGHLDGHFRQFHEHUGHVVHPRGRD)LORVR¿DGHULYDHPJUDQGHSDUWHGDREUDGH3LHUUH +DGRW &ISH[ 2TXHpD)LORVR¿D$QWLJD63 /R\ROD 6REUHVHXSRVVtYHO SDSHOHPXPD)LORVR¿DGD(GXFDomRFI-DQ0DVVFKHOHLQH0DDUWHQ6LPRQVA peda- gogia, a democracia, a escola%HOR+RUL]RQWH $XWrQWLFD &I'(:(RQOLQH@Q S
Revista Páginas de Filosofia, v. 7, n. 1, p.59-‐70, jan./jun. 2015
REVISTA PÁGINAS DE FILOSOFIA
69
SHUFRUUHQGRWRGRVRVFDPLQKRVMDPDLVHQFRQWUDUiVRVOLPLWHVGDDOPDWmR SURIXQGRpVHXlogos´" % eLPSRUWDQWHGHVWDFDUSRUpPTXHRFXLGDGRGDDOPDVRFUiWLFRH RFRQKHFHWHDWLPHVPRGpO¿FRQmRWrPQDGDGHSVLFROyJLFRQRVHQWLGR PRGHUQR2TXHVHHVFUHYHXQDHQWUDGDGRWHPSORGH$SRORSDUDTXHWRGRV RVYLVLWDQWHVYLVVHPIRLDOJRFRPR ³±4XHPYRFrSHQVDTXHpPRUWDO"´ XPFKDPDGRjPRGHUDomRHDSHUFHSomRGHVLPHVPRHVVH³VLPHVPR´ TXH6yFUDWHVLQVWDXUDHPXPDDOPDTXHpRSUySULRKRPHPRXPHOKRU DSDUWHPDLVQREUHGRKRPHPSRUTXHFDSD]GHFRQKHFHUHVHDXWRFRQKH FHUH[SHULPHQWDQGRDVLPHVPDWHVWDQGRVHDWHQWDQGRDVLPHVPD HP VXPDWRUQDQGRVHFRQVFLHQWHGHVL2³JQRWKLVHDXWRQ´VRFUiWLFRpXP DSHORGHVVDIRUPDjPRGHUDomRTXHIXQFLRQDFRPRLPSHGLPHQWRXP EORTXHLRTXHID]SDUDUDPDUFKD HPYH]GHIRUoiODDDFRQWHFHUVXELQGR D³HVFDUSDGDHQFRVWD´GDFDYHUQD 2TXHQRVUHVWDSRUWDQWR"2TXHSRGHQRVGL]HUWXGRLVVRQHVVH PRPHQWRTXHPDUFDRLQtFLRGHXPQRYRDQROHWLYRGR&XUVRGH)LORVR ¿D"7DOYH]RVHJXLQWHSHQVDQGRTXHDTXLIDORDSURIHVVRUHVRXIXWXURV SURIHVVRUHVGH)LORVR¿D 3ULPHLURTXHpSUHFLVRGHL[DUVHDOFDQoDUSHODH[SHULrQFLDUHÀHWLGD QRVHQWLGRTXHGHPRVDHODHTXHHVVDH[SHULrQFLDDQWHVGHWXGRGHYH VHUXPDH[SHULrQFLDGHVLRXWURPRGRGHGL]HUFXLGDGRGDDOPD3DUHFH GHVQHFHVViULRSRVWXODULVVRGLDQWHGHXPDSODWHLDGH¿OyVRIRVPDVVDEHPRV WRGRVFUHLRHXRTXDQWRRVDVVLPFKDPDGRV¿OyVRIRVVmRFLRVRVGHVXDV SRVLo}HVHGHVXDVWHVHVFDSD]HVVHPG~YLGDGHREULJDU6yFUDWHVDEHEHU FLFXWDQRYDPHQWHVHIRVVHSUHFLVR (PRXWURVWHUPRVSHQVRTXHPDLVQRVYDOHKRMHDLPDJHPTXH HQFRQWUDPRVQRPrimeiro AlcibíadesTXHDGR/LYUR9,,GDRepúblicaVH SHQVDUPRVQDVH[LJrQFLDVIHLWDVDRVSURIHVVRUHVGH)LORVR¿DTXHVRPRV$V DXODVTXHWHPRVHPXPDIDFXOGDGHGH)LORVR¿DSRXFRRXQDGDVHUHIHUHP jTXHODVTXHGHYHUHPRVGDUQD(GXFDomR%iVLFDQR(QVLQR0pGLR DTXL QDXQLYHUVLGDGHVRPRVWRGRVFRQYHUWLGRVjHVSHUDGR¿OyVRIRTXHYLUiQRV VDOYDUGRVJULOK}HVHGRVLPXODFURGRPXQGRRXHQWmRSLRUDLQGDVRPRV MiH[SULVLRQHLURVUXPRjVDtGDRXPHVPRTXDVHOiSDUDRTXHSUHFLVD UHPRVVRPHQWHGHDOJXPDDMXGDPDLVEXURFUiWLFDHIRUPDOTXHHIHWLYD 1mRQRVEDQFRVGDHVFRODSDUDRQGHLUHPRVRVMRYHQVTXHQRVHVSHUDP QmRVHUmRFRPRQyVVRPRV YLDGHUHJUDSRXFRRXQDGDVHLQWHUHVVDUmR SHOD)LORVR¿DRTXHQmRpGHWRGRUXLPPDVXPFDPSRDEHUWRIUDQTXHDGR Revista Páginas de Filosofia, v. 7, n. 1, p.59-‐70, jan./jun. 2015
70
FILOSOFIA COMO EXPERIÊNCIA E COMO EDUCAÇÃO
SDUDDH[SHULrQFLD¿ORVy¿FDVHDTXLVHUPRVID]HU'LDQWHGHVVHVDOXQRVR PRGHORGH)LORVR¿DUHSUHVHQWDGRSHODAlegoria da CavernaWDOYH]GHYHVVH PHVPRVHUGHL[DGRGHODGR,VVRTXHUGL]HU DSDUWLUGHOHQyVSURIHVVRUHV QmRWHPRVFRPRHYLWDUDLQFRUSRUDomRGRSDSHOGROLEHUWDGRUVHMDDSHQDV SHORIDWRGHOHYDUPRVDWpDVDODDLPDJHPHFRORFiODDIXQFLRQDU3RUpP QmRWHPRVQHQKXPDSUHUURJDWLYDQHQKXPGLUHLWRRXJDUDQWLDTXHQRVSRVVD SHUPLWLUGL]HUTXHRSDSHOGR¿OyVRIRQRVFDEH3RGHSDUHFHUH[DJHURH WDOYH]RVHMDSRUTXHPHXLQWHUHVVHPDLRUQmRpGL]HURTXHFDGDXPGH YRFrVGHYHID]HUGLDQWHGHVHXVDOXQRVHPVXDVVDODV$LVVRVHUmRGDGDV UHVSRVWDVDVPDLVYDULDGDVWRGDVSRGHQGRVHULJXDOPHQWHYiOLGDV2TXH PHLPSRUWDDTXLDQWHVGHWXGRQmRpRTXHRSURIHVVRUIDUiFRPD)LOR VR¿DPDVRTXHD)LORVR¿DIH]HIDUiFRPHOH2XVHMDDVVXPLURSDSHO GHVDOYDGRUHHQFDUQDUVHMDFRPRIRUHVVDVSUHWHQV}HVVRWHULROyJLFDVp FRORFDUVHQRDOWRHQHJDUDLPDJHPTXHHQFRQWUDPRVQRPrimeiro Alci- bíadesTXHGiFRPRWDUHIDGD)LORVR¿DXPWUDEDOKRTXHFRPHoDHPXP PHVPRQtYHOGHLQWHUORFXomR&RPLVVRQmRVHQHJDDEVROXWDPHQWHTXH RSURIHVVRUGHYDSRVVXLUPDLVFRQKHFLPHQWRHVDEHUHVTXHVHXVDOXQRV LVVRQmRpVyDGPLWLGRFRPRpXPDFRQGLomRSDUDRWUDEDOKRGRFHQWH±p D¿QDORSHUFXUVRSRUGHQWURGDWUDGLomRDH[SHULrQFLDnaHpelaWUDGLomR TXHSHUPLWHDRSURIHVVRUDVVLPVHFRORFDUQmRSRUJHQHURVLGDGHQmRSRU ERQGDGHPDVQRkPELWRGDPDLVHVWULWDGLVFLSOLQD¿ORVy¿FD eSUHFLVRTXHRSURIHVVRUGH)LORVR¿DH[SHULPHQWHFRQVLJRPHVPR SUHVWHDWHQomRHWRPHDVLPHVPRFRPRREMHWRGDH[SHULrQFLDUHÀHWLGD (VVDH[SHULPHQWDomRSDVVDREULJDWRULDPHQWHSHODH[SHULPHQWDomRQD WUDGLomR¿ORVy¿FDPDVGDPHVPDIRUPDSHODH[SHULPHQWDomRdianteGRV DOXQRVdianteGDVDODTXHSDVVDDVHUQmRPDLVROXJDUHPTXHVH³DSOLFD´ RXVH³GHPRQVWUD´RTXHVHVDEHSRUPHLRGHXPGLVFXUVRFRPSHWHQWHRX HVFODUHFLGR³LOXPLQLVWD´HHPDQFLSDGRURXRQGHVHHQFHQDD³FRQVWUXomR´ GHXPVDEHUMiFRQVWUXtGRFRPRTXDORVDOXQRVSUHFLVDPDSHQDVFRQ FRUGDUSDUDHVWDUHPFHUWRV±HRSURIHVVRUFRQIRUWiYHOHVDWLVIHLWR±PDV VLPFRPRXPOXJDUSULYLOHJLDGRQRTXDOD)LORVR¿DaconteceQHVVHKLDWR MiPDUFDGRHQWUHXPDQWHVHXPGHSRLVHVSDoRLGHDOGRDGPLUDUVHGR HVSDQWDUVHGRH[SHULPHQWDUXPHVSDoRGHDWHQomRTXHVHGiDVLHDR RXWUR1HVVHVHQWLGRSDUDRSURIHVVRUDRPHQRVD)LORVR¿DSRGHYLUDVHU HGXFDWLYDHPLQHQWHPHQWHHGXFDWLYDHUHSUHVHQWDUPHVPRRPDLVDOWRJUDX GHHGXFDomRTXHpDGHOLEHUDGDHFRQVFLHQWHPHQWHEXVFDGDDXWRHGXFDomR
Revista Páginas de Filosofia, v. 7, n. 1, p.59-‐70, jan./jun. 2015
Lihat lebih banyak...
Comentários
